The great merit of this first English-language biography of Charles Dupin is to draw renewed attention to the importance of this key player in the formation of nineteenth-century science. Born before the French Revolution, in 1784, Dupin was one of the first polytechniciens, taken straight from his studies under Monge to Boulogne to design barges for the invasion of England. After Trafalgar he was sent to the newly conquered Greek islands to help found the Ionian Academy, where he honed his rhetoric of science. In the aftermath of the restauration, he courageously wrote the éloge for Monge and would be a pioneer of the reformed Conservatoire des arts et métiers (CNAM). Almost reaching the advanced age of ninety years, he died as a baron in the aftermath of the Franco-Prussian war. He had been a radical and a supporter of British ways, a mathematician, engineer, promoter of statistics and politician. Above all, he had been an influential, if maverick, ideologist of science, industry and modernity. Anybody interested in the construction of nineteenth-century images of the relations between science, practice and the state should pay heed to Dupin.
For a century after his death in 1873 he was overlooked by historians of science, but his contribution was recovered as part of an English commemoration. It is now four decades since Robert Fox, in an article for Donald Cardwell's 1974 volume celebrating the foundation of Manchester University's ancestor, the Mechanics’ Institute in Manchester, first drew attention to Dupin. CNAM had been France's pioneering institution in adult science education. Having been founded during the French Revolution, Robert Fox showed how, in the aftermath of Napoleon's fall, it was captured from the protagonists of craft by a younger generation of protagonists for the application of science, led by Dupin. Perhaps surprising at first, the context of Robert Fox's paper was exactly appropriate, for Dupin was both a significant observer of the British industrial revolution centred on Manchester, and an important influence upon it. Having watched enthusiastically the teaching of Andrew Ure in Glasgow, he was the most active proponent of science appliqué aux arts, memorialized in the 1819 revised charter of CNAM, and translated into English as ‘science applied to the arts’.
A decade after the publication of Robert Fox's paper, the life of Dupin was the subject of a doctorat d’état, bound in seven, albeit slim, volumes of typescript, by intellectual-property specialist Fernand Perrin, under the supervision of René Taton. The typescript is available in such French academic libraries as that of CNAM itself, but, neither in its content nor in its accessibility did it do justice to its topic. Robert Fox's important paper was reprinted in French two decades later in a volume (edited by Carole Christen-Lécuyer, François Vatin and Robert Fox and published in 2009) that came out of a 2007 Paris symposium, the first systematic attempt to explore the significance of Dupin. That volume still provides the outstanding contextualization of the work and life of Dupin. It did not claim to be a biographical treatment but rather, as the introduction explained, an interpretation of the complex scientific, technological, social and political debates in which Dupin took a leading part. Two papers presented at the symposium were published elsewhere. One was by Ivor Grattan-Guinness, the other by his former doctoral student Margaret Bradley in collaboration with Fernand Perrin.
This volume testifies to the influence of Perrin, with whom it had been intended to be co-authored, and who – though he died before that was possible – made his research material available to Margaret Bradley. It draws on many letters scattered across archives, whose discovery testifies to long years of laborious work. Rather than the long view and the perspectival shots of the symposium a few years ago, this is, above all, built upon the detailed study of Dupin's life conducted by Perrin and Bradley. In an article published in 1991 in Technology and Culture, these two scholars had looked at Dupin's visits to Britain in the early post-Napoleonic years. As its title suggests, this volume focuses almost exclusively on Dupin within the French context. That is a limitation on our understanding of a man who played on his liminal role and whose correspondence, cited in a speech by Dionysus Lardner in 1835, was widely reported in provincial English newspapers, and was so well known across the Channel that he was even satirized in a Times leader.
The book is organized in eighteen biographically serial chapters. The first ten chapters, covering roughly one-half of the volume, deal with the years of Dupin's early life, his studies, his assignment to Corfu and his two visits to Britain. A short intermediary chapter cites a historical review highlighting the role of Dupin in the reform of CNAM but, regrettably, does not go beyond it, or its secondary sources. The second half of the book deals largely with his career as teacher, economist and baron, as Dupin became more established in the decades of the 1820s to the 1840s. Very little space is accorded to his role as leader of the French delegation to the 1851 Great Exhibition, or indeed to the final two decades of his life.
Students regrettably might find the volume rather dense in its information; oddly written as well, as if in places it was translated from the French; and perhaps too liberally sprinkled with extensive quotations from secondary sources. For those willing to overcome such minor hurdles, the book is, however, a most valuable resource. It provides invaluable biographical context for any scholar delving more deeply into particular intellectual and ideological studies of the period in which they come across an intervention of Dupin's or reference to this baron, hitherto ignored by historians, but of whom the Times warned its readers in a leader on 12 October 1839,
Besides this baggage of crosses, dignities, chairs, offices, diplomas, mantles, ribands, swords, Perryan pens, galloons, uniforms, bank-bills, money-bags, and trinkets of all sorts, with which M. Charles Dupin goes enwrapped, decorated, loaded, and encumbered, and which are dangling and draggling from every part, he has his books, his manuals, his maps, his plans, his manuscripts, his projects for bringing the sea to Paris where it is to appear neither more nor less than it does at the Havre, and his studies on Demosthenes, who, by the way, was not the most long-winded of orators.
