In geographical and chronological terms, the two books under review belong together. Jagdish Sinha's is a history of science on the subcontinent in the earlier part of the twentieth century, while Itty Abraham and the contributors to his volume look at the sociology and politics of science on the subcontinent in the later half of the twentieth century. Otherwise, however, these are remarkably different books. Let me give a brief overview of each before I turn to some historiographic reflections as a way of making sense of these differences.
Science, War and Imperialism grew out of Sinha's Delhi University doctoral thesis, previously the basis of papers by him in edited volumes and journals. Sinha began this work as part of the first wave of debates on colonial science in India, with scholars such as Deepak Kumar. His book remains very much rooted in this tradition. Colonial rule, the first-wavers held, constrained the development of local scientific traditions, with certain scientific disciplines neglected in the process. This neglect, Sinha now argues, was accentuated during the Second World War, which saw unwillingness on the part of the British government to mobilize Indian scientific capability for the war effort. This failure, in turn, had effects on the shape that postwar reconstruction of science and technology went on to take in free India.
Sinha, one could say, asks the Needham question of the Second World War and its impact on the advancement of the scientific enterprise in India. Why did the scientific establishment on the subcontinent not advance in ways comparable to North America or Britain? While some may argue that different questions may fruitfully be asked of this period, the extent to which historians remain engaged with explanations for the ‘lack of’ whatever in extra-European locations can –especially with the surge of global history – be surprising. Nevertheless, no other book with the same scope and analytic reach on science and India during the Second World War exists. On that basis alone, Sinha's chronicle is a welcome addition to the history of science on the subcontinent.
The Abraham-edited South Asian Cultures of the Bomb collects essays on the politics and popular understanding of the bomb in the postwar years. Dealing with more recent history, the volume is firmly rooted in a sophisticated amalgam of science and technology studies (STS) and postcolonial theory. Abraham himself has done much to establish this particular approach, with close intellectual connections to Shiv Visvanathan's scholarship, and above all perhaps to the work of M.V. Ramana and Zia Mian – both contributors to this volume. Another notable contributor is Srirupa Roy, whose recent book Beyond Belief: India and the Politics of Postcolonial Nationalism (2007) is one of the very few studies of contemporary India with a chapter dedicated to science and technology in the transformation of free India.
There are two striking features of this volume. One is that Abraham has brought together scholars writing on both Pakistan and India to reflect on the place of science, the atomic question, popular culture and the state. In doing so, he has managed to push forward a perspective that is transnational in a meaningful way for the subcontinent, as is evident especially from the chapter written by Iftikhar Dadi. The other is that most of the contributors share an anti-nuclear politics which is very much in the foreground.
Compare Sinha and Itty's volumes, and we notice some important markers that concern the historiography of science and technology on the subcontinent. It is not too much to see in the division of labour between these two books the characteristic trends of the larger body of scholarship in the two fields. While historians of the more distant past have engaged long and thoroughly with colonial science, contemporary history – especially for the period after independence – has been done justice mostly by social scientists and STS scholars. Without undermining the richness or the significance of the scholarship, it is nonetheless lamentable that very few historians in general, and of science in particular, have begun to develop a coherent agenda for the contemporary history of the subcontinent.
Even if Sinha has chosen not to engage with more recent approaches to his topic, especially postcolonial history, there is no mistaking the irony inherent in the contrasting traditions the two books come from. If Science, War and Imperialism is about the denial of science-led modernity, South Asian Cultures of the Bomb is a deep critique of the celebrated attainment of precisely that kind of modernity by the postcolonial state and its publics, and of the moral imperatives of global power. In the end, both books articulate positions along the spectrum of expectations of modernity on the subcontinent.
