One of Canada’s most prominent political philosophers, the scope of Kai Nielsen’s contribution cannot be overstated. In Pessimism of the Intellect, Optimism of the Will: The Political Philosophy of Kai Nielsen, editors David Rondel and Alex Sager have carefully compiled an assortment of Nielsen’s papers into a volume, thus paying homage to his industrious academic career and to his philosophical developments, which are best read as astute responses to the extraordinary political, social and cultural climate of our time. To be sure, this is no small feat: one need merely consider Nielsen’s seemingly paradoxical self-description as a “liberal socialist cosmopolitan nationalist” for evidence. And yet, the editors of this volume succeed in rendering Nielsen’s complex and multifaceted ideas intelligible by assembling a collection of his work that is as readable as it is intellectually stimulating.
The conceptual arrangement of the book introduces Nielsen’s sophisticated ideas in an approachable manner, allowing those previously unfamiliar with his philosophy to become comfortably acquainted with it. First introducing Nielsen’s methodology and the project of philosophy (Section 1), and then applying it first to questions of domestic justice (Section 2) and later global justice (Section 3), allows for Nielsen’s ideas to build upon each other in a logical and incremental fashion.
Broadly speaking, the first section focuses on Nielsen’s methodology, but more importantly, his ideas regarding the project of philosophy in general. Chapter one briefly examines the history of twentieth century philosophy and emphasizes the value of Rawls’ contributions, while suggesting the need for a critical Marxian political theory. Chapter two turns to examination and endorsement of Rorty’s methodology, specifically, his rejection of universality and unconditionality. Nielsen spends the third chapter examining wide reflective equilibrium (WRE) and explains his adoption of both Rawlsian and Rortian versions of the methodology. The closing chapter of the section builds on the aforementioned ideas to suggest a future for moral and political philosophy – one that ought to be attentive to global crises while remaining grounded in empirical study.
Theories and concepts expounded in the first section are applied to more specific questions of political theory in the second. This portion of the book focuses on domestic political philosophy, namely, issues of distributive justice. Here, Nielsen turns to his commitments to socialism and egalitarianism. The fifth chapter looks at the concepts of reform and revolution, and in particular, Popper’s and Marcuse’s ideas on these matters. In the sixth chapter, Nielsen asserts that Marx’s perspectivism and historicism do not imply that Marxians cannot build a prescriptive or critical theory. Nielsen thinks that this is both possible and desirable, and that the creation of such an account should employ WRE. Chapter seven turns to the question of egalitarianism and asserts that Rawls’ account leaves too little room for it, while accepting social stratification too readily. Nielsen introduces and defends the idea of radical egalitarianism which seeks to achieve equal division of benefits with adjustments for need. The eighth chapter sees Nielsen developing these ideas, suggesting that egalitarianism requires a socialist society. The last chapter of the section considers several versions of egalitarianism, all of which seek to answer two primary questions: how much equality is enough? And equality of what? Nielsen settles on a version of limited welfarism, asserting a combination of equal satisfaction of needs, as well as equality of effective freedoms, capabilities and primary goods.
Finally, the third section of the book augments the scope of inquiry and considers the global scale of political philosophy. Nielsen’s focus is tailored to two issues: asserting the need, as well as the desirability, of establishing global governance, and tending to the debate between cosmopolitans and liberal nationalists – positions which he sees as being reconcilable. In the first chapter of this section, Nielsen examines two arguments against the notion of a world government (the state of the world impossibility argument and the political will argument), and argues against both. Chapter 11 defends the right of nations to secession based on what Nielsen refers to as the Primary Rights Theory, as opposed to the Remedial Rights Theory. The final two chapters of the book, 12 and 13, focus explicitly on questions of global justice. The penultimate chapter argues for the compatibility of cosmopolitanism and liberal nationalism, contrary to widely held belief. Nielsen asserts that such a position is possible if one adopts a socialist version of nationalism. It is suggested that his hybrid account allows for greater human flourishing and superior protection of democratic life in contrast with anti-national cosmopolitan theories. The last chapter argues for the feasibility and appeal of a world government. Nielsen admits that the road to such a goal will be challenging, but proposes some steps that might be taken in order to move toward it.
Rondel and Sager exhibit great tact and ingenuity in their editing. Insightful questions posed to Nielsen in an interview-cum-epilogue gesture at a keen awareness of the most interesting and contentious aspects of his philosophy. Likewise, the editing indicates a commitment to accurate portrayal of Nielsen’s philosophical work without compromising intelligibility and accessibility. The introduction remains largely exegetical; perhaps this is understandable, given that the book is an anthology. However, it is clear that the editors possess great familiarity with Nielsen’s work and it would have been a pleasure to see more formal and critical engagement with some of his ideas. Nonetheless, Pessimism of the Intellect, Optimism of the Will remains a hugely informative, supremely readable and thought-provoking anthology of a highly influential political philosopher.
