Bosselmann is writing from an ecocentric world view, a nature-centred set of values where concern for the non-human natural world needs to be incorporated into a system of ethics. This gives the book a distinctive stance, positioning it at some distance from much of the environmental mainstream. For example, Bosselmann regards the Brundtland report as deficient because it did not attempt to incorporate regard for nature or the planetary eco-system (World Commission on Environment and Development, 1987).
Klaus Bosselmann believes that sustainability should be a key legal principle, as are liberty, justice and equality. He argues that sustainability has the historical, conceptual and ethical attributes to sustain this position. But more than that Bosselmann wants sustainability to be seen as a guiding principle for the entire legal system going beyond the confines of environmental law. Sustainable development is, for Bosselmann, an application of sustainability with sustainability as the most fundamental of all environment principles. Like other fundamental principles, it cannot always be defined precisely yet they are ‘absolutely indispensable as guiding ideals for the design of public policy’ (p. 63). How ambitious Bosselmann is can be seen from his discussion of ecological justice where he argues that non-human life forms must be given protection and respect in a global legal system based upon the principles of sustainability. In his chapter on ecological human rights, Bosselmann explains that they are two fold: the protection of individual freedoms and the protection of the environment. Rights have to be complemented by obligations, otherwise anthropocentrism results as in the case of property rights which pay no attention to environmental limits. The radicalism of his perspective can be seen in his chapter on the state as environmental trustee, where he argues that territoriality is an outdated concept as the territory encompassed by the nation state is part of the global environment and therefore states should be restricted in the use they make of the land. For him, states should be seen as trustees of the land and the environment they administer. Throughout the book Bosselmann refers to the principles laid down in the Earth Charter (http://www.earthcharterinaction.org), which was developed out of the Rio Summit deliberations in the 1990s and is inclusive of all beings and life on the planet.
The Principles of Sustainability is a stimulating and thoughtful analysis of environmental law from the ecocentric perspective. This is clearly manifest in his last chapter on governance where he asks the reader to imagine in relation to a particular law if the subjects of it were not only human beings but other creatures and ‘Do we have adequate techniques and methodologies for “consulting” and ascertaining the current and future interests of rivers?’ (p. 177). It would appear that environmental law is some considerable way from the perspective advocated by Bosselmann; indeed, he admits this when he concedes that we have a ‘state-centred anthropocentic system for the quality of environmental protection’ (p. 161). Nonetheless, for all interested in the concept of sustainability – lawyers or not – this is a stimulating discussion.
