Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T22:44:22.991Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Wuchiapingian (Lopingian, late Permian) brachiopod fauna from Guangdong Province, southeastern China: systematics and contribution to the Lopingian recovery

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 October 2022

Huiting Wu
Affiliation:
School of Geoscience and Surveying Engineering, China University of Mining and Technology (Beijing), Beijing, China <1910290526@student.cumtb.edu.cn>
Yang Zhang*
Affiliation:
School of Earth Sciences and Resources, China University of Geosciences, Beijing, China
Thomas L. Stubbs
Affiliation:
School of Earth Sciences, University of Bristol, Bristol, UK
Anfeng Chen
Affiliation:
School of Earth Sciences and Resources, China University of Geosciences, Beijing, China
Pengcheng Zhai
Affiliation:
School of Geoscience and Surveying Engineering, China University of Mining and Technology (Beijing), Beijing, China <1910290526@student.cumtb.edu.cn>
Yuanlin Sun
Affiliation:
School of Earth and Space Sciences, Peking University, Beijing, China
*
*Corresponding author.

Abstract

A diverse Wuchiapingian brachiopod fauna, which contains 57 species in 28 genera, is described from the Shuizhutang Formation at the Liannan section, Guangdong province, southeastern China. Four new species Tyloplecta liannanensis n. sp., Linoproductus huananensis n. sp., Araxathyris minor n. sp., and Permophricodothyris flata n. sp. are proposed. From well-preserved Liannan specimens, characteristics of the shell microstructures in Permianella are revised, and different morphologies of muscle scars in Permophricodothyris are distinctly shown. Until now, only several Wuchiapingian brachiopod faunas have been found in South China. Compared with these faunas, the Liannan fauna shows much higher α diversity and is more like faunas from southeastern China than those from the Yangtze area in faunal composition. The Liannan fauna is dominated with Neochonetes, Transennatia, Orthothetina, Permophricodothyris, and Cathaysia, which are normally larger and more strongly ornamented than their Changhsingian counterparts. The Wuchiapingian brachiopods in South China are represented mainly by the Douling fauna and Shuizhutang fauna. The Douling fauna has relatively low diversity and presents the survival stage after the Guadalupian–Lopingian boundary crisis. The Shuizhutang fauna has a much higher diversity and more key Changhsingian taxa and shows a rapid radiation stage. Faunal compositions of the two faunas indicate that the initial recovery of brachiopods occurred mainly at the genus level followed by a more rapid radiation at both genus and species levels.

UUID: http://zoobank.org/474cd988-6ec3-4d16-b045-f84d5fe3fb66

Information

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of The Paleontological Society
Figure 0

