Eugene Rogers' After the Spirit is one of the latest volumes in the Radical Traditions series. The book follows the mandate of the series by marshalling the resources of a religious tradition to challenge modernity. More specifically, After the Spirit draws on theologians from outside the modern West – Greek Fathers, Russian Orthodox thinkers and Syriac Christians, among others – to construct a pneumatology that redresses the problems bedevilling Western reflection on the Spirit.
Rogers' point of departure is a diagnosis of these difficulties. Karl Barth is the prime example of a problematic pattern: in Barth's extensive corpus, the Spirit seldom receives explicit mention. Christology does (almost) all the theological work, thus rendering the Spirit superfluous. Rogers playfully sums up the problem with much current pneumatology by adapting a ditty from Annie Get Your Gun: ‘Anything Spirit can do, Son can do better’ (p. 9).
Is there anything that the Spirit can do better than the Son? Rogers shows his theological acumen by framing his book around a nuanced answer to this question. He wants to avoid suggesting that the Spirit acts alone, for opera trinitatis ad extra indivisa sunt. Rogers attempts to distinguish, but not separate, the persons with this thesis: the Spirit rests on the body of the Son. The notion of embodiment seeks to ensure that this pneumatology does not become too spiritual, that is, lacking association with matter. The term ‘rest’ bears an active, not static, sense: it functions like ‘alight’ but without the latter term's suggestion of a temporary state. Though ‘rest’ is slightly elusive, Rogers goes no further with conceptual analysis. He prefers to illuminate his thesis by working through episodes in the New Testament in which the Son interacts with the Spirit. In each of these four iconic scenes, the focus is on the economic interaction, but Rogers explores ramifications regarding the Trinity itself and human participation in God.
For instance, at the resurrection, because of the Spirit, the Son can be the Messiah who fails, that is, one who relies on another (p. 94; cf. pp. 167–8). Rogers knows this language will shock Christians, but he nevertheless presses his point to stress the Spirit's role in the economy. The Spirit responds to Christ's waiting for him by offering an unexpected gift: the Gentiles. Through the Spirit, the Gentiles receive the blessings that the Jews retain. The resurrection identifies all three persons of the Trinity (Rom. 8:11).
Space limitations do not allow for a survey of the other three scenes (annunciation, baptism and transfiguration). Rogers reads a fifth episode, the Pentecost narrative in Acts, as a potential objection, a place in which the Spirit may act alone, after Jesus ascends to the Father. But, Rogers argues, Pentecost and Ascension are connected after all. Jesus reverses Adam's grasping at divinity and receives from the Spirit something that he already has so that he can share it with those who do not.
After the Spirit is the product of intelligent, intensive reading of the biblical text and some important tracts of the Christian tradition that Westerners have neglected for too long. The synthetic proposal is impressive in at least two respects. The tone of the book is gracious and ecumenical when dealing with the main dialogue partners (although sometimes tougher when the figures under discussion are Protestant). And, despite the range and diversity of the interlocutors, the argument is well designed, properly proportioned and clearly articulated.
There are, however, a couple of critical questions that deserve to be asked. First, Rogers proposes to interpret his interlocutors in optimam partem, in the best light. But has he done that with Karl Barth? Early on (p. 19, n. 1), he mentions two works of Barth scholarship which give a more positive evaluation of Barth's pneumatology than he does, but Rogers does not wrestle with their arguments. What of the fact that Barth typically does pneumatology through ethics? Or, what of the fact that we do not have Church Dogmatics, V, which presumably would have had much more to say about the Spirit?
Second, even if one is convinced that Barth's way of expositing the perfection of Christ's work necessarily gives short shrift to the Spirit, it is not clear that speaking of Christ's death on the cross as a failure is the solution. The formulation sits uneasily with Basil of Caesarea's notion that Christ did not need the cooperation of the Spirit (quoted by Rogers himself, p. 71). And it also would seem to fall foul of Col. 2:15, which speaks of Christ's work on the cross as a triumph. This reviewer cannot help but suspect that there are points in the book, especially aspects of the section on the resurrection, where the positive theological proposal takes all too much of its orientation from a problem and too little from scripture and the tradition which expounds it.
