Although the title (undoubtedly written by the marketing department) gives DeWitt Clinton top billing, what historian of science David Spanagel has written is largely an engaging biography of Amos Eaton, the early American geologist who made a lasting impact on his field through both writing and teaching. The book is ostensibly a history of geological ideas, but Spanagel prefers to narrate through individuals, and so a wide range of important people receive biographical attention, many of them well-known figures like Washington Irving and Thomas Cole. The most important members of the supporting cast are Clinton, the New York governor whose political skill ensured the construction of the Erie Canal, and Stephen Van Rensselaer, the patron whose great wealth supported both Eaton and science more generally through the creation of the Rensselaer School.
At the center of the book is the unusual biography of Eaton, who came from a comfortable family, studied at Williams College, prepared for a career in law, discovered his affinity for the study of botany, and then, in a very odd turn, was convicted of forgery and given a life sentence. Fortunately for Eaton, and the development of science in the United States, four years later, in 1815, the sentence was commuted as part of a general amnesty of nonviolent offenders. After his release, Eaton took up the study of geology, using his freedom to explore northern landscapes. Of special importance were the places opened up – literally – by the Erie Canal. In telling this story, Spanagel affirms the special role of New York State in the “flowering of American scientific talent” (3). Clearly New York was an especially favorable place for the study of fundamental geological questions, largely because of the opportunities provided by the canal and by the patronage of wealthy men like Van Rensselaer and connected men like Clinton.
But Spanagel has done more than tell the story of geology's role in the creation of the canal or the canal's consequences for the study of geology. His primary goal is to set evolving geological ideas in broad context, and so we hear from prominent figures in politics, such as Thomas Jefferson and Martin Van Buren, as well as leading artists and writers, such as William Cullen Bryant, who corresponded with and learned from Eaton. At points the contextual material feels tangential, but part of Spanagel's goal is to reveal just how far the science of geology had seeped into the everyday world of the young nation. This he accomplishes easily, perhaps most effectively in a late chapter on the relationship between religion and geology that describes the challenges that the evolving science posed as evidence began to point away from Noah's great Flood and toward some other explanation of how (and when) the Earth took its current form.
Spanagel covers some well-trodden territory, especially concerning the Erie Canal, but the book comes alive when discussing Eaton's pedagogy. While teaching at Rensselaer, Eaton took his students into the field, especially along the canal, where they engaged in intensive and largely self-directed research. Eaton's “pedagogic experiment” – taking annual nature expeditions beginning in 1826 – provided “maximum hands-on experience to his students” (123). Spanagel also explores Eaton's attempt to create an American nomenclature for New York's geological strata, part of the nationalist project of scientists hoping to distance themselves from Europe.
Spanagel has written a wide-ranging book, touching on politics, science, art, and religion, and he draws on an extraordinarily broad literature. Unfortunately, his continual references to this scholarship, some of it very old, makes this work less valuable for undergraduate students, who will undoubtedly find the picking of nits and offering of praise more distracting than helpful. At times Spanagel seems content to argue that historians need to pay more attention to Eaton, while other historiographical contributions might be summarized as “some fine-tuning,” to use the author's own phrase (213). Still, students of early American history will find this book a useful model of how one can weave the history of science more fully into our understanding of places and times. Spanagel's work reveals that in the early 1800s the mysteries of New York's varied landforms touched all corners of the state's culture, from politics to art. If only Americans today could say they lived in a society so steeped in the latest scientific ideas.
