Nostalgia and its uses
Lament and loss run riverine through literature on the Muslims of South Asia. Trauma haunts accounts of Delhi particularly, which, in those dark days following the rebellion of 1857, witnessed the final expiration of Mughal rule in India and the violent destruction of its urban fabric through colonial canon-fire. This was a loss vocalised by the city's bards, nowhere more strikingly than in the poetry of the heartbroken Mirza Ghalib (1797-1869). The eulogies of Ghalib were followed in the later nineteenth century by the melancholic texts of Muhammad Husain Azad (1830-1910) and Altaf Hussein Hali (1837-1914). Their works helped transform the ghazal, a poetic form that had traditionally lamented the pain of a lost lover, into a vehicle for social and cultural lament of boundless scale, while the genre of the shahr āshob (the disturbed city) came to focus mourning more decidedly on Delhi itself.Footnote 1
In the decades that followed, is grief came to refer to a general decline afflicting the entire Muslim body politic. In their commentaries on the state of Urdu poetry, these same poets created a narrative of decline that reached back to the eighteenth century, a narrative wherein aesthetic decline was both a reflection on as well as the cause of a wider social and moral decadence and corruption that brought Mughal rule to a demise.Footnote 2 1857 and its repressive aftermath became a watershed in the history of Islam in South Asia, when a definitive shadow fell across a certain urban, refined, intellectual culture among Muslims, particularly those of the ashraf (gentry) in north India, and initiated a process of lasting backwardness and underdevelopment, particularly in the realm of education.Footnote 3 Muslims languished, it would be said both by contemporaries and by later scholars, because they were mired in the nostalgic reminiscence of a proud past in which Islamic rulers had held political and cultural sway over much of north India and beyond. Hali's famed poem, Musaddas-e Madd-o Jazr-i Islām, or simply Musaddas-e Hālī (1879), was said to have “evoked and expressed” precisely this kind of “Indian Muslim nostalgia for the time when Islam was a great world force”.Footnote 4 Muslims, it was reckoned, had entered a twilight period: “To live on the British terms” and to “submit to a new syllabus of study for success in life” thereafter was “to agree to see the future as the British painted it”, to deny their past, and, perhaps, to acknowledge that Islam itself was an anachronism; it was to acknowledge “that history would never become Islamic, that the temporal order in the age of Western dominance had escaped God's will and pleasure”.Footnote 5 In the twentieth century, the poet of Islam's cultural and spiritual reawakening in India, Muhammad Iqbal (1877-1938), with the colours of his work “so brightly painted” and its emotions “so raw”, became for some “the epitome of the Muslim nostalgic sense of history”.Footnote 6
The standard account of Muslim cultural nostalgia slides easily towards political conclusions. An over-determined idea of the Muslim, clinging nostalgically to his experience of imperial rule and foreign origins, rendered him a problematic particularity from the very nascence of the politics of nationality and territorial nativism in India in the latter third of the nineteenth century.Footnote 7 Expressions of this ranged from the more benignly paternalistic to the fearful. The apostle of modern India, Jawaharlal Nehru (1889-1964), for instance, would write often in the former register: following the rebellion, the Muslim “upper classes” looked to Islam's past greatness – to periods when it was “a conquering and creative force in Baghdad, Spain” and elsewhere – in order to fill a psychological ‘vacuum’ produced by the break with the Mughal period.Footnote 8 In Nehru's case, such statements might be read as part of a broader working-out of the temporal logic of the Indian nation on the eve of independence.Footnote 9 For the most part, however, historicist diagnoses – which contain within them an implicit gesturing towards Muslim unreason and superstition, themselves tropes of some longevity in India – saw nostalgia as both cause and symptom of a fatal Muslim backwardness, evidence of the fact that Muslims were out of place and out of time with the time of the nation. Today, even well-meaning commentators can write with great pathos of the Muslims of contemporary India as “hostage to their past”, “occupying a position of suspended animation between present hopelessness and past glory”.Footnote 10 There is moreover a growing body of literature on the intersection between Islam and psychoanalysis that has returned nostalgia to its seventeenth-century clinical roots by developing the idea of “pathological nostalgia” in Muslim societies.Footnote 11
This ever-present temporal struggle is present in accounts of the body politic as a whole as well as in those of individual Muslims. In an essay on one of the most significant Muslim figures of twentieth-century India, Abul Kalam Azad (1888-1958), the famed historian Aijaz Ahmed wrote that, “By 1903, when he established his first full-scale journal, Lisān al-Sidq, he was writing a prose somewhat like [Altaf Hussain] Hali in its Islamic revivalist nostalgia, somewhat like Syed Ahmed Khan in its modernizing and reformist aspiration [. . .]”.Footnote 12 When Ahmed described Azad's prose as “like Hali in its Islamic revivalist nostalgia”, he indicated that the nostalgic register of the nineteenth century had itself acquired nostalgic status – nostalgia redux – as it permeated the literary life-worlds of India's early twentieth-century Muslims. With his allusion to revivalism, he also indicated the historian's tendency, which is heightened in his Marxist interpretation, to view that nostalgic tradition as indelibly marked by religion on each outing. Ahmed presented Hali and the “modernising and reformist aspirations” of Sayyid Ahmad Khan (1817-1898), founder of the Muhammadan Anglo-Oriental College and the Aligarh movement, as contrasts. The fact that Hali and Sayyid Ahmad had an important, intimate relationship – that Hali himself is regarded by scholars as having veered between the polarities of Ghalib and pre-Mutiny Delhi on the one hand, and the modernist Aligarh project on the other – is not insignificant.Footnote 13 That is to say, the curious mixture in Azad's style stands in for a longer series of estrangements within Muslim intellectual currents. This is a persistent tension in historical accounts of Muslim political life post-1857, as the self is seen to have rebounded between the draw of the past on the one hand, and social and political modernity that promised to propel the Muslim forward in time, or at least make him present, on the other.
