The growing accessibility of archival sources is enabling historians to reassess the economic transformations of the first decades following the post-communist transition in Central and Eastern Europe. By bringing previously inaccessible evidence into view, a historical perspective makes it possible to recover the contingency, complexity and diversity of these transformations. A more nuanced and less implicitly normative account of what has often been regarded as one of the most consequential social transformations in postwar European history is therefore beginning to emerge, through numerous case studies that illuminate overlooked particularities as well as the long-forgotten meanders, dead ends and diversions of political and social processes whose legacies continue to influence the region to this day.
A reader interested in recent research on the post-communist transformation and, importantly, its prehistory in the late socialist period, may already be familiar with the book series Studien zur Geschichte der Treuhandanstalt (Studies on the History of the Treuhandanstalt), published by the Institut für Zeitgeschichte in Munich and Berlin. The Treuhandanstalt was the German trust agency established in 1990 to privatise and restructure the former East Germany’s state-owned enterprises following reunification. As of January 2026, the series comprises eleven monographs, all of them recently made available as free downloads. The nine volumes dedicated to archival research on East Germany’s economic transformation make it the most thoroughly analysed Central European post-communist country with regard to privatisation, deregulation, deindustrialisation and the ways these processes were negotiated, implemented, debated and contested in the early 1990s. The remaining two monographs direct their attention abroad: Eva Schäffler’s Der Weg in die Marktwirtschaft (The Road to the Market Economy) examines Czechia, while German historian Florian Peters’s Von Solidarność zur Schocktherapie: Wie der Kapitalismus nach Polen kam (From Solidarność to Shock Therapy: How Capitalism Came to Poland) focuses on Poland. The forerunner of liberal economic reforms in the region, Hungary, unfortunately remains beyond the scope of the series.
Florian Peters’s almost 550-page monograph reconstructs how capitalism became politically conceivable, socially acceptable and institutionally achievable in Poland between the crisis of late socialism and the early post-communist period. Rather than treating 1989 as a self-evident rupture or the Balcerowicz reforms as the straightforward implementation of a ready-made neoliberal programme, Peters traces the longer and more contingent transformation of economic ideas, expectations and everyday practices during the 1980s. Particular attention is paid to the emergence of ‘shock therapy’: the rapid package of macroeconomic stabilisation and market-liberalising measures introduced at the beginning of 1990, including price liberalisation, restrictive monetary and fiscal policies, and the opening of the economy to market competition. Peters also stresses that this programme should not simply be equated with rapid privatisation, which followed a slower and more contested trajectory.
The book’s very first scholarly contribution lies in the way it prioritises analytical distance over taking a clear political stance, a characteristic of monographs written by engaged experts or figures that were politically active at the time.Footnote 1 A distinctive strength of the monograph is its unusually broad source base. Peters combines the records of the Polish United Workers’ Party, the Council of Ministers, the state-security apparatus, the International Monetary Fund, opinion polls and both official and underground periodicals. This enables him to reconstruct not only negotiations between late socialist leaders, Solidarność activists, reform economists and Western advisers, but also the changing intellectual landscape in which economic liberalism emerged from a marginal current into the dominant reform paradigm.
One of the book’s most original contributions is its reconstruction of this ideological shift. Peters shows that throughout much of the 1980s the opposition remained committed to workers’ self-management, while liberal economic ideas were largely confined to marginal figures such as philosophers Janusz Korwin-Mikke and Mirosław Dzielski. Only gradually did market liberalism gain support among expert circles and, under mounting economic pressure, within the communist leadership itself. At the same time, Solidarność increasingly reinterpreted workers’ self-management in terms of employee ownership rather than collective control. By 1989, advocates of market liberalism had developed a coherent reform programme, whereas supporters of employee-centred alternatives had not, leaving the former to dominate the political window of opportunity. This agency-centred approach differentiates the book from more intellectual histories of Polish economic liberalism (or simply neoliberalism, the term preferred by the author), such as Jerzy Szacki’s Liberalism after Communism or the more recent Jaki liberalizm? (What Liberalism?) by Lech Mażewski. It is precisely this combination of intellectual and political history based upon extensive use of primary sources that makes Peters’s book invaluable.Footnote 2 The book is accessible to readers without prior in-depth knowledge of the history of late socialist Poland, although they should possess a general understanding of developments in the Eastern Bloc after the Second World War.
