My path in academia has been atypical in that it has not followed the standard tenure-track path but instead one in which I have the opportunity to fully use much of my legislative studies training in racial and ethnic politics on a daily basis in a position that I absolutely love. More specifically, my deep understanding of racial and ethnic representation and its impact on substantive representation (Bratton and Haynie Reference Bratton and Haynie1999; Hero and Tolbert Reference Hero and Tolbert1995; Karnig and Welch Reference Karnig and Welch1980; Mansbridge Reference Mansbridge1999; Meier and Stewart Reference Meier and Stewart1991; Pitkin Reference Pitkin1967; Stewart, England, and Meier Reference Stewart, England and Meier1989; Tate Reference Tate2003; Whitby Reference Whitby1997), the inherent impact that institutional policies have on inequitable outputs and outcomes, and the influence of diverse deliberative bodies on policy outcomes (Gamble Reference Gamble2011; Mansbridge Reference Mansbridge1999; Minta Reference Minta2011) have all translated well in a higher-education administration context—particularly in the area of diversity and inclusion, the path that I am currently traveling.
Notably, the questions that I studied in the race, ethnicity, and politics (REP) field around representation and how it impacts outcomes were tied directly to my graduate-school experience. Most were connected to a common question in the REP field: “Does descriptive representation have a positive impact on substantive representation?” The idea is that when minority (i.e., descriptive) representation exists or increases in an environment, attention to and advocacy for minority interests also increase, which ultimately leads to positive outcomes for those minority groups. Conversely, there is a decreased likelihood of advocacy and, therefore, negative outcomes for minority interests in the absence of descriptive representation.
To provide a more concrete example of these definitions in a higher-education context, representation would be operationalized as faculty and students from historically underrepresented groups, and substantive representation would be operationalized as positive outcomes for them. Substantive outcomes include increases in those populations over time, PhD matriculation, tenure, positive advising and mentorship experiences, funding and research opportunities, and increased job opportunities, to name only a few.
Consequently, if I were to connect these variables to my graduate-school experience at my PhD-granting institution, there unfortunately would be little to no descriptive representation. More specifically, when I started my program, there were no other black students in my cohort or black faculty in the department; neither was there a faculty member conducting research in the content area in which I was most interested at the time. Although these limitations did not hinder the incredible support I received from a few select faculty in the department, it did present many challenges as a first-generation, low-income, African American female student in a department dominated by white men. Although I found faculty whose research areas closely aligned with my interests, I sought additional REP course opportunities through the interinstitutional program between Rice University and Texas A&M University. It was through this experience that I found a warm and welcoming community of black graduate students and supportive faculty. I participated in symposia, workshops, and conferences with other students as well as faculty of color. It was truly formative because I was able to present my work in an environment where students and faculty seemed genuinely excited about my ideas and who offered constructive feedback in a way that was not demoralizing but instead affirming. It was in this community, one outside of my home institution, where my ideas were validated and I felt a great sense of belonging. In part, this community and the mentorship that I received from Ken Meier was pivotal to my graduate-school success. Therefore, I posit that the descriptive representation present in my graduate-school experience did lead, in fact, to substantive representation outcomes.
Because of this support and the unwavering mentorship of my dissertation chair, Keith Hamm, my passion developed further and I felt strongly that my voice mattered in the field. My advice to the next generation of scholars, particularly black scholars who are seeking but not receiving support and validation, is to pursue this outside of your current environment. Understand that there are scholarly communities that want to support and encourage you on your journey. Seek out opportunities to connect with students and faculty in the same department at another institution, attend their colloquia and speaker programs, take a course via your institution’s interinstitutional program, conduct informational interviews with faculty who reflect your interests, and find ways to connect with minority-serving programs and conferences including the Ford Fellowship, the PhD Project, and Ralph Bunche programs. The community that you are seeking may be outside of your department or even your institution, but it does exist.
My advice to the next generation of scholars, particularly black scholars who are seeking but not receiving support and validation, is to pursue this outside of your current environment.
As a graduate student at Rice University, I had an amazing opportunity to teach my own course, “Race and Public Policy.” This experience single-handedly shifted my career focus because it confirmed my love for teaching, advising, and mentoring. However, I grappled with the idea that these passions were contradictory to the prescribed path for a student earning a PhD from an R1 institution, where my time and energy should be squarely focused on research. Furthermore, the prescription was to land a tenure-track job at a research-focused institution and progress accordingly.
However, my instincts and passion for teaching nudged me toward a postdoctoral-lecturer position at Princeton University rather than a tenure-track offer from a midsized state institution. This was a pivotal moment in my career because my plan was to spend a few years teaching and conducting research at Princeton, with the eventual goal of getting a tenure-track job at a small liberal arts college. It was important to me to pursue an academic career at an institution where teaching was rewarded with the goal of moving into administration after tenure. I believed that a small liberal arts college would be the perfect fit.
Those plans quickly changed when I was offered an administrative role after my first year teaching at Princeton, which subsequently led to my current role as a dean in the graduate school with the option to teach. In this position, I find that my REP training and research are extremely beneficial because, as a descriptive representative from an underrepresented group, I am able to create programs as well as inform policies, processes, and procedures that substantively and positively impact underrepresented students. I recognize that my training is not limited to the legislative studies field but also is transferable and meaningful in various contexts. Therefore, my final piece of advice is to make decisions about your career path that feels purposeful to you, even if this means you disappoint your advisor, your committee, or your colleagues. I know it sounds cliché, but follow your passions—they may lead to wonderful and unexpected places.
In summary, I do not regret the administrative path that I have taken and I am incredibly fortunate to have received the insight and training in the REP legislative studies field. This training shaped my view of the theoretical concepts that I learned during my graduate-school career and led me to a clear roadmap for how I analytically approach my daily work. Importantly, the field has shaped my passions about the tangible and quantifiable impact of diversity and inclusion at all levels in the academy—work that continues to need improvement.