Azad has proven a particularly ripe example of a divided self – Aamir Mufti's account of Azad has him from his earliest childhood ricocheting between places and thought worlds, between worlds designated taqlīdī (traditional) and ‘modern’; Azad's “disjointed life” is an “allegory of the trajectories and crises of the culture of the ashraf elites of North India”, a “fitful and fragmented narrative of emergence from the world of tradition”, writes Mufti.Footnote 14 Discontinuous time renders a self that is in tension with “cultural and temporal hierarchies”, “in the present but not of it”, questioning the narrative of development and “the antinomies of colonial culture – past and present, indigenous and alien, tradition and modernity”.Footnote 15 Azad's queer temporalities and spatialities thus offer him up as a critic of the insistent modernity of colonialism. Although Azad is in many ways an atypical personage, able to inhabit his ‘backwardness’ and bring the dialectical tension to productive use in his rhetoric, the trope of nostalgia is arguably nourished nevertheless by the paradigm of internal discord – the nostalgic Indian Muslim writ large is one who is longing for temporally coherent experience, for an undivided prior self that was wrought asunder by colonial rule and the demand to reform.
The concern for a lost unity of experience, and nostalgia for a supposedly prior period of unified experience, takes on a specific form in histories of Muslims in South Asia, but the concern itself is of course not unique to this context. The twentieth century is often characterised by the supposed crisis – or indeed destruction – of experience that resulted from Weberian ‘disenchantment’, which in turn provoked complex iterations of nostalgia for a time before alienation and fragmentation.Footnote 16 Across the political spectrum, people have worried, “with varying degrees of nostalgia”, writes Martin Jay, “about the gap between the potential for authentic lived experience and the structural abstractions that govern modern life”.Footnote 17 For Walter Benjamin, arguably the most famous writer on experience in the twentieth century, the First World War was the seismic event; the struggle thereafter was to “invest experience with a redemptive potential”.Footnote 18 In histories of the colonial world, disenchantment and the crisis of experience appear as foreign objects, thrust upon societies by the fact of modernising European rule.
As Svetlana Boym points out, however, the event of modernity – the advent of industrialisation and secularisation in crude terms – need not simply signal the opening up of a void of meaning; it might also increase emancipatory possibilities, making space for new imagined communities and novel political projects aimed at cultivating social cohesion.Footnote 19 Boym advanced a useful distinction between “restorative nostalgia”, desirous of a return to the past, and “reflective nostalgia”, which “dwells on the ambivalences of human longing and belonging and does not shy away from the contradictions of modernity”.Footnote 20 There is another tradition too, on the left, of thinking about melancholy and its relationship to political life. Melancholy can signal an “emotional commitment to an exhausted experience”, but it can also provide an opportunity to develop a critical understanding of the past from which to construct a future politics.Footnote 21 For Benjamin, for instance, it is melancholy voided of political content and deprived of its critical potentialities which had to be rejected.Footnote 22
The rest of this article will attempt to rethink the politics of Muslim nostalgia and particularly its association with temporal dislocation for the early twentieth century. It will look at a constellation of initiatives in this period that have usually been seen through the lens of rising pan-Islamic feeling. Pan-Islamism was an idea simultaneously vague and laden with dangerous connotations in this period. In the Indian context, it refers to the emotional association of Indian Muslims with the ailing Ottoman Empire and other Muslim countries from the late nineteenth century, which culminated with the Khilafat Movement (1919-24). Pan-Islamism harbours within it implications of nostalgia for Muslim kingship and imperial rule – interestingly enough, not necessarily, or solely, among those who were shipwrecked by the end of Mughal rule, but rather those among a younger generation who could have no personal recollection of it.
Many commentators sought to disprove the legitimacy of ‘pan-Islamism’ by demonstrating that it had little purchase in the wider Muslim word.Footnote 23 Others took to the language of anachronism: “an extraordinary wave of sympathy for Turkey” was a quintessentially irrational sentiment, ahistorical even.
In the early years of the twentieth century there were two trends among the Moslem intelligentsia: one, chiefly among the younger element, was towards nationalism, the other was a deviation from India's past and even, to some extent, her present, and a greater interest in Islamic countries, especially Turkey, the seat of the Khilafat.Footnote 24
Nehru states here that whereas nationalism was true to India's past, the kinds of sympathy for Turkey and the Ottoman Caliphate in particular evidence in the 1910s was an outright innovation. The latter statement holds true in a straightforward sense – there is little evidence of sustained Indian interest in the rest of the Islamic world much before the coinage of the term ‘pan-Islamism’ in the late nineteenth century.Footnote 25 What is more curious is the suggestion that “a greater interest in Islamic countries” was a deviation from India's present. It implies that nationalism was the sole affect proper to the present and that pan-Islamism was antithetical to it. This elides, among other distinctions, the fact that early-twentieth-century Turkey was also the home of the Young Turk Revolution (1908), which was for some contemporaries the apotheosis of modern, constitutionalist, reform-minded politics.
This article will argue that there was an early twentieth-century Muslim political register in India that can be described as nostalgic or melancholic, inasmuch as it meditated on history, on the passage of time and on the fleeting nature of the present.Footnote 26 But it did not, I suggest, thus demand any kind of recovery of the past or a return to another place. To the contrary, it appears acutely concerned with Muslim futurity. Mohamed Ali Jauhar (1878-1931), a significant figure in India's early twentieth century, features centrally in what follows. Born in Rampur, he studied at Aligarh before taking a degree in Modern History at the University of Oxford. He became widely known in the 1910s as a newspaper editor and political activist; later, under the pen-name ‘Jauhar’, he would also become known as a minor poet. Mohamed Ali established himself as de facto leader of a certain school of politics in Delhi – referred to by colonial officials as the ‘Young Muhammadans’, a term that was intended to diminish them by association with the revolutionary movement of the Young Turks – during the period under consideration.
The insistent demands of a new age
Mohamed Ali started his most famous journalistic endeavour, the newspaper Comrade, in Calcutta in 1911 while the city was still the capital of the Raj. On the heels of the Viceroy's announcement at the imperial durbar of December 1911 that the capital was to shift to Delhi, however, Mohamed Ali decided upon a translocation too. He had criticised the imperial decision at length in the pages of Comrade, but seemed ultimately to feel that being at the centre of political life was vital for him and for his newspaper. It was after arriving in Delhi that he established Comrade’s Urdu-language companion, Hamdard; although both papers struggled financially, this moment thus seemed to inaugurate the realisation of a coherent journalistic and political vision: “To reach the masses, we must use their own language, and if all India is to be our province, we must seek a more central place than Calcutta [. . .] we trust Delhi will once more influence the thoughts and actions of the people of our country”.Footnote 27 It was implicit here that Delhi was a site of historic Muslim political power, a centre that might have “once more” a radiating influence; it was precisely the “unlimited”, latent “possibilities of a centre like Delhi” for his future vision for India that drove this move.Footnote 28 After an interruption of a month, the first Delhi issue of Comrade was published on 12 October 1912; Hamdard emerged in April 1913.
