In 2001 Laurel Brake wrote an article entitled “On Print Culture: The State We're In.” Now, almost fifteen years later, where does the term “print culture” stand in relation to Victorian studies?Footnote 1 Brake was both brave and wise in her speculations. She knew very well that terminology – and fields and theories – have lives of their own and yet that sometimes someone has to step forward and try on certain names for size, make a pitch for style and fit and function. Brake took that risk in her endorsement of print culture. This essay considers the ways in which print culture has resonated in the intervening years by reviewing both books that have engaged productively with the term and books that have not used the term and yet are working under its umbrella.
This essay is less a stock taking, however, than a review article that bears in mind – and keeps at the forefront – the critical purchase of the term “print culture.” At the same time, it is by no means a comprehensive review essay. I hope that the result is not an inadequate treatment of both areas of focus – the salience of print culture as a category and the books under review – and I hope that it can begin to give some parameters to a term that is often loosely defined. This essay, then, is not a survey of the field. Indeed, when I was asked to do a review essay with a focus on print culture, I hesitated because I found the term too capacious. What, after all, does it not include? I thought that I would likely narrow my discussion, say, to periodicals. But as I scrutinized recent books with an eye to their engagement with print culture, I began to realize that it might be useful to articulate some aspects of the term that are not always articulated and think about its value, not in my kneejerk response to its capaciousness, but rather in the many ways in which the term is, in fact, delimited and productive in relation to those limits.
My first sense of the capaciousness of print culture relates to its affiliation with book history. Initially, I thought a review essay on book history would be more useful than an essay on print culture. Book history is a new field with relatively clear demarcations, whereas print culture includes book history and so much else. If book history leans toward (but is not defined by) material culture and print culture leans toward (but is not defined by) political culture, there is no question that print culture also embraces material culture. Indeed, there is no question that print culture gains its energy, in part, from the very “communications circuit” – Darnton's oft-cited phrase – that book history embraces.Footnote 2 Book history's society SHARP, after all, captures the network of interrelated aspects of print in its acronym: the society for the history of authorship, reading, and publishing. These ideas are taken up in both book history and print culture in relation to the production, distribution, circulation, and reception of texts. The field extends to include book-sellers, railway stands, government officials, censors, printers, and any number of other social actors and institutions that have a bearing on book or print production. Is print culture, then, just book history, only bigger?
Here it is helpful to turn to Roger Chartier's dual definition of print culture: in a broad sense, he notes, print culture refers to the circulation of print after Gutenberg; in a narrow sense, it refers to the uses to which that print is put and the new practices that emerge in its wake (including the use of printed matter as an object).Footnote 3 In terms of the former, Chartier writes, “[t]his new technique quite evidently encouraged the circulation of the written word on an unheard-of scale, not only because book making costs were lower. . . but also because production time. . . was shortened” (1). Elizabeth E. Eisenstein's The Printing Press as an Agent of Change (1979) is a foundational book in this context; it takes up the question of print in relation to the invention of the printing press and it (controversially) cements the powerful connection between print and political change.Footnote 4 Work on print culture, with its emphasis on periodicals and newspapers, often engages with a politics of print perceived to be inseparable from the culture of print. Many of the essays in the collection edited by Sabrina Baron et al., Agent of Change: Print Culture Studies after Elizabeth L. Eisenstein (2007), for example, both take issue with the charge of technological determinism in Eisenstein's work and testify to its continuing impact on “print culture studies.”
Consider too that commodious second word culture: book culture, literary culture, press culture, print culture (all phrases which occur in the books under review). Print culture differs from book history not only in the weight it places on print but also in the weight it places on culture. In a footnote, Ann Ardis and Patrick Collier make a pitch for the term “print culture” over “print media” in relation to Raymond Williams's tripartite definition of culture (10), and it is that expansive definition that resonates in references to print culture. If print culture embraces the book as well as other print forms, then, it also embraces history as well as culture. And yet. Book history is a clear area of study (indeed it is often capped as Book History) signaled not only in its name but also its institutional apparatus whereas print culture sits there more modestly with no society, no journal, and only the loosest claims to a field.Footnote 5 Indeed, in the books under review here many critics use the term simply to refer to a body of material rather than a critical practice.
