The author decided to attract and excite readers’ curiosity by adopting an eccentric title, which is the English translation of the Italian nickname Accademia dei Pugni used by the intellectual circle that collected the best brains of the Lombard Enlightenment. The subject of the book is the group of scholars who, in the Milan of the eighteenth century, arose on the initiative of Pietro Verri and Cesare Beccaria and published Il Caffè, one of the most representative journals of the age in Europe. The aim of Sophus Reinert is to recover and show the relevance of the historical contribution that the Milanese authors gave to the European Enlightenment and above all to the growth and institutionalization of political economy.
The subtitle explicitly reveals what is the interpretative key of the book: the Italian economists were involved in the process of building “commercial society,” that model of well-arranged modern society founded on market, human rights, and a fair and efficient legal justice, which was the dream of “Philosophes” in every corner of Europe. Indeed, the idea of commercial society—using the effective expression of Adam Smith—is the core of the public debate of the eighteenth century and the source of inspiration for the great season of reforms that characterized the European history of the age.
Really, the Italian Enlightenment—with the school of Naples and Milan—is one of the main protagonists of the eighteenth-century culture, and its most representative authors—Cesare Beccaria, Ferdinando Galiani, and Gaetano Filangieri—enjoyed an international success that had few comparisons. Yet, if its contribution to economic, legal, and political theories is well known and valued, it remains less studied than Physiocracy or the Scottish Enlightenment. Without doubt, Italian authors are penalized by the linguistic obstacle of the declining knowledge of Italian abroad, above all from the nineteenth century, an obstacle that doesn’t discourage Sophus Reinert, who shows an amazing mastery of Italian language and culture.
Therefore, the main merit of the book consists in introducing the international audience to the knowledge of the Italian Enlightenment and particularly of the Lombard School. This knowledge goes far beyond the mere comment on Beccaria’s masterpiece Crimes and Punishments, a work translated in all languages and known all over the world. Instead, Reinert explores the entire literary production of the “Fisticuffs,” considering both the published and unpublished works of each member of the group, including those of the less famous among them. The result is a detailed description and analysis of Italian economic and political thought within a great attempt of contextualization of ideas and theories to institutions, laws, politics, arts, customs, and mentality of the Italy of the time.
The work—which, with its almost 700 pages, is very voluminous—consists of seven chapters written with a style alternating between narration and analysis. The topic of each section is always developed by connecting it with a great variety of historical facts, public figures, constitutional frameworks, personal relations, and human psychology. The first chapter is a detailed description of the historical context of Lombardy in the eighteenth century, which introduces the reader to the political, intellectual, and human background in which the Academy of Fisticuffs was born. The following one presents the reformist agenda of the group, which ranged from criminal law to commercial rules. The third chapter is devoted to Henry Lloyd, the only foreign member of Fisticuffs, a Welsh military man and scholar, brother in army of Pietro Verri, whose intellectual contribution has been too long neglected. The successive chapter, through the political and social emergence of banditry, shows the concrete problems that the process of building a commercial society met in Italy of the age. The fifth chapter deals with the eighteenth-century meaning of the word “socialism,” which was used by the opponent of Fisticuffs to stigmatize their secular view of society. Chapter six is the core of the book, since it deepens the economic thought of Beccaria, Verri, and Fisticuffs, focusing on the social aim of reforms that characterized their political economy. The concluding chapter observes how successively, from the negative critique of “socialism,” the Italian culture of the age reached towards the positive concept of social science inclined to the reform of society.
Reinert’s book is doubtless well argued, carefully documented, and endearing, above all for non-Italian readers. The only critiques it is possible to address are two. First, the author lingers too much in historical digressions on fact and characters—some of them almost unknown also by an Italian historian—which often hinders the understanding of the book’s thesis. Second, Reinert insists a great deal on the issue of “eighteenth-century socialism,” which, instead, for the history of economic thought really appears less significant than the author believes. At the same time, the chapter on Henry Lloyd is so interesting and rich in information and analysis that even for it alone, the book deserves to be read.