This period of time was momentous for Mohamed Ali for other reasons too. The Ottoman Empire had become embroiled in a disastrous war against the Balkan League of Serbia, Bulgaria, Montenegro and Greece in October 1912. For the editor, this was an event of peculiar and unparalleled historical importance to Muslims, both in India and beyond. Trying to mobilise concerted support for the ‘sick man’ as it fought to retain its European provinces, Comrade despaired of the apathetic existing Muslim leadership in India. It turned for inspiration, instead, to poetry, more specifically to the “vitalising words of Iqbal [to] dispel the crowding hopelessness of the situation”: “We say to ourself [sic], why wander in quest of leaders when we ourselves may be the way as well as the wayfarer, the guide as well as the goal?”Footnote 29 In part to make himself “the guide”, Mohamed Ali organised the Turkish Relief Fund in late 1911 to help orphans, widows and refugees of the war against Italy over Tripoli. The fund's growing list of subscribers was regularly printed in the pages of Comrade.Footnote 30
In connection with the Turkish war effort in the Balkans, Mohamed Ali also established the All-India Medical Mission, which operated under the direction of the physician Dr Mukhtar Ahmad Ansari (1880-1936).Footnote 31 Dr Ansari had, like so many of his milieu including Mohamed Ali, travelled to Britain for part of his higher education and had begun his medical career there, becoming personally acquainted with Nehru and Iqbal along the way.Footnote 32 He returned to India in 1910 and became prominent in public life in the years thereafter partly thanks to the fame garnered during the Medical Mission. After the First World War, he would become a prominent ‘Congress Muslim’. The Mission to Constantinople, which was organised entirely by the so-called Young Muhammadans, aimed to render medical assistance to sick and wounded Ottoman soldiers. It included Indian officers, doctors, and nurses, many of whom were trained in Europe too, decked in uniforms designed by the organisers. The uniforms included khaki jodhpurs to emphasise the Mission's “distinctly Indian character”, a badge on the left arm with a red crescent, and a semi-military Norfolk coat that had two silver crescents on the collar and an Arabic inscription.Footnote 33 Mohamed Ali, largely through Comrade, raised money for the Mission and was its chief champion and publicist. He and Ansari lauded the fact that the members of the Mission came from all the provinces of India, and moreover from the “cultured middle and higher classes, representing the flower of Mohammadan youth”.Footnote 34
Part of the effect – and affect – that he sought to engender was the sense of Muslim India rallying around the afflicted Ottoman Empire, whose Sultan was also Caliph of the Muslim world. In so doing, he was profoundly rearticulating the relationship between Muslim India and the Ottoman Empire. This reflected the editor's broader interpretation of this historical moment as one of temporal rupture, which he conveyed through his journal. On 30 November 1912, for instance, Comrade published the first of a series of articles on ‘The Defeat of the Turk’. “Explain how we may, the startling events in the Balkans have brought a sudden and almost immediate disaster to the Ottoman Empire in Europe”, it began. The article proceeded to describe “this unexpected and overwhelming catastrophe”:
The events have been too staggering in their rapidity for their significance to be completely grasped. They are rich in historical suggestiveness and in all the elements that make a powerful appeal to the primeval instincts of race and creed. A proud and mighty conqueror had entered Europe more than four centuries ago, and ancient kingdoms and politics had crumbled into dust. He had led a virile race, young in hope, confident of its powers and resolute in aim, into new fields of endeavour and achievement. He did not realize at the time the peculiar nature of the heritage into which he had entered. He had broken through a web of hoary traditions that go to the roots of Roman history [. . .] The Balkans have, ever since the Turkish conquest, remained a vast theatre where a perpetual war has been going on between alien cultures and rival creeds. The present struggle seems to have ushered the last and most ruthless phase of that war. Perhaps it is destined to end with the departure of the Turk from Europe. One cannot help falling into a multitude of sad reflections when one sees a most eventful and thrilling drama in human history hastening to a tragic end.Footnote 35
This passage powerfully conveys the significance of Turkey's military defeats in Mohamed Ali's historical outlook. He viewed the very existence of the Ottoman Empire as a rupture into the fabric of one world, the old world of Christian Europe and “Roman history”, and regarded that rupture as having sparked a four-century-long cyclical struggle. He sensed that the present moment, which would later become known as the First Balkan War, was historically significant because it definitively broke this cyclical temporality, and augured a new age in which Turkey was exorcised from Europe altogether. European Turkey was about to become a nation that had “completed its cycle of destiny and ceased to be”. And yet, the fact of this completed cycle was not given over to providence; it was argued, perhaps contradictory to the depiction of the time-bounded existence of European Turkey, that this very “modern war” had been decided by the cumulative effect of trivial accidents, and that Turkish reversals in Macedonia and Thrace, for example, had “not apparently been decreed by fate”. This was, in a sense, a very human conclusion to an epic narrative.Footnote 36
This period of history was marked by many a crisis in ‘the Muslim world’ – in addition to Tripoli, French and German interventions in Morocco and Russian aggression in Persia exercised the Indian press. In June 1913, in the last instalment of a series of regular ‘War Supplements’ in Comrade, the newspaper reflected on the theme of unfolding fortunes once again: “As we look forward, we are conscious of a future so dim and uncertain, fraught with untold possibilities of good and overhung by such serious chances of evil, that the wisest would shrink from predicting its course”.Footnote 37 In an article of October 1913, by which time the Second Balkan War (wherein the Ottoman Empire regained some of its previous losses) had been concluded, the newspaper continued its prolonged, if vague, meditation on the liminal nature of the present moment:
In common parlance, the Mussalmans have arrived at the parting of ways, facing the gray [sic] vista of unknown things—the Future—with an embarrassed and puzzled air [. . .] The overstrung nerve and the pent-up emotion, even in direct moments, have their zest. Will they give way to a mood of blank, paralyzing despair? [. . .] It is needless to state that the Moslem excitement in India has been entirely due to the troubles, the sufferings and trials of the Moslem communities abroad. The aggressive movements of Europe against the independent Moslem kingdoms [. . .] shook the Indian Mussalmans to their depths. For the first time in their history they felt the pulse of Islamic unity and recovered their deep attachment and devotion to the basic ideas of their creed. This manifestation of Islamic brotherhood and solidarity has proved in an unmistakable manner that Islam is not yet a spent historical force [. . .]. It is still a force of cosmic vitality moulding the lives of millions.Footnote 38
If there was an anxiety reflected in this piece that without crises abroad, India's Muslims would return to their pre-existing state, a near-certain conviction that Turkey's fate had been irrevocably undone and that it was time for India's Muslims to step into the breach counteracted this. Ruminations on Turkey's fortunes and future fate were effectively a historical space-clearing exercise that allowed for Indian initiatives such as the Medical Mission to be imagined, enacted, and invested with political potential.