Does it help, then, to turn to the specificity of the Victorian period itself to develop sharper distinctions? If the printing press occasions revolutionary changes in the circulation of print and, accordingly, the organization of knowledge, Chartier identifies the nineteenth century itself as “the age of the second revolution of the book” (2). Its moment, of course, is another new technology – the steam engine – which contributed to another, even more intense, acceleration of print production and dissemination in tandem with changes to industry, transportation, and literacy, making the nineteenth century, as many note, “the first mass-media era” (Hughes 1). It was in this period that the “proliferation of print” (an oft-repeated phrase) took hold in dramatic ways that are captured at once in the visual culture of the period and in the statistics critics routinely, and still with amazement, recount (see Liddle 147-48, Rubery 6, King and Plunkett 2). This accelerated print field generated readings of the relationship between print and democracy as well as challenges to a singular celebratory politics of print.
The nineteenth century as the “second revolution” of the book owes a debt to the first revolution of the printing press. But we gain new modes of access to it through the third “revolution in the making” (Brake, “On Print Culture” 126) – our current period – occasioned by the invention of new digital technologies. The late eighteenth century, however, is the go-to period for the scholarship on print culture that also shapes Victorian studies. Not yet galvanized by the innovations following from steam, print was powerfully wedded to politics in the decades following the French Revolution (see Keen, Klancher, and Gilmartin). Scholars working in this area often invoke Enlightenment ideals – drawing on Habermas and Warner on the public sphere and counterpublic sphere respectively – that continue to inform scholarship in Victorian studies. The focus on print and politics returns again in the 1830s and 40s with the rise of Chartism, the penny press, and the unstamped press in combination with intensely depressed living conditions for the working classes and poor and fears of revolution at home and abroad. This period also brought calls for print censorship or regulation (of which the stamped press, of course, was a version), views that collided with Britain's longstanding and deeply felt commitment to freedom of speech in all its forms. The idea of a free press was distinctly British despite its departures from anything like full freedom and despite the caveats that even those who supported freedom of the press interposed. How the country sustained and even celebrated this view while also curtailing press circulation is a fascinating chapter in the history of Victorian print culture. This period of unrest and fertile productivity opened out into what Richard Altick has famously called “the democracy of print” (1). The broad strokes I have sketched in here pertain more to periodical and newspaper culture than to book culture and contribute to two distinctive features of print culture as it relates to the press: its capacity to shape publics and counter-publics and, related to this point, its role in the organization of knowledge. In addition to communicating and producing knowledge, periodical and newspaper culture also defined new forms of knowledge – fragmented, patchwork, non-linear, immediate – that are discussed in many of the books under review here.
I want to begin with a series of books that bring together newspaper and periodical studies and literature. Dallas Liddle's The Dynamics of Genre: Journalism and the Practice of Literature in Mid-Victorian Britain and Matthew Rubery's The Novelty of Newspapers: Victorian Fiction after the Invention of the News, both published in 2009, take up newspapers and journalism to say something about literature. Liddle's work follows a lovely structure that draws out different dimensions of genre (poetry, autobiography, and sensation fiction) as well as different dimensions of the communications circuit (the fact that Liddle critiques the communications circuit notwithstanding [159]). Liddle is sensitive to the complexity of periodical genres, noting that individual journals and newspapers have their own language, genres, rules, and ways of operating (4). His desire to pay more attention to the form of journalism, in particular, is welcome. This is an area, he persuasively demonstrates, that has not yet received the attention it deserves.
