In 1744 the churchwardens of Christ Church, Boston, New England (which was built in 1723 as the second Church of England place of worship in the town), having recently had a spire added to the tower of their church, and having now raised a subscription for a ring of bells, were in protracted negotiations with Abel Rudhall, bell-founder of Gloucester, Old England. The vestry were concerned that the tower would not be strong enough to hold bells which weighed 80 hundredweight or more, and Rudhall, one of the leading British bell-founders of his generation, had tried, unsuccessfully, to convince them not to have smaller ones cast. Having settled, for safety reasons, on a lighter set of bells, the vestry then urged Rudhall, through their intermediary, Thomas Gunter, to ‘use his utmost endeavour to have them as musical and compleat as he can, which will no doubt encourage people here as well as the neighbouring governments to send for one, this being the first ring in English America’.Footnote 1 The vestry had panicked that no one in New England would know how to install the bells, and Rudhall initially persuaded John Baker, a local Gloucester man, to go over to set them up, but at the last minute Baker bottled out when his wife fainted on hearing that the ship taking him and the bells to Boston had docked at Bristol.Footnote 2 The eight bells cost Christ Church vestry £560, with an additional £93 for some special apparatus and wheels sent over by Rudhall to help put them in position, with a detailed set of instructions explaining how this should be done.Footnote 3 Once the bells had arrived in 1745, the vestry had an inscription engraved on each of them. On the tenor bell, the inscription read: ‘this peal of eight bells is the gift of a number of generous patrons to Christ Church’; on the third bell: ‘we are the first ring of bells cast for the British Empire in North America’; on the fourth: ‘God preserve the Church of England’; on the fifth: ‘William Shirley, Esq, Governor of Massachusetts Bay’; and on the eighth: ‘Abel Rudhall of Gloucester cast us all’.Footnote 4
The story of how Christ Church obtained its bells can, in many ways, be taken as representing in miniature the position of the Church of England in eighteenth-century New England.Footnote 5 Just as its bells had to be manufactured in Old England, so Christ Church, and other Church of England churches, both in the heart of Puritan North America, and on the Continent more generally, were largely dependent for the essentials and the trappings of the Church's functioning on exports from England, which are graphic reminders of the reliance of the New World on some English goods and services in the 1740s and beyond.Footnote 6 Above all, the churches required Books of Common Prayer to be sent over in large quantities, for this was the Church's liturgical manual and without it the Church could not operate, but since 1651 it had been unlawful to use it in worship in much of New England.Footnote 7 The churches were also recipients from Old England of clergy, via the Society for the Propagation of the Gospel in Foreign Parts (SPG), founded in 1701 and the main conduit for sending Anglican goods to New England, such as bibles, books, pamphlets, catechisms, sermons and tracts.Footnote 8 New England Anglicans also received from across the Atlantic church plate (often the treasured gifts of monarchs from William and Mary to George III), vestments, furnishings, including altars, and altar pieces, and boards with the ten commandments, creed and Lord's Prayer painted on them, and, in one instance, an altar painting.Footnote 9 On occasion they even had to send certain books, such as large bibles, back to London to have them re-bound,Footnote 10 and at times they were forced to inquire in London for organists, since Church of England churches in New England had the first church organs, as well as the first peal of bells, in British North America, and those able to play them were thin on the ground.Footnote 11 The inscription on the bell memorialising Governor William Shirley, a churchman and English-born,Footnote 12 who held a number of high-level posts within the empire, can be taken as emblematic of the sometimes wished-for alliance of the Church of England and the state (even in New England), in a setting where Congregationalism was the de facto established church, but where it was frequently hoped that the Church of England would prosper. As such, Shirley can be taken as a representative of the English settlers and government officials who brought over and sustained the Church in what was an alien and hostile religious environment. In the inscriptions on Christ Church's bells, the bells themselves were highlighted as aural accompaniments to the tune of empire, and the role of the subscribers (virtually all members of the laity) in providing funding was also emphasised, indicating the massive dependency of the Episcopal Church in New England, and in British North America more broadly, on lay backing.Footnote 13
This reading of the place of the Church of England in New England in particular (and in other parts of British North America) as an agent of imperialism and reliant on external support has much to commend it.Footnote 14 As well as Bostonians, many of the subscribers for the bells were men and women living in England, naval and army officers, who were only stationed in Boston sporadically, and merchants from far-flung parts of the empire,Footnote 15 demonstrating the town's prominent position as one of the imperial hubs. Indicative of this was King's chapel, Boston, the first Church of England building erected in New England, built in October 1689 by a congregation which had been meeting since 1686 at the instigation of representatives of James II's government.Footnote 16 John Dunton, the Presbyterian London book-seller who was in Boston in May 1686 when the Anglican clergyman Robert Ratcliffe sailed into the harbour as part of the retinue of Edward Randolph, councillor in the new Dominion of New England (a political entity which overrode the original Massachusetts charter, and was thus detested by many New Englanders), noted the strangeness of the situation:
on Lord's Days [he] read the Common Prayer in His Surplice, and preach'd in the Town-House. Mr Ratcliffe was an Eminent Preacher, and his Sermons were useful and well dress'd; I was once or twice to hear him, and 'twas noise'd about that Dr Annesly's son-in law was turn'd Apostate. But I cou'd easily forgive 'em., in Regard, the Common Prayer, and the Surplice were Religious Novelties in New England.Footnote 17
But two years later, Randolph informed Archbishop Sancroft that Ratcliffe was attracting opprobrium: ‘some calling our minister Baal's priest and some of their ministers from the pulpit calling our prayers leeks, garlick and trash’.Footnote 18 Ratcliffe's congregation soon included Edmund Andros, a crony of James II and the loathed president of the Dominion, who was imprisoned during Boston's own version of the Glorious Revolution in April 1689.Footnote 19 The chapel was used, and financially supported, by naval officers, who among other things had pews installed in the new building in 1694 (where up until then seating had been on low wooden benches used in Congregational meetings),Footnote 20 and until the early 1770s was the favoured place of worship for the military stationed in the town. Henry Caner, the rector of King's chapel from 1747 until he fled Boston in 1775, baptised a large number of children of officers serving under General Gage in the chapel, and funeral services were held here for some of the British officers killed in and around Boston during the onset of Revolution.Footnote 21
