At a time when both Islam and Islamic movements are perceived as a major threat to Western civilization, Turkey constitutes an interesting case for the study of new Islamic movements. For a long time, social scientists as well as Turkey's indigenous elite hailed Turkey as the exemplar of a Muslim secular state in which the project of modernity was launched successfully. What makes this case more interesting is that Turkey currently is seeking entry into the European Union with a government ruled by a political party called the AKP, an offshoot of the most effectual and oldest representative of Sunni party politics. Modernity, Islam, and Secularism in Turkey is a timely contribution that examines the seemingly contradictory images that Turkey displays.
Following the conceptual framework of “alternative modernities,” through which the presence of modernity in a non-Western context is justified as a “creative adaptation,” the book attempts to analyze the trajectory of modernity in Turkey by examining both its adoption of official ideology by the founding state and challenges to it by the Islamists, who, according to the author, started to produce the ideology of an Islamic mode of modernization only after the 1990s (pp. 2–3 and passim). Regarding modernity as a series of acts and attitudes that aims to create a transformative intervention, Çınar sees no difference between the political means and the ideological techniques that were used by both the founding state and the Islamists to realize their own projects. To show how these two essentially nationalist modernity projects compete with each other, the book takes up the public sphere as its object of analysis; there the construction of the national subject, the making of national space, and the construction of national history can be observed through bodies, places, and time as emerging sites of negotiation. This argument also constitutes the original foundation of the book.
However, another major thesis of the book is that the public sphere must be studied as a visual field that is composed of performance and visibility rather than debate and dialogue (p. 9). Understood as such, the public sphere is presented as a site of performative politics that is pitted against identity politics (p. 29). The author argues that only through such a conceptual framework can the construction of a national subject be understood within the context of everyday life. Nevertheless, the book's examples focus exclusively on public events and debates. The author mentions Turkey's first beauty contest in 1929; Islamic fashion; the sex scandal of an Islamist couple in 1996 (chap. 2); a public debate about the never-realized construction of a mosque in Taksim Square in an effort to make (Ottoman) Istanbul, as opposed to Ankara, the capital of Turkey, in the center (chap. 3); and finally, a commemoration to celebrate the conquest of Istanbul with parades, firecrackers, and so forth, which was organized by the Islamists during the mayoralty of Recep Tayyip Erdoǧan (1994–98), the current prime minister of Turkey. The discourse developed around this performance is compared with the official narrative constructed to create the “founding moment” of the republic (chap. 4).
Although all these phenomena are narrated in a stylish way and include visual material that can also provide a good source of data for students, scholars, and the interested public, the elaboration of the conceptual framework of the whole text is based on extremely repetitious theoretical discussions in which drawn-out logical deductions overrun accurate, well-balanced theoretical reflections. Similarly, semiological readings and political and historical interpretations of chosen events are so rigidly interwoven with tightly framed logical reasoning that they do not invite the reader to ask further fruitful questions. Furthermore, the book's inadequate and, at times, erroneous literature review creates another intertexuality problem. For example, a reference is made to Kandiyoti instead of Behar and Duben, although the latter's arguments on 19th-century Ottoman family life are used (p. 25). Atatürk's speeches on women and hat reform are quoted either from Yeǧenoǧlu or from Aktaş but never from their original sources (pp. 62, 66, 68). In chapter 2, footnote 32, although Yeşim Arat is referred to by name, her work is not in the bibliography. Scholars such as Ernest Gellner and Richard Tapper, who have already pointed out that Islamic fundamentalism in Turkey is the other side of the same coin, that is, Kemalist fundamentalism, are not even mentioned by name.
Equally important, the works of some scholars such as Scott and Singerman never appear in the book, although they have written extensively on the importance of the quotidian, which has been neglected in political science literature. In addition, despite the effort made by the author to compare and contrast two separate historical periods and also to analyze time, the book lacks historical depth. This lack is not only because it confines the enduring arguments of Islamist politics merely to the recent developments of the 1990s, but also because it overlooks the significance of historical processes and networks, as well as the relevance of the Nakshbendi praxis within them, which made that “creative adaptation” of Islamist modernity possible.
Despite these restrictions and despite that debating Turkish modernity as a question of visibility is hardly an original idea, by highlighting the voyeuristic aspects of the political performance, the book makes a valuable contribution to the observation of the kaleidoscopic richness of Islamist politics in Turkey.
