Most observers of Chile will be aware of the central importance of the family to the social structure of the country, and possibly also to the way in which a rather idealised version of the family features in the campaign promises of candidates for election, but the centrality of the family to political debate in Chile has rarely been examined in depth. This well-researched and convincingly argued book is a welcome and original contribution to our understanding of the extent to which the family has played an important role in the contentious politics of Chile from the election of Allende in 1970 to the return to democracy in 1990. The text is enlivened by well-chosen propaganda images and posters from both sides of the political divide.
The basic question that the author asks is why all sides of the political debate shared common beliefs about the importance of the family and the relationship between the family and the state. There has been considerable analysis of the role of women – of both the Right and the Left – in Chilean politics, and the author provides an illuminating account of the mobilisation of women around the issue of the family, not least the mobilisation of right-wing women. But she is keen to demarcate her approach from those earlier studies and to concentrate on what she calls ‘the mobilization of familial beliefs’ (p. 12). She proposes a conceptual framework based upon four categories – the familial state, the familial nation, the patriarchal leader and militant families – and uses those categories to illustrate how diverse political sectors incorporated appeals to the importance of the family into their political discourse and electoral campaigning. Emphasis on the family affected views on the appropriate welfare system, on employment, on education and on citizenship rights, though of course the proposals made by different political groups were based on their particular interpretations of the policies necessary to defend and improve the status of the family. All candidates for election to the presidency used the family as a metaphor for the nation, and argued that their specific policies protected the family best and that they offered the best candidate to become the patriarchal leader of the nation.
The book proceeds through an examination of the major episodes of Chilean history, starting with the election of Allende in 1970 and moving through the intense political division that accompanied his government, the years of the Pinochet dictatorship and the development of opposition to it, and the debates over the family during the transition to democracy. It is notable throughout this period that the model family is one in which the man is the sole or at least the major wage-earner, and the role of the wife is to maintain and safeguard the family. Both the Left and the Right used this conception to claim that their policies would best secure the fortunes of this model family.
This raises the question of why this conception of the family was so deeply rooted in Chile (and though it is outside the scope of this book, one wonders how far this idealisation of the family was common in other Latin American countries). The author refers on several occasions to the influence of the Catholic Church – this analysis could have been taken further and extended to the evangelical churches that developed across the country, especially under the Pinochet regime. How important was religion in explaining this deeply conservative conception of the family held by both the Left and the Right? The author shares the view of many historians that the dominance of the family reflects the power of the elite families that emerged after independence, but it seems odd that this dominance lasted so long.
The concluding sections trace the erosion of the primacy of the idealised version of the family in the face of a more active and widespread feminism. At least on the centre-left, politicians started to come to terms with the fact that the idealised version of the family that they offered ignored the evidence of large numbers of single-parent families, of cohabitation, of domestic violence, of widespread illegal recourse to abortion, and of an anachronistic attitude to divorce and discrimination against women in the labour force. With the election of Michelle Bachelet there was a conscious effort to argue that all forms of the family were equally valuable and should be supported by the state – though this view was not shared by many sectors of the Right.
Gwynn Thomas has written a thoughtful and innovative account of the role of the family in Chilean politics from 1970 to 1990. It is an original and well-written book which has made this reviewer realise that this has been an unjustly neglected topic in the analysis of Chilean politics.
