On the surface, Edmund Husserl’s phenomenological cry to return to the things themselves suggests a philosophy concerned with isolated subjects who encounter alienated objects. For Peter R. Costello, Husserl’s work is better understood as a network of relationships. In Layers in Husserl’s Phenomenology, Costello claims that Husserl’s phenomenological method can help to reveal complex parts of the self. Through his discussion of layers, Costello explains many of Husserl’s dense concepts by providing clear and consistent real-life examples, and he highlights how Husserl’s philosophy has influenced other thinkers in Continental philosophy. This review provides an outline of Costello’s explanations of Husserl’s ideas, specifically the subject’s relationship to objects and other subjects. The review also assesses Costello’s book in terms of its accessibility for students new to or already familiar with Husserl’s work.
For Husserl, the subject is always encountering objects. The structure of the subject/object relationship is intentionality, which is the idea that the subject and the object are always already united (5). Costello explains that, for Husserl, the transcendental attitude is a unique way of existing in the world, as the subject engages with objects and other subjects in a more purposeful and reflective manner (15). The transcendental attitude uses an epoché, which is a way of describing one’s experiences without falling back on traditional assumptions of how things ought to appear (16). The descriptions of experience that result from the epoché are the transcendental reduction, which apply to the subject-object relationship (16). According to Husserl, the act of the phenomenological method is the noesis of the subject, and the appearance of part of the object in the reduction is the noema (16). The subject experiences different aspects or layers of the self through this special encounter with objects, resulting in what Husserl calls the transcendental ego (17). Husserl stresses that the transcendental ego takes place in the lived body (32). Through the sensation of touch, the subject can experience the organ-object-organ structure (88). This means that the body is revealed to itself through interaction with other objects (32). The objects respond to the subject and places the subject in the world (33). Costello explains that, “[as] sensed, the object is awakening; as sensing, I awaken” (86). The ego becomes aware of another layer of itself when it senses an object. Costello claims that touching other objects reveals the body to itself, just as the other person reveals layers of the self to the subject (90).
The encounter with another person, who is described as an alter ego, takes the form of intersubjectivity (5). Husserl’s emphasis on the self-other relationship allows Costello to state that overlaying is related to ethics (157). When with another person, there is the act of pairing, in which the other is a kind of mirror to oneself. However, pairing brings subjects together while preserving their differences (159). The experience of the alien other person is Fremderfahrung, and this is the only time that a translation for the term is given, even though the term is used extensively throughout the book (29). Providing a translation of this term more often, as Costello does with Deckung, would have been useful for the reader. For Husserl, the self recognizes the other and sees the other recognizing the self. The role of passivity is emphasized, as the self must let the alter ego be part of the relationship. Both action and passivity are involved with the encounter with the other (51). The subject also shares time and temporal experiences with the other (136). In time, the temporal field, the subject can only pay attention to certain things at a time, as one cannot remember everything. This is also a layered experience (123). The experience of the self and the other also structures all experience in general (81). Through the experience of pairing, the self is both a whole and a part in the world (148). Costello explains that individuals have their own existence in the world, but recognize that they exist with others in a unity. Costello writes that, “[it] should be because consciousness can perform the roles of piece and moment that it can identify them elsewhere” (152). Husserl stresses the need to treat others as wholes, as independent beings without totalizing them (156).
I highly recommend Costello’s book for a number of reasons. His use of examples is clear and consistent. Specifically, his primary example of jazz music is helpful in better grasping the phenomenological method. The complexity of listening to jazz and the way the musicians work together is a consistent and effective metaphor for the phenomenological method of reduction, of stepping back and forth into the experience to be involved with the different aspects or layers of experience. Costello eases the reader into the more complex ideas by way of this concrete example. Costello also clarifies a key term in Husserl’s philosophy that Costello believes is often misunderstood or mistranslated: Deckung means “overlaying,” and is deeply related to Entdeckung as “discovery” and Verdeckung as concealing (6). Deckung is often translated as “coincidence”, which lacks the physical and sensual connotations of Deckung as “overlaying” (7). The term Deckung foreshadows themes of “how the subject recognizes absence, difference, and distance” (7). Costello highlights Husserl’s influence on philosophers such as Heidegger, Levinas, Merleau-Ponty, and Derrida. A great success of this book is its ability to show how much of Husserlian thought appears in these thinkers, as Costello draws together Husserl’s ideas in a way that emphasizes the consistency of a philosopher whose work often appears fragmentary.
Costello makes use of the phenomenological method in his own organization and presentation of the material, constantly showing how the parts are related to the whole of the book. Structurally speaking, the introduction is important because it sets out the entire argument and chapter organization in a manner that is thorough without being overwhelming . The endnotes are an extensive resource for further research; they serve as an annotated bibliography, or perhaps even a literature review of Husserlian scholarship. While the endnotes are detailed, they are, at times, so extensive that they distract from the main book. Costello lays out the structure of each section; throughout the book, he makes connections that show how aspects of Husserl’s work are related. He consistently summarizes and synthesizes, thereby making complex ideas all the more clear. Costello provides a valuable addition to Husserlian scholarship, primarily due to the clarity of his writing and excellent choice of examples. Costello writes in a conversational style that is accessible to those encountering Husserl’s thought for the first time, and engaging to those already familiar with the philosopher.
