Sevan Terzian's Science Education and Citizenship delivers exactly what its title promises: a history of the changing character and purpose of extracurricular science education in the United States in the mid-twentieth century. The twist is in the book's chronology. Instead of starting with the Cold War – the familiar stimulus for a series of talent searches and science fairs designed to steer the best and brightest American youth into careers in science and technology – the launch of sputnik is, rather, the book's end point. Terzian's account makes clear that extracurricular science activities had became a familiar part of childhood in the United States well before cold warriors sounded the alarm on American scientific competitiveness.
The book's focus on the informal aspects of science education is a welcome departure from the existing literature on this topic, which tends to focus on curricular reforms, textbooks, and other formal aspects of classroom pedagogy. Nevertheless, Terzian's findings are unlikely to upend scholars' existing interpretations of the history of US science education. The Progressive Era science clubs and fairs sponsored by state academies of science were intended to develop students' habits of citizenship, following Deweyan ideals; during the Great Depression, the rise of corporate public relations threatened to undermine science fairs' connection to democratic values; the arrival of armed conflict in the form of the Second World War meant that manpower concerns (in the form of vocational training) ultimately trumped any lingering interest in using science to cultivate a rational citizenry. Terzian's careful documentation of the uneven participation rates in these programmes of African American and Hispanic youth, students from the poverty-stricken South and girls similarly provides useful data to back up critics' claims that meritocratic thinking perpetuates structural inequality.
The strength of Science Education and Citizenship is undoubtedly its ample use of several under-utilized primary sources, including the archival collections of the Westinghouse Educational Foundation and the American Institute of the City of New York for the Encouragement of Science and Invention. Both institutions sponsored science fairs throughout the New York metropolitan area; Westinghouse became a particularly avid supporter of informal science activities in the post-war era, underwriting talent searches, vocational agricultural training, classroom wallcharts and comic books. A somewhat separate strand of the book draws heavily on the journals and bulletins of state academies of science. Terzian's use of this neglected set of sources allows him to trace children's participation in science clubs in regions of the country more typically overlooked by historians. By 1946, approximately 300,000 junior and senior high-school boys and girls were participating annually in science-club activities across the country, from Alabama to Wyoming. While students living near urban centers usually had better access to laboratory facilities and scientific mentors, membership in a science club anywhere provided youth with opportunities to test their mechanical skills and observational mettle. During the Second World War, for example, the Secretary of the Navy requested that science-club members build 10,000 copies of fifty different model aeroplanes, to be used in training civilian spotters of enemy aircraft. Within months, thousands of model aeroplanes were pouring into the headquarters of the Army Air Force's First Fighter Command. Equal parts 4-H club and honor society, membership in a science club offered a student practical skills and civic engagement.
While the primary source material provides much of the book's rich texture, it also risks weighing it down. Terzian's laudably thorough footnotes suggest an impressive familiarity with the secondary literature not only in the history of science and education but also in broader US intellectual history; the text proper, in contrast, mostly does not engage with the interpretive issues raised by this literature. Given the author's deep excavation of the archival sources, for instance, he presumably has some insight into why organizations such as Westinghouse chose primarily to sponsor educational programmes outside schools. What was it that bothered them, specifically, about working within the public-school system? Did the organizers of extracurricular science clubs, fairs and talent searches mistrust (female) teachers? Schools boards? Parents? Was this a rogue attempt to establish national standards in an intensely localized school culture? An early attempt at privatizing what had previously been seen as a public responsibility? Or something else entirely? If Terzian knows, he doesn't tell us. Science Education and Citizenship will undoubtedly remain the source of record on mid-century American informal science education for some time to come, but the phenomenon itself awaits further explanation.