Figure 1.Location of the Liannan section, northern Guangdong Province, southeastern China.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Paleogeographical map of South China during Wuchiapingian (from Feng et al., 1997), showing the location of the Liannan section as well as the sites of the Yansha, Xiaoyuanchong, and Daijiagou sections also referred to in this paper.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Distribution of brachiopods from the Shuizhutang Formation at the Liannan section.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Q-mode cluster analysis of species abundance data using unweighted paired group algorithm and the Raup–Crick index.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Faunal composition of the Douling fauna and the Shuizhutang fauna. Yellow words represent their shared families. Blue-gray words represent their shared species. Red words represent Changhsingian key taxa.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Brachiopods from the Shuizhutang Formation. (1) Lingularia sp., a ventral valve, LN191001. (2–9, 26, 27) Fusichonetes soochowensis (Chao, 1928): (2–6, 9) external molds of dorsal valves: (2) LN221803, (3) LN223301, (4) LN223402, (5) LN223601, (6) LN216601, (9) LN221701; (7, 8, 26, 27) internal molds of ventral valves: (7) LN001801, (8) LN221301, (26) LN001401, (27) LN001701. (10–14) F. quadrata (Zhan in Hou et al., 1979): (10–12, 14) external molds of dorsal valves: (10) LN188903, (11) LN222301, (12) LN222703, (14) LN223703; (13) an internal mold of a ventral valve, LN222802. (15–17) F. flatus (Shen and Archbold, 2002), external molds of dorsal valves: (15) LN002603, (16) LN221102, (17) LN222003. (18–21) Neochonetes (Huangichonetes) substrophomenoides: (18–20) internal molds of ventral valves: (18) LN001201, (19) LN002403, (20) LN216503; (21) dorsal interior, LN220503. (22–25) N. (Sommeriella) strophomenoides Waagen, 1884: (22–24) internal molds of ventral valves: (22) LN003403, (23) LN218003, (24) LN219901; (25) an internal mold of a dorsal valve, LN220303. Scale bars = 3 mm.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Brachiopods from the Shuizhutang Formation. (1–6) N. (Zhongyingia) transversa Zhang et al., 2015: (1, 3–5) internal molds of ventral valves: (1) LN217101, (3) LN000501, (4) LN002001, (5) LN217801; (2) an external mold of a dorsal valve, LN216301; (6) an internal mold of a dorsal valve, LN217401. (7–10) N. (Z.) zhongyingensis Liao, 1980: (7, 8) external molds of dorsal valves: (7) LN217703, (8) LN218301; (9) an internal mold of a ventral valve, LN218501; (10) an internal mold of a dorsal valve, LN218601. (11–15) Cathaysia chonetoides: (11, 12, 14, 15) internal molds of ventral valves: (11) LN200402, (12) LN183703, (14) LN197803, (15) LN198403; (13) an external mold of a dorsal valve, LN195502. (16–19) C. parvulia Chang in Yang, 1977, internal molds of ventral valves: (16) LN002503, (17) LN195102, (18) LN196703, (19) LN197102. (20–22) C. yongdingensis Liao in Wang et al., 1982: (20, 22) external molds of dorsal valves: (20) LN196103, (22) LN200503; (21) an internal mold of a ventral valve, LN196903. (23, 24) Paryphella nasuta Liao, 1984, internal molds of ventral valves: (23) LN209201, (24) LN209601. Scale bars = 3 mm.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Brachiopods from the Shuizhutang Formation. (1–4) Acosarina minuta: (1, 3) internal molds of dorsal valves: (1) LN242203, (3) LN243302; (2, 4) internal molds of ventral valves: (2) LN243002, (4) LN243802. (5, 6) Hustedia lata Grabau, 1931: (5) an external mold of a dorsal valve, LN191502, (6) an external mold of a ventral valve, LN191702. (7–11) H. remota (Eichwald, 1860): (7, 8) internal molds of dorsal valves: (7) LN001902, (8) LN000803; (9–11) internal molds of ventral valves: (9) LN001003, (10) LN192503, (11) LN212203. (12–18) Prelissorhynchia pseudoutah (Huang, 1933): (12, 14) internal molds of ventral valves: (12) LN000602, (14) LN001903; (13, 18) internal molds of dorsal valves: (13) LN000702, (18) LN191101; (15–17) an inner core of a conjoined shell, LN192702: (15) ventral view, (16) dorsal view, (17) anterior view. (19) Uncinunellina postera (Waagen, 1883), an internal mold of a dorsal valve, LN177501. (20, 21) Uncinunellina sp., ventral valves: (20) LN186603, (21) LN188801. (22–24) Araxathyris beipeiensis Xu and Grant, 1994, internal molds of ventral valves: (22) LN169903, (23) LN176104, (24) LN187802. Scale bars = 5 mm.

