To the degree that this work addresses the history of a “community,” it is more in the sense that sociologist Georg Simmel posited in Conflict/The Web of Group Affiliations than it is any sense of communal harmony. Communities are bound by the general agreement on the rules by which conflict is carried out (and maybe resolved). Indeed, the climax of Martin Dusinberre's rich story is one of sharp conflict that continues to this day, a donnybrook over the siting of a nuclear power plant in Kaminoseki, a small town on the Inland Sea at the southern tip of Japan's main island, Honshu. By the end of this very human and humanely told story, the explicit vision of what constitutes residents’ sense or “community” is itself the object of bitter debate, currently over the nuclear plant, but (the author contends) reflecting long divisions within the residents of the historic rural settlements that today are bound into the single administrative unit that is modern Kaminoseki. Hard Times argues that throughout the eras of its focus, largely the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, political and economic elites in the Kaminoseki era struggled to bring wealth to themselves and grow their local economies. Shifts in how individuals and families pursued those dreams changed over time—from seeking by-employments, opportunities to improve fishing, and other activities in the early nineteenth century, to adapting to the needs of steam powered vessels and later, the capital demands associated with new forms of power such as oil (e.g., large tankers). These efforts, like nuclear power in the late twentieth century, had their competitive and somewhat divisive impacts, yet the pursuit of these opportunities from the reestablishment of Japan-European trade (1858 witnessed the first commercial treaty) on bound Kaminoseki communities to the wider worlds of Japanese politics, Western expansion, and global transformations of trade and production. Local populations moved, and not just domestically. Some residents journeyed to the United States, and others to Manchuria, linking this district to broad international currents, connections that became important sources of funding for local projects in the prewar years. In the postwar era, these efforts at adaptation and struggles ultimately failed in significant ways, marked by a local population decline that is widespread throughout smaller Japanese towns and cities today.
To marshal evidence for both historical analysis and the individual stories that bolster his argument, the author draws on a broad array of sources. Like many rural areas of Japan, local historical materials dating back to the eighteenth century and even earlier are abundant. The mid-nineteenth century brought newspapers, population registers, and government reports, all of which Dusinberre judiciously exploits.
Yet the standard historical data, no matter how effectively employed, could not have led to the nuanced and sensitive treatment Dusinberre provides absent two critical sources of information: extensive personal interviews and spending lots of time, feet on the ground, walking, driving, and exploring Kaminoseki. Detailed knowledge of the local physical, economic, political, and cultural geography facilitates understanding of different opportunities and fault lines of the region as well as the author's understanding of the symbolic and emotional meanings of local geography. Interview subjects not only provide enriching detail but suggest processes operating that are hard, if not impossible to tease out of written sources and photographs. The role of schmoozing as a way to grease the process of moving Kaminoseki in one direction or another, and the associated role of “study” tours are cases in point. While those highly positivistic in their thinking may balk at the suggestion that important political work was accomplished in such contexts or that an interview subject's suspicion that the informal workings behind the scene constitute sufficient evidence for explanation, those familiar with the contemporary role of “wet” socializing Japan's bars will find this evidence more persuasive.
While there is a great deal of interest in this work, readers who like a clipped and forceful argument should be prepared to exercise a bit of patience; even for people who lack that predisposition may find the (necessary) resort to quick references to individuals and families with unfamiliar names taxing. There were a bit too many forward references to later chapters for my taste, and it was not always clear to me initially how developments and relationships described early in the work were going to play out. Some graphic summary of elite persistence and transformation might have helped emphasis the important continuity of this group, and other graphics showing elite involvement in various manifestations of civil society would have reinforced a sense of how they both built and exercised their influence. Yet even without these aids, the evidence is there for readers to appreciate.
Patience in working through the early chapters is rewarded in the end. The various threads from early analyses are pulled together in the final three chapters in an analysis of dispute over “inviting” a nuclear power plant into the neighborhood. The analysis here both builds on and reinforces the arguments for the informal local power of networks made in earlier chapters.
Dusinberre's research focus is a region not often represented in English-language literature. Indeed, much work, both premodern and modern tends to focus on national trends and developments, or large urban areas (principally Tokyo, Kyoto, and Osaka) that are, in common judgment, important in and of themselves. Even in Japan, public opinion surveys of taste, moral judgment, and the like tend to simply only Tokyo residents. The end result is a very flat and unrealistic image of Japanese society marching in lock-step (older readers will recall the popular media image of a well-oiled “Japan Inc.”) While national means and medians are important, so too are variations around and from them. To the degree that we are not exposed to the diversity of Japanese society and its history, we are condemned to fail in efforts to analyze and understand them. In this alone, in helping readers understand the variety of experience and diversity of Japan and its history, this is a welcome contribution, one that testifies to the survival of ingenuity and initiative even in “group-conscious” Japan.