This interpretation of the Church as largely sustained by, and catering for, people who were in some senses ‘external’ to New England and who should not be regarded as ‘real New Englanders’ also meshes with contemporary Congregationalist discourse in which the Church of England was seen as not only as being corrupt, and little more than Popery in disguise, but as being intruded on New England. Increase Mather's voluminous publications included A Brief Discourse concerning the Unlawfulness of the Common Prayer Worship (1686), provoked by the use of the liturgy in Boston by Ratcliffe and his congregation, which made conventional ‘Puritan’ criticisms of the Prayer Book as being no better than the popish mass, likening the formulaic responses to ‘tennis balls’ tossed between the priest and the congregation, and decrying the hopeful prayers in the burial service, the use of the ring in marriage, making the sign of the cross at baptism, and kneeling when taking the sacrament.Footnote 22 His A Testimony against Several Prophane and Superstitious New Customs now Practised by Some in New England (published in London in 1687), which railed against the performance of stage-plays, putting-up maypoles, drinking healths, playing cards, dice or the lottery, giving new-year's presents, observing saints’ days, candle-mass and Shrove Tuesday, watching cock-fighting and the keeping of Christmas, which he was appalled to find were now being talked about in New England of all places (and where ‘promiscuous dancing’ had been practised the previous year),Footnote 23 urged New Englanders to stay away from these wicked pastimes. Cotton Mather in 1723 accused the Anglican clergy who came to New England of being ‘tippling sots’, but consoled himself that ‘by a strange Infatuation from Heaven’ they ‘have been generally men of such a Behaviour, that it was impossible to take a more effectual Course for the prejudicing of this religious countrey against that sort of men, or the begetting an Horror for the Church of England in the New England colonies’.Footnote 24 Noah Hobart in the late 1740s and early 1750s denounced what he called the ‘episcopal separation’, claiming that those Bostonians who had been attracted to the Church in the 1680s quickly became shame-faced and embarrassed after the Revolution of April 1689 by what they had done,Footnote 25 and Jonathan Mayhew in the early 1760s spear-headed the attack on the SPG's activities in New England as a misuse of funds (in large measure following Hobart's arguments), and broadcast the idea that Britain was about to send over a bishop.Footnote 26 From the 1680s to the 1770s, then, leading New England Congregational spokesmen portrayed the Church of England in New England as unscriptural and unloved. Nathaniel Appleton, Congregational minister at Cambridge, summed up the Congregational view, recalling the fact that early settlers had come to New England precisely to escape from the Church of England in the 1620s and 1630s, when he moaned in 1760: ‘it is grievous to think that when our Pious Ancestors came over into this Land, when an howling wilderness, to enjoy ye Gospel in ye purity & simplicity of it, yt the Chh of England should thrust it self in among us’.Footnote 27
Modern historians have, both wittingly and unwittingly, by and large accepted and reinforced this view of a Church which was either an unwanted alien in, or a feared predator on, New England. One early twentieth-century commentator, anticipating later high-profile studies by Carl Bridenbaugh in 1962,Footnote 28 J. C. D. Clark in 1994 (who has called the War of Independence a ‘war of religion’),Footnote 29 and more recently James Bell,Footnote 30 referred to ‘a fiercely-waged conflict’ between Congregationalists and Episcopalians that ‘prevailed almost unceasingly from 15 May 1686 [when Ratcliffe arrived in Boston] . . . to the Revolution [in 1776]’.Footnote 31 This echoes the view, which has seldom been properly questioned by historians, of a linear trajectory of New England suspicion and dislike of the Church from the 1680s which led inevitably to the ‘bishop controversy’ of the 1760s and early 1770s, where New Englanders feared that England was about to send a bishop or bishops to impose an eighteenth-century version of Laudianism on the colonies. In some interpretations this has been seen as the crucial trigger moving New Englanders, and others, to throw off the British government, and as part of that process to take revenge on clergy and members of the Church of England. This seemingly demonstrated that not only was the Church of England violently unpopular, but also that the very idea that an Anglican bishop might be sent to America was enough to stir Americans into revolt.Footnote 32 This paper does not focus on this particular issue, not only because this is well-trodden ground,Footnote 33 but more pertinently because I am more concerned with what the Church was actually doing in New England, rather than with its aspirations, or with the fears of its rivals. This is not because I think that such matters are unimportant (if suspicions about an Anglican bishopric in North America did contribute to the American Revolution how could they be?) but rather because concentration on the ‘bishop controversy’ has obscured the actual role and place of the Church in eighteenth-century New England. Bridenbaugh came close to accepting Congregationalist angst at face value, assuming that the powers that be in London were really contemplating sending over a bishop with Laudian pretensions to enforce religious absolutism in America, when this is patently not the case (indeed what is more striking is the refusal of the English authorities to take the matter further).Footnote 34 Clark's The Language of Liberty to a large extent continues Bridenbaugh's analysis, and it fits neatly into his wider programme (with which I concur) of stressing the importance of religion in eighteenth-century events, in contradistinction to the secular (and economic) explanations for eighteenth-century political change which had prevailed during much of the twentieth century.Footnote 35 But Clark was largely dependent on printed pamphlet controversies for his view of the bitter denominational rivalry between religious groups in New England, and British North America more generally, and there is a danger of using controversial literature to reflect day-to-day relations. He, Bridenbaugh and Bell are no doubt right to stress the ways in which Congregational discourse from the mid-1760s was able to mesh with, and inflame, other forms of discontent (economic and political) but, I argue, there is the risk of reading back from this that the Church of England necessarily had no place and no support within eighteenth-century New England. In any case denominational rivalry and competition (of which there was plenty) are not the same as religious conflict or war.
