Through an analysis of the experience of Hindus in Singapore from the period of the Straits Settlements to the present, this ambitious and well-researched book's pronounced objective is to ‘to articulate the actual points of engagement between institutions of religion and the state’ as well as ‘identify the various processes, mechanisms and strategies through which relations across these spheres are sustained’.
Dealing with such a large swathe of history spanning approximately two centuries is never an easy task. In order to achieve this dual objective, the leitmotif employed by Vineeta Sinha to sustain the book's narrative arc is the belief that in both colonial and postcolonial contexts, the interaction between Hindus and the prevailing statist bureaucracy of specific periods created a milieu where some aspects of religiosity were enabled while others were inhibited. Beginning with a helpful chapter offering background to the creation of the Straits Settlements, moving to the establishment in 1905 of the Mohammedan and Hindu Endowments Ordinance to the creation of the Hindu Endowment Board in independent Singapore, Sinha arrives at the conclusion that religious actors in Singapore are able to often successfully negotiate and navigate the occasionally stifling bureaucratic frameworks put in place to manage them.
Sinha's project is commendable for several reasons. First, her project goes some way in filling the underexplored relationship between Hindus and governance in Singapore — a gap made especially stark when compared to studies of other religions on the island such as Islam and Christianity. Second, and it is here that the book's greatest contribution is made, is the successful engagement with diverse data — both primary and secondary — that range from the archival to the ethnographic. The dividends from drawing on such rich data are most apparent in the discussion of the Straits Settlements, where both the religious landscape of the period as well as the relationship between coloniser and Hindu subject are vividly captured. Finally, by disciplining the discussion in each chapter into episodic blocks of history, the reader is permitted to appreciate how rules, laws, regulations and relationships are embedded in the past.
While there are indeed many praiseworthy aspects of the book, there are unfortunately some omissions. Two in particular are worth noting: the absence of a robust argument to justify why the Hindus as a subject best support the argument of the book and the failure to explicitly reveal the analytical framework utilised to arrive at the book's conclusion.
Two reasons are offered for why the Hindus have been selected to be the basis of this case study. Besides Sinha's own interest in the religion, the other reason proffered is that the Hindus have been understudied. These two reasons may not be sufficient to convince a critical reader as to why the Hindu community has been selected out of the plethora of religions in Singapore. Although the experience of the Hindus does to some degree support the argument, it begs the question of whether the study of another religious group would have led to very different conclusions. Can the experience of the Hindus be enough to draw the general conclusion that religious actors are able to successfully traverse bureaucratic obstacles? It is difficult to fully accept the conclusion that religious actors have been successful at overcoming bureaucratic impediments and hindrances in Singapore.
All in all, the points raised do not diminish the value of this book for anyone interested in either the issues surrounding the history of Hindus in Singapore or the nexus between religion and governance. It would be of interest to specialists already aware of the issues as well as students who require an introduction to the subject.
