This is a nice volume that brings together work by experts around a common theme, the choices made by founding fathers. The value added of this volume, relative to reading the authors’ other writings, is the presentation of the choices made with respect to the constitution, money, trade, banking, corporations, land, labor, and intellectual property in a single setting. The introductory essay and the papers give the reader a sense of the totality of the choices that the founding fathers made. The papers are also relatively nontechnical, making them suitable for use in graduate or even undergraduate classes in economic, political, or social history.
In Chapter 1, Sonia Mittal, Jack N. Rakove, and Barry R. Weingast set the scene. The Articles of Confederation were not working. The federal government was basically bankrupt. Without at least a modest and permanent funding stream, nothing could be done. Other issues had to be ironed out as well, notably slavery and representation. So, the states met in Philadelphia and established a framework that would turn out to be remarkably adaptable.
Chapters 2 and 3, authored by Richard Sylla and Douglas A. Irwin, complement the first chapter by laying out in detail the means by which the federal financial problems were resolved. Sylla documents how Alexander Hamilton's deep knowledge and ambition, the Constitution, and a relatively cooperative Congress led to a financial revolution. The revolution was unparalleled historically because of its rapidity. In 1789 the country was in financial trouble. By 1793 it was on sound financial footing with a restructured national debt that included assumed state debts, adequate tax revenue, a sound banking system, and an active securities market. Irwin provides a very nice overview of choices regarding tax revenue and the political necessity of using federal customs duties as the primary source. Here too Hamilton played a central role in keeping matters on a steady keel, often working behind the scenes to head off choices likely to impair revenues.
Chapters 4 and 5, by Peter L. Rousseau and Howard Bodenhorn, address choices related to money and banking. Rousseau describes the switch to a specie-backed federal monetary system from an unbacked state system. This switch gave domestic and foreign investors greater confidence in the system and Congress the ability to control the money supply. Under this system, the money supply, financial aggregates, and private domestic investment grew steadily. Bodenhorn picks up the related issue of banking, tracing the influence of the Bank of the United States charter on state bank charters. Four features of the Bank of the United States charter were particularly influential—term limits, (partial) state ownership, branch banking, and internal voting rules.
Chapter 7, by Farley Grubb, in some ways belongs with these earlier chapters. He describes early land policy. One of the critical decisions involved cession of state holdings to the federal government. This gave the federal government an important asset that enhanced its financial credibility. Grubb explores options the government had with respect to land disposal.
Chapters 6 and 8, by John Joseph Wallis and Robert E. Wright, are a natural counterpoint to Chapter 1 and many of the other chapters. The Constitution and key decisions regarding debt, trade, money, and banking allowed the federal government to survive. At the same time, most of the actual governing was done by the states. As Wallis highlights, states made key decisions regarding suffrage, judges, banking, corporations, and the building of transportation infrastructure. They were laboratories of change and engines of economic growth. Wright complements Wallis's discussion by exploring the rise of corporations. Many of the choices evaluated by earlier authors came into play here. The availability of state charters for those with political connections (and eventually more broadly) and the existence of a single currency, banks, securities markets, and a national market opened up opportunities that were seized by entrepreneurs.
The economy was ultimately built on individual labor. Chapter 9, by Stanley L. Engerman and Robert A. Margo, covers a lot of ground—labor, education and training, health, and migration. As they note, the Constitution is remarkably silent on virtually all issues related to labor except slavery. At the same time, the existence of slave labor very likely had implications for free labor and the economy more broadly. In Chapter 10, B. Zorina Khan examines the intellectual property framework that provided inventors, authors, and artists with incentives to practice their crafts. Their efforts contributed to growth.
I have only a couple of minor complaints about the book. First, discussion of the political economy and voting interests of individuals at the Constitutional Convention receives no discussion. Perhaps the founding fathers made all the key decisions, but some discussion seems warranted given the enduring influence of Beard's arguments. Second, the volume might have felt more cohesive if the authors had explicitly referenced one another's papers more often. Overall, this is an excellent volume that many readers will find valuable.