Although the Mission's successes took place in Constantinople, Delhi and Bombay played a critical role in bookending the emotional drama. According to Comrade, “upwards of fifteen thousand” Delhi Muslims had accompanied the Mission members from the Jāma Masjid to the railway station in Delhi to bid them farewell in December 1912.Footnote 39 Funded by ordinary Muslims, the Mission carried with it a message of “deep sympathy and good-will from Moslem India”, and demonstrated that “the heart of Islam beats in unison”.Footnote 40 The Mission “steamed out of Delhi amidst the cheers and prayers of thousands of Delhi Muslims”. In January 1913, Comrade published a four-page supplement about the Mission accompanied by several photographs of its final departure from Bombay by ship on 15 December 1912. These included pictures of Mohamed Ali himself seeing the party off.Footnote 41 On 5 July 1913 Comrade produced another pictorial supplement, this time with images of medical equipment, doctors and patients on wards, and the Mission's members arm-in-arm with Turks. There were also several photos of refugee camps.Footnote 42 The Mission stayed in Turkey for some eight months and throughout Ansari sent weekly reports to the Comrade, acting in effect as battlefield-correspondent for the journal.Footnote 43 According to his “lucid and unassuming letters”, the Mission provided valuable service to the Ottoman sick and wounded.Footnote 44
With the return of the Mission to Bombay in July 1913, Comrade was effervescent: this was the conclusion of a task that had been the first of its kind, which had been undertaken “with disinterested love of Islam and with a desire to extend the hand of sympathy and fellowship to their brethren in a distant land”; the poor had borne the burden of the cost; organising the Mission was a “unique achievement in the history of Indian Mussalmans, an achievement which has a distinct moral value of its own”; the Mission was a symbol of “a new hope and a glad prophecy”. Of lasting value too was the drawing together of the Muslims of Turkey and India, and the new links forged in their “Islamic relations”.Footnote 45
The sharing of the common sorrow and the sense of the common task will prove, in the fullness of time, assets of vital importance to the future of Islam [. . .] Can it not be that we have witnessed in this terrible period also the birth throes of a new era in the lives of the Moslem communities?Footnote 46
Such comments indicate the ways in which pan-Islamic ventures such as this were as much the cause as the product of a new-found sympathy for one's co-religionists. Part of the rhetorical task of figures such as Ali was to make clear over and again what the new relationship between the Muslims of Turkey and India constituted.
The visual spectacle of the Mission was important. The arrival of the steamer Sicilia, which carried the Mission's members to Bombay, was scheduled for 4.00 pm so that the public could afford them a rousing welcome.Footnote 47 As the ship anchored, Mohamed Ali went out to meet it in a smaller vessel, to receive the members, and to deliver them to port.Footnote 48 Hamdard carried a series of images of the landing – one image showed Dr Ansari, the Mission members, and Mohamed Ali on the deck of the vessel, in khaki uniforms. Others are seen in Turkish caps bearing the crescent moon. Further images show the Mission members garlanded after they stepped off the ship.Footnote 49 The members brought back from the “seat of war” a selection of trophies and mementoes to exhibit in India. After these effects were cleared by the Customs House, “the Mission departed to Noor Bagh to strains of music” along “decorated streets”.Footnote 50 That evening it was the guest of Sir Fazalbhoy Currimbhoy Ebrahim, a Gujarati Khoja Ismaili businessman. Among the Mission's other social engagements while in Bombay was an evening party hosted by the Anjuman-i Islam, when “a very large number of people” could meet the members.Footnote 51 Ansari used the occasion to extoll the high character of the Turk as he had done throughout his despatches: “Among the Turkish people there was a feeling of fraternity that was hardly equalled in any other race. They were thoroughly patriotic”.Footnote 52 The Mission was scheduled to leave Bombay on 8 July by mail train, bound for its eventual destination, Delhi. As it made its onward journey, the Mission would be entertained by the Begum of Bhopal, and the Muslims of Lalitpur, Jhansi, Muttra, and Agra.Footnote 53
Comrade hoped that the Muslims of Delhi would give the Mission a befitting reception.Footnote 54 Preparations began as soon as the date of arrival was set. Delhi was “not only the place that claims Dr. Ansari as one of her eminent citizens, but the actual birth-place of the movement which took shape as the All-India Medical Mission [. . .] It was naturally expected, therefore, that Delhi's welcome would be an event as unique as her position”. There were doubts about whether this would be possible, however – Delhi, “in spite of her newly-conferred dignity, [was] still dominated by her past which broods over the lives and activities of the living as well as the mouldering [sic] remains of the dead”.Footnote 55 The journal described how “An ever present sense of her tragic history has created in her people a cynical disregard for the needs, the joys and the sorrows of the present”. This spectral existence was why Delhi “has rarely felt the new enthusiasms which render the lives of modern cities so absorbing and fruitful, and have made them the nerve-centres of the common life of the country”.Footnote 56 Indeed, far from behaving as the inhabitants of one of India's foremost cities, her most eminent sons often demonstrated a mental horizon as if they lived in “any out-of-the-way mofussil town”.Footnote 57 History, the urban and the emotional are rendered in a complex matrix here – precisely because of its overwhelming history, it was being suggested, Delhi was unable to register the emotional registers proper to a modern city of significance.