There have also been some other valuable studies – less geared around explaining the causes of the American Revolution – which have added immensely to our understanding of the Church of England in British North America, but which have not taken as their central concern the progress made by the Church in New England, and these have tended to concentrate, perhaps understandably, on the prosopography of the clergy and on clerical pamphlets.Footnote 36 Much less attention, however, has been paid to the actual pastoral work of the Church of England clergy in New England, to the New England lay men and women who supported Anglicanism,Footnote 37 or to the successes in winning over adherents from other denominations. In examining the Church of England in New England, this paper explores something of the Church on the ground. I will argue that in some respects the Church in New England was in fact becoming rather more popular, and more indigenous, and more integrated into New England life, than both eighteenth-century Congregationalists or modern historians have wanted to believe, and this is particularly true of the period from the 1730s to the early 1760s, where the Church was making headway both in the Puritan heartlands, and in the newer centres of population growth. Up until the early 1760s, the progress of the Church of England in New England was beginning to look like a success story rather than one with in-built failure.
In what ways did the Church of England attempt to ‘refashion’ Puritan New England in the ninety years after 1680? Refashioning might imply a wholesale remaking and reordering; indeed the transformation or alteration of ‘Puritan New England’ into an ‘Anglican New England’ was advocated by a number of commentators (both clerical and lay) such as Lewis Morris, an active churchman, member of the SPG and later governor of New Jersey, who wrote to the English high churchman William Beveridge from Boston in 1702: ‘If the Church can be settled in New England, it pulls up schism in America by the roots, that being the fountain that supplys with infectious streams the rest of America’.Footnote 38 Certainly, those leading Congregational spokesmen already referred to seemed to fear that the Church of England was bent on a wholesale recreation of Puritan New England along Anglican lines. Rather more modestly (and more successfully), refashioning could entail more minor modifications to Puritan New England which gave concessions to other religious bodies, and allowed some kind of religious free market, enabling other religious groups to make headway, and this by and large was the attitude favoured in practice by New England Anglicans and the SPG. Hence the protracted struggle by the Church of England, and other ‘dissenting’ groups such as Baptists and Quakers, to gain the right to support their own ministers and teachers, using concepts of ‘liberty of conscience’, and ‘toleration’, as arguments for not having to contribute towards the maintenance of Congregationalist ministers, a battle which had largely, if grudgingly, been won by the late 1730s.Footnote 39
‘Puritan New England’ can be also regarded as refashioning itself. In part this was the product of generational differences, and one of the themes within New England historiography has been the thesis of declension after the glory days of the first two generations,Footnote 40 but there were several developments within Congregational circles in the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries which made it more receptive to Anglicanism. A number of leading Congregationalists by that time had considered it important to participate in the early European Enlightenment and were taken with the publications of those who might be deemed ‘moderate’ Anglicans, making the works of Archbishop Tillotson, at least according to one historian, the most widely read books in North America by the early eighteenth century.Footnote 41 One result of the greater acquaintance with the Anglican tradition (and this increasingly included a wider spectrum than ‘latitudinarian’ writers, as ‘orthodox’, and even what might be termed high church books, were studied)Footnote 42 were the sometimes spectacular changes of religious allegiance as Congregationalists, including some Congregational ministers, took Anglican orders, most famously in 1722 Timothy Cutler, president of Yale, who became the first rector of Christ Church (and memorialised on the second of the bells mentioned at the start of this paper).Footnote 43 In addition, there were broader political, social, economic, cultural and intellectual developments, particularly from the 1690s, and related to the wider changes in the transatlantic role of New England within the empire, which during the late seventeenth and eighteenth centuries were also reshaping New England. For example, Thomas Kidd's The Protestant Interest: New England after Puritanism has paid attention to the ways in which from the 1690s to the 1740s New England was brought into the wider Protestant world, backing the British government as the leading bulwark against Popery in America and Europe.Footnote 44 Puritan New England was also changing demographically, with new areas of settlement in the back country.Footnote 45 The refashioning of Puritan New England in the ways explored below was thus part of a larger story. It has become an axiom of recent writing on the relation between Britain and North America in general, and perhaps New England in particular, that there was an ‘Anglicisation’ during the eighteenth century that made New England by the 1760s culturally, economically, socially and even politically increasingly connected to the wider British world.Footnote 46 How far was there also an Anglicanisation of New England which was part of this broader trajectory?