One can hardly avoid comparing this book with The Triumph of Broken Promises by the American historian Fritz Bartel. Both authors examine the rise of neoliberal policies during the 1970s and 1980s, and Bartel himself acknowledges the significant influence of Mieczysław Rakowski’s memoirs on his work.Footnote 3 Their analytical perspectives, however, differ markedly. Whereas Bartel emphasises the constraining effects of external economic pressures—most notably the oil shocks of the 1970s and the Gierek leadership’s growing dependence on foreign credit to sustain consumer demand—Peters directs greater attention to developments within the Polish political and intellectual elites. He demonstrates how these external pressures, which Bartel largely treats as structural constraints on political agency, were interpreted by contemporary actors and translated into concrete political strategies and decisions. Both, albeit from different perspectives, illustrate the gradual narrowing of the political elite’s space for political manoeuvre and, without resorting to materialist (resources-focused) or idealist (neoliberal) determinism, demonstrate how the departure from socialist modernity was, over the course of the 1980s, increasingly becoming the likely policy option.
It is against these two books that the reader can assess the scope of Poland’s problems in the early 1980s. As highlighted by Bartel, these included high rates of debt. Nonetheless, despite the debt emergency, Peters shows how Polish economic experts were generally uninterested in thinking through possible ways of imposing austerity measures until the second half of the 1980s. The contrast between the powerful external pressures and the efforts of economic experts (largely siding with the opposition trade union movement Solidarność) seen elsewhere – mostly relating to the re-organisation of authority in the workplace and establishment of some form of workers’ co- or even self-management (samorząd) – reveals an important feature of how neoliberal thinking developed in Poland and post-communist Central and Eastern Europe. Peters explicitly challenges the retrospective reinterpretation of Polish political and economic thinking in the early 1980s in terms of neoliberal hegemony, and shows how later neoliberal pioneers like Leszek Balcerowicz or Janusz Lewandowski first developed labour-oriented reform proposals instead of pursuing a ‘privatize – liberalize – deregulate’ approach. Such reflections render his book at odds with some memoirs published by these figures in later decades (p. 68). This is also one of the book’s major contributions: by comparing the retrospective recollections of different actors, Peters is able to strip away the layers of later self-fashioning that have come to shape their accounts.
A simultaneous reading of Peters’s and Bartel’s books reveals a striking paradox. While The Triumph of Broken Promises argues that by 1980–1 leading Polish communist figures such as Wojciech Jaruzelski, Stanisław Kania and Mieczysław Rakowski saw little room for any response to the crisis other than fiscal austerity, Von Solidarność zur Schocktherapie shows that Solidarność-aligned economists, including Leszek Balcerowicz, had not yet embraced neoliberal principles, perhaps because these still lay beyond the bounds of what seemed politically feasible under the socialist dictatorship. Read together, the two books depict communist leaders advocating Thatcherite-style austerity while facing resistance from the Solidarność opposition, which continued to defend workers’ self-management and egalitarian ideals. Ironically, many of those opposing austerity would later become leading advocates of neoliberal reform. This substantially complicates the conventional picture of a confrontation between a socialist dictatorship and a democratic opposition by revealing a less intuitive divide over economic policy. Peters places particular emphasis on the role of Wojciech Jaruzelski, arguing (following Karol Modzelewski) that ‘it was Jaruzelski who paved the way for Balcerowicz’ (p. 417).
