Introduction: Udayagiri
When Candragupta II visited the sacred complex of Udayagiri at the beginning of the fifth century he made sure not to give offence to any of the parties involved in this grand project. His aim was clearly defined in the inscription that records his visit, namely the winning of the entire earth:
He (Vīrasena) has come here in the company of the king himself, who was on his way of winning the entire earth, and he has commissioned this cave out of devotion for Lord Śambhu.Footnote 1
Though himself a devotee of Viṣṇu and so a Bhāgavata, the king paid his respects to his learned chief minister Vīrasena, who came from Pāṭaliputra, by visiting the cave dedicated to Lord Śambhu, i.e. Śiva, which had recently been completed under the patronage of the chief minister. The chief minister was content and proudly recorded the honour that had been bestowed upon him in an inscription at the back of the cave.
However, this rather insignificant Cave 8, which probably enshrined a liṅga, can hardly have been the main purpose of Candragupta's visit.Footnote 2 For, next door, around the corner, a truly grandiose scheme had just been, or was about to be accomplished, a work of art that was designed to broadcast the king's larger ambition: ‘the winning of the entire earth’, expressed allegorically in the great Varāha panel of Cave 5.
As Michael Willis (Reference Willis and Hans2004, Reference Willis2009) has shown, the Varāha panel was intrinsically connected through a system of hydrological engineering with a natural cleft in the central ridge of the mountain. Water once cascaded down through this narrow passage, flowing underneath a large image of Viṣṇu–Nārāyaṇa. This panel shows the god in his cosmic sleep while resting on the primordial snake (Anantaśayana), floating on the cosmic ocean. At the bottom of the cascade, the water was collected in a reservoir at the feet of the Varāha sculpture of Cave 5, making the cosmic boar rise out of the waters.
It will not be our aim here to analyse the iconography and the allegorical double-entendre of these two panels, the Varāha and the Nārāyaṇa, which most recently has been done by Willis in a penetrating study referred to above.Footnote 3 What concerns us here is the ecumenicity of the situation: a Vaiṣṇava king, “whose prowess is [Viṣṇu's] Cakra”,Footnote 4 selects a prominent spot at the centre of the holy mountain of Udayagiri for celebrating his faith and political mission, and allows at the same time two leading figures of his kingdom, a minister (Vīrasena) and a vassal king (the Sanakānika mahārāja Soḍhala (?)), to construct next door cave-sanctuaries (Caves 6 and 8) dedicated to Śiva, the other high god of Hinduism. Inscriptions in both shrines duly recognise the sovereignty of Candragupta.Footnote 5 Admittedly, we cannot be certain as to the original dedication of the sanctuary of Cave 6 – the cave no longer contains its original sculpture – but the two Viṣṇu images at the outer wall, flanking the two Dvārapālas, as well as the image of Gaṇeśa overviewing the entrance at the left and a shrine of the seven mothers at the right of the sanctum, strongly suggest that Cave 6 was also a Śiva sanctuary,Footnote 6 in which the two Viṣṇu images, in the words of Joanna Williams, were merely “attendant upon the greater glory of Śiva”.Footnote 7
And, to complete the picture, adjacent to the Varāha cave on the other, southern side, was one more Śaiva cave (4), enshrining an ekamukha liṅga.Footnote 8 Thus it cannot have escaped the attention of the contemporaneous visitor that, with the establishment of Gupta power over the area, the Bhāgavata religion had taken pole position, not by ousting its Śaiva rivals, but rather by including them in a subordinate position. By doing so the three caves together mirrored the situation in Cave 6 on a larger scale: Śiva (Caves 4 & 6) “attendant on the greater glory of” the Bhagavat (Cave 5).
