Introduction
Horner syndrome is characterised by ptosis, anhidrosis (loss of sweating), miosis and apparent enophthalmos. It results from interruption of the sympathetic nerve supply to the eye and face. We present the case of a patient with Horner syndrome due to calcification and pseudoarthrosis of the stylohyoid ligament.
Case report
A 46-year-old man presented to the ophthalmology department with right-sided Horner syndrome. He was otherwise asymptomatic.
On clinical examination, there was no obvious cause for the patient's Horner syndrome.
As part of the patient's investigation, a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scan of the neck and skull base was performed. This showed ossification of the right stylohyoid ligament, with a prominent pseudoarthrosis in the mid-portion of this bony structure (Figure 1). The pseudoarthrosis displaced the right internal carotid artery (ICA) posteriorly (Figure 1a) and partially compressed it against the lateral mass of the C2 vertebra (Figure 1b). On the axial images (Figure 1b), the rounded, mixed signal appearance of the pseudoarthrosis adjacent to the ICA closely resembled a carotid dissection – a common cause of Horner syndrome. The scan did not demonstrate any alternative cause for Horner syndrome.
(a) Axial, unenhanced, T1-weighted MRI scan at the level of the pseudoarthrosis (arrow), demonstrating partial compression of the internal carotid artery (arrowhead) between the pseudoarthrosis and the lateral mass of C2 (b) Sagittal, T2-weighted magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scan demonstrating posterior displacement of the right internal carotid artery (arrowheads) by the pseudoarthrosis in the ossified stylohyoid ligament (arrow).
Surgical excision was discussed, but it was felt that the risks of surgery outweighed any potential benefit. Thus, no intervention was advised, unless the patient's symptoms changed or his neurological deficit increased.
Discussion
The sympathetic neural pathway to the eye is a three-neuron pathway.
The first-order neurons arise in the postero-lateral hypothalamus and descend through the brainstem to terminate in the spinal cord at C8 to T2.
The second-order neurons exit via the T1 root and travel close to the apex of the lung through the paravertebral sympathetic chain and the stellate ganglion, before terminating in the superior cervical ganglion at the level of the carotid bifurcation.
The third-order (post-ganglionic) fibres exit the superior cervical ganglion to form a plexus surrounding the internal carotid artery (ICA). The plexus follows the ICA into the cavernous sinus, then follows the abducens nerve and then the ophthalmic division of the trigeminal nerve to the orbit. Other fibres leave the ganglion and follow the external carotid artery.
The sympathetic nerves following the ICA control iris dilatation and contribute the motor supply to the smooth muscle fibres of the upper and lower lids. The sympathetic nerves following the external carotid artery control the vasomotor function and sweat glands of the face.
The aetiology of Horner syndrome can be divided according to the anatomical sections of the nerve pathway, as follows.
First-order neuron lesions comprise: Arnold–Chiari malformation; basal meningitis (e.g. due to syphilis); basal skull tumours; cerebro-vascular accident and Wallenberg syndrome (i.e. lateral medullary syndrome); demyelinating diseases (e.g. multiple sclerosis); intrapontine haemorrhage; neck trauma (e.g. traumatic dislocation of cervical vertebrae and traumatic dissection of the vertebral artery); pituitary tumour; and syringomyelia.
Second-order neuron lesions consist of: pancoast tumour (i.e. tumour in the apex of the lung, most commonly squamous cell carcinoma); birth trauma with injury to the lower brachial plexus; cervical rib; aneurysm or aortic dissection; subclavian or common carotid artery pathology (e.g. dissection or ischaemia); injury during central venous catheterisation; trauma or surgical injury (e.g. due to radical neck dissection, thyroidectomy, carotid angiography or coronary artery bypass graft); trauma associated with chest drains; lymphadenopathy (e.g. Hodgkin disease, leukaemia, tuberculosis or mediastinal tumours); mandibular tooth abscess; middle-ear lesions (e.g. acute otitis media); and neuroblastoma.
Third-order neuron lesions comprise: ICA dissection (associated with sudden ipsilateral face and/or neck pain); Raeder syndrome (paratrigeminal syndrome); oculosympathetic paresis and ipsilateral facial pain with variable involvement of the trigeminal and oculomotor nerves; carotid cavernous fistula; cluster or migraine headaches; and herpes zoster infection.
An MRI scan of the hypothalamus, brainstem, skull base, neck and spinal cord down to at least T2 is the single most useful imaging investigation for Horner syndrome, although computed tomography also has a role in selected cases.Reference Digre, Smoker, Johnston, Tryhus, Thompson and Cox1–Reference Yoshiura, Wu and Sorensen7
The stylohyoid process and ligament develop from the second branchial arch, and in adult life persist as a structure that passes from the skull base to the lesser cornu of the hyoid.Reference Chouvel, Rombaux, Philips and Hamoir8 The ligament passes between the internal and external carotid arteries.
Although calcification or ossification of the stylohyoid ligament is not an uncommon radiographic finding, pseudoarthrosis is very seldom seen. Our literature review found no other descriptions of cases of Horner syndrome caused by pathology of the stylohyoid ligament. In a case described by Godden et al., the patient's principal complaint was of a clicking jaw and retromandibular pain.Reference Godden, Adam and Woodwards9 Surgical excision via an extra-oral approach resolved the patient's symptoms.
• Horner syndrome is rare
• Investigation aims to image all parts of the sympathetic neural pathway
• Magnetic resonance imaging is the investigation of choice
In our case, the cause of the pseudoarthrosis was not clear, but it is possible that a fracture of the ossified ligament had resulted in non-union, and hence a pseudoarthrosis.
Conclusion
This case highlights the usefulness of MRI in the investigation of Horner syndrome. It is important to consider the pathway of the sympathetic nerve supply, from the hypothalamus to the nerves' final destinations, in order to elucidate the cause.