Comrade deliberately invoked the tropes of moribundity and lament that had saturated earlier literary reflections in order to, it seems, provide all the more greater contrast. For the reception that the city afforded the Mission in reality far exceeded its expectations. A detailed description began by noting that although the train carrying the members was to arrive in Delhi on 10 July at 5.30 pm, long before then large crowds of people had begun to assemble, packing every vantage point within the station to “utmost capacity”: “As the train moved slowly in, the air was rent with glad shouts of welcome. Thousands on the platform pressed forward to catch a glimpse of the man and his lieutenants. . . to kiss their hands and offer them flowers and garlands”.Footnote 58 The crowds could not be contained and it was only with great difficulty that Ansari and his party could find their way out to the carriage waiting for them. Then,
At last the procession moved, escorted by a body of mounted young Moslems, along the appointed route towards the Jam'i Masjid. The whole route was lined with spectators and thousands accompanied the procession all the way on foot. Dr Ansari's carriage, in spite of his protests, was dragged by enthusiastic admirers all the way to the mosque. Several Moslem merchants had decorated their shops along the route and had made arrangements for the distribution of iced sherbets and milk. The prosperous Moslem community of “Punjabi” merchants displayed great enthusiasm on the occasion, and spent a good deal in decorations and floral offerings and in dispensing lavish hospitality in sherbet and pan. The procession stopped at the front of the vast flights of stairs leading up to the eastern gate of the Jam'i Masjid.Footnote 59
At the mosque, Ansari was presented with a “beautiful casket” and made a “brief and gracious” speech.
As the party entered the vast courtyard of the mosque it was greeted with loud applause by the thousands of Moslems of Delhi, including hundreds from other places, who had gathered there on the occasion. It is difficult to give the exact number of people in the mosque and of the vast crowds that surged around it. But even according to a most conservative estimate they could not be much below thirty thousand.Footnote 60
The Mission members remained at the mosque until Maghrib prayers. A fine poem composed by the esteemed Maulana Shibli Numani (1857-1914) for the occasion was recited and “deeply moved the audience”.Footnote 61 Shibli had greeted the Mission's in Bombay too with a poem “singing the glory of Islam and praising the work of the Mission”, entitled ‘khair maqdam ānsārī’ (‘Welcome Ansari’), later printed in Hamdard.Footnote 62
After Maghrib prayers, the procession around the Mission formed again, as it started off along a different route for the Fatehpuri Masjid: “Even the oldest inhabitants of Delhi describe the night procession as a unique experience of their lives”. The entire route was “brilliantly illuminated”. The whole of Muslim Delhi seemed to have turned out for the occasion, and “Nothing but surging masses of humanity were visible in unbroken waves as far as the eye could reach in either direction”. This was visible testament for the swelling tides of change:
From the shops and the balconies and roofs of the houses rained incessant showers of flowers and garlands, and the air was laden with the fragrance of the rose-water that flowed from dainty flasks over the surface of the moving sea of men. Every now and then loud and irresistible voices called Dr Ansari to stand up and show himself, and he could not but obey the call.Footnote 63
Amidst such thrilling scenes, the long route through Delhi was traversed slowly until the procession reached its destination. Inside the Fatehpuri Mosque, ‘Isha prayers were offered, after which the exhausted party drove to Mohamed Ali's house for dinner.Footnote 64 For Comrade, the meaning of this dazzling, spontaneous spectacle was clear: “The mass of the Moslem population in Delhi is ignorant and poor, but its religious spirit is yet alive and its Islamic sympathies have not been smothered under the ruthless mutations of time”.Footnote 65 Evidently Delhi was no longer the city that harboured the mouldering remains of the dead.
Dr Ansari had shared a kind of trajectory with Mohamed Ali and Muhammad Iqbal by travelling to Britain for his education. For those who had experienced their own journey of departure and return thanks to the Mission to Turkey, such as Aligarh student Choudry Khaliquzzaman (1889-1973), Ali and Ansari now formed a hub of their own in Delhi, the epicentre of the Young Muhammadans, where the new political situation could be discussed.Footnote 66 The Mission's procession route was in this sense significant: following 1857, the ʿulama of the Jāma Masjid was largely politically quiescent; the Fatehpuri ʿulama were seen to be a little more unorthodox and politicised.Footnote 67 By encompassing both sites on the procession Mohamed Ali and other organisers created the impression that neither now truly represented Muslim Delhi. The outpouring of emotion, the iced sherbet and showers of rose water, demonstrated conclusively that the horizon had shifted for the old leaders, now “tragic historical curiosities”. Instead, “Men of different texture, endowed with a wholly different will and character, are needed”. With stirring words the paper announced, “Something new has come to claim the allegiance of the hearts of men, and its demand is insistent”.Footnote 68
Over the days and weeks to come, Comrade continued to publish testimonies of the noble service rendered by the Mission, including a letter sent by the President of the Ottoman municipality of Kale Sultanieh in the Dardanelles. A branch of the Mission had set up a hospital there that treated not only Ottoman soldiers, but “out-patients, men, women and children, without distinction of race or religion”, and “thousands of refugees”, all of whom it also fed and clothed on its own expense. When the Mission left the area, he wrote, “the military band was playing tunes of great pathos and feeling and [. . .] the notables of the city and spiritual leaders with thousands from amongst the population came to bid them farewell, which was very touching and full of love”.Footnote 69 Among other dignitaries present at the Mission's departure from Turkey was His Excellency Talat Paşa (a Young Turk leader and Minister of the Interior from 1913), who delivered a short speech about how moved he was by the great brotherly sympathy displayed by India's Muslims, before kissing and embracing the members of the Mission one by one.Footnote 70 Not to be outdone, Dr Ansari himself in his last letter as director, written on board the Sicilia, described the Mission's crowning moment – its formal presentation to the Sultan in Constantinople on 17 June 1913, the sumptuous dinner thrown in its honour by the Ottoman Red Crescent Society, and the touching farewell scene at the docks.Footnote 71
Cultivating affection
Suspicions have abounded about the motivations of Muslim newspaper editors, publicists, and political poets of this period. Were they simply reporting the news and the emotional state of the people, or were they in some very real way encouraging certain heightened emotional reactions to events? David Gilmartin speculated in the early 1990s, when Habermasian ‘public spheres’ and Andersonian ‘imagined communities’ were percolating through South Asian studies, that figures such as Zafar Ali Khan, editor of the Zamindar (Lahore) and a close associate of Mohamed Ali, were instrumental in transporting the emotion hitherto confined to Urdu poetry into a relatively more public, political forum through their newspapers – “the heart was made public” in part to create an avid readership for those self-same papers.Footnote 72 Spencer Lavan wondered four decades ago whether an incident in the town of Kanpur in 1913, triggered by the demolition of part of the Machli Bazar mosque, was rendered an “event of national proportions” partly because the “Muslim press” – papers such as Zamindar, Comrade and Hamdard, and Abul Kalam Azad's Al Hilal (Calcutta) – decided to devote so much hyperbolic attention to them, stirring up months of religious anxiety and anti-government sentiment.Footnote 73 The concern that something insincere lurked beneath Muslim public rhetoric in this period derives from a general scepticism of ‘political agitators’ in the historical scholarship, especially in the decades leading up to 1947. But, to borrow Margrit Pernau's observation in relation to one of the most successful Urdu authors of the pre-First World War period, feelings could be “strategically evoked and deeply felt at the same time”.Footnote 74 Nor, of course, was this dualism something novel or specific to north Indian print. While we might be thus wary of Comrade’s paeans to the emotional outbursts of Delhi's Muslims in 1912 and 1913, or extravagant testimonies of Ottoman-Indian fraternal feeling, it should be taken as fairly par for the course that politics and journalism deliberately cultivated emotional registers, often through idioms of religion and community.