Using some of Increase Mather's indicators for threats to Puritan New England, he would have been gratified to know that the stage-plays he so feared hardly encroached on colonial New England life, although in 1750 a performance of Thomas Otway's Restoration tragedy, The Orphan (1680), in a coffee house in State Street, Boston, caused a riot with so many Bostonians trying to see the play that the General Court enacted a law not only forbidding acting within the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, but even rendering spectators liable to a fine.Footnote 47 By contrast, two of Mather's other indices of a threat to the Puritan way – the existence of the Book of Common Prayer, and celebrations of Christmas – not only became more visible in the eighteenth century, but made some impact on Puritan New England, as well as among the settler communities. The essential step in establishing a viable Anglican community in New England was to ensure that copies of the Prayer Book were available, for without these efforts to carry out the Anglican liturgy would come to nothing. This was particularly crucial since it was virtually impossible to procure copies of the Prayer Book there (although in 1705 William Bradford, a New York printer who had recently conformed to the Church, was in negotiation with the SPG about publishing an American imprint).Footnote 48 Time and again New England clergy wrote to the SPG for more copies of the Prayer Book, believing that access to it would play a key role in weaning Congregationalists away from their anti-liturgical bias, and to some extent this seems to have worked. John Troutbeck, writing from Hopkinton, Massachusetts, noted in 1757 that ‘the people formerly thought that our Liturgy was a remnant of Popery, but upon Acquaintance with it, have corrected their false Prejudices’,Footnote 49 and similar statements can be found from other parts of New England, so much so that in 1764 Ebenezer Thompson reported that at Scituate, Massachusetts, ‘the Dissenting Congregation . . . have voted that a New Folio Bible be bought, and that their Teacher reads Lessons out of it every Sunday morning and evening, in imitation of the method of reading the Scriptures in the Church of England’,Footnote 50 which is an extraordinary suggestion of the ways in which, at least in this instance, some acquaintance with the Church of England way affected Congregational practice. By 1770, the SPG had sent over more than 150,000 bibles and Books of Common Prayer to North America (in addition to other books of instruction and ‘innumerable quantity of pious small tracts’),Footnote 51 and, as far as it can be calculated, a majority of these were sent to New England.
Besides bombarding New England with Books of Common Prayer, celebrating Christmas was another indicator of the ways in which the Church was able to make some impact on New England life. Alongside Increase Mather, Samuel Sewall, the redoubtable Puritan judge, was from the mid-1680s to the late 1720s on the look-out for Anglican encroachments, and his diary annually reported, with regret and dismay, the Christmas Day services at the King's chapel (as well as Shrove Tuesday festivities and sports), and he noted with displeasure those Bostonians who either declined to work on 25 December (pouring scorn on this as just a popish holyday) and even more disturbingly for him, those who attended Christmas Day services, including on occasion some of his extended family.Footnote 52 On 25 December 1697 Sewall recorded: ‘I took occasion to dehort mine from Christmas-keeping and charged them to forbear’, but evidently without much success, as he went on to lament: ‘most of ye Boys went to Church’.Footnote 53 By the 1730s and 1740s, both Boston's three Church of England places of worship, and those elsewhere in New England, were able to attract larger numbers than usual for their Christmas celebrations, and these included not a small number of Congregationalists. Timothy Cutler, for example, maintained that on Christmas Day 1744, Christ Church, Boston, was ‘thronged among others by some Hundreds of Dissenters’.Footnote 54 Five years previously, Ebenezer Punderson had observed that ‘the Temper and spirit of many of the dissenting brethren seems much altered for the better in so much that many of them on Christmas Day last resorted to the church and behaved soberly and decently’.Footnote 55 For Noah Hobart, writing in 1748 (and having read Punderson's report to the SPG), Christmas day services were just an excuse to take time off work and this fitted into his portrayal of New England Anglicans as lax and fun-loving, and any increase there may have been in attendances, he claimed, were purely because some New Englanders wanted to enjoy a day off, and hardly represented a success for the Church. ‘I hope the People of Groton, and in all other parts of the country, when they see what an improvement these Missionaries make of their keeping Christmas’, he observed, ‘will reform that bad Practice, and discover that they value the Religion of their Country and the Morals of their Posterity above a Feast or a Frolick.’Footnote 56 Hobart may no doubt have been right to suggest that this can hardly be seen as anything more than a superficial triumph for the Church, but it hardly speaks for thorough-going Congregationalism on the part of the New England laity either.Footnote 57 Indeed, one of the reasons for Congregational ministerial rancour against New England Anglicans from the 1740s was not only out of concern that the Church was making inroads into non-Anglican territory but also because this indicated that lay understandings of Congregationalism were sometimes rather different from – and did not always lead up to the expectations of – their teachers. What is also clear is the significance placed on the Christmas Day services by the New England Anglican churches, as if both to show-case the liturgy, and to emphasise the importance of the day in the Anglican calendar. Vestry books show the care put into preparing the interior of the churches for the day; they were decorated with greenery, and candlesticks were polished.Footnote 58 By the 1760s, Christ Church, Boston, was paying to have music printed for use at the Christmas service, and in 1769 the churchwardens were trying to find some ‘proper person’ to sing an anthem in the church on Christmas Day.Footnote 59
But not only were numbers of Books of Common Prayer in New England increasing, and Christmas Day services being attended by a growing number of Congregationalists, even more worrying for the Congregationalist critics of the Church of England, the number of Anglican congregations was also on the rise. Although the impetus for these often came from new English settlers, or exiled Huguenots who conformed to the Church,Footnote 60 they also attracted Congregational conformists. In their efforts to view Anglicanism as an intrusion, the Mathers and Mayhew downplayed the indigenous supporters of the Church, as well as those who conformed, dismissing those who signed petitions to the SPG requesting clergy as a very small number of ignorant, disaffected people, joining the Church because of private grudges and not out of religious reasons. Mayhew argued that the requests were usually trumped up, citing the case of Roger Price, the rector of King's chapel, Boston, who had wanted to become a missionary at Hopkinton, where he owned a farm, and who had allegedly brow-beaten his tenants to sign a petition.Footnote 61 Ezra Stiles later remarked:
