Kecia Ali's study of the Prophet Muhammad's biographies emphasized his multiplicity (The Lives of Muhammad, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2014). The continuing proliferation of his lives rests on digital media. Ruqayya Yasmine Khan's edited volume aims to address this crucial intersection, and, in doing so, contributes to conversations regarding Islam in Western representations and Western polities, and to the expanding field of Islam and media studies. Despite its title, the volume's chapters venture widely into anti-Sikh racism and Anglophone “New Atheist” works. If this editorial choice sacrifices potential questions particular to digitality and the Prophet, readers will nevertheless benefit from the volume's broader treatment of Islam and representation, Islamophobia, and “Islamophilia” (see Andrew Shryock, ed., Islamophobia/Islamophilia: Beyond the Politics of Enemy and Friend, Bloomington, IN; Indiana University Press, 2010).
Khan's introduction, written with Mashal Saif, makes the case for interpreting Islam in the “post-9/11 digital age” marked by the fragmentation of Islamic interpretative authority and by the global circulation of representations (2). If these trends would seem to suggest an opening or softening of dogmas, Khan and Saif, to the contrary, lament a hardening of lines, with humorless “mullah cults” on one side and zealous “Islam-bashing” on the other (2). The majority of the remaining chapters address this duality in Muhammad's multiple representations across literary and pictorial genres, all of which by necessity pass through digital media.
Chapters 1 and 2 provide distinct historiographic background studies. In the first, Fred Donner discusses debates over Muhammad and Islam's formative first century and the boon that digital reproduction offers for close reading of previously difficult to access manuscripts. In the second, religion historian Jonathan Brockopp rejects the dual image of Muhammad as cruel warrior or pacifist peacemaker in post-9/11 popular writing. Brockopp instead offers a convincing reading across classical Islamic and Christian traditions, which defined peace as (just) “social order” (48). Like Augustine before him, Brockopp writes, “Muhammad's example of peacemaking was a matter not of avoiding war, but of dealing with its consequences” (50).
The volume's next two chapters address recent and historical pictorial representations of Muhammad. In chapter 3, Jytte Klausen examines the Danish cartoon controversy and subsequent Euro-American censorship of Muhammad's images, as the effect less of an established Islamic aniconism than of our contemporary “global communicative orgy” (69). Klausen notes that some premodern Muslims did represent Muhammad in pictures, though only as a statesmen; yet, she argues, as Euro-American publishers bow to the current Muslim orthodoxy, they erase these lesser known Islamic traditions of representation. In chapter 4, Peter O'Brien examines popular European media images of Muhammad and Islam to argue that “postmodern teaching regarding the constructed nature of truth” supports European bigots and Islamic extremists’ mutual Islamo- and “Europhobic” propaganda (93). One need not accept O'Brien's thesis that philosophy rather than, say, global capitalism and empire, determine contemporary politics to agree that media form the prime sites of public contestation. Nevertheless, as an antidote O'Brien recommends a politics of hospitality (acceptance of difference) as manifested in the work of Tariq Ramadan.
Chapters 5 by Khan and 6 by Aysha Hidayatullah address representations of the Prophet Muhammad's wives. Khan's chapter hews most closely to the volume's stated theme by focusing on Muslim women's online commentaries (including cartooning) as decentering authority in the digital age. Hidayatullah reads two post-9/11 popular novels based on the empowered life of ʿAisha as efforts to counter Islamophobia. While critically identifying historical fiction as potentially feminist historiography, she also notes these works’ limitations as Islamophilic representations.
The final two chapters strain the limits of the book's purported themes, but make contributions of another sort. Simran Jeet Singh's examination of anti-Sikh hate crimes argues that attacks on “People Who Are or May Appear to Be . . . . . Muslim” (as categorized by the US Department of Transportation) are not so much a case of mistaken identity as a sign of “racialized religious identity” (159). Taner Edis’ reading of post-9/11 Anglophone “New Atheists” makes the key point that while Sam Harris, Richard Dawkins, et al., cite religion in general as contrary to science, their equating of Islam with terrorism “stands in tension with [their] expressed commitment to empirical accuracy” (177).
Khan's conclusion restates the book's contribution to studies of Islam and the powers of digital media. Scholars of varied levels will also appreciate the book's critical treatment of the dual dogmas of Islamophobia and Islamophilia, no easy feat in a contentious time when global connection passes for communication.
