Marylin M. Rhie's Early Buddhist Art of China and Central Asia, Vol. 3, is a study of Buddhist sculpture during the Western Qin kingdom (385–400; 409–431) in Gansu province of northwestern China. The short-lived and somewhat minor kingdom has had relatively little impact on Chinese history writing. This superbly researched and explicated study of more than 500 pages challenges any assumption of the insignificance of Western Qin in the history of Buddhist art. Instead, by the end of the book, the reader is convinced that a pivotal monument in Buddhist art history, probably the pivotal monument of the Sixteen Kingdoms period (304–439), dates to the last third of Western Qin rule and is in eastern Gansu province.
Different from previous volumes of Rhie's study, Vol. 3 does not divide into works from China and those from Central Asia. Rather, its focus and climax are one site, Binglingsi (Wade-Giles: Ping-ling ssu),Footnote 1 the subject of the middle five of the nine-chapter book. Logically conceived and clearly written, the first chapter introduces the Western Qin rulers and Buddhism. A dynasty of only four rulers of the Qifu family, it was an age of cross-continental travel by Buddhist monks. They include the famous Faxian who journeyed from China to India around the year 400. Chapter Two introduces a unique gilt-bronze Buddhist statue found in Jiuquan, Gansu province. Rhie relates it to the famous gilt-bronze Buddha from 338 in the Asian Art Museum, San Francisco, and other contemporary gilded images discussed in earlier volumes. The author also notes its relation to statues from Baoding, Hebei, with the same shape of mandorla, and she highlights the distinctive features that including dangling gold disks originally attached to the statue's canopy. The disks, Rhie rightly points out, suggest relations to crowns with decorative dangling pieces used across North Asia from Afghanistan to the Yan states of Liaoning at the same time. Just a chapter into the book, then, the strengths of Rhie's scholarship shine forth. The author intimately knows Buddhist sculpture from every part of China and Central Asia in the years that are her subject and from the periods before and after. This link from Gansu in western China, farther west to Afghanistan, and to easternmost continental Asia sets the stage for analysis of paintings and sculpture from Binglingsi.
Binglingsi is now on the tourist route along the Silk Roads and may be known to readers. The first Binglingsi chapter introduces the site, first through textual accounts and then through the monumental Buddha image in niche no. 1. Another fairly short chapter, Rhie brings in comparative material from the Gandhāran region and Afghanistan, specifically from Bamiyan, to argue for a pre-fourth-century date. Thus the reader is prepared for the seminal cave at Binglingsi, Cave 169, and a re-evaluation of its iconography and date.
Chapter Four focuses on the west wall of Cave 169. Description is detailed, and Rhie has a purpose in the careful observation. As each image becomes a focus, texts about its possible iconography are presented, many in Rhie's own translations. Turning to evaluation, comparisons are drawn from images as nearby as Maijishan and as distant as Bamiyan in Afghanistan and the Korea Koguryŏ kingdom. The author challenges every possible assumption, and while she concludes that the focus of the three main sets of deities may be the Buddhas of the past, present, and future, she reminds the reader that no text or treatise confirms even the grouping of images, that there is no reliable formula for order of excavation, and there is no obvious grand scheme. This is the central theme and challenge of the volume. Marylin Rhie proceeds to study the east and south walls in similar fashion in Chapter Five. Through inscriptions she is able to relate sculpture to painting. By now the set of images known as Group 23, five Dhyanasana Buddhas, and dates become significant. All dates presented at this point range between 400 and 424.
Chapter Six is the first of two chapters devoted to the south wall of Binglingsi Cave 169, together fully one-third of the book. Fourteen groups of sculpture are involved. Gandhāran evidence looms large in the discussion and the important statues of the Amitayus triad known as Group 6 are identified through inscriptions and specifically related to Gandhāran sources. Inscriptions and murals of Cave 169 are the subjects of Chapter Seven. Arguing that Group 6 must postdate the presentation of the Sukhāvatīvyūha Sutra in 421, and probably the completion of the Avatamsaka (Huayan) Sutra in 422, Rhie dates the statues to 424. Among the many interesting points in Chapter Seven are that the monk (bhikhu) Daorong may be among the donor figures, that the monk Kumarajiva may have been the first to refer to the Yaowang Fo (the healing Buddha), that aspects of the sculpture of the north wall relate to South Chinese sculpture, and that the donors depicted in Group 6 may be from one family.