Although the majority of the temple structures on the Udayagiri can be assigned to Hindu gods, this by no means excluded other persuasions to establish their own sanctuary on the hill. At the top of the north side of the hill is a cave of the heterodox Jains, which an inscription dates to the reign of Candragupta's son Kumāragupta (GE 106 = AD 436). “The inscription records the dedication of an image of Pārśvanātha”.Footnote 9 Jainism had been favoured in this region by Candragupta's ill-fated elder brother, Rāmagupta, who commissioned the three images that were reportedly found inside old Besnagar (Durjanpura), 1.5 km from Udayagiri.Footnote 10 Three inscriptions on the pedestals record basically the same dedication:
This image of the Lord, the venerable Puṣpadanta/Candraprabha, was commissioned by the Mahārājādhirāja Śrī Rāmagupta, at the instigation of Celūkṣamaṇa, son of Golakyāntī, who is the pupil of the preceptor Sarpasenakṣamaṇa and the grand-pupil of the pāṇipātrika Footnote 11 Candrakṣamaṇa, preceptor (ācārya) and forbearing monk (kṣamaṇaśramaṇa).Footnote 12
No direct evidence of a Buddhist presence in Udayagiri has come to light, the reason for which is not difficult to see: the great, ancient centre of Sanchi, 5 km to the south, naturally attracted all Buddhist devotion. This was, for instance, the case when another favourite of Candragupta, Āmrakārdava, donated in GE 93 (= AD 413),
[A]n allotment of land, called Íśvaravāsaka, and a sum of money to the Ārya-saṅgha, or community of the faithful, at the great vihāra or Buddhist convent of Kākanādaboṭa, for the purpose of feeding mendicants and maintaining lamps.Footnote 13
Candragupta's favours are explicitly said to have contributed to Āmrakārdava's way and means of life.Footnote 14
Thus we possess within a circle of five kilometers from the Udayagiri and within a time frame of a few decades around AD 400, plenty of epigraphical and sculptural evidence that proves that the reign of Samudragupta's successors ushered in a period of royal patronage that was not limited to one religious denomination only, but was beneficial to all the four major religions of their times: Bhāgavata (Visnuism), Māheśvara (Sivaism), Jaina (Jainism) and Bauddha (Buddhism). This is not to say, of course, that the Guptas invented religious patronage, but their rule marked the emergence of kings and courtiers as a major class of patrons, whereas earlier “groups of lay people” were the prominent sponsors.Footnote 15 And in contrast to most of the earlier patrons, their patronage extended to religions other than their personal persuasions, thus spreading an atmosphere of religious tolerance throughout the realm.Footnote 16
As we will see, this patronage could take the form of financing prestigious building projects as well as lending financial support to religious groups and individuals through gifts of money or land. We do not possess much direct evidence of courtly patronage of individual sculptors, decorators, architects or other artisans who worked in the visual arts, although this must have been substantial. They were paid, of course, and some artists more than others, no doubt. Since the king himself was the centre of the patronage system, it is remarkable that we do not possess epigraphical testimonies of Candragupta's own building projects. It looks as if he was satisfied with being credited by his subjects for his goodness, whereas the ones that appear to have been his own monumental plans, such as the Varāha and Nārāyaṇa panels, were apparently so obvious that they needed no special commemoration in the form of dedicatory inscriptions.
This large-scale and broad-minded religious patronage practised by the court, which involved the king, his courtiers and officials (amātya), favourites and so-called feudatories (sāmanta),Footnote 17 enhanced the development of the classical forms of the Indian religions, as well as their sacred architecture and art. It formed part of a wider system of patronage, which operated as a powerful political strategy, through which the king could advance and visualise a religiously sanctified social order (dharma), from which his authority as a ruler by God's grace was deduced.Footnote 18 Partly due to this policy, Northern India became covered with religious monuments of various sorts, a small number of which survived the ages. The Gupta court and its satellites promoted a lifestyle and devotional ethos that obviously was appealing to a broad section of the population; it proved not only to be politically effective, but it lent stability and grandeur to Gupta reign, thanks to which some still speak of ‘the golden age’, or ‘the classical age’.Footnote 19
Mandhal
This successful model set an attractive example for other dynasties to follow. Influence emanating from the Gupta realm becomes best visible in a dynasty to the south of the Vindhyas with which close relations were established, the Eastern Vākāṭakas of Vidarbha.
