The title of Hélène Mialet's long-anticipated book is both a promise and a pun. Mialet promises to explore the paradoxical corporeality of her book's ‘knowing subject’, the world-famous wheelchair-bound Cambridge cosmologist Stephen Hawking. Though his genius is often said to float free of his limited corporeal frame, here Hawking has no fewer than three bodies: what Mialet terms his ‘natural body collectivized’, his ‘collective body naturalized’, and his ‘sacred body as Lucasian Professor of Mathematics’ (p. 8). (The reference to Ernst Kantorowicz's influential formulation from The King's Two Bodies (1957) is explicit and well considered.) Every aspect of Hawking's existence, from his daily subsistence and speech to his scientific creativity and reputation, depends on large, variously visible and variously acknowledged collectives of students, nurses, engineers, physicists and many others. Hence the pun: Stephen Hawking here appears less like a subjectively individual person, and more like a subjectively elusive corporation: organized, institutionalized, bureaucratized, mechanized and even commercialized. Hawking, Mialet suggests, represents an extreme case whose physical disability, scientific and popular celebrity, and unusual way of working cast into sharp relief many normally hidden aspects not just of scientific life but of subjective human experience in the modern world.
Mialet has published extensively and provocatively about Hawking for over a decade in both English and French – though only her English essays are credited in this book – and readers familiar with these works will appreciate her achievement in assembling and expanding them into a sustained account that treats the confounding problem of Hawking's subjectivity with her characteristic critical engagement and ethnographic dexterity. Each of the book's seven largely self-contained chapters approaches this problem by exploring a different kind of activity where a different collective surrounding Hawking combines to produce a different facet of his peculiar existence as a knowing subject. One meets Hawking the famous lecturer; Hawking the scientific author, collaborator and mentor; Hawking the media icon; Hawking the enigmatic body-machine; Hawking the archive; and Hawking the statue. This multiplication of Hawkings, each richly explored and fascinating in its own right, makes a broader point about the multifarious and hybrid existence of what Mialet calls the distributed-centred subject – a subject who inhabits and becomes a vast network of bodies and institutions, media and machines, narratives and practices.
The distributed-centred subject – a notion elaborated from the author's first book, L'entreprise créatrice (2008) – is Mialet's answer to two important and seemingly conflicting strands in the sociology of subjectivity and agency. The first stresses the subject's decentring in networks of communication and activity, while the second stresses the subject's inextricably local material embodiment. Simply put: people are communities and people are bodies. Mialet here offers a framework and a method for understanding people as both at once.
There is a third aspect, as well, that seems particularly salient for Hawking, as Mialet has construed him. Between communities and bodies, people also take on a notional character as individuals – discrete, idealized, thinking and acting subjects – whose persistence and dominance at the root of accounts of subjectivity outside the traditions in which Mialet writes become, here, yet another aspect of subjectivity to be challenged and explained. For this task, Mialet introduces an analytic distinction between Hawking (‘the man’) and HAWKING (‘the genius physicist’). While she uses this distinction to some effect in chapters where HAWKING corresponds to an identifiably distinct kind of entity (an archive, a statue), one cannot fault Mialet for neglecting to sustain the conceit throughout a book that veritably militates against such a neat cleavage amongst different forms of subjective presence.
Instead, Mialet masterfully teases apart the many threads of what people do, what they say they are doing, what others imagine them to be doing, and so on, and weaves them back together into a brilliant tapestry of social action and agency that ties together people in many more different kinds of role than one is accustomed to encountering in an ethnography of science. If this sometimes makes her seem to take her informants too literally at their word, especially when dealing with Hawking's physics, the upshot is a refreshing view of the self-aware (often almost tongue-in-cheek) posture her informants themselves exhibit with respect to Hawking's peculiar character – a posture they might not so readily assume with respect to a less exceptional figure. The warp to this weft is a rich and nuanced engagement with a wide range of theoretical literatures on embodiment, agency and subjectivity, sustained mostly in Mialet's extensive endnotes. One will want to tuck a finger or a bookmark among these endnotes as one reads, for Mialet stages a number of provocative dialogues across intellectual traditions, in duelling quotations and in commentary, whose full force is not apparent in the main text alone.
Hawking Incorporated, while very much a work of anthropology based in the present, sits at the intersection of some of the most pressing questions for historians of science. To pose just a few: what is the relationship between individual and collective scientific activity? How do materials and machines matter in theoretical sciences? How is a subject constituted in an archive? How do private and public images of science shape scientific knowledge and practice and vice versa? Each question turns on Mialet's presiding interest in just who and what make up the knowing subject, a figure she unpacks in ways that can challenge and enrich many historians’ work.
Mialet's Hawking emerges, if it were possible, more enigmatic than he began. By showing just how many bodies, machines, words and images combine to produce the familiar and singular Hawking known far and wide, Mialet elaborates a sociology of subjectivity just as fuzzy, networked, embodied and mythologized as one comes to see subjectivity itself.