Figure 8

Table 1.List of species with only illustrations in the text.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Brachiopods from the Shuizhutang Formation. (1) Haydenella chilianshaniana, a ventral valve, LN179103. (2–11) H. kiangsiensis: (2, 10, 11) internal molds of ventral valves: (2) LN184303, (10) LN211103, (11) LN172003; (3–7, 9) external molds of dorsal valves: (3) LN202903, (4) LN204702, (5) LN207103, (6) LN207302, (7) LN208103, (9) LN208603; (8) lateral view of (7). (12) H. subextensa, an internal mold of a ventral valve, LN201403. (13–17) H. nasuta: (13–15, 17) external molds of dorsal valves: (13) LN201303, (14) LN202003, (15) LN204303, (17) LN208801; (16) an internal mold of a ventral valve, LN207603. (18–20) Spinomarginifera kueichowensis Huang, 1932, an internal mold of a conjoined shell, LN268503. Scale bars = 3 mm.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Brachiopods from the Shuizhutang Formation. (1–3) Spinomarginifera kueichowensis: (1) an internal mold of a ventral valve, LN186803; (2) an internal mold of a dorsal valve, LN213702; (3) an external mold of a dorsal valve, LN214800. (4–8) S. sp.: (4, 7) external molds of ventral valves: (4) LN213401, (7) LN214901; (5) an internal mold of a ventral valve, LN214401; (6) dorsal interior, LN214600; (8) an external mold of a dorsal valve, LN215001. (9–20) Transennatia gratiosa: (9, 11, 18) internal molds of ventral valves: (9) LN182901, (11) LN215901, (18) LN234801; (10, 13) posterior views of (11); (12) lateral view of (11); (14, 15, 17, 19, 20) external molds of dorsal valves: (14) LN227301, (15) LN233001, (17) LN233201, (19) LN234903, (20) LN235403; (16) an internal mold of a dorsal valve, LN233101. (21–24) T. insculpta: (21) ventral valve, LN205201; (22–24) external molds of dorsal valves: (22) LN224403, (23) LN224901, (24) LN225203. Scale bars = 3 mm.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Brachiopods from the Shuizhutang Formation: T. insculpta. (1) a conjoined shell, LN226203; (2, 3, 5, 7–10, 13, 16, 18–20, 22, 24, 25) external molds of dorsal valves: (2) LN227001, (3) LN228601, (5) LN230401, (7) LN235003, (8) LN238001, (9) LN224603, (10) LN170103, (13) LN225801, (16) LN227701, (18) LN227903, (19) LN229003, (20) LN229603, (22) LN229703, (24) LN230201, (25) LN232403; (17) enlarged rectangular area in (16); (4, 6, 11) internal molds of ventral valves: (4) LN229203, (6) LN232001, (11) LN225403; (12, 14, 15, 21, 23) lateral views of (11, 13, 16, 20, 22), respectively. Scale bars = 3 mm.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Brachiopods from the Shuizhutang Formation. (1–12) T. insculpta: (1, 2, 5, 10, 11) external molds of dorsal valves: (1) LN233901, (2) LN234303, (5) LN235302, (10) LN238303, (11) LN238803; (3, 4, 9, 12) lateral views of (2, 5, 10, 11), respectively; (6) an internal mold of a dorsal valve, LN236301; (7) an internal mold of a ventral valve, LN236503; (8) lateral view of (7). (13–19) Tyloplecta huadongensis: (14, 15) external molds of dorsal valves: (14) LN161303, (15) LN163903; (13) lateral view of (14); (16) dorsal interior, LN184902; (17, 19) internal molds of ventral valves: (17) LN261403, (19) LN261903; (18) posterior view of (16). (20–29) T. liannanensis n. sp.: (20) ventral exterior, LN185601; (21) lateral view of (20); (22, 27) external molds of dorsal valves: (22) LN160803, (27) LN165903; (23) an internal mold of a dorsal valve, LN163703; (24, 26, 28, 29) internal molds of ventral valves: (24) LN164803, (26) LN165403, (28) LN173103, (29) LN175203; (25) posterior view of (24). (30) Tyloplecta sp., an external mold of a dorsal valve, LN214001. (31) Linoproductus huananensis n. sp., an external mold of a ventral valve, LN163303. Scale bars = 1 cm.

Figure 13

Figure 13.Brachiopods from the Shuizhutang Formation. (1–8) Linoproductus huananensis n. sp.: (1) an external mold of a dorsal valve, LN163103; (2, 3) enlargements of rectangles in (1) and (8), respectively; (4, 8) external molds of dorsal valves: (4) LN182103, (8) LN228302; (5) an external mold of a dorsal valve with part of internal mold of a ventral valve and part of ventral valve, LN212601; (6) an internal mold of a ventral valve, LN212901; (7) a ventral exterior, LN213601. (9–12) Licharewiella costata, internal molds of ventral valves: (9) LN194901, (10) LN202503, (11) LN206501, (12) LN210001. (13–24) L. liangyangensis, internal molds of ventral valves: (13) LN168200, (14) LN204000, (15) LN166603, (16) LN201603, (17) LN201803, (18) LN202203, (19) LN202703, (20) LN203102, (21) LN203302, (22) LN203703, (23) LN203902, (24) LN205702. (25) Leptodus lacuna Liang, 1990, an internal mold of a ventral valve, LN240403. Scale bars = 1 cm.

Figure 14

Figure 14.Brachiopods from the Shuizhutang Formation. (1–5) Leptodus lacuna, internal molds of ventral valves: (1) LN262403, (2) LN262803, (3) LN262903, (4) LN263803, (5) LN268003. (6–8) Oldhamina squamosa, internal mold of a ventral valve, LN263203: (6) ventral view, (7) posterior view, (8) lateral view. (9) Perigeyerella sp., an internal mold of a ventral valve, LN190803. (10, 11, 15–17) Permianella typica: (10) an external mold of a dorsal valve with part of inner core, LN262101; (15, 16) respectively, enlargements of upper and lower rectangles in (10); (11) an external mold of a ventral valve, LN262201; (17) enlargement of rectangle in (11). (12) Derbyia sp., an internal mold of a ventral valve, LN177902. (13, 14) Alatorthotetina derbyiformis He and Zhu, 1985: (13) an internal mold of a dorsal valve, LN240102; (14) an internal mold of a ventral valve, LN166204. (18–23) Orthothetina frechi (Huang, 1933): (18, 20, 21) internal molds of ventral valves: (18) LN239403, (20) LN239203, (21) LN240902; (19, 22, 23) internal molds of dorsal valves: (19) LN239503, (22) LN241202, (23) LN182603. (24–29) Peltichia kwangtungensis (Zhan in Hou et al., 1979): (24, 28) internal molds of dorsal valves: (24) LN172502, (28) LN180101; (25–27) an inner core of a conjoined shell, LN172703: (25) dorsal view, (26) posterior view, (27) ventral view; (29) an internal mold of a ventral valve, LN240700. (1–14, 18–29) Scale bars = 1 cm; (15–17) scale bars = 2 mm.