Von Solidarność zur Shocktherapie does not adhere to a single analytical framework, but implicitly presents its explanatory line as an answer to several key questions, some of which are even mentioned in the subchapters’ titles (‘How to retain power in Poland?’, ‘On the road to socialist Thatcherism?’, ‘The radically pro-market shock therapy as an import from the West?’). All of these build up to answering the central inquiry from the monograph’s subtitle ‘How capitalism came to Poland’. What the reader encounters, therefore, is a sequence of explanations and nuanced statements rather than a single overarching conclusion of the kind offered by Bartel, which makes Peters’s book a more demanding read. Many of Peters’s findings deserve particular attention, as they highlight important features of the political process through which the groundwork for capitalism was laid. While Solidarność was fundamentally an anti-dictatorial movement, Peters’s focus on its economic programme and egalitarian language of protest highlights the centrality of its trade union roots. This aspect of the Polish protest movement, analysed by Peters, invites comparison with developments in East Germany and Czechoslovakia in 1989, where popular protests likewise linked discontent with communist rule to calls for social and economic self-organisation, and even to the invocation of workplace-democracy values.Footnote 4 In all three cases, however, these largely labour-oriented tendencies later had to be reconciled with emerging forms of industrial relations that did not allow for the degree of labour-interest representation expected by many protesters.
The tension between the increasingly neoliberal-oriented modes of economic governance adopted by post-communist governments and the labour-oriented aspirations articulated in the preceding months and years was present both in Poland and in Czechoslovakia, though it translated differently into concrete reform policies. This difference is particularly visible in the ways post-communist governments addressed questions of ownership transformation. Peters shows that support for employee ownership became a retreat position for those who, by the end of the 1980s, had concluded that extensive workers’ co-management would have to be curtailed in order to enable macroeconomic stabilisation, but who did not wish to abandon the cause of labour-oriented reform altogether. Employee- and management-centred privatisation indeed became a sort of first-line solution in Poland and was widely used in the early 1990s, whereas in Czechoslovakia it was – after a brief period of initial support in 1990 – lambasted and sidelined as crypto-socialist, insufficiently radical and fundamentally unjust. Peters shows that similar critical voices, arguing against prioritising employees over, for example, the general public (through voucher schemes), could also be heard in Poland, but never gained the same momentum as in Czechoslovakia. In East Germany, the comparatively weaker labour-oriented protests of 1989 did not translate into privatisation policy at all, as privatisation was organised mainly without the direct involvement of broad segments of the public, whether employees or participants in mass voucher schemes.
Comparing Peters’s analysis of the Polish ownership debate with the existing research on Czechoslovakia highlights the importance of Solidarność’s legacy in shaping discussions about what reform measures (beyond the Balcerowicz plan) would look like. The prospect of workers mobilising against the reform policies in the name of co-management was an important factor the Polish policymakers had to be aware of (p. 438). In both countries, ambitions to establish co-management (Mitbestimmung) as a central feature of the emerging industrial relations largely failed to materialise and were instead deliberately diverted into the ownership debate, where they produced only modest results. Even in Poland, where the employees got a greater chance to become co-owners, their position was often substantially weakened by the managers’ and foreign investors’ share (pp. 472–4).
Another example of how similar reform measures were framed differently in national political debates – and consequently provoked different reactions – is the legalisation of private business activity. Peters underlines the importance of the so-called Lex Wilczek of December 1988, which enabled extensive asset-stripping within still state-owned enterprises and effectively made the late-socialist nomenklatura the first social group capable of privatising. While this ‘nomenklatura privatization’ raised concerns among some Sejm deputies, it did not translate into tangible countermeasures, such as restrictions on acquiring formerly state-owned assets (p. 437). By contrast, a broadly similar development in Czechoslovakia – where, following the May 1990 laws legalising private business, a form of nomenklatura-driven spontaneous privatisation emerged – triggered a political crisis.Footnote 5 Economic liberals were quick to capitalise on this crisis in order to mobilise support for a radical and large-scale privatisation scheme. In Hungary, by comparison to Poland, private businesses had been operating for years, and no comparable shock occurred.Footnote 6 Clearly, the ways in which distributive justice was negotiated during the transformation differed across all three Visegrád countries, as did public sensitivity to former political elites being granted opportunities to convert their social capital into advantages within the new system.