Candragupta had married a princess of the Nāga dynasty (an old enemy of his father Samudra) named Kuberanāgā, by whom he had a daughter. This princess, who came to be known from her own inscriptions by her dynastic name Prabhāvatī Guptā, was married to the Vākāṭaka prince Rudrasena II in about AD 388.Footnote 20 The Nāgas had been a major force in Eastern Malwa and the region around Udayagiri–Vidiśā till the Gupta conquest, and the marriage of a Gupta-Nāga princess with the crown-prince of the Vākāṭakas established a triangular political relationship between the centre of Gupta power in the Gaṅgā-Yamunā doab in the North, Vidiśā in the West, and the Eastern Vākāṭaka kingdom in the South.Footnote 21
Rudrasena, once king, inspired it would seem by the example of his in-laws, initiated a tradition of large-scale religious patronage within the Vākāṭaka kingdom.Footnote 22 Two inscriptions of Rudrasena himself bear testimony to this: the Deotek Inscription and the Mandhal Plates, Year 5. The Deotek palimpsest stone inscription (Rudrasena overwriting an inscription that apparently pertains to the reign of Aśoka) records the erection of a Dharmasthāna, evidently in the vicinity of present-day village Deotek on the Beṇṇā or Wainganga River. No further details of this building are known. Forty kilometers to the north of it is the site of the second Rudrasena inscription discovery, which was found while ploughing a field near the village of Mandhal.Footnote 23
The locations of both inscriptions indicate that the earliest political heart of the Vākāṭaka kingdom was along the Wainganga, to the south of Nagpur. This may have been the Padmapura district that is known from two inscriptions, one of which is Rudrasena's Mandhal Plates. Although the exact size and location of this district is unknown, the area around the present village of Mandhal no doubt belonged to it.Footnote 24 Padmapura itself must have been the capital of this district. This capital features in the so-called ‘unfinished Durg’ or Mohallā Plate.Footnote 25 Closer consideration of the Mohallā Plate leads to the hypothesis that Padmapura was the political centre of Rudrasena II's reign.
Padmapura
After mentioning Padmapura as the place of issue, padmapurāt, the Mohallā Plate begins the dynastic genealogy, i.e., the praśasti, of the Eastern Vākāṭaka kings in words that are identical to Rudrasena's Mandhal Plates up to bhavanāgadauhitrasya (ll. 2–7), which refers to Rudrasena I.Footnote 26 The inscription breaks off abruptly; no other plates have come forward and the single plate found in Mohallā lacks the mark of approval: dṛṣṭam, although space had been reserved for it.Footnote 27 Until now the Mohallā Plate was either ascribed to Pravarasena II or his son Narendrasena (proposed by Mirashi),Footnote 28 or to Pṛthivīṣeṇa I or his son Rudrasena II (proposed by Shastri),Footnote 29 or to “a successor of Pravarasena II” (proposed by Shrimali).Footnote 30
The discovery of Rudrasena II's Mandhal Plates has revealed that the praśasti of the dynasty of the Eastern Vākāṭakas was already fully developed by Rudrasena II's time, thus taking the edge off Mirashi's argument that the praśasti of the Mohallā Plate resembles that of the grants of Pravarasena II.Footnote 31 The wording of the praśasti resembles indeed the one found in Pravarasena II's inscriptions, but it equally resembles the one of Rudrasena II's charter. The box-headed palæography of the Mohallā Plate does also not significantly differ from the Mandhal Plates of Rudrasena, nor from Pravarasena's plates for that matter.Footnote 32 However, Pravarasena's charters were issued from either Nandivardhana or Pravarapura.Footnote 33
Pṛthivīṣeṇa I, the most likely author of the Mohallā Plate according to Shastri,Footnote 34 is an unlikely candidate in my view, since it is questionable whether this king already used the medium of copper plates to record his chartersFootnote 35 – at least nothing has been found – although, admittedly, he might have been the founder of Padmapura.Footnote 36
To finish our review of possible authors of the Mohallā Plate, there is Pṛthivīṣeṇa II, the only successor of Pravarasena II of whom we have inscriptions. His charters were issued from, a) the Rāmagiri (Mandhal Plates, Year 2), or b) Pṛthivīsamudra (Mahurjhari Plates), which is unidentified, but may have been a new residence of Pṛthivīṣeṇa II, or c) the Beṇṇātaṭasthāna (Mandhal Plates, Year 10), but nowhere does this king refer to Padmapura.Footnote 37 The Beṇṇātaṭasthāna, called vaijayika dharmasthāna, was a place at the bank of the Wainganga, probably not far from Mandhal, and this Dharmasthāna may have been the same as the one reported by Rudrasena in his Deotek inscription.Footnote 38 Pṛthivīṣeṇa II was, like Rudrasena II, a Bhāgavata.
