General works on Chinese and Russian history have repeatedly dwelled on Mongolia's isolation during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, an assertion that has been challenged over the past decade. Numerous Chinese merchants either visited or lived in the country in the nineteenth century, while Russian adventurers, explorers, and scientists travelled there and or conducted research on Mongolian flora and fauna. Individual Scandinavian, German, and British citizens arrived in the Land of the Blue Sky to engage in trade, to promote Christianity, and to map and study this vast, largely uninhabited domain. The Danes were especially active and collected Mongolian artifacts and manuscripts, which are currently housed in an ethnological museum and the Royal Library. Americans, entranced by the country, also came to Mongolia, and the Mongolist Owen Lattimore and the adventurer and curator Roy Chapman Andrew, in their writings, brought Mongolia to the attention of the world.
Japan and individual Japanese were also among the most prominent foreigners with a great interest in Mongolia. Specialists on early-modern and modern Mongolian history have known about Japanese involvement, but Dr Boyd, in the book under review, has produced the first monograph on the subject. Chinese, Western, and Mongolian historians have written about Japan's political and military policies concerning Mongolia, but Dr Boyd, who consulted Japanese archives and books, offers the Japanese perspective. His book is unique because most previous analyses have focused on Chinese, Russian, or Mongolian policies and attitudes toward Mongolia.
Dr Boyd's major theme is that Japanese policy makers were interested in influencing and perhaps dominating Mongolia from the late nineteenth century on. Thus conventional wisdom has been that the Japanese military drove Japan into armed confrontations regarding Manchuria and Mongolia. Dr Boyd shows that government officials recognised the geo-political significance of Mongolia and sought to capitalise on the Qing dynasty's collapse in 1911 to become the dominant force in Northeast Asia. The Communist revolution in Mongolia in 1921 precluded a role for the Japanese, so they turned their attention to Inner Mongolia, a region where they would meddle in the 1930s. Their involvement in Inner Mongolia has previously been described, but Dr Boyd provides a straightforward narrative, bolstered by new information from the Japanese archives.
The most intriguing aspect of Dr Boyd's book is the Japanese perception that its “relationship with Mongolia [was]. . .a special one.” (p. 8) The Japanese had a romantic view of their identification with Mongolia, stretching back to Mongolia's prehistory as a fountainhead of Japanese culture. Historians bolstered these links by pointing to the shamanism and Buddhism that both shared, and some nationalists bizarrely claimed that Minamoto no Yoshitsune had not died in his 1189 conflict with his brother but had simply fled to the mainland and assumed the name “Chinggis Khan”.
In short, Dr Boyd's book adds to the relatively few works on early-modern and modern Northeast Asia.
