Carrie Rosefsky Wickham has added to her reputation as one of the premier scholars of the Arab scene with this meticulous and penetrating examination of the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood. Written with an eye for scrupulous detail, Wickham's fluency in both written and spoken Arabic informs her thesis at every juncture and her elaborate portrayal of the rise and development of the Brotherhood takes the reader on a journey that is both informative and provocative. Hasan al-Banna, founder of the Muslim Brotherhood, is familiar to virtually every student of twentieth-century Egypt, but Wickham sheds new light on his work and his lasting influence on the Egyptian people, and to many others in the surrounding Arab world. Indeed the author not only details the spreading, deepening impact of the Brotherhood throughout the Near and Middle East but focuses not a few pages on Muslim Brotherhood development in Jordan, Kuwait, and Morocco. But the author's main intention is to explore the contemporary character of the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood. She is committed to producing a book that traces the evolution of the movement from its years before World War II through the turbulence of military takeovers to the current emergence of a reborn Brotherhood vying for the soul of the Egyptian nation.
Wickham exposes the reader to the Brotherhood's complex internal struggles that have made it an organization representative of a large portion of Egypt's diverse population and thus acknowledged by a growing number of observers as a legitimate governing instrument for the larger nation. With a degree of deftness and with considerable success she examines the root causes of the Brotherhood's emergence as a force in shaping Egypt's political destiny. Always the grieving antihero, the Brotherhood has engaged in developments that lie at the heart of Egyptian efforts to steer a course into the future. Although the events are not described in voluminous detail the reader is given sufficient data to recognize the guideposts that not only make the Brotherhood a formidable political force but allow it to sink its roots deep in the psyche of the Egyptian masses.
With a masterful sense of proportion and balance Wickham wastes no time in setting the scene for the Brotherhood's appearance on the Egyptian stage in 1928. It is helpful if the reader is familiar with the period and Egypt's peculiar experience in the aftermath of World War I. British colonialism had already swept over the African continent from north to south and ancient Egypt and its relatively new Suez Canal loomed large in British naval circles. So too the prevailing Egyptian monarchy was no match for European wile and maneuver. A proud people were humbled by the distant culture that placed its imprint on the larger region and belittled Muslim achievement that earlier and many centuries prior enjoyed its own special eminence. Adding to the insult imposed on the Muslim ego the British took the lead in the formation of the Mandate System which not only rearranged the Arab Middle East, defined its boundaries, and sanctified its leaders, but made place for the rebirth of the ancient land of the Jews at the heart of reconstituted Arabia. Indeed the latter is threaded throughout the treatise. Although explained with a light touch Wickham leaves no doubt that the combination of British power and European dominance of Arabdom energized the early Muslim Brotherhood and sustains it in its current form. Many decades later Great Britain may no longer be a decisive force but its legacy continues to nurture the resistance to the Muslim Brotherhood's effort to restore Egypt's ethos as a central Islamic homeland.
The Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood in these early years of the twenty-first century is acknowledged to be the largest, most successful organization of its kind in the Muslim world. Born in the circumstances described above it has never given up its quest to become the Islamic world's most potent Islamic organization and the only true organization to frame the Muslim desire to live a life solely devoted to the teaching of the Muslim shari'a and transmission of the word of God. The bulk of Wikham's study explores this latter theme in the words of those who have and continue to represent the Brotherhood today. Wickham has placed herself in the very midst of Egypt's attempt to obliterate the main elements of Egypt's twentieth-century transformation and the Brotherhood's particular role in framing the Islamic alternative in a land struggling to define a course between secular expression and religious renewal. Central to this thesis are elements particularly within the Egyptian army that bear the tradition of Gamal Abdel Nasser, Anwar Sadat, and Hosni Mubarak. Again Wickham sidesteps telling the story of the Brotherhood's confrontation with the Egyptian army or the essentials of their differing positions on matters of religion and lifestyle. It is obvious, however, that the army remains the bulwark against Brotherhood attempts to transform Egypt into the total Islamic state. Secular Egyptians that include Egypt's minorities and major segments of the nation's intelligentsia would be no match for the Brotherhood without the support rendered the latter by the Egyptian military. The fact that they are of a single mind in limiting the effort by the Brotherhood explains the sustained struggle; it also underlines the strenuous program year after year and decade after decade to suppress it.
The reassertion of the Brotherhood in the period today known as the Arab Spring covers roughly the last half of the book. The acknowledged success of the Brotherhood in modifying its character during the changing conditions made manifest by Egypt's sustained political turbulence, and most importantly the Brotherhood's assumption of a key political role in Egyptian society, by sheer weight of numbers, is recounted in the movement's success in competing with and overwhelming the political forces arrayed against it. Muhammad Mursi's success in representing the winning side in the 2011–2012 elections following the fall of Mubarak and his claim as the new Egyptian president to represent all Egyptians are not without controversy, and, although not covered in this book, his sudden but predictable ouster by the Egyptian army leaves the country in limbo, more violence prone than at any time in its long history.
Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood has never yielded its stand to represent God's will on earth and its opposition has never countenanced its claim. The struggle that has long pitted Egypt's political forces against one another has attained proportions that today appear unmanageable. Carrie Rosefsky Wickham has authored a singularly important work for those especially interested in learning how religiously representative Egyptians think about their lives and the way forward. The author is commended for her labor and diligence and notably for her exploration of the mindset that has captured the fascination of people the world over.
