Stefan Winter's study of the Lebanese Shiʿa who inhabited the regions of Jabal ʿAmil and Baalbek during the 17th and 18th centuries fills an important gap in the history of Ottoman Arab Shiʿa. The primary concern of this study is to explore the sociopolitical and economic aspects of Shiʿi political leadership and the relationship of these leaders to the Ottoman state. More specifically, it elucidates the historical circumstances and processes shaping the rise and fall of Shiʿi muqataʿjis of notable families such as the Hamadas and the Harfushes, who were appointed by the Ottoman state to police and tax the rural districts of Sidon, Tripoli, and Damascus and bring them under the fold of state authority. Winter highlights the shifts in the position and functions of the Hamada and Harfush leaders and the Ottomans’ approaches to them, first as state agents and second as Shiʿa. He discusses how these leaders were co-opted by the Sunni Ottomans during the 16th century and then how their power declined and became decisively impaired under the Ottomans during the late 18th century, leading eventually to the political marginalization of the Shiʿi community.
Winter draws upon on an impressive array of Ottoman, Turkish, Arabic, and French sources, compensating for the meager official archival sources on Ottoman rule in Jabal ʿAmil during the 16th century by turning to chronicles, biographical dictionaries, legal documents, and travel accounts. In this respect his work draws critical links between legal texts and state politics and is able to trace the changing conditions and developments in the sultans’ policies. Winter tries to provide a more nuanced account of the relationship between various Shiʿi groups and the Ottoman state. In this area, he goes against a number of earlier works that stressed either the systematic persecution of the Shiʿa throughout the Ottoman period on the basis of religious doctrine or the normative “Islamic” status and favorable conditions that the Ottomans extended to the Shiʿa. Instead, Winter illuminates the official legal designation of Shiʿa as rāfiḍīs (heretics), who are deemed a threat to Ottoman interests, but distinguishes the Ottomans’ approaches to different Shiʿi figures and groups based on political expediency. He argues that the legal designation of the Shiʿa as rāfiḍīs allowed the Ottoman state to legitimize its persecution and suppression of several Shiʿi and heterodox groups regarded as a threat to the empire's integrity and security. At the same time, Winter elucidates the particular historical circumstances, such as the military and political conflict with the Safavids and state centralization, that transformed a discourse on heresy (rafḍ) into political practice. He notes, for instance, the increase in the number of anti-Shiʿi fatwās issued by the Ottoman jurist Ebu-Suʿud (d. 984) at the peak of the struggle between the Safavids and the Ottomans. Winter's use of the term “pragmatic” to describe Ottoman policies, however, may not cohere with the rich picture he draws of the relationship between practice and the structural basis for marginalizing the Shiʿa. The state may have decided at times to forcefully move or execute certain groups even when one can argue that accommodation may have been more “pragmatic.”
Winter offers an insightful look into the conditions of Shiʿi feudal leaders, which is also useful for scholars dealing with the transitions as well as continuities between the political arrangements of late Ottoman society and Grand Liban under the French Mandate (1920–43). Winter shows how the Shiʿi provincial leaders, in comparison to their Druze and Maronite counterparts in Mount Lebanon, experienced a decisive setback during the late 18th century. The increasing autonomy of the Druze emirates in Mount Lebanon under the Ottomans, Winter suggests, was achieved precisely through the elimination of the Shiʿi emirates of the Hamadas and the Harfushes. The Shiʿi leaders and notables who emerged during the 19th century were unable to achieve the power or economic dominance which these emirates enjoyed. Consequently, the French were under little pressure to accommodate Shiʿi economic and political demands.
Lucid and thoroughly researched, The Shiites of Lebanon under Ottoman Rule is an impressive work that invites new research and inquiries into comparable Shiʿi communities under Ottoman rule.
