The past ten years have been particularly exciting for scholars studying early China. The field has witnessed the publication of a number of scholarly monographs dealing with recent discoveries, and Xiaolong Wu's recent monograph on the Zhongshan sites during the Warring States Period (475–221 BCE) is a significant and refreshing addition to that growing bibliography and to our knowledge of early Chinese material culture.
In this book, Wu comprehensively investigates the material and ritual remains of Zhongshan, an important kingdom once existing in present-day Hebei province in north China. At the center of the investigation are two royal cemeteries (especially King Cuo's tomb, numbered as M1) located outside of the city of Lingshou, the last capital of the Zhongshan. Wu's selection of Zhongshan as the subject matter of his monograph is significant, because most researchers had been dealing with Chu, Qin, Jin, or other major Huaxia 華夏 states or cultures, and relatively little has been published on the remains of the “other” polities—that is the non-Huaxia ones—including Zhongshan. The “unique” and “ambiguous” character of the Zhongshan features was usually associated with the White Di (Bai Di 白狄), whose historical presence is elusive. Although historians are able to piece together a complete history of Zhongshan with fragmentary records from various textual sources,Footnote 1 the important archaeological discoveries made in the 1970s of Lingshou and the royal cemeteries demand in-depth analysis. The goal of the book, as Wu claims, is “to investigate the role played by material objects, such as court luxuries, ritual objects, and mortuary objects, in the political life of the Zhongshan state” (6) or “to explain material culture from the state of Zhongshan as agents of political power and social order” (7).
Working within the framework of “interpretative archaeology,” championed by Ian Hodder and others,Footnote 2 Chapter 1, “Historical Setting and Approaches to the Study of an Ancient State in Warring States China,” examines the confusion around the concept of “identity,” which can be either objective or subjective. Wu contends that the material remains from archaeological sites cannot be used to reconstruct the objective ethnicity (identity) of the Zhongshan people, because artifacts, he argues, are another sort of ideological or political “image” rather than a faithful reflection of social facts. Therefore, Wu argues that the existence of North-Zone artifacts, such as the winged felines found in the Zhongshan burial, can only prove the subjective identification of the Zhongshan people.
Chapter 2, “Life, Death, and Identity in Zhongshan,” provides an overview and evaluation of the archaeological data from the Zhongshan capital, Lingshou. In this chapter, Wu not only “sorts out the archaeological evidence,” as he claims in the subtitle but also compares it with textual records about Zhongshan. Wu aims to provide a nuanced account of the archaeological remains that have usually been attributed to or associated with the Bai Di. Instead of combing numerous archaeological samples for universal traits, Wu acknowledges the diversity and difference, declaring that “even tombs in the same group are not culturally homogeneous … their mortuary practice and style of bronze artifacts display great diversity” (33). Hesitating to consider the sites in north Hebei and Shanxi as representing one homogeneous culture, Wu notes: “it is impossible to pinpoint ethnicity-specific artifacts among these remains, or in any other archaeological setting” (34). It seems almost inevitable, however, for scholars to determine what “parameters” carry the most distinctive cultural significances (in comparison to the Huaxia). For example, scholars have considered a special type of earring with a trumpet-shaped end which was commonly possessed, as Wu notes, between north (Shanrong 山戎 or Dai 代) and south Hebei (Xianyu 鮮虞), as a defining trait for the North-Zone cultures.Footnote 3
Chapter 3, “Royal Mortuary Practice and Artifacts,” analyzes the royal cemeteries and their contents to show their political significance as symbols of power. Wu carefully compares the tomb structures of M1 and M6 and observes their subtle differences in the design of the interior of the tomb shaft. He notes a “hall” of imitation pilasters, and points out that “unlike M6, the main chamber of M1 features four successive steps on four sides leading from bottom to top, marking a conspicuous deviation from M6's design” (79). But to understand how “conspicuous” this detail is we have to understand the whole tomb as a multilevel vertical structure.Footnote 4 Wu also observes that the six auxiliary tombs that accompanied M1 “were all excavated deep into living rock, so that the lower part of these burial pits resemble a stone chamber.” (85) This is an insightful view that might tell us more about the distinctive practice of stone burial in Zhongshan.Footnote 5 One of the most interesting parts in this chapter is the discussion of the two storage areas in M1. Wu observes that the west and east storage areas contained different objects. The west one was filled with ritual objects with less ornament; the east one was full of more lavishly ornamented daily objects. Wu concludes: “The east storage chamber represents a living and working area of the king … in contrast, the west storage chamber represents an official, ceremonial space for the king” (113). More importantly, Wu points out that the former meant more to the king as “symbols of his own persona” (107, also repeated on 138).
Chapter 4, “Interstate Politics and Artistic Innovation during the Reign of King Cuo,” presents an intriguing interpretation of the fact that in bronzes found in M1 “the method of decor changed dramatically in the fourteenth year” (138). Prior to that year, the bronzes have smooth, undecorated surfaces, while those made in the fourteenth year bear intricate ornament, especially using the method of inlay. Wu relates the “sudden” stylistic change to the historical episode of the allied attack of Yan led by the Qi army in 314 BCE. Wu coordinates the evidence from the bronze inscription from M1 and that in the two inscribed so-called Chenzhang 陳璋 hu vessels to support the argument that the Zhongshan's participation in the conquest of Yan brought to Zhongshan the talents and resources to create a new style. What might further contribute to this interpretation is the inscriptional evidence preserved in Yan seals. As other research has shown, Xianyu was used as a person's name in some Yan seals dating from the Warring States period, which might indicate some sort of population movement from Zhongshan to Yan.Footnote 6
Chapter 5, “Statecraft and Zhongshan Bronze Inscriptions,” shifts its attention from art to text by focusing on three long inscriptions made on a ding tripod and two hu vessels in M1. Wu argues that the text has the rhetorical function of warning Sima Zhou, the prime minister of Zhongshan, to follow the moral principle and remain loyal to the king. The praise of Sima Zhou in the ding and fang hu inscriptions is indeed an unusual feature, which might even make one wonder (in the light of Western Zhou inscriptions) if Sima Zhou himself was also one of the sponsors of the ritual bronzes. With the assumption that the ruler and the minister might have had a tense power relation, Wu argues that “the Confucian ideology was only used by the rulers for political legitimation” (159).
Chapter 6, “Funerary Architecture, Kingly Power, and Court Politics,” focuses on the bronze blueprint of King Cuo's mausoleum that was found in M1. The blueprint shows a unique plan of the king's tomb flanked by the tombs of the two queens and further by those of two lesser wives. After comparing the plan with the actual archaeological remains, Wu argues that “the bronze ground plan was made … to maintain the established political order and thwart potential political profiteers who would emerge after Cuo's death” (177). Wu supports his argument with evidence he has found in one of the three long inscriptions made on the round hu vessel. This text states that the successor of Cuo was a son by a qie (concubine). This suggests “the status and well-being of Cuo's queens and other consorts could be in jeopardy after his death” (177). Following this reasoning, Wu argues that the planning of the mausoleum as an immortalization of the status of the queens, who wanted to consolidate their political status after the death of the old king.
In sum, I very much welcome the publication of this new book which provides a comprehensive, up-to-date, and refreshing interpretation of one of the most important archaeological sites in early China. The results and achievements of the book make us marvel at how many more secrets we can unlock from an even closer look at just one individual site such as the Zhongshan royal burials.