I find the Church of England, especially in New England, inspired with a secular principle, unanimated with the love of Jesus as with the love of dignities and pre-eminence, making the Church an asylum for polite vice and irreligion . . . The greater part of the converts in New England had fled from other communions for Drunkenness, whoring, swearing & other moral scandal – I say the greater part, & I say it from a very particular examination of the history of Church proselytism there for fifty years past.Footnote 62
Nevertheless, despite Stiles's disparaging remarks, the growth of New England Anglicanism, and the inroads it was making in eighteenth-century New England deserves some attention. In 1702, it was estimated that there were fewer than 1,000 adherents of the Church of England in New England,Footnote 63 and at that date most of these were either found in Boston (the Puritan heartland), associated with the King's chapel, where it was reported that on occasion there were over 400 present at services,Footnote 64 or in communities such as Newport or South Kingston in Rhode Island, which was not part of Puritan New England proper, and where other groups who had opposed Congregationalists – such as Quakers and Baptists – had made early headway.Footnote 65 By 1760, Anglicans could be found throughout New England. The number, according to Stiles, who may have been likely to undersell his rivals, was about 12,600 Anglicans out of a total New England population of just over half a million,Footnote 66 and by 1774 he calculated that the Church had just over 24,000 adherents out of a total New England population of just under 750,000.Footnote 67 This growth is significant given that it has been estimated that Anglicans in North America as a whole quadrupled in the century, while in New England growth was at least twenty times, which made it the fastest-growing denomination there (and which in part accounts for the Congregational concern). This made Episcopalians 3 per cent of the New England population by the 1760s, and nearer 4 per cent by the mid-1770s. In some ways, this may look like a rather trivial figure, and certainly makes Mayhew's invective look rather misplaced, if not hysterical. But the small number does not mean they are not worth studying. For instance it has been reckoned that fewer than 2 per cent of the British population were Methodists in the 1790s, and yet an enormous historiography has been placed around them, including crediting them for the avoidance of a French-style Revolution in England.Footnote 68 And the figure of 4 per cent is for the whole of New England, and hides a large amount of variation. By 1774 the figure for Connecticut was over 8 per cent,Footnote 69 and individual townships, such as Reading and Newtown, had over 50 per cent Anglicans (with more attending the Church of England places of worship than the dissenting ones).Footnote 70
We do not have a full analysis of all those who made up the New England Anglican congregations (the published records of baptisms, marriages and burials from Trinity Church, Boston, the third Anglican church founded in the town in 1733, can give us some sense of the milieu),Footnote 71 but what we do know indicates that Anglicans could come from a wide social strata ranging from the fashionable Newport smart set to much more humble groups (including some slaves and Native Americans, particularly those living within New England families). In some cases congregations could be fairly numerous (Christ Church, Boston, regularly had over 600 people by the 1730s),Footnote 72 which frequently led to extending churches or building galleries. James Honeyman, the rector of Newport (itself a growing congregation which necessitated that the original church of 1699 was rebuilt in 1726, and extended in 1762), noted in 1722
that he had been to preach lately at Providence . . . to the greatest number of People he ever had together since he came to America, that no House being able to hold them, he was obliged to preach in the Fields; and that they are getting Subscriptions for Building a Church.Footnote 73
This report is suggestive of the economic commitment congregations might give in financing the Anglican mission (if they were able), paying for the building of a church, a glebe and a house for the missionary, and contributing towards his salary. The norm was that before even approaching the SPG, as evidence of their commitment, New England Anglicans might have already built a church. To this extent New England Anglicanism was a market-driven phenomenon.
What is also clear is that if New England Anglican missions were more a response to an indigenous request than an invasion, once established they could act as a stimulus for others to join the Church of England. Why did some New Englanders want to become Anglicans in the eighteenth century? As early as 1733, George Berkeley (the clerical philosopher and future bishop), who had lived in Rhode Island for over two years (preaching regularly both at St Paul's, Kingston, and Trinity, Newport), maintained that the general population had shaken off their prejudice against the Church, and that some were conforming to Anglicanism.Footnote 74 Mayhew thought this was nonsense and informed his readers that Berkeley knew nothing about real New England, having lived as an academic recluse in Rhode Island.Footnote 75 But what we do know of eighteenth-century New England congregations suggests that those from other denominations could, as surprising as it might seem, find Anglicanism attractive. There may have been a variety of religious reasons for becoming an Anglican, and not just the secular ones highlighted by Stiles. Unlike Congregationalism, Anglican membership was open to all; whereas the sacraments of baptism and Holy Communion were denied to many New Englanders.Footnote 76 In 1732 Matthias Plant thought that the Church had increased at Newburyport because of the ‘love and unity which is among them, while their dissenting neighbours are in great confusion and disorder’.Footnote 77 It is also clear that Anglicans in New England were also attempting to market the Church as being best for society as a whole. In this they argued that the Anglican Church was nearer to the primitive church; they stressed the attraction of Church of England worship (the beauty of holiness); their theology of benevolence and reason; and they made much of the connections with the Crown.Footnote 78 Congregationalists also benefited from Anglican pastoral work, with clergy visiting the sick of all denominations.Footnote 79 It also seems that the presence of an Anglican missionary might have dispelled some of the myths about the Church. There is even evidence of other denominations helping to build or improve Anglican churches, and tellingly a few Congregationalists subscribed for the bells for Christ Church, Boston, mentioned at the start of this paper.Footnote 80 Such evidence of cooperation, slight though it is, is marginalised by Bridenbaugh and Clark.