His own project is focused on genre: the specificity of journalistic genres, their interaction with literary genres, and the competition between the two in an increasingly complex print marketplace. Heavily indebted to Bakhtin (whose work provides an epigraph for every chapter except the introduction), Liddle discusses works by Elizabeth Barrett Browning, Harriet Martineau, Anthony Trollope, George Eliot, and countless unnamed others to offer a picture of the volatile print field at mid-century. I completely support Liddle's effort to bind journalistic content to form/genre, but I felt uneasy with what felt like a wholesale dismissal of the insights growing out of theories indebted to Habermas, Benedict Anderson, and Pierre Bourdieu (to whom Liddle, rightly, attributes much of the recent work in what he variously calls “book history and the study of print culture” and “history of the book”) (141-59).Footnote 6 In less than twenty pages one cannot give adequate coverage to the contributions these theorists have made let alone to critics who have relied on them (by my count, Liddle offers only five examples – two related to Habermas, one to Anderson, and two to Bourdieu – and offers only very spare comments for why he does not value these particular works). This is not the place to chart these issues in detail but I think several of the scholars who have taken up insights related to a Habermasian public sphere (or, more often, the critiques of the public sphere) would be surprised to find their work called unhistorical (see, for example, Gilmartin, Keen, and Kamra). More to the point of this essay is Liddle's claim that book history and print culture studies would be “better” served by a Bakhtinian literary/historical approach (158). I enjoyed Liddle's readings and often learned a great deal from them, but I didn't think they were necessarily better than other approaches; they simply brought out different aspects of his focus on “the interactions between the press and literary forms” (174).
Rubery's The Novelty of Newspapers, not surprisingly, shares many assumptions with Liddle's book even if it also departs from it in significant ways, one of which is indicated in the priority given to newspapers in the title. Rubery's claim that “the transformation of news during the nineteenth century profoundly influenced literary narrative in ways that have yet to be realized” (4), for example, is similar to Liddle's effort to trace the ways in which the “competition between artistic and journalistic genres did indeed affect mid-Victorian literature” (33). Liddle's competing genres becomes Rubery's “rival practice[s]” and “competing media” (4). Unlike Liddle (who attends to a range of periodical forms), Rubery seeks to revive a sense of the newness of the news, to capture again the sense of disorientation and potential it posed for a population not yet inured to its norms and conventions and moments of surprise. The structure of this book – moving from the front page with its focus on shipping news and personal advertisements in the first two chapters to the middle of the paper with its features of the leading article, personal interview, and foreign correspondence through the back page – captures Rubery's appreciation of the newspaper form. His readings yield insights into Trollope, James, Conrad, and sensation fiction (a genre often addressed in print culture studies) among others. Unlike other books under review here, Rubery references print culture only in passing and in his focus on newspapers as a “source of thematic and formal innovation for Victorian novelists” (11), his readings do not always intersect with the political, material, and epistemological approaches developed by others.
A trio of books that engage with newspapers or periodicals in other contexts point to directions that new scholarship is likely to take. James Mussell's The Nineteenth-Century Press in the Digital Age (2012) is a first extended foray into the dialogue between new digital technologies and nineteenth-century print media (his term of choice) and will likely be followed by many others. Sukeshi Kamra's The Indian Periodical Press and the Production of Nationalist Rhetoric (2011) is a welcome contribution to the nexus of Victorian studies, periodical studies, and postcolonial studies. And Ian Haywood's The Revolution in Popular Literature: Print, Politics, People, 1790-1840 (2004) addresses the question of popular literature that runs, in one way or another, through many works in print culture studies. Both Kamra and Haywood also admirably address issues of print censorship and regulation in considerable detail. A fourth book, Alberto Gabriele's Reading Popular Culture in Victorian Print (2009), takes up popular culture two decades after Haywood's study leaves off. By this point the field looks very different. His focus is on a single journal, Mary Elizabeth Braddon's Belgravia, but his reach is much further, extending at once to a broader analysis of discursive formations and readership (sketched in as a “new intertextual methodology”) and the experience of urban modernity in general.