On account of the above considerations it is our best guess to ascribe the unfinished Mohallā Plate to the same Rudrasena II who issued the Mandhal Plates, Year 5. However, instead of mentioning Padmapura as the place of issue, as one might have expected on the basis of this hypothesis, these Mandhal Plates specify the god ‘Mondasvāmin’ as the issuing agency. Yet, there is archaeological and historical evidence that makes it plausible that this authority relates to a Viṣṇu temple in the Mandhal area, that is, arguably, in the vicinity of Padmapura, as we will see below.
Muṇḍasvāmin
In his Mandhal Plates Rudrasena II styled himself as someone “whose rule is based on the cakra, the emblem of the Bhagavat”,Footnote 39 i.e. Viṣṇu; in other words, just like his father-in-law Candragupta, Rudrasena professed to be a bhāgavata. The Vākāṭaka kings before and after him, with the exception of Pṛthivīṣeṇa II, were all devotees of Maheśvara (Śiva), i.e. Māheśvaras, so it seems that his conversion to Bhagavatism had been part of an antenuptial contract.
And there is more in this inscription, which may be dated to c. AD 400, that links up with Candragupta, who, at about this time, was engaged in his grand Udayagiri project. The opening of the Mandhal inscription runs as follows:
Success! Approved. By order of Lord ‘Mondasvāmin’, God of gods, who holds the conch, discus and sword; after He had made the Nāga king stretch out on the waters of the ocean, He has entered a state of yogic sleep, while lying on the serpent coils of that (king), the Infinite One (Ananta) – a bundle of expanded hoods bending (over Him by way of canopy).Footnote 40
The reading of the first lines of the first plate are difficult due to severe damage. The editors Gupta & Shastri read in the middle of line 2: mondasvāminas°; in the published photograph of Plate 1, I can read °svāminas°, but the reading ‘monda’ is impossible to confirm. The word monda gives apparently little sense. Dental and cerebral nd are identical but for their top part, in which the square head-mark is replaced by two short curved strokes. Assuming that the reading moṇḍa is correct, we could think of Prakrit influence by which ǒ replaced u before a double consonant without much change of pronouncation.Footnote 41 If moṇḍa is not the correct reading – the upper and lower part of the akṣara are illegible – one could think of reading mau instead of mo, the difference between mo and mau being only that the right top stroke is making an upward curve rather than being a horizontal curve. Or, more likely perhaps, mu, in which the straight stroke down forming the short syllable u has become erased. I tentatively conjecture the reading muṇḍasvāminas°, but mo(au)ṇḍasvāminas° cannot be excluded either.
The image described is that of the great Nārāyaṇa relief in Udayagiri. But who is this Monda- or Muṇḍasvāmin who gave the instruction (saṃdeśa)? Certainly this refers to Viṣṇu–Nārāyaṇa, but it remains unclear whether it signifies a local deity (i.e., image) installed in a temple in Mandhal/Padmapura. The editors of the inscription do not come forward with a satisfactory explanation of this name.Footnote 42 I would like to suggest that the first part of the name muṇḍa refers to an eponymous person who envisaged and installed this manifestation of the Bhagavat.
