Family Secrets is a ground-breaking and much-needed study of incest in Mexico. Based on in-depth interviews with 45 women and 15 men from a range of ages and ethnic and socio-economic backgrounds in four major Mexican cities, this book provides insights into the meanings of incestuous arrangements. While Gloria González-López goes to great length to emphasise that this is only one set of stories and, hence, that the resulting analysis is not necessarily generalisable – not for Mexico, Latin America, nor the world – at the same time, they clearly provide tremendous insight into experiences of incest, and how we may understand those, far beyond these specific narratives collected by the author. González-López knows that the importance for her analysis reaches far beyond the individual cases here discussed, and provides a wide-ranging analysis that will be relevant far beyond her case studies.
González-López's interviews lead her to draw out five main findings: firstly, one of the most prevailing forms of incest is the father–daughter relation, in which girls become either conjugal daughters, fulfilling the marital ‘duty’ of wives – and by extension, daughters – or marital servants, in which girls keep marriages together by serving men sexually with the complicity of the mother. Secondly, González-López refers to sisters and cousins subjected to the sexual experimenting of boys as family sex surrogates. This reflects the common narrative in Latin American male fiction, in which early or first sexual ‘needs’ of boys is fulfilled by cousins or domestic servants – another common pattern of sexual abuse that fits the analysis, but that is not the focus of this book. Such sexual experimenting among siblings or cousins goes hand in hand with the gendered servitude the author observes in the father–daughter abuse. Thirdly, again following the same gendered pattern and logic, González-López found that one of the most prevalent arrangements was uncle–niece abuse, which involves maternal uncles in particular. She explains this pattern by referring to ‘family cultures of rape’, in which the persistent devaluation of girls and women leads to sexually intrusive behaviours towards girls, boys, and younger men and women within the family. The devaluation of women as figures of authority within the family explains the maternal uncle phenomenon. Fourthly, drawing on conversations with men who experienced sexual abuse within the family, González-López introduces the term kinship sex along a continuum between consent and coercion, of pleasurable experimentation to homophobic abuse. Lastly, and importantly, González-López concludes that all these patterns of gendered and sexualised processes in incestuous families are part of everyday life, continuously producing and reproducing inequalities, privilege and subordination.
There are strong suspicions that incest, and, more broadly, sexual violence against children and adolescents perpetrated by family members or others close to the victims (friends of the family, neighbours, teachers, priests), is widespread throughout the world. One in five girls, and one in ten boys, are estimated to experience sexual violence in their families and communities globally; the same estimates emerge from the fragmented data available for Latin America. As González-López states, more qualitative accounts suggest that even these estimates may be underestimating the problem, and sexual abuse of children may be even more widespread (p. 19). Accurate data is scarce. Most children are made to believe the violence is somehow normal, deserved, or shameful on them and, hence, few report such violence to the authorities. In addition, when children do report what happens to them, adults in the position to protect them, including mothers or police officers, often do not believe them, underplay their accounts, or indeed, blame the victims for the abuse. We know this from scattered studies carried out throughout the region, and this book confirms it once again.
González-López does not pretend to solve the problem of the lack of data. Rather, Family Secrets provides a qualitative study of the trauma and recovery, drawing on Judith Herman's Trauma and Recovery, of women and men who experienced child sexual abuse. It explores what this abuse meant within the circle of trust in which it could take place and could be kept secret, how victims survived and what explains successful recovery or continuous trauma. With tremendous respect for the individuals who share their stories with the author, González-López provides an analysis of meanings of incest that are useful and recognisable for those who are familiar with the problem, and possibly shocking to those who are not. Judith Herman observed that father–daughter incest was possible because of the patriarchal sexual division of labour, in which women and girls serve men in the domestic order, and hence, beyond the domestic sphere. Likewise, González-López argues that the patriarchal organisation of home and society is profoundly sexist and homophobic, and that sexual abuse reproduces gendered inequalities at home and in wider society.
The book raises further questions, and possibly frustrations: as the narratives of the women and men in this book indicate, if the everyday-ness, the ‘normality’, the silence, and the complicity of wider society in maintaining the sexual status quo is so deep that it permeates families, how is policy against sexual abuse of children, and also of adolescents and women, possible? The multiple dimensions and specific patterns that facilitate widespread sexual abuse in these specific Mexican cases are so complex and ingrained that it seems impossible to address such patterns from a more general policy perspective. Where to start? But, as Family Secrets also clearly points out, what is perceived as normal through silencing can be unsettled and denounced by speaking out. The fact that violence is part of the everyday does not mean it is not exceptional and that it should not be addressed as such.
Recently two developments have started to put pressure upon Latin American governments and on civil society, including the Church, to exceptionalise and address everyday gender violence: a global policy effort to specifically focus on sexual violence against children (Global Partnership to End Violence against Children), and a regional civil society movement gaining increasing popular support to denounce violence against women and girls via the Ni Una Menos (Not One Less) protests. Family Secrets is an important part of this increasing need to expose and address incest and everyday gender-based violence in general. As such, this book is an essential read for all students, activists and policy makers interested in further understanding and tackling gender inequality, violence against women, girls, and children more broadly, and of course, the possibly widespread, but still largely hidden, prevalence of incest.