Peters’s work offers another point of comparison by examining popular sentiments and the public mood surrounding economic reforms, particularly privatisation. As in East Germany – where Treuhandanstalt-led privatisation quickly became associated with corruption, unemployment and deindustrialisation despite early hopes that it might lead to outcomes other than a rapid sell-off to West German firms – Peters portrays the Polish case as similarly marked by a notable lack of enthusiasm.Footnote 7 Privatisation was framed as an unavoidable necessity and was accompanied by a rather cool and restrained public mood, given concerns about speculators and Western businessowners. When Peters turns to the point at which neoliberalism emerged as the dominant rationale of economic governance, he argues that alternative worldviews had simply been exhausted, leaving neoliberal individualism as the last ideological option (p. 484). This was actually welcomed by the early post-communist policy makers, as illustrated by a statement made by Waldemar Kuczyński, then minister of privatisation, who publicly praised ‘apathy’, i.e. public disengagement from politics, so long as it coincided with individuals ‘taking their future into their own hands’ in the economic sphere (p. 488). No wave of enthusiasm for privatisation comparable to those surrounding the voucher privatisation scheme in Czechoslovakia in 1992 emerged in either Poland or East Germany, and its authors were unable to generate widespread optimism or expectations of a brighter economic future. This also helps explain why support for Poland’s radical liberal reforms failed to endure: they never passed through an initial phase of widespread enthusiasm, only one of pragmatic acceptance.
A closer examination of the Solidarność-aligned milieu shows that situating many of the reform ideas developed during the 1980s within the simple binarity of ‘socialism vs. capitalism’ or simply putting them under the vague label of ‘third ways’ without further specification substantially flattens the complexity of the contemporary intellectual landscape of Polish oppositional economic and political thought. Peters convincingly deconstructs this retrospective neoliberalisation, for example by demonstrating that the concept of a form of ‘shock therapy’ was in fact already invoked by Balcerowicz as early as 1980 (pp. 100–1), but lacked both the scope and the qualitative meaning of the radical market leap undertaken after 1989. Similarly, the search for a ‘concrete owner’, understood as an actor endowed with substantial ownership rights and the authority to modernise the enterprises, can be traced within Solidarność as far back as 1985 (p. 214). At that stage, however, it was linked not to privatisation but to the empowerment of workers’ councils. Peters’s reconstruction also suggests that the famous TINA (‘there is no alternative’) framing became dominant only after the decision in favour of a market economy had already been made, retrospectively recasting earlier debates into a polarised opposition between supporters and opponents of the supposedly ‘only possible’ path. His analysis thus encourages the reader to disentangle historical aspirations from the retrospective reinterpretations shaped by TINA-style thinking.
Some of the findings presented in Von Solidarność zur Shocktherapie are only briefly explained and would benefit from further elaboration and comparison with other research. Peters’s analysis of labour-oriented political thought shows how strongly the Polish self-management movement was embedded in the national context and how the Polish experience with the post-1956 work councils shaped it. By contrast, the contemporary Yugoslav experience played a relatively minor role in conceptualising a labour-oriented economy, despite the decades-long efforts of Tito’s regime to position itself as a world leader in the field.
The final part of the book turns to the role of Solidarność trade unions at the enterprise level in the 1990s, and shows how tame these were in negotiating with new owners and managers (p. 474), a pattern that aligns with the broader trend of decline in unionisation across the continent.Footnote 8 Peters’s explanation that this can be interpreted as a side-effect of a conscious strategy pursued by Solidarność’s enterprise-level representatives, who wanted to present themselves as a modernising force, offers a plausible explanation for why the demise of organised labour in the region was so quick and occurred without major clashes and union busting. Peters’s book is, therefore, well positioned to become a significant scholarly contribution to the rich and complex history of capitalist restoration in Poland and an important point of reference for future research on the post-communist transformation of East Central Europe.
Vaclav Rames is a historian at the Institute of Contemporary History of the Czech Academy of Sciences. His research focuses primarily on the history of postsocialism, economic policy, and social history, particularly the transformation of ownership and labour relations. He is the author of the monograph A Free Market or Economic Democracy? (2021), which examines debates over property transformation in post-revolutionary Czechoslovakia, as well as studies on economic thought, privatization, and changing industrial relations.