Here it is instead the understanding of self and time undergirding the work of emotional cultivation that is of particular interest. If there was a crisis of experience afflicting the Muslim self in the early twentieth century, it was a crisis of which Mohamed Ali was cognisant. He wrote at length, for instance, on the mental torments of the “young Indian”, a product of modern education caught between the past and the future, trying but ever-failing to mentally grasp its vision of Utopia.Footnote 75 It was also a crisis that he was desirous of embracing for all its emancipatory possibilities. As mentioned, Comrade was deeply interested in the demise of Turkey as a world-historical event – as a moment of irrevocable rupture in the temporal fabric – not simply for its own sake, but because it signalled the potential of India's Muslims to realise a world historical role of their own in the epoch to come. There is nothing of a ‘restorative nostalgia’ to the Mission since this was a role that they had never hitherto played; the Mission was framed as “a unique achievement”.Footnote 76 Nor was there a prior moment of deep fraternal feeling between Ottomans and Indians that could be called to mind – Indian Muslim interest in the Caliphate itself was of relatively recent origins.Footnote 77 As the accounts of the return of the Mission suggested, “even the oldest inhabitants of Delhi” – presumably those who could remember the dying days of nominal Mughal rule – “describe the night procession as a unique experience of their lives”. The Mission and the emotions that surrounded it had no precedent; they were indeed intended to be augural, the “birth throes of a new era”. It is not simply the language of newness but specifically that of unprecedentedness that is important here – that is to say, a repeated acknowledgement of how little could be predicted of the future to come seems to suggest a particular openness to historical time.
In Boym's distinction, reflective nostalgia can be seen in contrast to restorative nostalgia as “concerned with historical and individual time, with the irrevocability of the past and human finitude. [. . .] The focus here is not on the recovery of what is perceived to be an absolute truth, but on the meditation on history and the passage of time”.Footnote 78 Reflective nostalgia as a historical emotion is not anti-modern but rather coeval with modernity – it is properly its emotional counterpart.Footnote 79 It has prospective potentialities.Footnote 80 This does not mean it is necessarily always forward looking; it might also look sideways, stifled by conventional confines of space and time.Footnote 81 But while a return ‘home’ was the traditional cure for the malady of nostalgia, for the ‘off-modernists’ a ‘homecoming’ is perpetually deferred, an impossibility, for there is no mythical lost home to return to; the home is in ruins or has been transformed beyond recognition:Footnote 82 “It is precisely this defamiliarisation and sense of distance that drives them to tell their story, to narrate the relationship between past, present, and future”.Footnote 83
As well as the Mission, other contemporaneous efforts undertaken by Mohamed Ali, with the help of Dr Ansari and Comrade, demonstrate how pertinent this distinction of nostalgia that does not look backwards is in this context. Among the litany of proposed schemes – exchanges of newspapers, teachers, embassies, a joint Indo-Turkish steamship company to transport pilgrims and so forthFootnote 84 – two projects are striking for their personal and almost sentimental appeal. The first, a small-scale effort, was Mohamed Ali's arrangement to have several orphans of the (First) Balkan War brought to India. Dr Ansari wrote in his final letter as Mission director that he had selected ten children – six boys and four girls, aged between six and nine years – but had been unable to bring them with him on the Sicilia as final permission from the chief of the municipality was still wanting. These orphans of war had been left with the Mission's manager, and they would come to India in a week or two, accompanied by two accomplished Turkish ladies, the widow and the daughter of a Turkish officer. “As arranged with you, the ladies’ services will be utilised as teachers in your family or in a girls’ school”.Footnote 85 If this demonstrated a desire by Mohamed Ali to bring living representations of the new Ottoman-Indian sympathy to India, a second more ambitious scheme demonstrated how far India itself might lay its mark in the world.
In 1913, as the Medical Mission pondered its departure from Turkey, efforts were made to form an ‘Indo-Ottoman Colonisation Society’, which would seek to establish a colony at Adana in southern Anatolia where Muslim refugees from the Balkans could be relocated.Footnote 86 The journal described in horrified terms the ‘war of extermination’ against Muslims in European Turkey; the responsibility for these people would “lie at the door of every Moslem throughout the world who has a crust of bread and did not share it with his brother the Turk”.Footnote 87 Although Muslims had sent money, nothing had been done for the future needs of refugees fleeing from “the mouth of hell”, the paper decried. After writing to ask what could be done for the “permanent relief” of war victims, Ansari had cabled Mohamed Ali in December 1912 to say that he intended to start work on a Model Colony of two hundred families in Anatolia, for which the Ottoman Government was granting land. In May 1913, as the Mission prepared to return home, Ansari wrote to say this would induce half a dozen of the Mission's members to stay on in Turkey and take a practical part in building the colony.Footnote 88 It is important to clarify, since there has been confusion in the historiography, that the organisers were in no way advocating resettlement of Muslims from IndiaFootnote 89 – after all, this was to be a demonstration of India's Muslims stepping into the breach caused by Turkey falling out of history's favour.
