Fabien Tarby’s extended interview with Alain Badiou in Philosophy and the Event is an excellent text for anyone curious about the work of Alain Badiou. The conversational style allows for a jargon-free entry into Badiou’s work, and does not require readers to have prior knowledge of his work, making it amenable to a diverse group of readers.
The text is comprised of six chapters. The first four cover what Badiou calls ‘truth procedures.’ They include: politics, love, art, and science. For Badiou, truth is what is novel, a form of knowledge that has not already been structured by our various institutions. For instance, there may be an idea of art that functions within a given historical period. However, when an entirely new form of art appears on the scene that puts into question this basic idea, the very concept of ‘art’ must be thought anew. Most often in Badiou literature (and Badiou’s work as well), these four procedures are delineated in order to examine one particular truth procedure, to the exclusion of the rest. However, what is unique to this text is that each procedure is treated both independently and in relation to the other procedures. For instance, the second chapter succinctly states the difference between love and politics.
In each of the first five chapters, Badiou conveys the meaning of the technical concepts of his work (e.g., ‘event,’ ‘multiplicity,’ ‘truth’), allowing the reader to understand how these concepts are used in each truth procedure. In addition, Badiou maps out the relation between his larger texts: Being and Event, and Logics of Worlds—currently his two largest and most closely related texts—as well as Theory of the Subject and The Immanence of Truths. Philosophy and the Event therefore situates his project as a whole. As a result, one can approach Badiou’s work, not in a piecemeal fashion, but with an (albeit brief) understanding of the conceptual mapping of his entire system. For this reason, this text is helpful for anyone wanting to navigate Badiou not only for independent study, but for the uptake of Badiou in the classroom. In fact, the timeliest aspects of this interview are Badiou’s discussions of his project in relation to contemporary issues, such as the Israel-Palestine conflict, and his take on environmentalism.
Chapter One addresses the most prevalent theme in Badiou’s work: politics. Tarby’s knowledge of Badiou’s work is considerable and shapes the interview in an important way. His questions are pointed and diverse, and he doesn’t shy away from hard-hitting problems such as how Badiou would respond to the criticism that his text “Uses of the Word ‘Jew’” can be read as anti-Semitic. Chapter Two is a discussion of Badiou’s concept of love. In tandem with the previous chapter, it starts off by drawing distinctions between love and politics. Badiou discusses what love is, and, importantly for his view, why it is not a psychological state of mind. He also provides an elucidation of his often elusive and controversial account of masculine and feminine sexuality. Chapter Four commences with a discussion on Martin Heidegger and technology in relation to this chapter’s theme: science. Tarby challenges Badiou by having him account for his prioritization of mathematics and logic over biology, physics, and chemistry.
Perhaps the most interesting chapter, and the most accessible, is Chapter Three, the chapter on art. Here, Badiou defends why certain kinds of art are capable of producing truth, and why others, such as popular art, are not. He not only describes what is necessary in order for a new form of art to appear, but also the importance and role of both artist and spectator. This chapter goes beyond the most prevalent example of art for Badiou, the shift from tonal to a-tonal classical music, to cinema (e.g., Jean-Luc Godard, Charlie Chaplin), rock ‘n’ roll (e.g., The Beatles, Metallica), the muralist projects of 1930s Mexico, and perhaps of interest to many students of Badiou’s work, a discussion about jazz generally, and John Coltrane in particular. What is significant is that Badiou attempts to clarify that he has (at least somewhat) thought about the Eurocentrism of his own examples. Badiou notes his examples are not the only examples that can be given, but that he draws primarily from his own field of study and experience, which does not properly attend to the non-Western world.
Following the discussion of the four truth procedures in the previous chapters, Chapter Five moves into a discussion of philosophy more generally, and a brief, yet clear, articulation of the content and structure of his third book in the Being and Event trilogy. This forthcoming text, entitled The Immanence of Truths, will be the culmination of Being and Event and Logics of Worlds because it attends “from the point of view of truths” to the topics of being and appearing (the topics of the former and latter texts, respectively) (107).
If there were one limitation of this book, it would be Chapter Six: “A short Introduction to Alain Badiou’s Philosophy.” The interview provides a concise and jargon-free account of Badiou’s project. This chapter, however, presents to a more complicated picture of Badiou’s project. Chapter Six begins by sensationalizing Badiou as a political figure, and as is common with Badiou scholarship, Tarby is unable to wholly refrain from falling into Badiou’s dense philosophical jargon. This chapter is thus better suited for an audience with a comprehensive understanding of the history of philosophy, than for a more general reader with an interest in Badiou’s writings.
Overall, Philosophy and the Event is a formidable text for anyone seeking an introduction to the work of Alain Badiou. In addition to being a point of entry into Badiou’s project, the text provides several yet to be explored facets of his system, and, as such, should also be on the reading list of even the specialized reader.