As Isaacson and I have shown elsewhere, the ‘Kevala Narasiṃha Temple Inscription’ on the Rāmagiri mentions the princess that was wedded to Rudrasena by the name of ‘Muṇḍā’ – “a younger daughter who resembled the lustre of the moon”,Footnote 43 the same lady who, from her own inscriptions, came to be known as the ‘Lustrous One’, Prabhāvatī. This queen may have used the name Muṇḍā as long as her husband was still alive and may have changed it into the dynastic ‘Prabhāvatī Guptā’ after she had assumed power in Vidarbha as the regentess of her minor sons in about AD 405.Footnote 44 Muṇḍa- or Moṇḍasvāmin, and even Mauṇḍasvāmin interpreted as a Karmadhāraya compound, may thus be taken to mean ‘Lord of Muṇḍā’, ‘Muṇḍā's Lord’ that is the ‘God of Prabhāvatī’. As far as I am aware, this is the first attestation of the practice to name the installed deity after a living founder (svanāmnā).Footnote 45
The aim of Rudrasena's Mandhal inscription is not the installation of this deity, but rather the donation by the king of four villages in the eastern division of Padmapura to a pair of settlements (adhivāsa) of the Sātvata caraṇa (branch/school), which came from Vatsagulma, the capital of the Western Vākāṭakas.Footnote 46 This is the earliest attestation of royal support of a Bhāgavata organisation named Sātvata, a religious sect known, for instance, from the Mahābhārata (12.332.13–18) and the ‘Tusam Rock Inscription’.Footnote 47 The Sātvatas worshipped Vāsudeva and the four other members of the Vṛṣṇi clan; they originated from western India.Footnote 48 The invocation of the god of his wife strongly suggests that Rudrasena was acting on her behalf: the queen hiding herself behind the god Mu(o/au)ṇḍasvāmin at whose command the grant was made. The heuristic principle cherchez la femme has again proven its value.
The Mandhal inscription thus seems to prove that the Vākāṭaka queen (née Gupta) followed in her father's footsteps by favouring religious organisations and building temples. She may have been the major source of inspiration of her husband and have brought the Sātvata ritual experts from Vatsagulma to Padmapura in order to serve in her new temple.
Archaeological excavations in Mandhal have brought to light three temples, the most prominent of which stood on top of a hillock named Boṃgī Huḍkī (BHK II); this temple was built on a massive platform (11.70 × 14.70 m), with a garbhagṛha and maṇḍapa. The platform was partly built into the surface of the rock, which was levelled by 32 layers of brick at the southern side.Footnote 49 At the foot of this hillock excavations revealed another building (BHK I); underneath its brick floor a dozen of Hindu sculptures were found, among which two or three images of the Sātvata deities: Vāsudeva, Saṃkarṣaṇa, and (possibly) Sāmba (Āditya).Footnote 50 Whether or not this Vāsudeva image represented the Muṇḍasvāmin is impossible to say. The fact that, next to these three Vaiṣṇava images, five stylistically very similar images of markedly Śaiva nature were discovered,Footnote 51 testifies to the apparently harmonious way by which the Bhāgavatas and Māheśvaras existed side by side, tapping the same royal source of subsistence.
Rāmagiri
Rudrasena died young. His sudden death may account for the fact that the Mohallā Plate remained unfinished. His Gupta queen assumed power, officially as regentess of her minor sons. Her Poona Plates, dated in the thirteenth year of the yuvarāja Divākarasena, i.e., around AD 418, show that momentous decisions had been taken since the Mandhal foundations.Footnote 52 The dowager queen had her residence moved northwards, to Nandivardhana at the foot of the Rāmagiri, which hill she was developing into a state sanctuary that could match her father's Udayagiri. Again a hilltop was chosen; two minor caves were excavated on its slope, but the main Bhāgavata sanctuaries were stone temples on the top, five of which survive till today.