Ann L. Ardis and Patrick C. Collier's edited collection Transatlantic Print Culture 1880–1940: Emerging Media, Emerging Modernisms (2008) and Elizabeth Miller's Slow Print: Literary Radicalism and Late Victorian Print Culture (2013) both offer a complex sense of the print field in the latter decades of the nineteenth century – the former through its introduction of the transatlantic lens and the latter through its attendance to forms of print culture that have previously escaped sustained critical notice – and they both use periodical culture to rethink modernism. Transatlantic Print Culture collects together essays that sharpen the dialogue that emerges in the heady mixture of new forms of print journalism and new forms of popular literature. The focus is on the way these hybrid, often understudied, works link to articulations of modernism not as a monolithic movement but as a series of distinctive, and sometimes discrete, innovations in the print field. It is attuned, in particular, to works that have escaped critical scrutiny because they do not conform to modernism as it has been traditionally defined.
The collection flags “print culture” in its title and the editors, not surprisingly, engage directly with the term in their introduction. Their endorsement of the term, however, is somewhat tepid; it is “admittedly vague,” they acknowledge, but will “suffice” (3).Footnote 7 Following Brake, they read print culture as embracing “the entire ecology of print media in nineteenth-century Britain: the organization of the newspaper industry, the hierarchy and circulation of weekly and monthly periodicals, the book publishing industry, and the evolving dynamics among literary agents, reviewers, authors, and their increasingly diverse audiences” (3). The essays in this volume often engage with the commercialization of the print field and the question, familiar from the late eighteenth century, of whether the increased volume of print material, in combination with increased literary rates and print accessibility, was a cause for critique, caution, or celebration.
Miller's Slow Print offers a different delineation of the field in a focus on radical print culture that comprises newspapers, periodicals, literature, and pamphlets among other print forms. In fact, more than in any other book under review here, Miller takes advantage of the capaciousness of print culture as a category. The lineage she traces goes back to Enlightenment ideals that linked the circulation of print with the promise of democracy, a view that, as noted above, was especially vibrant in the 1830s and 40s with the rise of a radical press and the many efforts to counter the taxes on knowledge. By contrast to the 1830s and 40s, however, Miller illustrates that by the 1880s and 90s writers were less sanguine about the benefits of mass circulation and mass culture. They worried, Miller elaborates, about the evacuation of politics that followed from a focus on consumption, a worry that echoes Habermas's oft-noted characterization of the shift from a culture of conviction to a culture of consumption that occurs over the course of the nineteenth century.Footnote 8 By the late nineteenth century the potential of print culture was felt to be either exhausted or wrong-headed: “radical thinkers,” Miller notes, “came to believe that print's endless reproduction made it especially subject, as a technology, to the expansive market ideology of industrial capitalism” (6).
Like others, Miller defines her period as a “watershed moment” in the “explosion of print production” (2).Footnote 9 In contrast to this “explosion,” Miller gives us slow print, a contraction rather than an expansion of print culture. Miller defines “slow print” as “print that actively opposed literary and journalistic mass production”; “it was,” she continues, “often explicitly political in objective, as socialist, anarchist, and other radical groups came to believe that large-scale mass-oriented print was no way to bring about revolutionary social change” (2). Slow print is a brilliant phrase on Miller's part, drawing together as it does not only a new sense of urgency in response to accelerated capitalist production at the end of the nineteenth century but also our own period's response to the heightened acceleration wrought by new digital technologies and captured, for us, in antidotes like the “slow food” movement and “slow living” (which, tellingly, have very little to do with the political). In a single term Miller collapses two periods and helps us to understand both better.
Each of the writers she addresses struggles, in different ways, to confront a perceived sense that print culture in its late-century forms was no longer realizing radical political goals; indeed, as Marx predicted with respect to capitalism in general, print culture was at once absorbing critiques and repackaging them in forms more conducive to the promotion of existing conditions than their demise. Miller does an excellent job of harnessing the journals' stated intentions to their united opposition to a print marketplace marked by capitalism, of demonstrating the alternative audiences and spaces imagined and created by her conception of slow print, and of bringing all of this to bear on new understandings of modernism. With its emphasis on print culture in relation to politics, its range of reference, its focus on all stages of print production, and its challenge to received views of modernism, this book is a wonderful example of the readings that can result from the enlarged interpretive lens that print culture often provides.