In an unexpected way, the Church of England in New England also benefited from the religious revival of the 1740s which has been labelled ‘the Great Awakening’.Footnote 81 While it is often asserted that the growth of Methodism in Old England was a threat to the Church of England (although recent research would certainly modify such a statement),Footnote 82 the Great Awakening in New England had the unforeseen consequence of attracting those Congregationalists who were unhappy with the ways in which the revival seemed to spiral out of control, and the wild enthusiasms of those associated with the revival played straight into the Church of England clergy's hands. This allowed Anglicans to claim that not only were Congregationalists in mid-eighteenth-century America potentially the same as those in mid-seventeenth-century England, but also that the mayhem associated with revivalist meetings was contemporary proof of their proclivity to ‘enthusiasm’. Henry Caner, writing from Fairfield, Connecticut, in November 1743, reported that at Norwalk, Ridgefield, and Stanford there ‘have been large accessions of persons who appear to have a serious sense of Religion; where the late Spirit of Enthusiasm hath most abounded the Church hath received the largest accessions, many of the deluded People as their Passions subside, seeking for Rest in the Bosom and Communion of the Church’.Footnote 83 Of course, the Great Awakening was not all gain for the Church (how could it have been with George Whitefield fuelling it on his tour through New England in 1740),Footnote 84 and it was reported that Ebenezer Punderson, the itinerant SPG missionary in New England, had moaned that ‘Enthusiasm had so unsettled many People from all sober and steady Principles, that great Prophaneness and Disregard for the instituted Means of Grace appear’, and that ‘though he had been constant in his Labours, and preached twice every Sunday, and once or more in every Week, the Success did not answer his Hopes’.Footnote 85 Nevertheless, compared with the endless splintering of Congregational congregations, and the divisions between Old Lights and New Lights – it has been calculated that over 170 new congregations emerged as a result of the Great AwakeningFootnote 86 – the Church of England was a gainer rather than a loser from the revivalist fervour. From the 1740s, reaction to the Great Awakening was frequently cited as a reason for coming over to the Church, and a joint letter of the New England missionaries to the SPG declared that ‘it is a Matter of great Comfort . . . to see in all Places the earnest Zeal of the People in pressing forward into the Church from the Confusions which Methodism has spread among them; in so much that they think nothing too much to do to qualify themselves for obtaining of Missionaries from the Society’.Footnote 87 In December 1744, Timothy Cutler reported that hardly a Sunday went by without some Congregationalists joining them in the Church service at Christ Church:
multitudes being now inclined to examine, and look into both Sides of a Question which few comparatively could be persuaded to do heretofore, till the late Revival of Enthusiasm among them; and some Hundreds have thereupon been added to the Church, insomuch that in many Places, where Error, Confusion and every evil Work did abound, Grace through God's Mercy doth now much more abound.Footnote 88
Cutler's understanding of the Great Awakening as a ‘revival of Enthusiasm’ – in typical Anglican fashion – portrayed the religious developments of the 1740s in New England as a recurrence of the religious enthusiasm that had caused such chaos in Old England in the 1640s and 1650s, and Anglicans in New England reminded their congregations of the political and social upheaval that had caused. Another clergymen noted:
not only Teachers, but Taylors, Shoemakers, and other Mechanicks, and even Women, Boys and Girls, were become (as their term is) Exhorters. From all which, however, this Advantage hath by God's kind Providence arisen, that it hath remarkably engaged serious People's Attention to our Liturgy and the Doctrines of our Clergy, and this hath brought many considerable Families . . . to be added to the Church.Footnote 89
Moreover, and perhaps with some irony, the Great Awakening allowed moderate Congregationalists (‘Old Lights’) to mirror this Anglican discourse by accusing their ‘New Light’ rivals of continuing the enthusiast tradition, while distancing themselves from it. Charles Chauncy, minister of the First Church of Boston and a leading New England Old Light spokesperson, preached and published a sermon in 1742, Enthusiasm Described and Caution'd Against, which reads remarkably like Anglican critiques of seventeenth-century Protestant nonconformists and eighteenth-century Methodists.Footnote 90 A recurring refrain during the 1740s was that moderate Congregationalists and other dissenting groups in New England were more charitable towards the Church because of the Great Awakening, and in 1751 Cutler claimed that the Church of England ‘hath the second place in esteem with all the sects’.Footnote 91
There were two main areas of Anglican growth in colonial New England, first the seaboard and coastal towns, such as Portsmouth, Newburyport, Boston, Falmouth, Bristol, Newport, Providence and New London. This included invitations to preach in such traditionally Puritan towns as Plymouth. In 1756 it was reported that Ebenezer Thompson had been
invited by several of the good People of the Town Plymouth to come and officiate to them there, where the Liturgy of the Church of England (tho’ that Town has been settled more than 120 Years) was never publickly used before, he went thither on the Feast of the Epiphany, and read Prayers and preached in the Court-house, the High Sheriff of the County and the Chief magistrates attending Divine Service, and about 300 persons more.Footnote 92
That the Church of England liturgy was being used in such an iconic place in New England's religious heritage as Plymouth, and to such a large number of people, is indicative of the ways in which the old order was changing, and by 1758 there were three Anglican churches in Plymouth county (at Scituate, Marshfield and Bridgewater).Footnote 93
But, second, by the 1760s the real headway was in new centres of population growth and what some saw as the industrialising hinterland, such as Lichfield county, Connecticut, with Anglican congregations emerging in Danbury, Sharon, Cornwell and Salisbury. These could rightly be claimed to be pays de mission (since there were no existing ministers of any denomination), and Anglican missionaries seem to have been adept in reaching out to new back-country settlements. Thomas Davies wrote from Lichfield county in 1762: ‘People . . . seem to have lost their ancient bitter Temper, and think that Christianity is clearly taught in our Church, and are resolved to erect churches.’Footnote 94 He also noted:
by advice of the Rev Mr Caner of Boston, a few families in Barrington, the westernmost settlement of that colony, sent their earnest desire that I would come and visit them. Accordingly in September last I went (it is sixty miles) and preached to a large concourse of people, and baptised some children and instructed them in the meaning, use and propriety of the Common Prayer Book. They informed me that many of them had long been dissatisfied with their dissenting instructors, being constantly taught rigid Calvinism, and that sin was of advantage and advanced happiness greatly in the world; that if the Church was introduced there they must pay tithes etc; that the Church was just like the papists; that the service book was taken from the mass-book etc.Footnote 95
Davies put them right on these last points, and established an Anglican congregation.
