The Council at Nicaea in 325, the quarrels that led up to it and the controversies that stemmed from it dominated the theological landscape for the great bulk of the fourth century. A flood of scholarly writing has addressed its events and meaning. Lewis Ayres has managed to produce a volume that not only serves to organise and respond to much of the modern scholarship on the period, but also strives to take a broader, more representative view of the era's thinkers and writers. An explicit awareness of the current importance of the original discussions is a welcome feature of this work.
The work is divided into two main sections: a narrative of the controversy and the developments it helped to spur and an attempt to isolate and describe the main lineaments of what he calls ‘pro-Nicene Theology’. A final chapter, discussing some lines of movement in the modern scholarly approaches to the period, and an interesting epilogue, ‘On Teaching the Fourth Century’, conclude his offering.
As he begins his journey, Ayres makes clear that he has chosen certain tasks that he would like to accomplish: he would like to try to show that the common division of the theological debate into eastern and western realms is too glib and does not truly represent what the sources show us; he would like to demonstrate that one of the main topics of debate were ‘the “grammar” of human speech about the divine’ (showing that the disagreement reached all the way down to theological bedrock); he would like to argue that those involved in the debates were concerned more with ‘debates about the generation of the Word or Son from the Father’ than with questions of Christ's status ‘as “divine” or “not divine”’. More basically, and, in my opinion, more likely to provoke an energetic response in the long run, Ayres tries to cast his net more widely than the standard works that have gone before him by including figures whose contributions have been underplayed or completely overlooked. The most glaring of these omissions, in my mind, has been the complete neglect of Ephraem the Syrian, who makes an appearance in Ayres's narrative, and so begins the final stage in recognition that those who read his writings have awaited for more than a century. In this regard, Ayres's work ushers in a new stage of serious engagement with the past and he should receive grateful recognition for his willingness to go where others have not cared to venture, though I wonder at Ephraem's not being consulted with reference to his very fully developed ideas of theological reserve.
What does Ayres see when he looks at this fraught and frantic period in the life of Christianity and in the life of the later Roman Empire? We cannot attempt a full account here, but certain elements push themselves forward to gain the reader's notice. Ayres is careful to point out a number of times when it seems truer to the evidence to understand the participants as driven by deeply felt ‘religious’ motives, rather than by philosophical or theological constructs. What Maurice Wiles has done in making Eunomius a more humane figure in our eyes, Ayres tries to do also with the Cappadocians, especially Basil and Gregory of Nyssa, both of whom receive intelligent and very helpful attention in this book. Another strand in his argument that seems particularly well founded is his contention that the arguments arising over the course of the period are evidence of a wide variety of theological approaches and positions existing among Christians before the century began. Others have argued this before him, but Ayres supports the suggestion with a sustained effort to demonstrate how long the process of developing new consensuses actually was and how many different stages there were along the way. Ayres also explicitly resists creating a theological taxonomy of the period, holding that any such scheme would give a false clarity and formality to groups that changed over time, had little sense of themselves and no formal organisation. His insistence, and demonstration, that the Nicene group was deeply variable in its expression and general understanding is a welcome corrective to those who imagine variety only on the other side of the debate.
Ayres describes this position towards the development of the Controversy as ‘strongly revisionist’. It may be a sign of my being a member of the same academic generation as Ayres, but I do not think that this position is one that can readily be questioned. I do think, however, that he makes this important point more successfully than any other modern treatment of the period I have seen, to date. This fact, that the different theological positions were present already in the church before the outbreak of the public phase of the argument is a very important piece of background to fix in the heads of students, who still tend to imagine an initial period of doctrinal purity, in the face of scriptural evidence. The conclusion that the arguments of the fourth century were, in large part, a competition between the variant tacit understandings of commonly acceptable baptismal creeds and rules of faith gives a very different flavour to how we read the arguments that survive. (It explains, for example, why those of all parties express honest feelings of betrayal when they realise what other people had been thinking was the accepted teaching of the church.) Ayres's description of this view of the period's dynamics will, I hope, help support its taking a more prominent place in the classroom.
In his useful final chapter, Ayres contrasts the epistemological reserve central to the pro-Nicene approach to trinitarian theology and Christology with the current trends in theological reflection. He shows the current divorce between theology and religious life as well as the great difference in the latent ideas of God that existed, unexpressed, in the minds of the pro-Nicenes of the fourth century and that inhabit the minds of many present-day theologians. Is it unfair to say that God seems to exist more vividly as a subject of study than as a living being for many currently active theological professionals? Reading Ayres's last chapter discussing how the moderns have dealt with and appreciated the fourth century leads one to think so.
The argument of his final chapter deserves to be aired here. His evaluation of how our times connect with the fourth century is based on both theological and historical grounds. Ayres's position is ‘not that modern Trinitarianism has engaged with pro-Nicene theology badly, but that it has barely engaged with it at all’. His goal in making his case is to sharpen the contours of our picture of the movements in Christian theology in the fourth century and to urge the theological academy to engage with the fourth century as we are coming to know it. Only by making use of the best knowledge we have and taking seriously what we have learned can modern theologians really do theology in dialogue with the formative fourth century.
Ayres's presentation makes clear the fascinating swirl of different ideas that the fourth century displayed about how to read scripture, how to speak about the nature of God, the appropriate limits of theological speculation, the relation of God to the creation and the effect of that relation on human nature and freedom. Any reader who works through the mass of judgements Ayres presents would probably wish to take issue with him for his conclusions on some details, but I think that students of the period will be grateful for his efforts at sorting out the tangle of those times and trying to present them to us in a shape that will help us see them clearly and engage with them fruitfully. Ayres's work marks another step forward in our grasp of this crucial period in the history of Christian thought.