The Poona Plates convey the impression that Prabhāvatī was personally involved in promoting the cause of the Bhāgavata religion. The charter was issued on the twelfth of the bright half of Kārttika, after breaking the fast of Prabodhinī Ekādaśī, Viṣṇu-Nārāyaṇa's awakening from his cosmic sleep (earlier referred to in Rudrasena's Mandhal Plates). This festival of cosmogonic re-awakening had an important political dimension, as has been shown by Michael Willis in the case of Candragupta and Udayagiri,Footnote 53 a case that must have been very well known to the queen. Styling herself as entirely devoted to the Bhagavat (atyantabhagavadbhaktā), at this occasion she bestowed land upon another bhagavadbhakta, the ācārya Canālasvāmin, who may have been one of the priests responsible for the waking rite and who may have been the queen's own teacher.Footnote 54 The grant was first ritually offered (nivedya) to the bhagavadpādamūla, the feet of the Lord. As we learn from Prabhāvatī's Ṛiddhapur Plates, which mention the pādamūla of the Lord of the Rāmagiri (rāmagirisvāmin),Footnote 55 this may be taken to refer to the main sanctuary on top of the Rāmagiri.Footnote 56 A parallelism with Udayagiri can even be extended further, since the oldest image that survives on the hill is that of the Boar, Varāha, lifting the world (Bhūdevī) on his tusk out of the cosmic ocean. That the idea was taken over but not slavishly copied, appears from the fact that the Rāmagiri Varāha is theriomorphic instead of half man half boar.Footnote 57
At Nagardhan and environs, the area identified with Prabhāvatī's residence Nandivardhana, (fragmentary) images have been found of Viṣṇu, but also of Gaṇeśa and the goddess Mahiṣāsuramardinī, whereas the discovery of a hoard of three splendid Buddhist bronzes, three prabhāvalis, a parasol, a bell and an incense-burner at Hamlapuri (a village near Nagardhan) testifies to the presence of the Buddhist Saṅgha close by the court of the Vākāṭaka queen.Footnote 58
Within this court Prabhāvatī's three sons grew up, but of only the youngest of them Pravarasena, do we possess records. These show that the prince had returned to the faith of his ancestors, since he called himself entirely devoted to Maheśvara.Footnote 59
Mansar
For several years Bhāgavatas and Māheśvaras were living together in the Nandivardhana residence, but somewhere between the eleventh and sixteenth years in the reign of Pravarasena, the latter had decided that he should construct his own residence, Pravarapura, and his own state sanctuary, Pravareśvara, both named after the king himself.Footnote 60 For these two building projects wonderful sites were found, which mirrored, as it were, the old residence and the Rāmagiri: five kilometers to the west on a hill, again, the Pravareśvara complex was erected, facing the Rāmagiri, whereas at its foot the residence Pravarapura arose. Excavations at these two sites near the village of Mansar (MNS III and II) during the last ten years have brought to light a wealth of material, which has been the subject of a symposium in the British Museum in 2008.Footnote 61
The personal seals, both, of Pravarasena and Prabhāvatī found in MNS II, suggest that the Vākāṭaka king stayed close to his mother and that she, at an advanced age, remained a powerful figure behind the scenes,Footnote 62 also in the new palace of her youngest son, which was her third and last residence since she had left the Gupta court of her youth – Padmapura, Nandivardhana, Pravarapura. When the Gupta-Nāga princess, the queen mother of the Vākāṭakas, eventually died in her early seventies in c. AD 443–444, a funeral monument (eḍūka) was erected, as I have argued elsewhere, at a location in between the Rāmagiri and Pravarapura, a monument that was appropriately guarded by a Nāga.Footnote 63
In the present context it may suffice to evaluate the recent discoveries at Mansar in as far as they throw light on the theme of this essay, royal patronage, religious tolerance, and the formation of Gupta-Vākāṭaka culture.
