The title of this excellent study is somewhat misleading. Though show trials and the theatricality inherent to the courtroom do not go unremarked, Arjomand's main interest is in the unique role that theatre as an institution might play in public life by allowing a space for audiences to make judgments in the company of others. Partially formulated as a response to theatre companies in Europe and the United States that wish to do away with the theatre by blurring the lines between performance and real life (often through participatory events that take place outside of the theatre proper), Staged: Show Trials, Political Theater, and the Aesthetics of Judgment presents a powerful argument for theatre as a distinct institution worth preserving, and for the role of aesthetic judgment in the process of justice (18–20).
Arjomand's central interlocutor is Hannah Arendt, whose thought runs throughout the first three chapters of the book, but she also draws on the ideas of Bertolt Brecht and Erwin Piscator. It is a strength of the author's approach that she weighs Arendt's, Brecht's, and Piscator's theories and practice of theatre not only in a historical context, but also with an eye to their implications for contemporary discussions, including color-blind casting and cultural appropriation (both treated in the Conclusion in the context of the work of Anna Deavere Smith). In doing so, Arjomand avoids a relativistic historicism without disregarding history. In fact, the book is remarkable for the dense sociohistorical context integrated into every discussion of theory, a quality to which the following summary cannot do justice.
Chapter 1 focuses on Hannah Arendt's thought, touching on her famous account of the Eichmann trial and the role that theatre played in it. According to Arjomand, Arendt's problem with the trial wasn't that it was theatrical, but that it drew on the “wrong type” of theatre (24): Greek tragedy. This proved to be a poor model, because in such a trial, there could be no tragic hero. Furthermore, the inevitability implied by the tragic arc of the testimony and proceedings formed a justification for the state of Israel as a military power insofar as it cast the Holocaust as the logical culmination of centuries of anti-Semitism, which could be redeemed only through the creation of a modern Jewish state (24). Instead, according to Arjomand, Arendt—though lacking faith in Brecht's dialectics—nevertheless can be read as prescribing his epic acting style as a more appropriate model for the trial, and for a type of public conduct that can be nourished in the theatre. Instead of being “extreme Method actor[s]” like Adolf Eichmann, we should step outside and interrogate the theatricality of our public roles (49–50). Furthermore, Arjomand argues that the materialistic basis of Brecht's theatre helps us understand why “some [social] roles are particularly difficult to think or step out of” (50).
Chapter 2 deals with Brecht's aesthetics of epic theatre, his critique of socialist realism, and his fraught relationship to the East German Socialist Unity Party (SED), especially after the 1953 workers’ uprising. Brecht, who used trial scenes in many of his plays, encouraged the audience to judge for themselves what they saw in the theatre. Putting on a play under the watchful eyes of the SED, however, meant that some judgments would be more acceptable than others. Arjomand uses archival materials, including programs and rehearsal notes, to trace the skillful way in which Brecht employed his signature List (cunning) (66) to create a production of The Caucasian Chalk Circle that was simultaneously affirmative and critical of the SED. In doing so, Arjomand argues, Brecht and his team may have been “estranging epic theater itself” (87), with the result that the theatre “could provide another outlet for thinking and judging that would quell dissatisfaction with the regime” (92). Arjomand shows how Brecht's directorial methods, which allowed for input on the production from multiple parties, nevertheless preserved the ultimate control of the author. This gives rise to an unsettling insight: “plurality and democracy are not necessarily aligned” (92). This chapter, which contains some questionable interpretations of the plot of The Caucasian Chalk Circle (Arjomand reads the two groups in the frame story as “nomadic tribes” who have been “displaced” by the fight against the Nazis [70], instead of Soviet agricultural collectives [kolkhozes] who have themselves been fighting the invaders, as in Brecht's text), is nevertheless a highly sophisticated analysis of Brecht's role in the GDR that avoids both easy moralizing and complete exculpation of the writer.
Chapter 3, on Erwin Piscator, is an especially welcome account of a director who established his own version of epic theatre in parallel with Brecht, and who often stands in the latter's shadow (97–8). Piscator revised his politics and aesthetics in his later work, focusing on the role of anti-Semitism in German and American life, and allowing for strategic uses of empathy in the epic theatre depending on the context of the production and its audience. What resulted, as Arjomand convincingly illustrates, was a type of theatre that trod the line between a universalism that might imply that “it was mere chance that made some [humans] victims and some perpetrators” and a particularity that risked making the Holocaust irrelevant for contemporary audiences (135). The main plays discussed in this chapter include The Burning Bush, The Crucible, The Golden Doors, and, most important, Peter Weiss's documentary play on the Frankfurt Auschwitz trials, The Investigation.
Chapter 4, “Trials in Nuremberg,” discusses two productions of Trial in Nuremberg, a documentary play by the East German playwright Rolf Schneider. In the East German production of his play, Schneider, like Brecht, found a way to satisfy SED censors while simultaneously allowing for a reading that criticized abuses of power. The production at the Burgtheater in Vienna, however, featured several changes that ultimately blunted its critical message for audiences. Nevertheless, because it provided a forum for victims and perpetrators to come together and share a meal and perform as equals (albeit outside the context of the play itself), the Austrian production made a convincing case for the importance of the theatre as an institution. This volume does the same.