The utopian idealism of the colony has been a largely untold story within histories of this period. The estimated cost of four and a half lakh rupees, or £30,000, to build the colony was it seems to be met entirely by Indian Muslims.Footnote 90 Mohamed Ali naturally helped lead the call to raise funds. Comrade sent £3,000 (Rs. 45,000), left over from the Turkish Relief Fund, at the outset and indeed the first two colonies were to be named after Comrade and Zamindar.Footnote 91 A commission that toured Anatolia and Adana looking for a suitable place to locate the colonies consisted of Zafar Ali Khan and Ansari as representatives of India, but also experts on agriculture, on medicine and sanitation matters, and on town planning.Footnote 92 And indeed the nizamname (regulation) issued by the Turkish Government for the Colonisation Society stipulated among other things that each village to be established had to be in a suitable climate, near neither marshes or ponds, to be constructed around two large paved boulevards at least 15 metres wide that would run from north to south and east to west through the town, have a large five or six-acre central square at the intersection where there ought to be a mosque, school, and a recreational garden, have adequate water supply or wells, and be close to communication lines. Every house had to be located in the middle of at least an acre of land, streets were to run parallel to each other, and separate lands at a distance from the village had to be reserved for barns, cattle grazing, and a cemetery.Footnote 93
Such guidance suggests that these were clearly colonies planned with a future of plenitude and continued Indo-Turkish cooperation in mind. For Ansari, Adana was a particularly viable site for the colony for it was already the model of progressiveness and fertility – it “could give many lessons to the most up to date agricultural district in India”.Footnote 94 By implication to locate the refugee colony there would be to induct it immediately into a well-functioning, modern and technocratic way of agrarian life. Ansari was surely making implicit reference to the canal colonies of Punjab, a hyper-modern exercise in environmental and social engineering in British India; less clear, however, is the extent to which Ansari was cognisant of a much more proximate parallel – the successful agricultural colonies of Jewish settlers (themselves in many cases refugees from Europe) in the Ottoman Empire, particularly in Anatolia.Footnote 95
For Comrade, which ironically claimed that this scheme would not suffer the “utopian [. . .] idealism” of a similar scheme led by the Ottoman statesman (and later Grand Vizier) Damad Ferid Paşa, the project was not as much about the numbers of people helped as the symbolism of the effort.Footnote 96 Whereas the Mission was “ephemeral”, this would be a “permanent colony of the refugees of European Turkey, established in the heart of Anatolia, entirely at the expense of Indian Mussalmans”. Even though it could only “touch the fringe” of the refugee problem, this was a way of claiming others’ futures:
So long as a single descendent of the thousand refugees in the Moslem Indian Colony of Anatolia lives and breathes he will feel that practically all that he and his family possesses in the world they owe to the fraternal feeling of Indian Mussalmans, and [. . .] every addition to its members will be a link added to the chain of good feeling and brotherliness that binds the Mussalmans of Turkey with the Mussalmans of India.Footnote 97
Comrade imagined a future in which every Muslim country in the world would establish such a colony in Asia Minor, and Muslims from those countries would visit ‘their’ colony to see the good they were doing. The dwellers within these colonies would act as living testament to the affection of others, so much so that they would relinquish their own names – refugee names – in preference for that of their guardians. If an entire town in India were to decide to take part in this noble work, a house in the colony might bear an inscription with that town's name, and the refugee family might adopt the name of that town. Bigger cities such as Lahore and Bombay might lend their names to roads and lanes, and the families dwelling therein might take on the name of individual mohallas that had contributed substantial sums. Mohamed Ali wished the part built with Comrade funds to be called ‘Aligarh’, and suggested the families therein could take the names of the honorary secretaries of the college and its chief benefactors and workers, thus linking up “the greatest constructive work of Moslem India with a no less noble if more modest constructive work in Turkey”.Footnote 98 The colonies, it was thus imagined, would become annexes of India. They would serve as both ongoing demonstration of Indian generosity and as permanent monuments to the vast strides forward that had already been made by the Muslims of that part of the world.
It is difficult to say what would have come of the Colonisation Society and other such Indian schemes if the First World War had not brought about a complete disruption. We can suggest, however, that for Mohamed Ali, these schemes were in part an exercise in articulating the relationship between the Muslims of India, and the rest of the Islamic world. ‘Pan-Islamic’ projects that seemed redolent with nostalgia for imperial Islamic rule appear on closer inspection to have been deeply concerned with engendering and governing certain forms of emotional ties that were far from melancholic. Spatiality was important. In Mohamed Ali's imagination, Delhi specifically and India in general, would become the centre and beating heart of Islam, with a “radiating influence”.
In 1912, in an essay called ‘The Future of Islam’, Mohamed Ali had commented that where once Sayyid Ahmad Khan, in the wake of 1857, might have contemplated refuge in Egypt, no Indian Muslim would today consider retirement to Turkey, for “the proper place of an Indian Mussalman” is “in India itself”. There was now for the Muslim in India “a hopeful and a progressive future”. They had no need to “import Enver Beys” (referring to Young Turk military leader and Minister of War from 1913, Enver Paşa); indeed, they might yet realise Sayyid Ahmad's vision to send “missionaries of progress” to backward Muslim states.Footnote 99 The schemes discussed and pursued in 1913 demonstrate attempts to put this vision into effect and thereby settle any lingering doubt about the “proper place of an Indian Mussalman”. Although the tone is altogether more despairing than triumphant, a similar settlement is reached in a poem by Shibli Numani published in 1912:
O Shibli! Where are we (Muslims) to go even if we leave our countries,
For now how long will (peace and) security last in Syria, Nejd and Qirwan?Footnote 100
Finally, a place of no return
If the refugee colonies were to be testament to Indian Muslim benevolence, another organisational effort displayed a more militant spirit. The prospect that the Turks would fail to protect the holiest sites of Islam from Western aggression was an ever-present concern in the Muslim press in India in this period. Many commentators took a critical line, blaming the Turks’ irreligiousness or haughty attitude towards Arab sentiment in the Hijaz for this impending fate. But Mohamed Ali's newspapers took a much more sympathetic line. The Turk, “who [had] for centuries stood as [their] sentinel at the Kaaba”, was weaker today than he had ever been and had “to guard his own hearth” now; “Musalmans who are numbered amongst the subject races” must therefore take over his responsibilities by protecting the harāmain (the noble sanctuaries of Mecca and Medina) in Arabia. Those who had watched the tragedy of Turkey in Europe, Persia, and the Muslim kingdoms of Africa “cannot now find the same comfort in their past achievements or present temporal power when they are minded to think of the future of their sacred places”.Footnote 101 Nostalgia was a luxury, inexpedient to the present times.
