Deborah Rhode's motivation for writing this book about the agenda for the women's movement is discussed in the Introduction and highlights just how prolific gender inequality was in the 1970s. Rhode witnessed first-hand the endemic and all-consuming nature of gender inequality during her time as a student at Yale, and later as a law teacher at Stanford. Commenting how ‘sex discrimination was everywhere except on the curricula’ (p. 5), Rhode notes the normalisation of this type of discrimination and provides shocking accounts of how it was accepted, or at best tolerated, in 1970s America. What is most sobering about her description of events is, in her words, ‘how little this was striking … then’, and how this belated retrospective ‘does stagnate change’ (p. 5): a problem that persists for women today as there remains a ‘lack of consensus that there still is a serious problem, or one that they have any capability or responsibility to address’ (p. 6). With this stagnation in mind, in the chapters that follow Rhode aims to ‘jump start a conversation’ about gender (in)equalities and the role of the women's movement (p. 9) by focusing on some of the core issues facing women today. The content mostly highlights research and policies in the US, but the challenges they present for feminism and governments are of relevance to us all.
Chapter 1 provides an historical view of the women's movement and ponders both why so few women are willing to identify with feminism and why this lack of engagement matters. The ‘demonisation’ of feminists, the way they have been caricatured by the press and how their association with activism can make women uncomfortable are suggested as reasons for this reluctance to engage. Whilst this critique is not especially original, it reminds us of the internal challenges facing the women's movement, and the injection of comments by leading and popular US writers on women's issues, such as Joan Williams and Sheryl Sandberg, add to the narrative (pp. 14–15). Chapter 2 then gets to the meatier issue of women and employment and suggests that, whilst there have been some advances in terms of participation, women are not well represented in senior roles and, when they are, they are not paid the equivalent of men in those roles: shockingly ‘only 4% of CEOs of Fortune 1000 companies are women, and they earn only about half of what their male counterparts earn’ (p. 29). In this chapter, drawing on a broad range of research, Rhode considers core and persistent workplace inequalities such as unequal pay, unconscious bias, gender stereotypes and the leadership gap. Highlighting that legal strategies alone are unable to address these workplace inequalities, Rhode notes that fewer than 20 per cent of sex and race discrimination claims filed with the federal equal opportunities commission result in a favourable outcome for the complainant. In addition, only 2 per cent of those who go to full trial are successful, and 40 per cent of trial wins are reversed on appeal (p. 33). Such figures resonate with debates in the UK around the effectiveness of employment rights, especially in the light of the impact of employment tribunal fees on the numbers pursuing a legal claim (see, for example, Dickens, Reference Dickens2012).
Chapter 3 tackles the related and equally challenging issue of reconciling work and family life, and recounts the shocking reality that the US has the least family-friendly policies in the developed world. The chapter then outlines how the US offers no right to paid maternity leave, let alone provisions such as the right to request flexible working or paternity leave. Protection against discrimination on the grounds of pregnancy and maternity is archaic, requiring equal treatment with those who are ‘similar in their ability or inability to work’ (p. 56, ftn 144) rather than accepting, as has been the case in the EU for the past fifteen years, that the need for a comparator is unhelpful in this context and diminishes these women's ability to access justice when confronted with discrimination at work. Moreover, there is no government-supported, comprehensive childcare system in place. Whilst the lack of legal entitlements and support are destructive, we are reminded that work/family stresses are compounded by ‘mandatory overtime, rigid and shifting schedules, lack of proportional pay and the absence of paid personal or sick leave or other basic protections’ and by ‘greedy institutions’ where extended hours are viewed as a measure of commitment (p. 65). The impact on women is clear: as Rhode explains, many women are opting out of labour market participation as a result, and this, as we know, has implications for their long-term well-being.
