This ambitious study is pathbreaking. It grapples with issues of regime type, political transition, and policy implementation. It compares and contrasts the capabilities of culturalism, institutionalism, and rational choice to explain political behavior. The primary focus is on populism, which the author constructs as an ideational paradigm. Kirk Hawkins's work synthesizes a decade of fieldwork, employing mixed methodologies to develop findings that are important and often counterintuitive.
In this volume, populism emerges as a set of ideas that are critical for understanding Chavismo, the social movement of Venezuela's President Hugo Chávez Frías. This places the work in the culturalist tradition pioneered by Mark Ross. Hawkins draws on this tradition to construct populism as a “worldview” or “discourse” about the nature of politics, one revolving about the Manichean struggle between “Good” and “Evil.” Good encompasses the “will of the people,” or the natural common interest of the citizens once they are allowed to form their own opinions. Evil is a conspiring elite that has subverted this will (p. 5). Only through comprehensive institutional change can the will of the people triumph over an evil regime. The imperative of triumphing trumps procedural rights.
Hawkins wastes no time in tackling methodological concerns. First is whether ideationally specified populism can be measured in a way that is valid, reliable, and efficient—with results that can be replicated and verified by others (p. 48). He asserts that methodologies exist that facilitate measurement and replication. Second, he acknowledges that his approach raises ontological issues that are subsumed in the question of whether populism is real if it is spoken and thought but never followed. The concern here is that populist movements engage in varieties of behavior that are shared by different kinds of political organizations and leaders. Hawkins's rejoinder is that what marks diverse actions and organizations as populist is their meaning for participants and onlookers, and that meaning can be specified and measured. A final methodological concern involves the real world importance of populism defined as worldview. In other words, does populism matter, or do political actors respond to sets of preferences rooted in, for example, material self-interest? Hawkins argues that ideas matter.
This work investigates three basic questions about Chavismo. First, what is it? Hawkins moves quickly beyond the obvious to define Chavismo as an ideational concept in the culturalist tradition. The second question inquires: How did Chavismo emerge? Third, Hawkins asks: What are Chavismo's consequences for political organization and resource allocation?
The chapters of this volume begin with narrow studies of Chavismo and move to broader comparisons with political behavior in known populist regimes. Chapter 2 profiles the successes and setbacks of Chavismo—from the unforeseen coup attempt of February 4, 1992, through efforts in 2008 to impose constitutional changes that voters rejected in 2007. Chapter 3 probes the extent to which the behavior of President Chávez between 1992 and 2008 resembles that of other populist leaders. Chapter 4 examines the causes of Chavismo, while chapter 5 analyzes the rise of populism cross-nationally, in 35 other instances. Two additional chapters specify the consequences of Chavismo. One examines neighborhood associations known as the Bolivarian Circles and the other analyzes presidential “Missions.”
Three essential findings flow from this work. First, Chavismo emerges as a paradigmatic example of populism that becomes most comprehensible when examined through the culturalist lens. President Chávez is shown to possess a Manichean worldview that deprecates liberal democracy and leads to the demonization of opponents. Hawkins finds little support for strong constructivism as a technique for grasping the operational characteristics of Chavismo or populism. Rather, he concludes that traditional behavioralist approaches are most appropriate for understanding the causal properties of ideas, which he sees as responding to material constraints in our environment and in ourselves.
Second, Hawkins finds that Chavismo and populist movements in general are most likely to be successful when citizens view their governments as corrupt, especially when this perception rests on the failure by governments to implement rights of citizenship (particularly the rule of law). However, assessments that governments are corrupt by themselves appear insufficient to bring about regime change. Transformation to populism becomes more likely when perceptions that corruption is rampant interact with economic crisis.
Finally, in terms of consequences, this work finds that movements with a populist worldview (or dialogue) are inclined to eschew hierarchical organizations in favor of spontaneity and an organizational mentality in which anything goes. It also leads to discretionary spending (as with Chavez's presidential missions) that reflect an idiosyncratic partisan logic that often works at cross-purposes with the goal of maximizing electoral support.
A weighty theoretical question left hanging concerns whether populism is a stable regime type or a transitional form. On balance, Hawkins implies the former his populism appears as a regime type comparable to monarchy, fascism, liberal democracy, or leftist authoritarianism. Hawkins opines that because early in his presidency Chávez did not describe his movement as socialist, he was not an authoritarian leftist. Hawkins does acknowledge that ideology can transform a worldview, “but in the case of Chavismo this transformation has yet to occur” (p. 85). However, events in Venezuela between 2006 and 2011 cast doubt on this assessment. It is plausible that following his release from prison in 1994, Chávez calculated that if he openly embraced socialism he would undercut his appeal, and that early in his presidency he eschewed the socialist label because he feared that it might threaten his hold on power. Following victory in the recall election of July 31, 2004, Chávez's position became more secure. Subsequently, he orchestrated changes to Venezuelan political institutions that produced bureaucracies that bear a striking resemblance to their counterparts in communist Cuba. This supports the proposition that populism is a transitional configuration in which charismatic leaders (as described by Max Weber) use personal authority to bring about regime change.
Reluctance to view populism as inherently unstable reappears in the presentation of likely evolutionary scenarios for Chavismo. Hawkins argues that the most credible scenario is one in which the essential characteristics of Chavismo persist. Two less likely scenarios are dissolution and transformation. However, this work suggests another important scenario, the slide into authoritarian leftism. This is hinted at on several occasions but never examined systematically.
The contributions of this work are substantial. Most significant is the skillful formulation and justification of an ideational-based “minimal definition” of populism. Hawkins defends this definition on logical grounds, showing how it plays out across countries and over time. The use of a quantitative technique from educational psychology (holistic grading) to analyze the worldview of a large sample of leaders breaks new ground. The resulting data set provides strong support for the proposition that culturalist concepts can be measured and taken seriously.
This volume also adds to our knowledge of the causes of populism. Earlier explanations ignore the normative underpinnings that receive a central place here. The research makes a strong case that charismatic leaders are the essential catalyst in transitions to populism when they convey the right message. Hawkins identifies other causal mechanisms and traces them through the use of individual-level data. Finally, this work breaks new ground by identifying how populist ideas shape political institutions and influence discretionary spending. Thus, ideational populism emerges as a force that shapes the solving of problems that have moral dimensions rooted in material reality. The author's skill in crafting this perspective and in painting Chavismo as the paradigmatic case of populism marks Venezuela's Chavismo and Populism in Comparative Perspective as a work of major significance.
