Of the many Latin American states that experienced military dictatorships and subsequent democratic transitions during the 1970s and 1980s, Chile represents a paradigmatic case much studied by social scientists. Chile: Política y modernización democrática represents a valuable contribution to the literature on Chile's transition to democratic consolidation. The edited volume, which includes works by scholars from Spain, the United States, Germany, the UK and Chile, was published in 2006, in Spanish. The timing of the book could not have been better, since it appeared shortly after the constitutional amendments that finally erased the last ‘authoritarian enclaves’ introduced by the military regime in the Constitution of 1980, and just a few months before the death of General Pinochet, both events said to have finally ended Chile's long path toward ‘full democratisation’. The book is organised in ten chapters, and focuses mostly on the political-institutional elements of Chile's democratic transition, although there is a chapter that deals with the interplay between the state, the political system and civil society, and another describing the cultural transformations experienced by the country over the last decade and a half.
The volume starts with a concise but solid description of Chile's recent history, with an emphasis on the evolution of its political-party and electoral systems. Here the editors emphasise the way in which the country's peculiar electoral laws have forced a multi-party system to behave like a bipartisan one, something that it is said to having contributed to the unity and success of the governing coalition Concertación de Partidos por la Democracia, which has won all four presidential elections (as well as all legislative and municipal contests) held since the return to democracy.
The introduction is followed by a section focusing on the evolution of Chile's political parties, civil society and political elites during the transitional era. Here the most interesting chapter is that of Leticia Ruiz Rodríguez, who traces the ideological changes experienced by each of the country's main political parties and in the population at large, concluding that even though the political parties have remained ideologically polarised, they have nonetheless been ‘programmatically pragmatic’, that is, willing to compromise around policies that do not necessarily fit their ideological commitments, particularly in the case of the parties of the government coalition. This, argues Ruiz Rodríguez, helps to explain the political stability experienced by Chile over the last seventeen years. The section also has a useful piece by Robert Funk, on the role that the ‘political learning’ of the once radical Chilean left has played in the transition to democracy. Finally, there is a chapter by Angel Soto on the cultural changes experienced by society, which draws largely from empirical and analytical works by the UNDP and Eugenio Tironi. Regrettably, in his piece Soto defends the old – and by now largely discredited – notion that only authoritarian regimes can radically alter economic policy in developing countries, by arguing that Chile's recent economic progress owes more to Pinochet's dictatorship than to all the democratically elected leaders that preceded or followed it (pp. 44–5).
The last and most extensive section of the book focuses on political institutions and the democratic process and includes chapters on Chile's presidentialism (by Detlef Nolte); on the paradox of a good economic and political performance accompanied by bad perceptions (by Alan Angell); on the interplay between the state and civil society (by del Campo García); on foreign relations (by Fuentes and Fuentes); on the politics of accountability for past human rights violations (by Samuel Valenzuela); and on the role of the military during the transition period (by Felipe Aguero). Aguero's account of the way in which Chile's armed forces slowly abandoned their loyalty to Pinochet's regime is excellent, as is Valenzuela's remarkable piece on the democratic government's handling of the legacy of human rights violations perpetrated by the military regime, in which he ably dismisses the notion that Chile's transition failed to do justice and to compensate the victims of the authoritarian era. In an insightful chapter, Allan Angell addresses the rather paradoxical gap between the political and economic improvement that the post-authoritarian era brought to Chile, and the perception of disenchantment with democratic institutions and the economy held by a significant share of its population. Angell argues persuasively that part of the problem lies in the fact that since the democratic era has also been equated in the eyes of sympathisers of the right with the rule of the Concertación, they tend to blame the democratic system for the failures of the coalition in power; something that should disappear at such time as the opposition finally seizes the executive branch. He also shows that the scepticism with regard to the economy, held by large portions of the population, is the result of the still deep economic inequality characterising Chile, which remains one of the most unequal states in the region. Detlef Nolte's piece on the ongoing debate over the vices and virtues of Chile's presidentialist regime is also useful, particularly his taxonomy of the different approaches to this complex issue. The same goes to Ester del Campo García's analysis of the growing political relevance of Chile's formerly weak civil society.
To end this all too brief account of the different chapters of this book, in the piece dealing with Chile's foreign relations in the post-authoritarian era, Fuentes and Fuentes correctly argue that the successive Concertación administrations have shown great consistency in their foreign policy. Furthermore, and contradicting the commonly held indictment that the latter has been excessively focused on expanding Chile's international markets through multilateral and bilateral trade agreements to the detriment of other valuable foreign policy goals, they claim that the democratic governments' international relations have included not only economic matters but also ‘the promotion of peace, respect for human rights, democracy and cooperation in the multilateral arena and a substantive progress in ending pending borders disputes with Argentina’ (p. 266). This assessment, while accurate with regard to the promotion of peace in the world and with Argentina, it is wrong in the case of Chile's supposed promotion of human rights and democracy in the multilateral arena, as President Aylwin's refusal to condemn China's human rights abuses in the early 1990s, and Lagos' hesitation to immediately reject the aborted coup against President Chávez in Venezuela, reveals.
In conclusion, despite some shortcomings, this edited volume represents a valuable addition to the study of Chilean politics after authoritarian rule, analysing some of the most important factors explaining the trajectory from a brutal military dictatorship to a stable and rather prosperous democratic regime.