The remaining chapters continue in this format, explaining and exploring issues of key contention for women today. In Chapter 4, sex and marriage are discussed, a discussion that includes consideration of ‘hook-ups’ and ‘sexting’, cohabitation, marriage and same-sex relationships. Whilst I was unconvinced by and uncomfortable with the way that this chapter implicitly presented marriage as the norm against which other relationships were positioned and judged, the coverage of research and issues within the limited space provided is impressive. Chapter 5 considers reproductive justice and economic security, assessing the ‘political obstacles’ currently in place that prevent women in the US from controlling their fertility and economic security in a way that should now be possible. Here, Rhode provides a strong critique of the various restrictions (legal and economic) placed upon women seeking an abortion, and their potential and complex impact upon women's health and well-being, impacts that are used strategically by both pro- and anti-abortion activists. Acknowledging the divisiveness of the issue, Rhode concludes that there is a need to rethink ‘policies towards pregnancy, birth control and the feminisation of poverty’ (p. 91). The discussions that follow, regarding punishing pregnant women for drug and alcohol abuse during pregnancy, restraints on birth control, and lack of information for teenagers regarding reproductive issues, demonstrate just how big a leap is required in this domain.
The pervasiveness of sexual harassment in workplaces, schools and ‘cyberspace’, as well as the trivialisation, frequency, causes and consequences of domestic abuse and the horrific realities of rape and human trafficking are all outlined in Chapter 6. Containing graphic examples of abuse, and drawing on a wide range of sources, the chapter is informative, and the depressingly familiar inadequacy of legal responses is captured throughout. Suggested strategies for reform link, appropriately, to discussions highlighted elsewhere in the book, such as the need to alter assumptions about the legitimacy of male aggression and the trivialisation of its consequences (p. 132, and ftn 250). Chapter 7 considers the injustices associated with appearance, as well as the implications of this for women in terms of costs, and suggests reform strategies which hint at consumer power and the potential strength of activism: ‘women can boycott products, join protests, organise lobbying campaigns, and write letters, op-eds, and blogs’ (p. 147). Rhode also welcomes the trend in some European countries to ban excessively underweight models whose health is at risk (p. 147, ftn 120), and concludes that ‘appearance must be seen as not only an aesthetic issue, but as a legal and policy one as well’ (p. 149).
The final chapter highlights a core challenge for the women's movement as a whole: the underrepresentation of women in political leadership. Exploring some of the reasons for and ramifications of this gap, the discussion grapples with the old dilemma of whether more women in political leadership roles necessarily means an increased focus on issues that are of core importance to women, issues of the type tackled in this book (p. 154). Rhode, in response, highlights: (i) the need to recruit and support candidates (male and female) willing to make women's issues a priority; (ii) the importance of a strong women's movement; and (iii) a shift in focus so that (privileged) individuals and organisations consider the needs of disadvantaged cohorts of society (p. 155). The brief conclusion to the book is located at the end of Chapter 8. In sum, Rhode, reconsidering the question posed at the outset – ‘What will it take to get women what they want?’ – suggests a need to better understand the complexities of that question. In doing so we must continue to confront ‘all the sources of subordination with which gender interacts’, challenge the lack of social consensus that there is a significant problem and reduce the ‘gap between legal rights and daily realities’ (p. 158).
This book covers a broad range of topics and provides a mass of memorable facts that help us to gauge the complexities and challenges for today's women's movement, especially in the US: for example, that motherhood is now a greater predictor of wage inequalities than gender in the US (p. 29, and ftn 52); that Americans work the longest hours of any industrialised country (p. 50, and ftn 63); that care-giving fathers experience the highest rates of mistreatment at work amongst men, such as being excluded, humiliated and bullied (p. 53, and ftn 101); that more than two-thirds of those providing unpaid care-giving for the elderly are women (p. 59, and ftn 180); that the 400 richest Americans now have more wealth than the entire bottom half of the population (p. 101, and ftn 188); and that the US ranks 78th in the world for women's representation in political office, behind Tajikistan, Slovakia, Bangladesh and Saudi Arabia (p. 151, ftn 11). The book may not, as is claimed in the Introduction, ‘jump start’ a conversation about gender inequality. That conversation, albeit ad hoc and patchy in terms of progress, has been ongoing for decades. Rhode, however, contributes to that discussion by providing an accessible and informative account of research that is of relevance to women (and men) and the women's movement today.