Although Anglicanism was intimately connected with New England's fashionable elite (and was satirised by Congregational clergy on these grounds),Footnote 96 it also made surprising successes with the lower levels of society and flourished in some of the remoter regions. John Wentworth, governor of New Hampshire, and himself an Anglican descendant of the Puritan William Wentworth, noted in 1750s that ‘if the Church service was performed without Expense, or any zealous attempts to proselytise, the People would naturally flock to it’.Footnote 97 Anglicans in New England seem to have behaved not unlike Methodists in Old England, doing well in new areas of population growth such as Simsbury, where, by 1762, there were reported to be 2,000 people (many of whom had lately arrived from England to work in the copper mines).Footnote 98 Arthur Brown, the missionary in Portsmouth, reported success in the frontier settlements of New Hampshire.Footnote 99 The missionary at Hebron boasted in 1762 that he had ridden 2,000 miles that year (intimations of Wesley), at the request of various congregations, and had preached over 100 week-day lectures, on top of his usual Sunday services.Footnote 100 In reports such as these, SPG missionaries could be seen as itinerants. Itinerancy in both Old and New England was often viewed as a hall-mark of Evangelicalism, and moderate Congregationalists disapproved of the practice as much as did most Old England Anglicans.Footnote 101 But some SPG missionaries participated in this practice and competed for souls in an Evangelical way. Indeed at a certain level most SPG missionaries itinerated given that the area encompassed by their missions was frequently large and encompassed a number of settlements. From his Newport base, James Honeyman in the 1720s, 1730s and 1740s often visited Freetown, Tiverton and Little Compton, and at one point preached at the latter on week-days in a Congregationalist meeting house,Footnote 102 which is itself suggestive of a more accommodating relationship between Anglicanism and Congregationalism than Bridenbaugh's thesis implied. In similar vein, in 1763 Matthew Graves was asked to do duty in a Congregationalist meeting house because their minister was sick, and where he used the Anglican liturgy, with the consent of those present. He further reported that he had preached for several weeks in a private house belonging to a member of the Church who was ill: ‘This Sunday Evening Exercise was attended with crowded audiences of various denominations.’Footnote 103 Likewise, in 1761 Ebeneezer Dibblee was asked by the dissenters at Greenwich, with the permission of the church people, to officiate to them.Footnote 104 Samuel Fayerweather, himself a former Congregationalist minister, and a Church of England conformist, reported that Congregationalists were now treating him pretty charitably, citing his practice of allowing total immersion at baptism as a reason for this.Footnote 105
Reports from the 1760s noted that ‘people of every Denomination, especially the young’ were inclined to conform to the Church, indicative of the Church's ability to reach out to the rising generation,Footnote 106 suggesting that the long-term future for the Church in New England seemed favourable. Moreover, two high-profile Congregationalists conformed to the Church in the late 1760s, as if to demonstrate the ways in which the old order had indeed been refashioned. In 1767, Nathaniel Rogers, the descendant of the Puritan minister Nathaniel Rogers, who had emigrated to New England in the 1630s, and who was thus seen as coming from the purest Puritan stock, became a parishioner at the King's chapel.Footnote 107 Henry Caner, now rector there, characterised him as being from the first families in the country (by which he meant that Rogers was descended from the Puritan fathers), and noted that Rogers was believed to be related to John Rogers, the martyr in Queen Mary's time, as if to stress a common Protestant heritage for both Congregationalists and Episcopalians.Footnote 108 Caner further described Rogers as being ‘warmly attached to the cause of liberty & particularly to that of the colonys, yet firm in his Duty & loyalty to the king & the British Government, and an enemy to the factious proceedings which have taken place, and are still too cherished’.Footnote 109 How far we are to infer from this that Rogers only conformed to the Church because he was dismayed by the tense political atmosphere of the late 1760s is unclear, but the statement does suggest the complex set of allegiances which people like Rogers were trying to hold together. In the spring of 1768 Mather Byles, a Congregational minister, the great-nephew of Cotton Mather, the great-grandson of Increase Mather, and the great-great-grandson of Richard Mather (who had fled England for Boston in 1635), and therefore a member of a family who arguably represented ‘Puritan New England’ more than any other, accepted the post of rector at Christ Church, Boston.Footnote 110 Byles maintained that he conformed on account of his reading (this was the most common reason given by former Congregational ministers who came over to the Church), and he told his former flock that he still believed the Congregational church to be a true church, and that he had only changed his views about the validity of Anglican ceremonies. ‘There is not a sermon that I have preached in this place’, he promised them, ‘but what I shall in the Church of England’.Footnote 111 Again it is hard to know quite what to make of this statement, except to suggest that besides the large volume of Congregational and Episcopalian printed tracts and pamphlets which were directed at each other, there were other areas, such as the reformation of manners, on which clergy of all denominations could find common ground. It is also instructive to compare the reaction to Byles's conforming to the Church in 1768 with that experienced by Cutler, Brown and Johnson in 1722. The ‘Yale apostasy’ had provoked an enormous frisson in Congregational circles, whereas Byles's conforming nearly fifty years later, while provoking comment, did not create such as furore, even when the ‘bishop controversy’ had been at its most vehement, and when the political tensions in Boston were at a height. It is true that a number of satirical verses were written about Byles, largely accusing him of going over to the Church for financial reasons, and suggesting that he would end up in Rome, and on 25 April 1768, the Boston Gazette printed ‘A Wonderful Dream’,Footnote 112 where the spirit of Richard Mather prophesied bad things for his great-grandson and for any attempts to establish an episcopate in America, but it is significant that there was not even more vehement criticism.
