Anna Rose Alexander's urban environmental history explores the dark and fiery side of modernity and urbanisation in Mexico City between 1860 and the eve of the Mexican Revolution. As population grew and industry expanded, fire forced city officials, engineers, doctors, inventors, merchants, insurance agents, and residents to ‘reevaluate how they understood and interacted with the dangers and limitations of their physical world’ (p. 4). The author argues that not just the educated elite but everyday citizens responded with technical expertise and innovation to the new fire hazards that ravaged butchers’ shops, match factories, bakeries, tanneries, and soap manufacturers. Indeed, by demonstrating that residents played a primary role in shaping fire control and prevention within an ‘infrastructure of flammability’ (p. 6), the author identifies new sources of expertise in a ciudad científica, which privileged the applied science of engineers, positivists and social Darwinists during President Porfirio Diaz’ rule (1876–1911), particularly the period beginning in the 1890s. Fire allows the author to tell important stories about health and hygiene, socioeconomic status and urban space, and Porfirian order and progress. Additionally, by exploring tensions between public intervention and the increased privatisation of responsibility for fire safety, the book resonates in our own neoliberal era, in which blind faith in the ‘free’ market displaces collective response.
City on Fire claims to break from traditional periodisation and to demonstrate that important developments took place in Mexico City in the two decades prior to the Porfiriato (1876–1911). Justifying the decision to end the study on the brink of the Mexican Revolution, the author argues that although combat and arson produced fires during the long civil war, fire became a revolutionary tool and not the ‘accident of modernity’ that this study takes as its primary focus (p. 4). The book makes a new contribution to Mexican science and technology studies by moving beyond mining extraction, textile manufacturing and railroad development. A close reading of newspapers, broadsheets, contemporary medical and engineering journals and fiction, to name just a few, allows the author to sketch a diverse and engaging social landscape in which citizens expanded ‘fields of science, engineering, medicine, and business in order to confront urban risk’ (p. 5).
The book is organised thematically. Chapter 1 explores how fires created a culture of fear and danger and forced urbanites to imagine the ‘city as an unsafe, disorderly place full of vice and danger’ (p. 17). Examining fire-fighting in the ciudad científica, Chapter 2 demonstrates that scientific governance was not limited to large and ambitious projects or endeavours but indeed insinuated its way into smaller-scale regulation, monitoring and behaviour regulation. Chapters 3 and 4 turn their attention to the role of expertise. While fire brigades lent ‘an air of modernity and progressiveness’ to Mexico City, they also ‘helped to reinforce the severe inequalities of the period’ by seeking foreign investment and protecting industrialists and the business environment (p. 41). The ‘technocratic form of political administration’ popular during the Porfiriato emphasised applied science and engineering. Indeed, this ‘disaster expertise’ responded to ‘a global trend that gave privilege to university-trained scientists and engineers, who increasingly were called upon to offer insight on how to confront problems that plagued cities’. Regulatory actions ceded control to engineers and other experts who applied scientific rationality to planning and public policy (pp. 57, 77–8).
Chapters 5–6 shift the focus to ‘homegrown’ responses to disaster and bring the debate over public outlays and private solutions to the forefront. Scientists and engineers ceded space to inventor-entrepreneurs who step forward to develop new fire-fighting technologies such as fire grenades, copyrights and patents for inventions, fire insurance policies to protect private property, and medicines to treat burns. Residents used their knowledge of local conditions to ‘challenge the idea that technology had to be imported from the United States or Europe’. Throughout, the study underscores ‘parallel processes’ of public and private responsibility (pp. 78–80). Residents at once demanded intervention from municipal government officials to provide fire protection while producing their own inventions to respond to hazards. Similarly, public officials at once placed responsibility on residents for fire safety and made their own commitment to citizen safety.
City on Fire is well written, engaging, and accessible for undergraduates and graduates as an introduction to science and technology studies, urban history and disaster literature in Latin America and beyond. The author's creative use of primary sources populates the book with diverse actors and creates a cityscape that would be at home in any social history. At times, fire safety and prevention debates seem divorced from the historical context of the pre-revolutionary period and sketch an urban context removed from the rural upheaval to come. However, while the author demonstrates that Mexico City's ‘attempts to imitate the building styles, electric lighting, and transportation systems of Western Europe and the United States ultimately made the capital more prone to fires’ (p. 250), the author is careful not to lay this at the feet of Dependency Theory or to wallow in the failure of the ‘periphery’. Mexicans from many socioeconomic orbits shaped and informed a response to the modern phenomenon of fire disaster within a unique social, cultural and economic context.
