Over a decade ago Michael H. Hunt wrote, “in seeing Chinese foreign relations in historical perspective we face not a single embarrassing tradition but rather an embarrassment of traditions.”Footnote 4 In making such an observation this noted diplomatic historian sought to call attention to the deleterious effects of the common tendency to understand China's past approach to external relations, and its influence on the present, in a monochromatic fashion. The flaw within such an approach stemmed from the fact that, rather than being imprisoned within any one frame, modern Chinese foreign relations stand at the confluence of multiple historical traditions.
The subsequent writings of a handful of historians and political scientists took this admonition to heart and have done a remarkable job of illuminating the complex nature of earlier Chinese approaches to the rest of the world, as well as the layered influences of such experiences on the present. However, much of this work was oriented primarily toward academic audiences and all too often has been ignored beyond its confines. As a result, the broad simplifications that Hunt found so objectionable have continued to play a prominent role in more general studies of China's foreign relations and Asian security. In other words, what has been lacking in the field is a concise, accessible discussion of the pertinence of the past for China today, one that would give those who might all too easily promote historical simplifications some pause. Past and Present in China's Foreign Policy goes a long way toward accomplishing this goal. While it is rather slim, it is also quite comprehensive and readable, and should quickly become required reading for any seeking to make sense of this point of intersection within China's foreign relations.
The volume contains a series of short papers by an impressive array of preeminent scholars and influential policy advisors. Broadly speaking, their contributions can be divided into three categories. First, a trio of historians (editor John E. Wills, Jr., James L. Hevia, and Peter Perdue) dissects various aspects of historical Chinese approaches to neighboring polities. Each focuses on different facets of this dynamic, but all illustrate the diversity it encompassed. Second, Alice Miller and Brantly Womack contribute essays that also focus on history, but place a heavier emphasis on its imprint upon more contemporary issues. For Womack such a consideration revolves around the persistence of asymmetrical relations within Asia. In contrast Miller provides a particularly compelling debunking of much of what still passes as the conventional wisdom about the past. Her effort in this regard makes this chapter the best contribution to an excellent book. Third, more policy-oriented pieces are provided by Michael D. Swaine and Harry Harding. Both authors warn observers not to overestimate the influence of the past, while at the same time they quite adroitly point out its significance. More specifically, Harding observes: “But while history certainly influences the present, it does not completely determine it. History's message is ambiguous, its lessons are not always pertinent, and its influence is constrained by more contemporary factors” (p. 111).
Such a caution resonates deeply with Hunt's earlier contentions, and forms a fitting conclusion to the book. This being said, it provides no easy answers and contains a number of contrasting arguments and points of emphasis. Yet, in both its sum and parts it is utterly convincing in presenting the past as complex and demonstrating its relevance to current developments.
The volume then stands as a strong rebuke to those who would argue along more simplistic lines. Moreover, due to its short length and engaging writing style, the book has the potential to convey such a message to a broad readership. World leaders looking to make better sense of where China has been and is now heading are unlikely to find a better source in regard to the external facet of this dynamic (and would do well to pay particular attention to the chapters by Miller and Harding). In addition, and perhaps more likely, undergraduates struggling to make sense of the same concerns should find the book to be especially useful. As someone who has taught such students for over a decade and often failed in illuminating such issues, this reader is convinced that the book will fill a rather gaping hole in his teaching arsenal. It is well deserving of occupying a similar spot in the courses of others who attempt to explain and describe the international relations of Asia.