A desire to intercede in the fate of Arabia led to the creation of the Anjuman-i Khuddām-i Kaʿba (‘Society of the Servants of the Kaʿba’), founded by Mohamed Ali and his brother Shaukat Ali (1873-1938), along with their spiritual preceptor Maulana ʿAbd al-Bari (1878-1926) of the Firangi Mahal seminary in Lucknow and the barrister Mushir Hussain Qidwai (1878-1937). The Anjuman gathered thousands of subscribers before the First World War and spawned many local branches in India and abroad; it enlisted, apparently, legions of men in India as oath-bound devotees who were ready at a moment's notice to go to the defence of the Kaʿba, “the very first centre of unity in the world”.Footnote 102 Initial plans even spoke of potentially supplying aeroplanes and dreadnoughts. This, again, was to be India's Muslims stepping into the breach – here, moreover, they would be securing a sacred geography for Islam. It was not entirely conceptually resolved in the 1910s and 1920s to what degree the Caliph was regarded as an object of veneration by Muslims because of his position as the guardian of the holy places and thus whether any such guardian would be similarly entitled to be called Caliph; the implications of this Indian scheme were potentially unsettling enough that Mohamed and Shaukat Ali took great pains to emphasise in a letter to Talat Paşa in July 1914 that the Anjuman, in positing itself as the khādim of the harāmain, was not thus vying for the governance of the harāmain.Footnote 103
The vigorous denial of any ulterior motives underscores just how unprecedented it was to think about the relationship between India's Muslims and the traditional heartlands of Islam on such terms. To do so was not simply to reconceive the geographic relationality of the Muslim world, but also to reverse the direction in which history flowed. Arabia, and the sacred cities in particular, were the birthplace of Islam; from there it had spread far and wide. It had had numerous worldly governors over the years, most recently the Ottomans, but never had it fallen under non-Muslim rule. Now it seemed, that land was incapable of being defended and Muslims from distant lands – where Islam was comparatively younger and more vigorous – were minded to return to where they had never been, in order to protect it. To go to Arabia would not be a ‘homecoming’ but an altogether new chapter.
A striking articulation of this is found in a commentary Mohamed Ali offered of Muhammad Iqbal's famous poem, Shikwā (‘Complaint’) (1911). Having surveyed Iqbal's lament against God, Ali surmised (astutely, as it happens) that Iqbal was not actually saying that God had forsaken Muslims as some thought. Rather Iqbal's complaint was that Muslims themselves had lost their way. Ali wrote:
The full realisation of the ideal of Islam is in the womb of futurity; but the history of that Golden Age of Islam [. . .] has shown to every subsequent generation of Mussalmans a glimpse of human perfection which went far to convince it that the ideal of Islam is not unattainable.Footnote 104
This was in some ways an astonishingly bold statement, for contrary to much prevailing orthodoxy, Mohamed Ali was stating that the “full realisation of the ideal of Islam” had never existed, even during the Golden Age, that is, the time of the first four Caliphs, the Rāshidun. He was thus referring, implicitly, to an as-yet-unrealised future political and social order. Though the past, and particularly the spirit of the early Muslims, could be an inspiration then, it could be no guide. There was nothing to return to, temporally speaking, because whatever the telos of Islam was, it lay dormant and unknown within ‘the womb of futurity’. It bears re-stating here how unlike a ‘restorative nostalgia’ this reads.
Moreover, Iqbal's poem and Mohamed Ali's commentary on it appear to demonstrate that critical potentiality of melancholy discussed earlier; for one thing, they were able to distinguish between a thing lost and a thing lacking, which should be understood as quite different objects of melancholy.Footnote 105 A certain spirit of onward historical progress had been forgotten but neither men were melancholic for a lost period of ideals, because that, they claimed, had never been realised. Elsewhere, Comrade intoned, “the things that once have been can never be again. History never repeats itself [. . .] The moving finger writes and, having writ, moves on”.Footnote 106 In Jawāb-i Shikwā (‘Answer to the Complaint’) (1913), Iqbal had God promise the plaintive Muslim that if he stayed faithful to the last prophet, he would recover his ability to shape futures: “To write the world's history pen and tablet we offer you”.Footnote 107 Demonstrating the extent to which such reflections on history and time were about India as much as they were about Islam, Mohamed Ali wrote:
The illusions of the nations that are alive with hope and vitality are about the future; and this makes all difference. India wants no “re-formers” but revolutionaries who would release the heart and the mind of the people from the thraldom of the dead past and turn them confidently ahead.Footnote 108
Ali and Iqbal recognised, perhaps, a truism elucidated by Dipesh Chakrabarty, that the present moment is necessarily already the future of the past. “All our pasts are therefore futural in orientation. . . There is, in this sense, no ‘desire for going back’, no ‘pathological’ nostalgia that is also not futural as well”.Footnote 109 Iqbal's belief that movement was the central principle in the structure of Islam – and the reason why Islam retained a latent dynamism despite its manifest struggles – has been well documented.Footnote 110 Less appreciated, however, is how through devoted readers and interlocutors such as Mohamed Ali this idea had a wider resonance and was able to take more distinctly political and embodied forms in the early twentieth century.Footnote 111
For Boym, the nostalgic is never a native, but rather “a displaced person who mediates between the local and the universal”, a person for whom “home” is in ruins.Footnote 112 Figures such as Mohamed Ali were not displaced by geography as much as by a certain kind of historical understanding. During a period of frenetic activity in the early 1910s, against the backdrop of the demise of the Ottoman Empire, he used the world beyond India to define both a Muslim sense of belonging in a particular space, but also to think about the Muslim's place in a particular time. He concluded that the Muslims of India, while they could and should render valuable service to the world, had nowhere else for which to yearn; they were already home and perfectly present. These are not, perhaps, the conclusions to be expected from a study into retrograde ‘pan-Islamic’ political activities. But that unexpectedness is perhaps precisely why we should conclude that if the trope of nostalgia is to have any analytical value in the history of India's Muslim, it must be thought of as an expansive nostalgia that contained within it vast spatial and temporal potentialities.
