As political scientists and observers of Egypt now grapple with the precipitous rise to power and then fall of the Muslim Brotherhood in the transition period that followed the 2011 revolution, they would do well to turn their attention to the origins of the organization in the cities of Egypt's Suez Canal Zone during the late 1920s and 1930s. For this purpose, scholars could scarcely have asked for a more timely intervention than Beth Baron's The Orphan Scandal: Christian Missionaries and the Rise of the Muslim Brotherhood. This remarkable book moves well beyond the organizational blueprints of the organization that Richard Mitchell so importantly provided in his now classic text, The Society of Muslim Brothers (London: Oxford University Press, 1969). Baron breathes life into the story of the Brotherhood's development in the 1930s through a specific focus on a sectarian incident hitherto little noticed by historians—the brutal 1933 beating of the Muslim orphan Turkiyya Hasan in the precincts of the Swedish Salaam Mission School.
The beating, undertaken by Swiss missionary Alzire Richoz, would precipitate a veritable firestorm of controversy in Egyptian politics and the press, focusing on the question of whether Richoz had sought to force young Turkiyya to convert to Christianity. This is where the nascent Muslim Brotherhood, founded only five years earlier in nearby Ismaʿiliyya, saw a tremendous opportunity. By casting light on Turkiyya's suffering at the hands of a European proselytizer, the Brotherhood branch in Port Said could draw attention to the organization's broader cause of destabilizing British rule and European prerogatives in Egypt, as well as foment outrage at the apparently poor state of indigenous social welfare for the most vulnerable in Egyptian society. The effort to thrust Turkiyya and her case into the limelight was crowned with success, for her photo would appear on the front page of al-Ahram newspaper the day after she was interviewed by the public prosecutor about her injuries.
However, The Orphan Scandal is not merely an account of the Brotherhood's political opportunism. Baron has crafted a meticulous and entirely convincing account of a moment in Egyptian history that must be regarded as a watershed in a variety of ways. The reader is made witness to not only the burgeoning of the Brotherhood as an organization, but also to a devastating blow to the Christian missionary movement and intercommunal relations on Egyptian soil, as well as to the impetus for the Egyptian state's subsequent intervention into the sphere of social welfare. These various topics are tackled with remarkable insight into the zeitgeist of the mid-1930s, and with particular attention to the importance of storytelling. Indeed, never is the reader permitted to forget that at the center of this book is the very human drama of a young Muslim orphan named Turkiyya. Much like Ussama Makdisi's brilliant Artillery of Heaven (Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press, 2008), The Orphan Scandal uses microhistory to cast light on the larger events and movements of the day.
Baron succeeds in this by weaving together strands of evidence from a range of archives, including the British National Archives in Kew, the Presbyterian Historical Society in Philadelphia, and the Flower Pentecostal Heritage Center in Springfield, Missouri. Further, the characters in this story are as varied as the sources, ranging from Turkiyya herself and the Swiss matron responsible for her beating to the Brotherhood's representatives throughout the Canal Zone to the Finnish historian, Helmi Pekkola, who first chronicled the history of the mission wherein the beating took place. The chapters of the text successively address these characters and the organizations and movements they represent, detailing their varied roles in the denouement of the orphan scandal. However, they follow a prologue that must be described as no less than a tour de force, recounting the characters’ vastly different visions of Turkiyya's experience in Rashomon-like fashion.
In substantive terms, this book demonstrates that the customary invisibility of non-Muslims in the historiography of modern Egypt is no longer sustainable—one cannot tell the history of modern Egypt by limiting one's purview to Muslims alone. In this vein, one of the most fascinating insights that Baron's text offers is that the early strategists of the Muslim Brotherhood actively drew upon the models of Christian missionaries in the provision of social welfare. Accordingly, the development of the Brotherhood's daʿwa activities must be viewed as emerging from the particular context of the mid-1930s, when social organizations of various types provided relief to Egypt's most vulnerable.
The Orphan Scandal is a most welcome intervention in the now quite active field of Middle East missionary studies, joining works by Heather Sharkey, Akram Khater, and Marwa Elshakry. Yet, as I have explained above, there are several additional audiences for which this text is a must read—among them, all who are interested in Egypt's semicolonial interwar period, the history of childhood and youth in the Middle East, and the origins of Islamism.
