What does black identity look like in Latin America? What strategies are being employed to carve out spaces for cultural and political expression and affirmation? Comparative Perspectives on Afro-Latin America examines these and other questions concerning black identities, primarily in the contemporary period. In particular, the anthology grapples with how the multicultural turn of the 1990s and 2000s ushered in national policies to address racism, identity and citizenship for Afro-Latin Americans. The 15 essays are well researched and persuasive, at times challenging scholars within the collection and occasionally incorporating nineteenth-century roots of inequality into the analysis. In three thematic sections, the work first sheds light on degrees of invisibility experienced by people of African descent, then analyses their continuing efforts to challenge regional forms of discrimination. It concludes with an assessment of state responses to Afro-Latin demands.
Part One describes the configuration of Afro-Latin American identity through the intersections of ethnicity, culture and politics. Patricia de Santana Pinho's essay illuminates how the current ‘reinvention of Bantu culture’, reveals the vacillating competition and alliance with other Brazilian manifestations of Africanness (p. 22). Situating artistic expressions at the centre of blackness, Heidi Feldman argues that the Afro-Peruvian music and dance revival of the 1950s and 1960s produced the first major successes in twentieth-century black political resistance, which ushered in additional strategies that challenged Peru's dominant creole national identity. In contrast, Sujatha Fernandes notes how the emergence of gangsta rap in Venezuela sidestepped calls of racial injustice, instead focusing on economic marginalisation as a means to unite a ‘racially diverse urban poor’ and foster new modes of belonging (p. 6). Angela Castañeda highlights the commodification of blackness in Mexico through state-sponsored cultural festivals, particularly the 1994 initiation of the Afro-Caribbean Festival and its evolution, critiqued for being simultaneously sanitised and exotic. Nonetheless, these celebrations created a space for greater public discourse and consumption of the legacy of Africans in Mexico.
Part One concludes with Patricia Morán's analysis of how the paintings of Victor Patricio de Landaluze depicted black invisibility in late nineteenth-century Cuba. Although she does not explicitly reference black political volatility in the preceding decades, ranging from the Escalera Conspiracy (1843–4) to the Ten Years’ War (1868–78), Morán points out that by the 1880s, Landaluze's renderings of black subjectivity revealed the depth of white anxieties about the intersections of race, class and the colonial imagination. Morán's compelling essay, however, seems out of place as the only one that deals directly with the nineteenth century, an era especially significant for insights into the roots of contemporary racial discourses in Cuba and elsewhere in Latin America. A more explicit connection to artistic parallels or inversions in the twentieth century would have strengthened its impact on this section's themes of culture and black identities.
Part Two addresses Afro-Latin American community protest in the wake of multicultural legislation. While Colombia's recent constitutional reforms have fostered multiple spaces for redefining citizenship, the process, according to Peter Wade, has ‘indigenized, regionalized and ruralized the question of blackness’ (p. 141). As noted by Bettina Ng'weno, this reconceptualisation yields new concepts of citizenship by reframing notions of autonomy, beyond indigenous and maroon communities, to include the broader Afro-Colombian population. Both scholars urge us to scrutinise race, ethnicity, and equality across multiple and competing perspectives. Keisha-Khan Perry considers how race, politics and space are linked with class, gender and urban environs by highlighting the leadership of black women in challenging policies that have cast impoverished urban neighbourhoods as unworthy of the benefits of modernisation. As she insists, more studies are necessary that attend to the intersections of gender, race, class and geopolitics in Brazil, and throughout the region.
Two essays on Ecuador round off this section. They approach the integration of Afro-Ecuadorians from seemingly opposite vantage points. Ollie Johnson investigates the last three decades of black activism, while Jean Muteba Rahier focuses on how the country's 2008 multicultural constitution affected black citizens. Both writers expand our understanding of blackness in Ecuador, yet while Rahier acknowledges that the past 30 years have led to major strides towards achieving equality for Afro-Ecuadorians, Johnson posits the opposite. Nevertheless, both concur that Afro-Ecuadorans remain largely ‘noncitizens or ambiguous citizens’ (p. 214).
Part Three redirects our gaze to state responses to black mobilisation. Using examples from Brazil, Uruguay, Colombia and Honduras, Judith Morrison notes that overall policy initiatives and partnerships with non-governmental agencies have enhanced the social gains of Afro-Latin Americans. In her exploration of Nicaragua's English-speaking Creole population, Juliet Hooker asserts that creoles’ emphasis on black activism and identity have forced the government to acknowledge the ‘persistence of racial hierarchy’, and to forge connections with indigenous and Afro-Latin movements (p. 278). Shane Greene contends that the reverse has occurred in Peru, where multicultural policies are ‘largely superficial’ in comparison to places like Brazil and Colombia, by underscoring how state depictions of Inca ‘whiteness’ have omitted discourses of blackness within the Peruvian nation (p. 290).
Elsewhere in this section, Antônio Guimarães urges us to move beyond the polarising debates of Brazil's myth of racial harmony and the necessity for Brazil to craft more policies that address the social realities of race. Lastly, Ernesto Sagás draws our attention to the Dominican Republic as a country whose recent anti-Haitian/Haitian-Dominican policies remain in opposition to race-based identity and to those perceived of as being outside an accepted national framework. The varying policy initiatives presented here, for better or worse, recast existing discussions that may reinscribe, open, or challenge prevailing constructions of race, ethnicity, citizenship and equality.
Overall, this is an excellent collection for scholars concerned with contemporary issues in the African Diaspora in Latin America. It is well suited for use in undergraduate and graduate seminars on Afro-Latin America, and in Latin American and African Studies courses featuring hemispheric comparisons. Despite its occasional inconsistencies, the anthology is a welcome addition to the study of the agency of Afro-Latin Americans, and offers important insights into their efforts to claim their rightful place in community, state, and transnational arenas.
