In Freedom without Permission, Frances S. Hasso and Zakia Salime offer us a timely contribution to the scholarship on women's political expression, specifically within digital spaces during the Arab revolutions. This edited volume not only explores digital platforms as spaces of dissent, but also serves as a historical archive of women's actions in Tunisia, Egypt, Morocco, Bahrain, Yemen, Saudi Arabia and Turkey. Few books on the so-called “Arab Spring” have considered the sociopolitical uprisings in the Arab Gulf or the role of women. Freedom without Permission also unabashedly considers the about-face in women's rights in recent years. For example, women's rights and security in Egypt declined under president Mohamed Morsi (June 2012— July 2013) in comparison with women's expectations during and after the toppling of Hosni Mubarak (October 1981— February 2011).
The book's analysis of women's resistance on digital platforms and in physical spaces converges in its descriptions of untamed public geographical spaces (such as Tahrir Square, Bardo's sit-in, or Pearl Square) and/or their parallel digital spaces (blogs, Facebook, etc.). The political expression in these spaces lacked the traditionally revolutionary ideologies of Marxism or Islamism, considered by the Arab world to be failed political ideologies during postcolonial times. Rather, cries for “freedom,” “dignity,” and “social equality” dominated public space. The counter-revolutionary forces rendered women's bodies sites of dissent, oppression, and subjectivity in a world where public space has been traditionally a male domain.
In the first chapter, “Politics in the Digital Boudoir: Sentimentality,” Sonali Pahwa explores young Egyptian women's blogs, which she refers to as “intimate” accounts. However, she makes the case that they were also created to contest the dominant national political narrative and to protest the public/private spatial constraints imposed upon Egyptian women. Blog posts offered an outlet for women to not only express their intimate selves, a subtle protest against conservative norms, but also to assert their political stances.
Lamia Benyoussef takes us to Tunisia in the second chapter, “Gender and the Fractured Mythscapes of National Identity in Revolutionary Tunisia.” Benyoussef explores the “mythscapes” in music, cartoons, satire, visual culture, and videos to analyze revolutionary as well as post-revolutionary narratives. The political “mythscapes,” a term sociologist Andy Bennett coined (2002) to express the connection between space and place in the digital music platform, revealed themselves as four contested narratives: populist, pluralist, secularist, and Islamist. Benyoussef is forthcoming in her positionality vis à vis the revolution and evaluates the gender and political implications of anti-feminist musical texts amongst other digital platforms. She concludes that the revolution of 2011 allowed for the birth of new forms of activist feminism disassociating Tunisian women from the patriarchal state-sponsored feminism imposed by Presidents Bourguiba and Ben Ali.
From Tunisia, where the “Arab Spring” ignited, Susanne Dahlgren transports us to Yemen in her chapter “Making Intimate ‘Civilpolitics’ in Southern Yemen.” The term “civilpolitics” resumes the notion that state power as an imaginary transcends the military, religious and tribal allegiances to the realm of the “civil.” Dahlgren demonstrates how the public spaces of Aden became revolutionary sites of care and relief which encouraged women's re-entry into the public space regardless of their education or social status.
Frances S. Hasso investigates the Pearl Revolution's representative sectarian divides in Bahrain. She argues that the 14 February revolution disrupted “gendered arrangements of bodies and voices” and aimed to sexualize women as a repressive state technique, to which she attributes the term “sex-sect-police nexus” to describe the processes used to implement such state oppression directed toward Bahraini women.
In the fifth chapter “The Women Are Coming”: Gender, Space and the Politics of Inauguration.”, Zakia Salime focuses on Morocco's 20 February Movement. She contends that the movement gave birth to “aesthetic citizenship,” a term for artistic, performative, and discursive spaces, which provided a platform to discuss gender, sex, politics, and culture and which has given new meanings to Moroccan feminism.
In the sixth chapter, Susana Galán investigates the “Women 2 Drive” campaign in Saudi Arabia, a country which did not witness a revolution similar to the countries previously discussed. This campaign challenges women's restrictive spaces and has allowed Saudi women to organize resistance communities as well as employ a radical language to support their demands for mobility. By voicing their demands in cyberspace, Saudi women campaigning for their right to drive have begun to open doors to new imaginaries and future possibilities in which women determine their spatial mobility.
I find chapter 7, “Revolution Undressed: The Politics of Rage and Aesthetics in Aliaa Elmahdy's Body Activism,” particularly fascinating. Here Karina Eileraas reads Aliaa Elmahdy's nude body posted on her blog as a “performance of rage” expressing internal fury against the general state of affairs in Egypt. In fact, Eileraas depicts Elmahdy as a woman who writes herself into history as both a sexual and a political agent. By exposing her body on the internet, she rendered herself vulnerable to sexual harassment and violence in real life. Yet, and despite the voyeuristic seduction of Elmahdy's body, she exerts control with the time and space she chooses to expose herself.
Finally, Banu Gökariksel concludes the book with her chapter “Intimate Politics of Protest: Gendering Embodiments and Redefining Spaces in Istanbul's Taksim Gezi Park and the Arab Revolutions.” She considers Freedom Without Expression in its entirety as a project and reflects upon the Taksim Gezi Park protests in Istanbul's contestation of normative gender discourses. Gökariksel illustrates how women's bodies are an intimate political space and shows a back and forth between the public/private space dichotomy throughout the uprisings. Overall, Freedom without Permission offers a variety of analyses and viewpoints while considering women's bodies and spaces as sites of revolutions and uprisings. All contributing authors demonstrate an eye for detail and a strength of analysis that have shaped gender politics and the politics of gender during and after the revolutions.
