This edited book aims to address a number of different issues about musical creativity, including: How can it be defined? How might it be developed in different learners at different ages? How do players improvise collaboratively, and how is creativity used for a variety of purposes? In his introduction, the editor Oscar Odena tells us that it is written by 11 international experts (drawn from four continents), and that the broad focus is on studies of composition and improvisation, as well as collaborative performance and practitioner-led research. These opening questions imply that the book will adopt a fairly traditional conceptualisation of musical creativity.
The traditional conception of creativity is increasingly being challenged by authors in different disciplines. The basic problem is that of overgeneralisation: since creativity exists in so many different forms, activities and contexts, the formulation of unitary descriptions or explanations are doomed to failure. Cook (Reference COOK, Hargreaves, Miell and Macdonald2012) points out that the term refers to ‘an indefinite number of related concepts or behaviours’, such that it may be better instead to speak of multiple ‘creativities’. Whereas the traditional view of creativity is of a special individual gift which is conferred on rare geniuses such as Mozart, Cook suggests that it ‘revolves round social interaction, and is embedded and embodied in the practices of everyday life’ (p. 451). It is more useful to think in terms of ‘distributed creativity’: to consider that individual's social and family background, his or her interactions with significant others in their environment, as well as the current cultural and political climate. My own work has suggested, further, that creativity is only one facet of a much broader phenomenon, the central core of which is imagination, which incorporates creative perception as well as production: studies of creative listening are relatively few and far between (Hargreaves, Reference HARGREAVES2012).
Pamela Burnard does express some aspects of this view in Chapter 1 of the book, arguing for a rethinking of the concept of musical creativity, and like Cook (Reference COOK, Hargreaves, Miell and Macdonald2012), for its replacement by the notion of ‘multiple creativities’ which take on board the socially situated perspective mentioned above. She sees musical creativities as existing within ‘different cultural, social and historical activity systems’, and draws on some ideas from cultural-historical activity theory, on Bourdieu's sociologically based ideas about ‘habitus’ and ‘practice’, as well as on Czikszentmihalyi's ‘systems perspective’ on creativity. She also uses some descriptive accounts of her own research to illustrate this perspective. With the exception of this opening chapter, however, there is little attempt in the rest of the book to engage directly with theoretical issues. Barrett's chapter adopts a broadly socio-cultural theoretical approach, Soares adopts activity theory in explaining the results of his research on Brazilian adolescents’ composing activities, and Webster's chapter on the role of the teacher in helping pupils to revise their compositions could have had an explicit Vygotskian basis – but these issues appear to have had little or no impact in the planning of the book.
The book is organised into three sections. Part 1, ‘Conceptualizing musical creativity’, consists of just two chapters: after Burnard's opening contribution, Odena and Welch offer a brief review of the recent educational policy developments in the UK with respect to musical creativity, followed by a description of a research project which investigated six English secondary school teachers’ perceptions of creativity, and which gave rise to a ‘generative model’ of how teachers’ thinking about creativity may develop over time.
Part 2, ‘Examples from practice’, has seven chapters which deal with ‘early music learning and engagement’ (Barrett); ‘composition as a way of learning: emotions and the situated self’ (Veloso and Carvalho), ‘pedagogies of revision’ in composition (Webster), composing by Brazilian adolescents (Soares), ‘empathetic creativity in music-making’ (Seddon), cognition and musical improvisation in individuals and groups (Hsieh) and a chapter by Leslie Bunt on his view of music therapy as ‘a resource for creativity, health and well-being across the life span’. This is quite a diverse selection of topics, but one feature which binds them together is that each author provides examples from his or her own research to illustrate the more general conceptual points.
Part 3, ‘Paths for further enquiry’, contains two chapters: ‘Action-research on collaborative composition: an analysis of research questions and designs’, by Gabriel Rusinek and ‘Perspectives on musical creativity: where next?’, by the editor. Rusinek's chapter offers a useful systematic comparison of nine empirical studies of collaborative creativity carried out in the USA, Spain, the UK and Iceland between 1994 and 2008, and Odena's reflections on the book as a whole lead him to four main conclusions: in brief, that the increased diversity of contemporary forms of musical expression in the mass media and online have not led to a clearer definition of musical creativity; that there is a great deal of local and international variation in the ways in which musical creativity is expressed; that emotion plays an important part in musical creativity; and that some clear practical implications for music education policy follow from these studies.
I think that conceptions of musical creativity have indeed moved on, as indicated at the start of this review, and that the abandonment of the term itself may be the best way of dealing with this: but I wholeheartedly agree with Odena's second and third conclusions. Indeed, I suspect that he may have missed a trick as far as his second point is concerned, since several of the authors with Hispanic origins from Spain, Portugal and Brazil, as well as the editor himself, could have valuable things to say about the processes of musical creativity from a specifically cross-cultural or international perspective. The environments and processes of musical creativity may well be different in these cultures: the informal nature of a good deal of South American music-making is well documented, for example, and many of these authors would have been well qualified to compare this approach with the Western classical canon. The way forward is to consider specific musical creativities within these different social, international and cultural contexts, thereby adopting a broader conception of creativity than is represented in this book.
