In recent times, there has been a burgeoning of studies on Dalits in India, primarily in response to their arrival on the Indian political landscape to redefine the contours of social science scholarship within South Asian studies. It has forced social scientists to reconsider the relevance of the caste category and untouchability as tools of analysis to understand the social and historical transformations of modern India. Scholarly interventions by Ramnarayan Singh Rawat, Badri Narayan, and Gopal Guru have brought to the fore vital historical information and have contributed new theoretical insights to the field. They help us to contextualize Dalit lives and their struggles during colonial and postcolonial times. Moreover, these new studies, through their critical reflections on the multiple dimensions of social, economic, cultural, and ideological contestations, reevaluate the making of the modern Indian society and its political avatar—liberal democracy.
Anupama Rao's The Caste Question: Dalits and the Politics of Modern India feeds into this stream of contemporary scholarship and adds another layer of theoretical sophistication to the field of Dalit studies. It coalesces the colonial and postcolonial predicament of Dalits as one historical process to show the indispensable link of the Dalits to the project of modernity in India. The book traces the roots of anti-caste (anti-Brahmanism) and Dalit consciousness to colonial modernity and its institutional structures. It demonstrates the critical role of the spread of modern education, employment opportunities, and ideas among untouchables in contesting injustice and devising tools of emancipation based on the ethos of liberal humanism and democratic egalitarianism.
The strength of the book lies in its massive historical archival research backed up by meticulous anthropological fieldwork. Since the book covers a long period of history from the early nineteenth century to the 1990s, it skilfully uses multiple theoretical insights in retrieving Dalits from visible and invisible forms of violence, oppression, and domination. At one level, while placing the Dalit as central to the narrative of the book, it weaves the complicated relationship of Dalits with Hinduism and its institutional structures that reinforce inhuman oppression and justify inequality as sanctioned by religion. On the other hand, the book also brings out the contradictory role of the colonial and postcolonial state policies intended to protect Dalits from the social stigma of caste and its oppression, which ironically made them more vulnerable to violence and violation by caste Hindus.
In the caste-ridden Hindu society, Dalit existence as an untouchable subject is predicated on multiple deprivations, from basic economic necessities to social, cultural, and physical exclusion. The book investigates the activism of educated Dalits from the early nineteenth century to help their brethren to avail themselves of multiple avenues to improve the prospects of life as well as their persistent endeavors to rebuild and reformulate new social identities to get rid of the stigma of untouchability and achieve social equality. Rao narrates the struggles of Dalits who successfully impelled the society and state to recognize their deprivation as civic disability, resulting in state intervention to help and protect Dalits after centuries of exploitation, violence, and segregation. She aptly points out that the recognition of untouchability as an issue of human rights by the colonial state and nationalist leadership was the result of concerted struggles of Dalits, especially of Dr. B. R. Ambedkar. Accordingly, leaders like Gandhi responded using the principles of religious ethics and morality to cleanse Hinduism of the blot of untouchability, even though Gandhi fell short of the expectations of Dalits. Rao also argues that even for Gandhi, similar to Dalit activists, the making of a new identity for Dalits (as Harijans) was at the core of the project of emancipation. In Western India, like in the rest of India, Dalit identities evolved and transformed in response to the changes within and outside the community. As Rao shows, untouchable Mahars in the beginning claimed a Kshatriya lineage (a Mahar military lineage) and were given other nomenclatures like Harijan, Depressed Classes, and Scheduled Castes, then finally emerged as Dalits—a radical confrontational identity. The book argues that the way in which Dalits emerged from the negative social stigma to become worthy citizens in a democracy is fundamental to the formation of Dalit identity.
Another interesting aspect that the book succinctly brings out is the crucial role of Dalits in the making of modern India and their creative use of liberal democracy and its institutions as a tool of emancipation. Through their ideological articulations against untouchability, social oppression, and economic exploitation in caste-Hindu society, they enhanced the meaning of liberal democracy and viewed engendering its institutional processes as a way forward in terms of their right to self-respect and social equality.
In Rao's account, Ambedkar emerges as the quintessential symbol of this democratic struggle of Dalits in Western India, whose intellectual ideas and political mobilizational strategies emanated from the roots of Western liberal ideas. Ambedkar remains a central figure in the book's narrative of the struggles of Dalits in pre-independence India, as he transformed the meaning of democracy to fight against the iniquitous social institution of caste and the inhuman oppression of untouchables. Therefore, Ambedkar's meetings, protests, and writings, intended to galvanize his fellow untouchables to take control of their lives and assert themselves in the public sphere, were meant to carve out a distinct social identity apart from oppressive Hinduism, based on the principles of social equality and human dignity. The inseparability of caste and untouchability from Hinduism compelled Ambedkar to search for a new political identity on par with Muslim minorities to ensure social and political rights for Dalits (which was vehemently opposed by Gandhi). As the book rightly argues, even though the agenda of separation had to be abandoned, Ambedkar was successful in inscribing the Dalits' fundamental rights and ensuring reparative justice through reservations in the Constitution as the chairman of its drafting committee. By framing the Constitution to guarantee political rights and provisions for social justice, Ambedkar and his followers continuously expanded the possibilities of democracy as a project of social emancipation.
The story of Dalit emancipation is riddled with darker realities and Dalits' incomprehensible endurance of everyday violence in independent India. These stories, which are often glossed over in media reports or even in sophisticated academic debates on the political empowerment of Dalits in modern India, are powerfully addressed and depicted in two chapters. The first focuses on Sirasgaon village, where in 1963 four Dalit women in one family were stripped and paraded naked by the caste Hindus for resisting the sexual advances of a Maratha landlord. The other chapter narrates the story of Ambadas Sawane, a Dalit Kotwal in Pimpri village, who was killed in 1991 on the steps of a Hanuman temple for trying to install a statue of Ambedkar in the village. In these two chapters, Rao not only brings to the fore the vulnerable existence of Dalits in Indian villages but also indicts the state and its apparatus for their complicity with the perpetrators of violence from dominant, landholding, caste-Hindu backgrounds.
By combining the colonial and postcolonial struggles and resistances of Dalits, Rao's work portrays the poignant realities Dalits face every day in India, especially the price they pay in terms of physical assaults, brutal killings, and the rape of their women for their political assertion and resistance of injustice. By paying attention to the violence and Dalits' vulnerability in post-independence India, Rao not only exposes failures of the state and caste-Hindu society but also presents the uncompromising resolve of Dalits to protect their dignity and self-respect. The book unfolds the ironic trajectory of Dalits in Indian democracy—the gradual retrieval of their rightful share in the social and political spheres through political struggles as well as the endurance of marginality and violence as the price for aspiring to be equals. Therefore, the book's narrative persuasively moves between the democratic possibilities for Dalits and their nemeses that constrain and scuttle them. By tapping into the historical and contemporary lives of Dalits, the book recounts multiple stories about India's escape from the colonial yoke to its standing as a model democracy among postcolonial nation-states. Most interestingly, this book presents the Dalit not as a marginal subject but as an active political agent in the very imagination of democracy and its ideals.
I would like to point out a couple of typographical errors that need to be corrected: on page 220 Ranajit Guha's name is misspelled as “Rangit Guha,” and on page 222 the word “event” is missing the “t.”