Rhie is now able to assess Binglingsi Cave 169 as a whole. She has demonstrated that carving began around 375, probably with the standing Buddha in Niche 1. The earliest painting was rendered about a quarter-of-a-century later. Groups 20 and 23, and perhaps a few other grottoes, date to the middle period of carving, the first two decades of the fifth century. The year 424 is confirmed for the north wall triad of Amitayus, Avalokitesvara, and Mahasthamaprapta. Slightly later images, with dates as late as 431, include Groups 7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, and 19. The last period, 420–431, is richly endowed with sutras newly translated into Chinese. Before concluding the chapter Rhie introduces the little known cave site Yejigou whose paintings are contemporary with the last Binglingsi period.
In Chapter Eight Rhie returns to Gandhāra, beginning with sites Buddhist monks who traversed Binglingsi may have seen. She argues that Binglingsi draws from many of them, with Takht-i-Bahi one of the most important. Rhie further shows connections between imagery at Binglingsi Cave 169 and sites across Afghanistan, recognising that stylistic development does not always follow a clear, linear pattern. The chapter ends with one of the most important sections of the book, Rhie's new understanding of five-Buddha iconography. Querying arrangements of five as three images and two as opposed to four images plus one, the author turns to the five caves at Yungang associated with the monk Tanyao. She argues that the five main Buddhas in caves 16–20 at Yungang can be considered as three plus two and as four plus one. Showing Tanyao to have been familiar with the Buddhist art of Gandhāra, Rhie presents all possible iconographic identifications of the five deities before concluding that they represent a kind of intermediate stage in a five-Buddha presentation, a very early moment in the development of Esoteric Buddhist imagery when Gandhāran Buddhism is on the wane and nearly two centuries before the serious rise of Esotericism in China. The pivotal position of these five Yungang caves in the narrative of Chinese and Buddhist art is uncontested, but the iconographic programme has not been solved. It should be expected that Rhie's ideas will be associated with five-Buddha arrangements hereafter, and that they may be debated.
The last chapter introduces the Qin-period caves, Cave 78 and Cave 74, at the rock-carved cave-temples of Maijishan, just west of Taiyuan in Shanxi province. The two open niches with colossal images are suggested to have unified iconographic schemes, traceable to Gandhāran imagery. Rhie argues their dates as 405–410 and 410–420, respectively, the middle period of Binglingsi. She further shows that their explanation is grounded in the Lotus Sutra. Appendixes of routes from Gansu westward to Central Asia and beyond and of sutras important to the study are found at the end.
Marylin Rhie summarises her conclusions well on pp. 507–511. Chronology and iconography of the Binglingsi statuary, especially Cave 169, are central. So are the monks Tanmabi and Daorong. The cave sculpture of eastern Gansu has been connected to that of Gandhāra and Afghanistan, and of China's Southern Dynasties, and the relation between early fifth-century painting and sculpture has been shown. Perhaps most impressive is that Rhie has confirmed that every detail of Binglingsi's extremely complicated Cave 169 is intentional and further, that each later detail of this cave was executed in response to, or to build upon, earlier ones. The concept of an inter-related, composite cave temple has long been queried by scholars, but rarely can it be proved. Here it is proved for one of the most complex caves in China or Central Asia. Explication of every Buddhist cave-temple as a unified entity may not be possible, but surely it should be sought. As the earlier volumes in this study, every image discussed is illustrated, often from multiple views and sometimes with Rhie's own line drawings.
With volume three, Early Buddhist Art of China and Central Asia has reached a new level and thereby changed course. The meticulous research and careful analysis and presentation in volumes one and two remain but, whereas the earlier books cover approximately a century and distribute attention across the eastern side of the Asian continent, this volume focuses on eastern Gansu of much shorter duration. No similarly detailed study of Buddhist art and its textual basis has been achieved, and thus the standards for scholarly analysis of Buddhist interior space have been raised. It goes without saying that Marilynn Rhie's Handbuchen are unlikely to be surpassed. Indeed, the focus of this book leads one to anticipate as many as ten volumes before the series is completed.