Figure 15

Figure 15.Brachiopods from the Shuizhutang Formation. (1–4) Araxathyris beipeiensis, internal molds of ventral valves: (1) LN244300, (2) LN246503, (3) LN248903, (4) LN249101. (5) A. glossexserta Zeng et al., 1995, an internal mold of a ventral valve, LN245003. (6–11) A. indentatus Zeng et al., 1995, two inner cores of two conjoined shells: (6–8) LN192903: (6) ventral view, (7) dorsal view, (8) anterior view; (9–11) LN193903: (9) ventral view, (10) dorsal view, (11) anterior view. (12–16) A. minor n. sp., internal molds of ventral valves: (12) LN000101, (13) LN000104, (14) LN245200, (15) LN245303, (16) LN245903. (17–20) A. undulata Shen et al., 1992: (17) an internal mold of a dorsal valve, LN246802; (18–20) internal molds of ventral valves: (18) LN247501, (19) LN247701, (20) LN248701. (21) Crurithyris sp., an internal mold of a dorsal valve, LN186902. (22–25) Spiriferellina nasuta Cooper and Grant, 1976: (22, 23, 25) internal molds of dorsal valves: (22) LN001303, (23) LN178301, (25) LN180401; (24) an internal mold of a ventral valve, LN178401. (26) Qinglongia sp., an internal mold of a dorsal valve, LN176404. Scale bars = 5 mm.

Figure 16

Figure 16.Graph of spondylium size to body size of all Araxathyris specimens from the Liannan section.

Figure 17

Figure 17.Brachiopods from the Shuizhutang Formation. (1–9) Permophricodothyris affinis: (1) an external mold of a dorsal valve, LN169403; (2–8) internal molds of ventral valves: (2) LN170303, (3) LN186403, (4) LN187103, (5) LN250403, (6) LN252403, (7) LN252702, (8) LN252903; (9) an internal mold of a dorsal valve, LN256303. (10–21) P. extensiformis: (10–12, 19) internal molds of ventral valves: (10) LN161903, (11) LN168403, (12) LN254102, (19) LN162503; (20, 21) lateral and posterior views of (19), respectively; (13–18) two inner cores of two conjoined shells: (13–15) LN254102: (13) ventral view, (14) dorsal view, (15) anterior view; (16–18) LN260702: (16) ventral view, (17) dorsal view, (18) anterior view. (22–28) P. nodosa: (22, 23, 27, 28) internal molds of ventral valves: (22) LN166403, (23) LN171703, (27) LN183103, (28) LN183503; (24, 25) internal molds of dorsal valves: (24) LN179503, (25) LN181603; (26) an external mold of a ventral valve, LN182503. Scale bars = 1 cm.

Figure 18

Figure 18.Brachiopods from the Shuizhutang Formation. (1–12) Permophricodothyris nodosa: (1) an internal mold of a dorsal valve, LN185203; (2–11) internal molds of ventral valves: (2) LN253303, (3) LN249803, (4) LN250003, (5) LN250203, (6) LN250702, (7) LN250903, (8) LN251403, (9) LN251603, (10) LN251803, (11) LN259203; (12) an external mold of a ventral valve, LN255603. (13–15) P. ovata: internal molds of ventral valves: (13) LN170700, (14) LN251003, (15) LN255101. (16–19) Permophricodothyris sp., internal molds of ventral valves: (16) LN176901, (17) LN183301, (18) LN188704, (19) LN253901. (20–31) P. flata n. sp.: (21–26) internal molds of ventral valves: (21) LN183904, (22) LN251104, (23) LN252503, (24) LN253103, (25) LN253703, (26) LN175804; (20) posterior view of (21); (27, 28, 30, 31) two inner cores of two conjoined shells: (27, 28) LN259302: (27) ventral view, (28) dorsal view; (30, 31) LN259802: (30) ventral view, (31) dorsal view; (29) the external mold of the ventral valve of (28). Scale bars = 1 cm.