J. V. Field once asked, ‘what is scientific about a scientific instrument?’ The present volume of essays on the illustration of medically orientated texts raises the parallel question: what is medical about medical illustration?
The closely focused and generally accomplished essays range across various herbals and botanical books, illustrations to Pico della Mirandola's Pliny, aristocratic compilations on health, the anatomies of Leonardo, and images of the temperaments in the sixteenth century. Not all of these fit even loosely within the ostensible classification of ‘medieval’. Nevertheless, the factors that lay behind Field's question – patronage, production, cost, ownership, distribution and utility – are all relevant here. What survives is exceptional, not just in terms of happy accidents but also with regard to the luxurious, often aristocratic and collectable nature of what was best fitted to survive. In short, the less typical and utilitarian an object was, the more likely it was to be cherished over the ages. This bias is now reinforced by scholars' understandable focus on spectacular texts with notable illustrations.
The question of for whom the manuscripts or printed volumes were made is crucial. Where the initial owner of a manuscript can be identified, they fall into various major camps: aristocratic (as with Gian Galeazzo Visconti in Milan), high-level learned (Pico della Mirandola, also aristocratic) and institutional (guild, university and so on). It is rare to be able to point to a surgeon or physician in professional practice as the patron or even the first owner of one of the manuscripts. If there are examples in the book, I have missed them. Most of the luxury products come into the category of textual and visual boasting by those searching for remuneration or employment.
This means that the items' relationship to medical practice is problematic. This is highlighted by the issue of naturalism, which does not map neatly onto utility. High naturalism in its earlier phases was exclusive and expensive, often being used to seduce the patron rather than to provide information for the practitioner. Indeed, many of the most elaborate illustrations were not directly involved in instruction or in the conveying of practical information. The herbals, with their tradition of naturalism, are a partial exception, but the examples that flourish the most striking illustrations were not in the hands of those who practised physic in the community. Generally the level of naturalism declines in the more utilitarian texts, especially early printed ones. With plants this did not matter too much, since a schematic rendering, like diagrams of Linnaean flower parts, could serve the herbalist's immediate function of identifying adequately.
When printed botanical books were overtaken by extensive suites of naturalistic illustrations, above all with Leonhart Fuch's De historia stirpium of 1542, they mutated into luxurious printed picture books of high cost, particularly if hand-coloured. Initially they inserted themselves primarily into the market occupied by illuminated manuscripts rather than creating the new wider market that was later to arise. Inventories testify that great printed books of science like Vesalius's Fabrica (1543) were valued at the same level as hand-produced volumes on vellum. The high naturalism of such books became an intellectual ambition, manifesting a great new method, as the authors rhetorically declared. They did not claim to be communicating to the masses, even to the professional masses. Vesalius's great book was directed, not least, at Charles V, his future employer. It did its job well.
The role of the new modes of representation in science needs more nuanced handling than it tended to receive in the past. There are welcome signs of this in the present volume. The incidents that attract most attention are unlikely to be typical, Leonardo's anatomical studies not least. It is now evident, following the researches of Domenico Laurenza, that Leonardo began with some conventional rudiments of medical knowledge (most notably in the ‘situs figure’, Windsor 12597) in his early period in Florence. In Milan he was in contact with the rich practice of Sforza-sponsored medicine, as is shown here, and in Florence he undertook an ‘autopsy’ on a man of a hundred years of age in the hospital of S. M. Nuova. The context may look normal but what he did was not. How many post-mortem anatomies – ‘autopsy’ is a rather anachronistic term for the period – resulted in a complete quest into the irrigation systems of the body, and a series of drawings in which this knowledge was synthesized into extraordinary three-dimensional renditions using all known and many new illustrative techniques? The answer is, of course, none. When Leonardo picks up the technique of the ‘nature printing’ of leaves, he characteristically proposes revising it so that the parts of the leaf that are ‘in relief’ – the veins and so on – will be printed white on a dark background. Not least, he showed remarkably little interest in any aspect of medical practice. Anatomy for Leonardo was a foundational science apparently detached in his mind from orthodox medical utility.
Our safest generalization about the material in this book is that nothing can be taken as typical. A book of health lavishly illustrated with activities in the countryside for a patron who cherished beautiful manuscripts, a Pliny illuminated in close collaboration with a rich philosopher who owned a thousand books, a sumptuous herbal and Leonardo's notebooks are very different kinds of things. Even if we look within one genre, say the herbals, the range is considerable but rarely extends to the rudely utilitarian. This does not mean to say that we cannot draw coherent conclusions, but it does indicate that the window we are opening onto medical practice through the study of illustrated texts discloses only a small and socially exclusive portion of the total medical landscape of the late Middle Ages and Renaissance.