New areas of study are often legitimated through the publication of primary documents readers. Paul Keen's Revolutions in Romantic Literature: An Anthology of Print Culture, 1780–1832 and Andrew King and Jon Plunkett's Victorian Print Media: A Reader were published in 2004 and 2005 respectively. Both collections give shape to the category of print culture through section headings that include autobiographies, literature, the French Revolution, British India, and the Slave Trade among others (in the Revolutions anthology) and the influence of print, law, popular print forms, and graphic media (in the Victorian reader) as well as sections on periodicals, publishing, and the reading public that overlap in both collections. King and Plunkett discuss their decision to privilege “print media” over “print culture” in terms of their sense of its focus on mediation, remediation, and process (6). In the same vein, Colette Colligan and Margaret Linley's edited collection, Media, Technology, and Literature in the Nineteenth Century: Image, Sound, Touch (2011) makes a case for the nineteenth century's “invention of media” (1) and is alert to media history (and, importantly, its erasure). Colligan and Linley also note the nineteenth century's elaboration of new media technologies, helpfully illustrated in Lisa Gitelman and Geoffrey B. Pingree's New Media 1740–1915 (2004) which uncovers, as Colligan and Linley put it, “the history of old new media” (10). If one wanted to be persuaded of the salience of “print media” as a term for the Victorian period, I would turn here instead of Plunkett and King's brief rationale. Still, I prefer the term print culture to print media. I cannot shake the anachronism of “media” in reference to nineteenth century culture. John Guillory's “On the Genesis of the Media Concept” makes this point. After Aristotle, the medium, as it related to communication was “set aside. . . for two millennia” (323). It reappears, with one exception, in the late nineteenth century with the introduction of new technologies like the telegraph and the phonograph that, through remediation, drew attention to the medium itself. The one exception is the invention of printing in the early modern period which, like new media technologies in the late nineteenth century, drew attention to print as a remediation of writing (324). Despite my hesitations about Victorian print media, however, as my subtitle indicates, I want to make a pitch for mediation as one lens through which to understand Victorian print culture.Footnote 10 Mediation recurs as an idea, if not a word, in most of the works discussed here in at least three ways: first, it highlights print as a medium; second, it signals print as an always mediated form (mediated by printers, publishers, booksellers, editors, readers, censors, and so on); and third, it signals the ways in which meaning itself is always mediated and, accordingly, inextricable from the production of knowledge.
I want to return now to Chartier's second, narrower definition of print culture: “to reconstruct the multiple uses of the many forms of print” (8) by crossing “the study of representations of reading practices. . . with the study of printed pieces as material objects” (9). Within this definition we can identify two types of uses, one familiar and widely accepted, and the other new and not often the focus of scholarly inquiry. The former is reading (in all its manifold forms) and the latter is everything else (exquisitely catalogued in Price's recent study in a series of lists: books as “[bought], sold, exchanged, transported, displayed, defaced, stored, ignored, collected, neglected, dispersed, discarded” [20], pages used as “[w]rapping, wadding, padding lining” [221]).
The focus on reading, of course, has a long history in nineteenth-century scholarship. Richard Altick's social history of the reader in The English Common Reader (1957) is the point of departure for much of that history. Many of these studies attest to the ways in which the new fields of book history and print culture are not far from the “old” fields of social history on which the new critics rely. If print culture increased at dramatic rates so too did the new reading publics. Beth Palmer and Arlene Buckland's edited collection, A Return to the Common Reader: Print Culture and the Novel, 1850–1900 (2011), revisits Altick's seminal study. Interestingly, it borrows a structure that is a contracted version of King and Plunkett's Victorian Print Media: its first section focus on publishers, authors, critics, and readers, and its second section on scenes of reading (from jails to ships to the Royal Colonial Institute's library to Australia). This book takes up Altick's still compelling call to give close and textured attention to that elusive category, the common reader, from a wide range of perspectives. The distinction in Palmer and Buckland between print culture and the novel in the subtitle, however, gave me pause. The editors note the ubiquity of fiction in Victorian print culture – “the novel,” they argue, “traversed the book and the periodical in this period” (4) – and no doubt they want their title to capture this point but it also speaks to the incoherence that the term print culture sometimes produces.
