One of the first, and most frequent, questions asked of congressional fellows is: What do you want to get out of your fellowship? Fellowship Director Jeff Biggs, former fellows, professors, chiefs of staff, legislative directors, and members will, at one point or another, raise this topic. At an abstract level I had an answer: I sought a better understanding of the legislative process. But, at times, it felt like a trick question. At a practical level I had almost no idea what I was getting into. I had few expectations or preconceived notions about the lessons that would come over the next year. Without legislative experience to fall back on, setting out to accomplish a prearranged set of goals seemed impossible. So I took a different tact. Rather than search for expertise in a particular policy area or with a specific goal in mind, I sought a placement that would treat me unexceptionally. I set out to find an office assignment that would offer complete emersion as a congressional staffer. I fashioned myself as a miniature Clifford Geertz. I needed to get as close as possible to living the life of a full-time staffer, complete with long hours and a significant portfolio. After I came up for air at the end of my fellowship, I figured I will have learned lessons I did not necessary start out to find, but would nonetheless enhance my understanding of the institution and how those within it practice and perceive politics.
Finding the “right” assignment was a daunting task. There is no shortage of options on the Hill. Working for a committee offered the opportunity to specialize in a specific policy area. It also gives fellows the opportunity to interact with multiple members and staff that serve on the committee, potentially expanding their insight into a variety of different offices and operations. Conversely, personal offices often allowed fellows to cover a broader range of issues, especially in the House. It also exposes fellows to the electoral connection and the overlap of personal goals on the policy process. Depending on the fellow's priorities, there is a seemingly endless range of opportunities. I interviewed in several offices—in the House and Senate and with committee and member staffs. Although I was fairly set on finding a personal office, every interview had exciting prospects. The further I got into the interview process the more obvious it became that there were incredible opportunities that would lead to very different experiences with very different advantages. While I had a fair amount of anxiety entering the interview process, the actual interviews made it clear that there were plenty of good assignments.
I ultimately landed in Congressman Keith Ellison's office, the representative of Minnesota's Fifth District. I met the staff from his office at a meeting set up by the fellowship. The Congressman is a very active member. He is the co-chair of the Congressional Progressive Caucus, a member of the leadership as a Chief Deputy Whip, and actively engaged on several issues ranging from civil rights and economics to foreign policy. After interviewing with the Chief of Staff and Legislative Director, I knew it would be a hard position to turn down. Fellows in Congressman Ellison's office serve as full legislative assistants during their time on the Hill. In the past, APSA fellows had served there and they had glowing recommendations to show for it. So shortly before Christmas I accepted the assignment.
Working on a personal staff has been a very rewarding experience. My portfolio bridged my interests in government and legislative process with substantive policy areas. Over the past year in the office I was responsible for issues in government affairs, legislative process, voting rights, campaign finance, trade, telecommunications, human services and welfare, part of the financial services portfolio, and small business. I experienced firsthand the information overload many former fellows and staffers described. To put it in their words, working on the Hill is like “drinking from a fire hose.” What you need to know often outweighs what you can consume. Thankfully, the staff has been hugely helpful. They taught me to parse through the information that was important and irrelevant, how to convey the importance of an issue to my information overloaded boss, and how to manage a diverse portfolio. Often their advice led to deeper understanding of the institution more generally. In covering different issues I interacted with different staffs, committees, groups, and constituencies. In many ways, contrasting their experiences with my own was a great way to learn. Throughout the fellowship the staff has been an invaluable source of guidance.
Looking back over the past year the experience has been nothing short of enlightening. I spent most of the year dedicated to staff work while occasionally seeking opportunities to be a fly on the wall. In the last year I met with constituents, researched bill ideas, wrote issue briefs, helped with the introduction of bills and amendments, drafted talking points, fostered relationships with other offices, wrote press releases, organized briefings, courted cosponsors and endorsements, wrote speeches, staffed the congressman in committee hearings and markups, made vote recommendations, and yes, wrote the occasional constituent letter. Additionally, my member, chief of staff, and legislative director found opportunities for me to sit in on meetings they believed—correctly—would enhance my understanding. My fellowship year has been exhilarating, exhausting, and illuminating all at once. The ways it has brought the institution to life will undoubtedly give texture to my research and teaching in ways I cannot yet fathom. But to put it simply, the fellowship experience lives up to the hype.
Understanding Legislative Process from the Inside
Getting the “big picture” while inside the institution has been challenging at times. Some experiences reinforced what I already knew while others contradicted it entirely. For example, my introduction to the process began on an awkward foot. My first day in the office was January 2, 2013. During the next few months the operation of Congress challenged much of what I thought I knew. Throughout my graduate years I read multiple articles and books about Congress's historic levels of partisanship and polarization. Given that background, the first three days were decidedly odd. On day one, Speaker Boehner broke the Hastert rule and passed a fiscal cliff deal that failed to gain a majority of his caucus. Two days later, I watched members' swearing in and the election of the Speaker from the gallery seats—compliments of my boss—when conservative Republicans fell short in their attempt to overthrow John Boehner. In the months that followed the House passed the Violence Against Women Act and the Hurricane Sandy relief bill. Again, both bills failed to gain support of a majority of the majority party. Bipartisanship prevailed to enact three of the most important bills in 2013. From my perspective, either the previous research did not apply or a new paradigm had emerged.
However, the bipartisan “episodes” quickly disappeared and the partisanship that has defined the lower chamber for the past 30 years reemerged. After those first couple months, the leadership and Rules Committee limited debate and amendments that threatened the fidelity of the Hastert “rule.” I was able to observe reciprocity between the parties dwindle as long-standing procedural norms fell. For example, I was present in May as the committee minority was not granted its customary “amendment in the nature of a substitute” on a Ways and Means bill moving to the floor. In another instance, a parade of Democrats took to the floor to offer unanimous consent agreements to stall consideration on one half of the split farm bill. Republicans responded by charging debate time against the minority. The procedural battle broke a long-standing tradition in the House: not to count unanimous consent agreements against debate time. Like most power plays in the House, the minority lost its battle to delay the bill. However, these incidents also highlighted the decaying relationship between minority and majority in the House. From a procedural standpoint, polarized politics has led to more hardnosed politics in both parties. The minority party continues to try and devise novel ways to throw a wrench in the works. Meanwhile, the majority is increasingly incentivized to clamp down on obstruction to maintain their agenda and voting coalition. We often think of polarization in ideological terms, but often it is most manifest through the House's procedural battles.
As I prepare to leave the fellowship I have gained a much better appreciation for the social aspect of politics. Of course rules and norms structure the lawmaking process but that is only part of the story. The process is also inextricably linked to the relationships that personify that process. Unspoken norms often govern members' interaction. Developing relationships, or the lack thereof, can be the difference between pushing your bill through committee and not getting a hearing. A certain level of trust between members can be the difference between striking a deal and not. As much as the rules affect lawmaking, relationships are just as, if not more, important. Congress is an extremely social institution. In its most basic form it is an institution where peers congregate to identify problems and find common ground on solutions. Socialization in Congress is not an easy dynamic to capture. As a result, it is possible that many studies in congressional research have shied away from tackling the problem. However, it may be the next essential frontier for legislative scholars and observers.