The magnificent state sanctuary (devakulasthāna) erected on the Hiḍimbā Tekḍī (Pravareśvara) near the village of Mansar (MNS III), served as the place where the ceremony of issuing royal charters was performed (dharmasthāna), as attested by the ‘Pāṇḍurṇā Plates of Pravarasena II, Year 29’, i.e., AD 441.Footnote 64 A generous land-donation was granted to a group of Vājasaneya brahmins, and the same inscription records that one of the donees (Somārya) received some more land later, after a ceremonial offering of sesamum (tilavācanaka), i.e. a śrāddha ritual, had been performed in that dharmasthāna.Footnote 65 The king's largesse towards his subjects was immortalised in the benign smile of the main Śiva image of this temple, the god who bestowed life on his devotees by extending his right hand to them, filled with flowers, in a gesture of benevolence (varadamudrā).Footnote 66
Conclusion
In the four decades or thereabouts following Candragupta's inauguration of his Udayagiri monument at the turn of the fifth century, his daughter (Muṇḍā/Prabhāvatī) had consecrated her sanctuary in Mandhal, probably on the Boṃgī Huḍkī, dedicated to Muṇḍasvāmin, and after that the sanctuaries on the Rāmagiri (Rāmagirisvāmin), and his grandson (Pravarasena) had founded his own state sanctuary, Pravareśvara, on a hilltop near the village of Mansar. Yet, as is the case in the Gupta kingdom, we have no documentation of the founding of these royal sanctuaries by the Vākāṭaka monarchs themselves.Footnote 67 The fact that, 1) these sanctuaries bore the names (Muṇḍasvāmin, Pravareśvara), 2) were alternatively dedicated to either the Bhagavat or Maheśvara, and, 3) served as hallowed places for making large donations to various religious groupings (Sātvatas and Vājasaneyins), shows however, that the policy of religious patronage initiated by Candragupta and his court was successfully continued in the Eastern Vākāṭaka kingdom, where it took on more and more the form of land donations.Footnote 68 And later a similar policy was practised by the Dharmamahārājas of the Western Vākāṭaka branch in Vatsagulma, in whose kingdom we find the famous Buddhist cave monuments of Ajanta. Though here too we witness the same curious phenomenon: the lack of charters of foundation issued by the reigning king, Hariṣeṇa himself.
Although the kings showed clearly their religious orientation, we have no evidence whatsoever that could point to great enmity between the religious organisations, although rivalry for patronage as well as clients no doubt did play a role. The first four decades of the fifth century, dominated by the rule of Candra- and Kumāragupta in the north and Prabhāvatī Guptā and Pravarasena in the south, may be counted among the most stable and peaceful periods in ancient Indian history. It is this stability established by good policy and tolerance that created the conditions for an unprecedented development of the religious imagination, reflected in the literary and visual arts, achieving a perfection that still impresses today.
The iconographic programme developed on the Udayagiri mountain was only partly taken over in the Vākāṭaka kingdom: images of Viṣṇu, Varāha, Narasiṃha, Gaṇeśa, and Mahiṣāsuramardinī are found at both locations, all nearly in the classical form that would remain normative for the centuries to come. However, in Vidarbha this sophisticated artistic tradition blended with a local form of craftsmanship which lent to it its peculiar, somewhat rustic flavour and which gave rise to creative experiments that were not all equally successful. The sculptures found in Mandhal are a good example of this. But in the course of a few years since the Mandhal inception, the classical images on the Rāmagiri of Varāha, Trivikrama, and Narasiṃha were created in the mature Vākāṭaka idiom, which surpassed their Udayagiri counterparts in artistic quality and refinement.
The workshop set up by Prabhāvatī for the production of high quality, red-sandstone sculptures continued to work under her son and reached an unmatched level of sophistication and originality in the sculptures that once adorned the Pravareśvara Temple. Although the research of these sculptures is still in its infancy and their iconography is still little understood, their appeal lies in their tranquility that expresses mood and emotional state (bhāva) rather than action (vikrama), sentiment and emotion (rasa) rather than force (bala), and as such they are characteristic of the best that Indian art has produced.
