In his 1988 presidential campaign, George H.W. Bush praised the American civic tradition and its multitude of community organizations operating outside of formal government as “a thousand points of light.” His paean to American political culture had a robust historical lineage. Politicians and scholars have long echoed Alexis de Tocqueville’s influential celebration of American civil society following his 1831 tour of the young republic. The United States, as Arthur Schlesinger put it a century later, was a “nation of joiners” and its vigorous civil society a rich repository of collective power and an alternative to a potentially overweening central state.Footnote 1 Over the past thirty years, however, a generation of scholars has undermined the “myth” of the weak American state by reassessing the role of civil society in the nation’s political culture. Far from a sign of historic statelessness, they have shown, the nation’s rich civic tradition has been instead a key component of a distinctive—and dynamic—“associational state.”Footnote 2 Elisabeth Clemens’s Civic Gifts: Voluntarism and the Making of the American Nation-State is an impressive and important contribution to this scholarship.
From the inception of the United States, Clemens shows, voluntary organizations have been a key component of an “expansive but not statist” system of governance” (21). The outlines of a distinctive “civic state” became visible during the first half of the nineteenth century, when a multitude of reform associations—the so-called Benevolent Empire—worked toward what they believed to be the cultural advancement and moral uplift of the young republic (47). The most powerful demonstrations of this emergent model, however, came in times of crisis and conflict. During the Civil War, Clemens demonstrates, the Union war effort depended considerably upon the contributions of citizens, whether they served in the nation’s armies, donated money and clothing, or purchased war bonds. In combination with the efforts of voluntary organizations such as the United States Sanitary Commission, they actualized a model of the state rooted in its ties to society, one that was “quite different from the establishment of new bureaucracies or professionally dominated agencies” (54). The combination of public institutions and private organizations continued during the half-century that followed, yielding an “expansible” nation-state in which private organizations worked in partnership with local, state, and national governments to confront the problems caused by natural disasters and the ascendance of industrial capitalism. The First World War, and the resulting exigencies of economic production, military support, and refugee relief, encouraged yet another “immersion in decentralized but coordinated governance,” and created even stronger ties between the federal government and voluntary groups such as the American Red Cross (105). Though the limitations of this arrangement were laid bare amidst the later tumult of the Great Depression, that crisis did not result in a purely government response but, instead, a complex choreography in which the capacities of private organizations were coordinated, though not centralized, by the federal government. The flowering of this arrangement during the Second World War ultimately led to a deeper incorporation of private organizations in the projects of the nation-state, generating a novel synthesis embodied by the prominence of the “nonprofit sector” in postwar American government.
Clemens highlights the complexities, conflicts, and contradictions that attended the participation of ostensibly private groups in the projects of the nation-state. Like recent works by Gary Gerstle and Richard White, Civic Gifts portrays an American state suffused with conflict and contradiction.Footnote 3 Clemens has characterized it elsewhere as a tangled and disorderly “Rube Goldberg State.”Footnote 4 Foremost among Clemens’s insights is her analysis of the “constitutive contradiction” between benevolence, with its connotations of dependency and hierarchy, and the principles of a liberal democratic nation-state, in which claims to citizenship were rooted in the values of economic independence and self-sufficiency (259). Tensions between the two were only ever partially and impermanently resolved, and, she shows, and periodically revisited and revised as part of a halting and piecemeal process of “iterated problem solving” (19). Voluntary organizations played an important role in this process, whether by replacing the direct, dependence-inducing relationship between donor and recipient with a generalized, nationwide project of exchange, or through their policing of the distinction between the “worthy” and “unworthy” poor.
Clemens is attuned to the complex and often contradictory consequences of partnerships between public institutions and private organizations. Their participation in the projects of the nation-state gave private actors a powerful and often problematic role in the trajectory of political development. Their ability to withdraw from the partnership at times of their own choosing ensured that the growth of governing capacity during times of emergency was undercut by its impermanence, while the delegation of public responsibilities to private organizations often redounded to the benefit of the socially and financially powerful. The prominence of organized benevolence in the response to mass unemployment during the late nineteenth century, for example, reflected a specific vision of the municipal political economy with “distinctive advantages for municipal and corporate elites,” providing both a means of preempting social disorder while also protecting wealth from tax-based public solutions (95). The participation of private actors also reflected the nation’s enduring centrifugalism: by delegating public responsibilities to associations rooted in diverse localities, local priorities and prejudices were accommodated in the projects of the nation-state. The construction of the “expansible” nation-state, Clemens demonstrates, “drew upon and amplified local capacities, solidarities and prejudices,” ensuring the preservation of some of the nation’s most tenacious and discriminatory social realities (105). As Clemens makes clear in this signal piece of scholarship, a nation-state composed of a thousand points of light may also contain a thousand shadows.