It was only a matter of time before a critic began to look past the equation between books and reading to consider the myriad other uses to which books could be put. In How to Do Things with Books in Victorian Britain (2012), Leah Price takes up this latter challenge with great verve and insight. Still, I hesitated about including this book here. It is squarely situated in a book history context (her first chapter addresses many book history issues directly, she continues a dialogue with book history throughout her study, and she only rarely uses the term print culture).Footnote 11 At the same time, an entire chapter is dedicated to Henry Mayhew and she often engages with newspapers and periodicals. Price asks “what meanings do books make even, or especially, when they go unread?” (2). Her focus is on the relationship of “thoughts to things,” of texts to books (2, 4). “The Victorians,” Price writes “cathected the text [‘a string of words’] in proportion as they disowned the book [‘a physical thing’]” (4). She wants, in other words, to find ways “to discuss the circulation and handling of books while bracketing their textual content” (14). Against the grain of much recent criticism, Price asks, “[w]hat exactly would it mean to study books without privileging reading?” (20).
Price devises many clever locutions from rejection theory to reading blocks and absorbent books (one of my favorites is “Wrapping Up,” the title of the Mayhew chapter's last section). Her target is “nonreading” – people doing things with books that have nothing to do with, or are only inversely related to, reading – and, as her title states, how people do things with books. The range – from reading to defacing to throwing to ignoring to wiping and so on – is often amusing. Price gives many examples of the wayward uses to which books are put through reference to novels by Dickens and Trollope, It-narratives,Footnote 12 and journalism. This book also includes a provocative implicit dialogue with print censorship – it is not Price's topic – that emerges from frequent examples that focus on references to, or practices of, censorship.Footnote 13
Any treatment of print culture in recent works cannot avoid the question of digitization. Indeed, it arises, in passing or in detail, in every book discussed here. That said, this topic is much too large for a brief review and so I want to close by simply gesturing toward the ways in which this third “revolution” – following Gutenberg and then the steam engine – has been taken up. In both the first and second “revolutions,” the focus is put on print proliferation, speed, and acceleration, and in both cases copious numbers are recited to bolster the view that the circulation of printed matter has changed in manners too dramatic to fully take in. Digital technology, however, marks a difference. It is a shift not just in quantity but also in kind.Footnote 14 What, if any, difference does this make? If there was an exponential increase in print culture in the nineteenth century, with digital technologies there has been an exponential increase in our access to it. In the 1990s I spent hours in the Colindale Newspaper library; now I spend hours at my desk looking at a screen, doing word searches (unimaginable then), and waiting only as long it takes my computer to load material. There is a loss: the feel of the pages, the tactile knowledge of their varying sizes, the smells, the heft of the printed matter or, conversely, its fragility. And, of course, there is a gain: speed, access, searchability. Digitization, then, heightens many of the points already discussed. Works are disseminated to a broad range of audiences that are diverse and untraceable and these audiences themselves have expanded exponentially in every thinkable category (by class, geography, gender, age, and so on).
“One of the problems,” Brake notes in her 2001 essay, “of this field [print culture] appertains to its vastness, much of which is unmapped” (Brake 127). What emerges, in part, in the books under review are some new mappings of print culture in Victorian studies.Footnote 15 Has the “new field” envisioned by Brake, then, come to pass? Before turning to some generalizations, I want to note one point that is clear: there is an energy and liveliness to the books under review here. These critics seem to know that they are charting new waters and they do so with great excitement, suspense, and conviction. It is as if the challenge to the humanities, wrought by that very neoliberal politics that locates its origins in the nineteenth century (and capitalism), has emboldened humanities critics to make claims for their areas in the most vivid, exuberant, and committed terms.
