This beautifully written and edited book provides different perspectives on ‘fatherlessness’ in the ancient Mediterranean world. The essays offer ‘for the first time a cross-section of thematic and methodological approaches to ancient father-absence’ and seek to lay ‘a foundation for an initial approach to fatherlessness in the ancient Mediterranean world’ (4). The topic of father absence in modern life has garnered much attention from both politicians and academics; this book ‘about family dynamics and the ways in which ancient people compensated for the loss of a father’ (4) makes a valuable contribution to the multidisciplinary history of the family. Hübner and Ratzan present research showing that fathers do not share a cross-cultural, essential nature and timeless role but rather ‘three vital familial functions, namely the provision of economic, social, and emotional support for the mother and her children’ (8). In antiquity fatherlessness was mostly caused by death rather than divorce or abandonment, although ‘multiple demographic regimes may be detected at work in different socio-economic strata and geographic regions’ (9). The patriarchal nature of ancient cultures meant that fatherlessness would have had ‘a measurable impact on families and children’ (10) in economic disruption and loss of social capital, whether it occurred in a joint family household arrangement in Classical Greece or an aristocratic Republican Roman nuclear household. For certain types of fatherless children, the institution of guardianship was important. Because of the wide range of cultures, time periods, and evidence at play in this volume, the editors arranged the contributions by theme. Space constraints limit my remarks to only a few.
Part I: ‘Coping with Demographic Realities’ contains four studies which ‘trace the basic demographic, economic, and social dimensions of fatherlessness in the ancient world and glance at some of the ways in which individuals and communities responded’ (18). First, Walter Scheidel summarizes research on the demography of father absence, working especially with Richard Saller's analysis of numbers of men available to fulfill the paternal role for orphans. This analysis depends on the variables of ‘male age at first marriage and age-specific mortality levels’ (33). He concludes by presenting ‘three ideal-typical categories’ of father experience for children: (1) children of relatively young fathers, growing up under their father's care and potentially having to care in a paternal capacity for younger siblings, (2) children of relatively young fathers, orphaned while minors and growing up under the care of their fathers’ male relatives, but not having to assume such a role for younger siblings, and (3) children of older men orphaned while still minors and growing up under the guardianship of those who were not close male relatives. This provides a template for structuring the experience of ancient father-absence. Mark Golden (‘Oedipal complexities’) supplements Scheidel's template by using a variety of sources (such as epic and law) to broaden our picture of the fatherless experience. After bringing out the strangeness of figures such as stepmothers and stepfathers in myth, Golden discusses statistics showing fatherlessness as a common experience among teens and its effects. Citing modern statistics about stepfathers, who murder children under five years old ‘60 times as frequently as biological fathers . . . and are 120 times as likely to beat them to death’ (52), Golden compares Greek myths which never mention stepfathers abusing stepchildren, a suggestive omission since forensic oratory presents us with cases of conflict between them. Hübner's essay, ‘Callirhoe's dilemma: remarriage and stepfathers in the Greco-Roman East’, focuses on the neglect of stepfathers. Surveying varied genres to see how stepfathers interacted with their stepchildren, Hübner is careful to note generic influences on stepfather portrayal. While stepmothers are stereotypically evil, stepfathers are often protectors or guardians of fatherless children. In reality, very few fatherless children would have lived with stepfathers, since children were often left with their paternal relatives upon maternal remarriage. Hübner suggests that the negative stepmother stereotype arises from the common experience of stepmothers, whereas ‘cohabiting stepfathers’ were rare. Finally, Marcus Sigismund examines how biblical texts conceptualize fatherlessness and what the reality of the fatherless child was in Jewish and Christian communities.
Part II, ‘Virtual Fatherlessness’, examines types of fatherlessness caused by factors other than paternal death. After Hübner and Ratzan set out the vocabulary of fatherlessness, both actual and social, Daniel Ogden examines bastardy in Classical Athens, arguing that Classical Athenian culture put obstacles between fathers and male illegitimate children, constructing ‘a legal, social, religious, and even physical distance’ between them (105). For this reason, the status of bastard was associated with fatherlessness, in both myth and reality. Ogden's discussion of imagery of straightness (legitimate sons) and crookedness or deformity (illegitimate sons) is especially thought-provoking. Myrto Malouta contributes ‘Fatherlessness and formal identification in Roman Egypt’, analysing the effect of the legal designation of people unable to establish legitimate paternity as apatores. Malouta concludes that this status, common in all levels of Roman Egyptian society, was not damaging, since apatores appear to have had a ‘middling social position, extending from dike workers to village officials’ (138).
Part III, ‘Roles Without Models’, contains three articles examining specific examples of fatherlessness in Homeric epic and Roman history. Louise Pratt studies ‘Diomedes, the fatherless hero of the Iliad’, contending that Diomedes, who does not remember his father, serves as a foil to Achilles, whose relationships with his father and various surrogate fathers are important elements in the poem. While Diomedes’ fatherlessness does not keep him from achieving social success, it prevents him from developing the ‘emotional capacity for care’ that enables ‘the tragic vision of Achilles and of the poem itself’ (143). Focusing on father loss in Homeric epic, especially Telemachus in the Odyssey, Georg Wöhrle concludes that ‘in Homer's world a fatherless child's fortunes were precarious — socially, economically, emotionally — sometimes fatally so’ (174). Turning to fatherlessness as it affected élite women in Republican Roman culture, Judith Hallett examines how two daughters, Cornelia and Sulpicia, write about their distinguished, and absent, fathers. By ‘reading between the lines’ of these problematic sources, Hallett argues their fathers’ absences both influence the women to behave publicly in certain ways and to adopt rather ‘masculine’ stances.
Part IV, ‘Rhetoric of Loss’, is the largest of the volume, with five contributions focusing mostly on Roman and early Christian examples. Sabine Müller opens with a case study of how Sulla used his fatherlessness strategically to present himself as a ‘divinely protected, self-made man’ (200). Müller performs a ‘reality check’ on narratives of Sulla's life story. Needing to downplay male ancestors, patrons, or father figures in order to craft the personality cult of a charismatic hero, Sulla ‘sacrificed not only the memory of his family, but even that of his erstwhile mentors, Marius and Catulus’ (209). Sulla innovated by using both heroic narrative types and Eastern and Hellenistic models of divine favour (source of his felicitas). Ann-Cathrin Harders offers her own case study, ‘An imperial family man: Augustus as surrogate father to Marcus Antonius’ children’, asking why the Princeps chose to play this role. Observing that playing avunculus fulfilled social expectations, Harders argues that ‘(b)y ostentatiously demonstrating social responsibility for orphaned children, Augustus actually perverted a traditional Roman family strategy … to his own political ends’ (219). Especially interesting is her discussion of how this affected Antonius’ children. Finally, several articles look more generally at paternal surrogates in imperial Roman literature (Neil W. Bernstein), the education of orphans (Raffaella Cribiore), and ‘Christian ideals and the obligations of stepfathers in Late Antiquity’ (Geoffrey Nathan). A bibliography and index follow the essays.
The editors took great care with this volume, which contains few errors and excellent cross-referencing of the other articles contained within. The essays are of uniformly high quality; everyone interested in the ancient family will gain much from reading them.