If I am right to suggest that the Church was making some inroads into Puritan New England by the early 1760s, what went wrong? In large measure, as political, social, economic and cultural historians have emphasised, the broader context changed remarkably sometime in the mid-1760s (although there are large debates about the causes, nature and timing of those changes).Footnote 113 This is not the place to rehearse the debates about the impact of legislation from the Stamp Act onwards, and the economic and political and economic crises which followed; nevertheless it is clear that as anti-British government feeling grew, the Church of England clergy became victims of this, and the Church was viewed as an agent of an unpopular government.Footnote 114 But even in this changing context, the mid-1760s were not the mid-1770s. The missionary at Salem in 1764 felt that
establishing missions in New England has contributed much to promote Peace and Harmony between Churchmen and Dissenters, and to wean the latter from their rigid notions and aversion to the Church . . . when they see our Service fairly set forth before their eyes, they are convinced that those things what they were informed concerning us are nothing. Ocular demonstration (and perhaps nothing else could) abates their prejudices and satisfies them that our Service is neither idolatorous nor superstitious.Footnote 115
Moreover, overt and public displays of the Church's position did not seem to arouse much comment. A report to the SPG in 1766 noted that the Church of England Convention of New England clergy had met in Boston, with fourteen clergy attending. ‘We made something of an appearance for this country, when we walked together in gowns and cassocks’, the author recalled, ‘but we have heard of no jealous or unfriendly remarks upon the occasion’.Footnote 116 In the abstracts of proceedings for that year, attached to the printed version of the annual sermons to the SPG, and containing reports from on the ground, some clergy were at pains to emphasise that they and their parishioners were on cordial terms with members of other denominations.Footnote 117 As late as 1773, reflecting on activities in 1772, it was noted at Simsbury, Cambridge, Scituate and Marshfield that ‘there is more harmony than formerly’ between members of the Church of England and ‘the dissenters’,Footnote 118 and in 1774, referring to 1773 at Norwich, the SPG missionary had ‘the satisfaction to observe in the Dissenters a gradual increase of peaceableness and goodwill to the Church of England’.Footnote 119 There may, of course, be problems with this particular kind of evidence. Some clergy maintained that the secretary of the SPG who compiled the abstracts from information sent out to him from clergy working in America, misjudged or misunderstood what they had sent him (although in fact the originals of these letters in the SPG archives do say in these cases exactly what the digest claimed).Footnote 120 And J. C. D. Clark has warned us of the dangers of accepting these kind of statements at face value because they are hard to square with what would transpire over the next two or three years, and perhaps partly because they do not fit into his picture of denominational rivalry.Footnote 121 Nevertheless I would be wary of dismissing them altogether. If, as other kinds of research indicate, people took different paths to Revolution, then it may be that in some places the Church was simply not the issue as it was elsewhere.
But, it is certainly true that by the early 1770s, as in other areas of New England life, attitudes were hardening considerably. Henry Caner saw the Massachusetts Marriage Act of 1773 – which meant that ministers could be fined if they did not know the couple whom they were marrying – as an attack on the Church: ‘it is utterly impossible’, he claimed, ‘for any clergyman to know all the seafaring and low people who ask them to marry them’.Footnote 122 Worse, in October 1774 he lamented that Samuel Peters, the SPG missionary at Hebron, had been ‘driven by violence’ from his parish by people who called themselves the ‘Sons of liberty’.Footnote 123 The following month, Ezra Stiles noted that the Episcopalians in Cambridge had not observed Thanksgiving Day that year,Footnote 124 which was indicative of a cultural split, and a departure from the last eighty years where members of the Church of England in New England had observed the November Thanksgiving Day (itself suggestive of how something that had roots in a ‘Puritan’ context had in the recent past been able to transcend possible anti-Church of England connotations). Yet even at this juncture Stiles could observe that the Church of England congregation at Christ Church, Boston, who had been annoyed that their rector, Mather Byles, had not opened the church for a service on that day, were ‘more for liberty’ than any episcopal congregation north of Maryland.
During the next year, and those that followed, Church of England clergy were harried from their parishes, and church building were damaged, or used as store rooms, or even as Congregationalist meeting rooms. From then on, the reports back to England from Church of England clergy in New England were almost universally grim, and in 1777, after detailing the sufferings inflicted on clergy in New England and elsewhere during the previous year, the secretary of the SPG claimed that
were every instance of this kind faithfully collected, it is probable that the sufferings of the American clergy might appear, in many respects, not inferior to those of the same order in the great rebellion of the last century; and such a work would be no bad supplement to Walker's Sufferings of the Clergy.Footnote 125
Evidence such as this would fit well into the model of a Church which had been roundly rejected by Congregational New England. But as I have tried to demonstrate this should not be seen as the only possible way to understand the Church's place in New England, particularly from the 1730s. Indeed by the early 1760s, the Anglican Church was doing rather well in the colonial religious market place (benefiting perhaps from consumer choice, which, in a recent analysis of pre-Revolutionary America, Timothy Breen has argued was an overriding factor in American culture),Footnote 126 and, in its way, the Church of England was becoming embedded in New England life. As one of Mayhew's Anglican critics told him: ‘Pray sir be calm, is this not our country, and the native country of most of us, as well as yours?’Footnote 127 If nothing else, the evidence I have produced might provide us with a richer context – a thicker description – with which to evaluate the significance of the ‘bishop controversy’, and relations between Congregationalists and Anglicans. Above all, it might make us wary of the temptations of teleology. Because of the events of the years after 1776, it has been easy for some historians to discern necessary links between anti-Britishness, anti-Anglicanism and anti-Episcopalianism.Footnote 128 But New England Anglicanism was not an oxymoron in Puritan New England, and both it (and bishops) found a small home in the United States after 1784.Footnote 129
