This volume aims to illuminate two broad but related areas: the genre of ancient biography and the issue of ‘fictionalization’ in narrative literature (xi). It is divided into four parts. The first part (Ancient Biography Revisited) introduces the theoretical basis of the volume. Parts II (Individual Biographies), III (Collective Biographies) and IV (Biographical Modes of Discourse) include papers on a range of authors and texts, including the Life of Aesop, Plutarch, Lucian, Philostratus, the Greek translation of Jerome's Vita Malchi, Sulpicius Severus, Diogenes Laertius, Suetonius, the Historia Augusta, Chion of Heraclea, the Ps.-Hippocratic letters and Heliodorus.
In Part I, the key theoretical point of Koen De Temmerman's ch. 1 is to nuance the distinction between truth and fiction by distinguishing ‘fiction’ and ‘fictiveness’. The former he defines as being untruth which relies upon a contract between writer and reader to establish that the work is not intended to be taken as truth. In contrast, ‘fictiveness’, he argues, need not operate at the level of the entire text; rather, ‘techniques of fictionalization’ may exert a transient or localised fictionalising impact (7). These ‘fictionalizing techniques’ and their functioning in biographical texts are the key focus of the volume, which considers ‘how ancient biographical narratives articulate contracts with readers about (non)-fictionality and believability’ (13).
This chapter could usefully have made more of an attempt to investigate whether ancient and modern ideas about ‘fiction’ and ‘fictiveness’ are entirely the same. In addition, not all of the claims are entirely convincing. De T., for instance, argues that ‘metaphorical characterization’ (giving the example of likening the biographical subject of the Life of Aesop to Thersites) is an index of fictionality on the grounds that it creates a parallel which does not exist outside of the text, but is constructed by the narrator and thus confronts the reader with the ‘artificiality’ of what they read (21). Such a technique may confront the reader with the ‘artificiality’ of the discourse, but all discourse — fiction and non-fiction — is ‘artificial’ (in the sense of ‘constructed’), so I do not see that this specifically suggests ‘fictionalization’.
De T. also claims that ‘associations of characters with paradigms almost by definition deviates from factual truth representation and can therefore be labelled instances of fictionalization’ (21). It is not clear to me that this is true. Most frequently ‘metaphorical characterization’ in ancient biography functions to reveal features of the biographical subject. When Plutarch, for instance, likens Pelopidas to Euripides’ Kapaneus (Plut., Pel. 3.5), he is using a particular manifestation of a figure with whom all his readers can be expected to be familiar to make the point that Pelopidas was a wealthy man but not haughty (gauros) on that account. The parallel between Euripides’ Kapaneus and Pelopidas does not exist outside of Plutarch's Life, but Pelopidas’ wealth and his modesty in spite of that wealth did exist, and to reveal this in part through ‘metaphorical characterization’ does not seem to me to ‘fictionalize’ the biography in even a transient way.
In ch. 2, David Konstan and Robyn Walsh suggest a distinction between two kinds of ancient biography: what they call ‘civic’ and ‘subversive’. They trace these strands back to two works by Xenophon: his encomium, Agesilaos, as the forerunner of ‘civic’ biographies, and his Socratic collection, the Memorabilia, as the origin of the ‘subversive’ strand. ‘Civic’ biography, they suggest, is concerned with individuals who operate within the established norms of society, and aims at revealing character to provide examples of virtue and vice. ‘Subversive’ biography, they argue, focuses instead on individuals on the margins of society who may challenge established orthodoxies, and whose biographies aim to show what is unique or extraordinary in the subject rather than to provide exemplary paradigms. ‘Civic’ biography, they argue, will generally favour chronological arrangement for a focus on actions, while ‘subversive’ biographies are less interested in actions and chronology, preferring to highlight words and speech. The authors rightly acknowledge that such a distinction cannot be applied rigorously and that there is overlap between the two kinds in areas such as the interest in the biographical subject's speech. They end with the claim, however, that the distinction is heuristically helpful for tracing the evolution of ancient biography, which is not entirely convincing. The distinction seems somewhat to over-privilege Xenophon in the history of ancient biography at the expense of many other influential texts and authors. Moreover, most ancient biographies share features with both Xenophon's Memorabilia and Agesilaos. In addition, this distinction, in practice, though founded on different criteria, aligns quite closely with the traditional distinction between literary and political biography, and thus does not significantly advance debate.
The theoretical ideas of Part I are taken in a variety of directions in the contributions in Parts II, III and IV. In Part II, for instance, Grammatiki A. Karla (ch. 3) starts from a classification of the Life of Aesop as ‘fiction’ and as an example of ‘subversive’ biography to consider whether the Life is a work of ‘popular literature’, coming to the conclusion that it is. Mark Beck (ch. 5) problematises the ‘civic’/‘subversive’ distinction of ch. 2 by showing the influence of both Xenophon's Agesilaos and Memorabilia on Lucian's Demonax: Beck shows that the structure of the Life owes much to Agesilaos but he argues that Lucian advances on the characterisation found in Xenophon's encomium by revealing both the virtues of Demonax as an exemplary figure and his individuality, which emerges particularly from the narration of sayings.
Many contributions in Part III explore different kinds of truth in ancient Lives. Maarten De Pourcq and Geert Roskam (ch. 9) take Plutarch's Agis and Kleomenes – Gracchi as a case-study with which to consider fictionalisation in the Parallel Lives. The authors suggest that it is possible to discern in these Lives a shared deep structure at the actantial level (following Greimas’ model), and that this deep structure places the Lives on the same level as fiction and myth. One may wish to question the validity of Greimas’ structuralist approach, which has lost favour over time, in particular for its arbitrary selection of narrative features from which shared deep structures emerge. However, whether or not one accepts the arguments about the deep structure of these Lives, De Pourcq and Roskam make a valuable contribution in demonstrating how what we (and they are careful to distinguish our standards of fictionality from those of the ancients) might consider to be fictionalising techniques in Plutarch's narrative are put at the service of revealing truths about character and morality. They show, moreover, how Plutarch uses techniques found also in historiography to underscore the veracity of his account.
Eleni Kechagia (ch. 10) looks at deaths of philosophers in Diogenes Laertius and argues that it is impossible to know the real details of the deaths of Zeno and Epicurus, but that Diogenes Laertius’ fictionalised accounts of them nevertheless reveal important philosophical truths about the doctrines of these philosophers. Rhiannon Ash (ch. 11) also considers issues of fictionalisation in death-scenes, this time within Suetonius’ Lives of the Caesars. Ash argues that many of these scenes have structural and verbal similarities, and that it is very important to read these scenes as elements of serial biography, in which readers draw parallels with other death-scenes in the same series. She argues that when these scenes are read as part of the series, an optimistic message emerges about the enduring nature of the Principate, even when individual emperors are victims of assassination.
Part IV, and the volume as a whole, concludes with Luke Pitcher's discussion of the Life of Homer embedded within Heliodorus’ Aithiopika. Pitcher sees in this Life an ‘epistemological examination’ of the canons of literary biography which encourages the reader to consider what it means to write biography (304–5). This article, then, provides a fitting end to a volume which itself does much to further such a consideration.