Generalizations are always risky and prone to be challenged but here are a few that emerged from the books under review. Critics who adopt print culture perspectives are often inclined to situate their studies in the context of the Enlightenment, the public sphere, and politics; they are accordingly attuned to print as a practice, a politics, and a mode for the organization of knowledge. They always draw on periodicals or newspapers and they are likely also to extend the range of print forms consulted to include items like train timetables, advertising circulars, posters, book wrappers, pamphlets, and so on as well as a range of literary genres.Footnote 16 They are likely to engage with at least two dimensions of the communications circuit; they do not, in other words, look at print in isolation from other social, political, economic, material, and use factors. In the context of both the extension of the range of print and the sense of print's engagement with material practices, they are keenly aware of print in relation to mediation: print as a medium that draws our attention to mediation; and print as generative of culture practices that invoke mediation – with its affinity to interactivity, intertextuality, and what Linda Hughes calls “sideways” methodologiesFootnote 17 – in relation to the production of knowledge. In theory, this last line of inquiry extends to an analysis of print culture itself as a mediating category (as Brake suggests in her early essay and others develop although there is certainly more room for this sort of analysis in Victorian studies). I think (and hope) that many scholars working in the field will take issue with aspects of these generalizations and I certainly welcome a dialogue on what, if anything, constitutes this field. But it did become clear to me, after reading the above books through a print culture lens, that print culture did signify not only an expanded range of reading material but also a set of implicit scholarly conventions.
I opened this review with a source from periodical culture – Brake's essay – and I want to close this section with another essay that we could perhaps see as bookending Brake's incursion into the “new field,” Linda Hughes's 2014 essay, “Sideways! Navigating the Material(ity) of Print Culture.” Prompted by the rise of digitization, she begins with a question: “How are we to conceptualize this pervasive material presence and navigate what remains an incompletely charted archive in both its print and digital forms?” (1). The reference to navigation and charting recalls Brake's sense of the unmapped field and, to be sure, there are many ways in which print culture studies continues to be inadequately conceptualized, the generalizations I note above notwithstanding. In the context of the dizzying increase in the availability of printed matter, Brake proposes “moving ‘sideways’ in these print and remediated forms” (1). Moving “sideways” involves the elements of surprise and insight – and sensitivity to mediation – that I have appreciated in all of the books under review. It illustrates the unexpected alliances that follow from juxtaposing forms of print that haven't been set side-by-side before as well as returning forms of print that were once side-by-side to their original print contexts.Footnote 18
Before practicing several “sideways” readings, however, Hughes begins with one of the questions that has preoccupied me here: how “to conceptualize the mass circulation of Victorian print” (2). In place of the metaphor of the body, she suggests two interconnected metaphors for print culture: the city and the network. She's alive to the point made by Brake in Print in Transition (2001), and taken up often by others, that “books and serials were interactive rather than distinct media” (3); this interactivity produces a “pervasive dialogism” that supports the metaphor of the network and, of course, invokes digitization via the web. Still, Hughes notes, both of these metaphors on their own, and the conceptualizations they enable, have their limits. Taken together, however, Hughes suggests, they offer a sturdy enough framework to accommodate the challenge posed by a print culture “so massive that it exceeds scholarly ability to document it” (5). Her readings of Eliot, Dickens, and Thomas Hood's “Song of a Shirt” illustrate just how rich such forms of reading can be.
I have experienced the same problem with the material under review that many of the authors in this review relate to nineteenth-century print culture: a “proliferation” of material “so massive that it exceeds scholarly ability to document it.” It is at once inspiring and daunting. My solution has been to let go of the effort to document in any comprehensive way new work in Victorian print culture and rather to focus on a range of books that productively engage with “print culture.” Print culture itself encourages us always to cast a wider net. One of its strengths is to invest scholarship with a new energy that often draws together questions of mediation, practice, politics, and knowledge. Another of its strengths is to show that categories scholars once took for granted require this broader reach to be fully understood. And another is to demonstrate the defining force of categories in the first place.
