Muriel Lightbourne's book concerns itself with issues of agriculture and what she terms “food security”, which I understand to be not only the reliable provision of food but also ensuring that this food is nutritious. The title mentions intellectual property and biotechnology and, indeed, there are passing references to both topics. However, the book in substance mostly concerns itself with international treaties on biodiversity and seed exchanges, with a few other topics (such as collective action theory, patent law, and the history of the “Green Revolution”) thrown in. Intellectual property takes the form of the UPOV (International Union for the Protection of New Varieties of Plants) Treaty on the protection of plant varieties, but national variants and implementations are largely not dealt with.
The first chapter provides a background to the science and history of agriculture, sets out the characteristics of the agricultural market, particularly those concerned with biotechnology, and gives an unfortunately extremely short discussion of the patent law of Japan, the EU, and the US as they apply to agriculture (this was a lost opportunity). The science section is interesting, but has a jumbled structure. The two other sections are brief but useful. The history of the Green Revolution in the first chapter is very useful but highlights a certain lack of connection between the book's concerns and the level of abstraction at which it deals with the applicable legal framework.
The second chapter, like the rest of the book, is disorganized in its structure, with a long discussion of genetic erosion and conservation with genetic resources, but with insufficient clarification of how this relates to hunger and malnutrition, the purported focus of this chapter.
The third chapter includes an imperfect discussion of collective-action theory—which needs to be reconsidered in future editions—and considers benefit-sharing arrangements between developed and developing countries for the use of biological resources. Very problematically, the author does not touch on this massive problem: since such benefit-sharing would take place between countries’ governments and between developed and developing countries’ companies, it is hard to see that anyone else, particularly the developing countries’ citizens, will see any such benefit.
The fourth chapter provides general remarks on the FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization) International Treaty on Plant Genetic Resources.
The fifth chapter is very useful and provides case-studies of the seed markets in China and Ethiopia. If case-law from the sample countries and other empirical data were added, this chapter would be much improved.
I did not have a wonderful experience with this book. I should caution that, like anyone, I have my particular tastes when it comes to legal writing. For writing that addresses social issues, I most desire a clear grasp of the policy issues at hand and a very practical, ideally empirical study of how the law plays a part in this. For an exegesis of the law applicable, I'm usually happy with a summary with a reference to texts that focus on setting out the law. What the author offers is something closer to the writing style in Civil Law countries: much of the text rephrases the law, case-law that is, the analysis remains at a high level of abstraction, and case-law and other examples of practical applications are, like salt, sprinkled sparingly.
This area of the law being so underserved, this book has a place in it, qualified by the comments above. Nevertheless, it may be helpful for the author to restructure a second edition as a “Cases and Materials” text, which might be the best way to present the book.
