In 1907, writer and Oxford graduate Lionel Portman began his novel The Progress of Hugh Rendal: A 'Varsity Story with an impassioned attack on the university system of fees and credit. “An unrighteous anomaly it seems that on entering Oxford University the first thing you have to do is to pay money,” Portman protests,
Once entered, apparently, you may owe it to the limit of your taste. The shops smile “Credit;” the streets sing of it, the breezes whisper “Put it down”; the whole spirit of the place assumes it as a matter of course; and that so sweet a symphony should begin on so harsh a chord appears an outrage unpardonable. But so in the wisdom of most colleges it is ordained. Thirty pounds, “caution money,” must be paid to the Bursar before he will write your name in his book of the Elect. And till this is paid, be your other debts what they may, you cannot owe to College or University. (1)
Upon enrolling in Oxford, the novel's earnest freshman hero Hugh is immediately subjected to a “baptism of debt,” and, by the end of his first year, he agonizes over the £58 in bills he owes to his grocer and other merchants (2, 102). Portman suggests that young undergraduates from families of modest means were ill-equipped to negotiate the consumer temptations that characterized the university experience and often met with painful – even disastrous – financial consequences. “What undergraduate,” the novelist asks his readers, “finding himself for the first time in the sublime position of having unlimited credit if very limited cash gives a thought to that distant but inevitable sunset, when he is informed that ‘The accounts of Mr. ––– have been placed in our hands for collection,’ etc., etc.?” (30).
Student debt figures prominently in Victorian and Edwardian university fiction, a once-popular literary subgenre in Britain. In Tom Brown at Oxford, the lesser-known Reference Hughes1861 sequel to Thomas Hughes's beloved Tom Brown's Schooldays, the title character finds himself owing £100 when he falls among the fast set and loans money to acquaintances who cannot pay him back. College Debts (1870) centers on undergraduates Edward Grantley and his dissolute classmate Fitzherbert Osborne who both find themselves so deeply in debt to tradesmen and moneylenders that they are forced to leave Oxford. In Beatrice Braithwaite Batty's Passages in the Life of an Undergraduate (Reference Batty1887), Oxford student Gerald Delane's large university bills are accidentally discovered by his grief-stricken widowed mother. And the hero of Charles Turley's Godfrey Marten, Undergraduate (Reference Turley1904) amasses considerable debts when assisting a classmate suffering from a prolonged illness.Footnote 1
Historian Barbara Weiss has argued that the specter of debt, bankruptcy, and financial ruin profoundly haunted the nineteenth-century British middle classes – a fear solidly rooted in reality, as personal bankruptcies increased significantly during the early- and mid-Victorian years (15, 27).Footnote 2 For Britons, heightened economic anxieties bolstered the already close associations between financial solvency and middle-class morality. Herbert Sussman has traced how the growing emphasis placed on individual economic value within capitalist culture meant that a man's well-being was “defined solely in monetary terms” (88). Earning a living and living within one's means were skills integral to nineteenth-century notions of bourgeois manhood. Consequently, as James Eli Adams has contended, self-discipline became “the special province and distinguishing attribute of middle-class men” during the nineteenth century (Dandies 7). Frivolous spending, waste, and amassing large debts were regarded as condemnable sins in direct opposition to a middle-class male ethos of hard work, self-restraint, and the accumulation of wealth. For Victorian readers and writers alike, financial failure and ruin were largely caused by personal irresponsibility, moral blindness, or lack of manly virtue (Weiss 19, 71). Economic insecurity and the terror of losing one's fortune were central narrative features of “that most middle-class of art forms,” the nineteenth-century popular novel (Weiss 15). Both Weiss and fellow historian V. Markham Lester note the prevalence of bankruptcy and economic ruin as themes in Victorian novels, citing such notable examples as Dickens's Dombey and Son (Reference Thackeray and Sutherland1848), Thackeray's Vanity Fair (Reference Thackeray and Sutherland1848), Charlotte Brontë's Shirley (1849), Gaskell's North and South (1855), Eliot's Middlemarch (1872), and Trollope's The Way We Live Now (1875) – all tales of individuals struggling with debt and financial disaster that bourgeois readers could regard with “grim fascination” from the safe haven of their sitting rooms (Lester 1; Weiss 66, 48).
This essay examines how the portrayal of student expenditure and debt in popular Victorian and Edwardian novels set in Britain's ancient universities of Oxford and Cambridge – together known as “Oxbridge” – both reflected decidedly middle-class socioeconomic anxieties and privileged middle-class masculine ideals. Paul Deslandes's invaluable 2005 study Oxbridge Men: British Masculinity and the Undergraduate Experience, 1850–1920 explores the formation of undergraduate identity in relation to notions of British masculinity, professionalism, and imperialism. His work demonstrates Oxbridge students' preoccupations with class, gender, and generational identity as well as their self-conscious attempts to distinguish themselves as members of a highly educated elite who were “destined for greatness” (13). By examining a very specific body of primary evidence – the nearly two hundred undergraduate periodicals produced by Oxford and Cambridge students from 1850 to 1920 (11) – Deslandes focuses on how undergraduates represented themselves to each other within a rather hermetic community of like-minded individuals.
Equally valuable is an examination of how the university experience was represented outside of Cambridge and Oxford to a largely middle-class readership. The more than 160 university novels published in Britain between 1837 and 1910 serve as a vital record revealing how Oxbridge and undergraduate masculinity were presented to, and understood by, a popular audience during the Victorian and Edwardian eras (Proctor 217–22, Batson 167–71, Chainey 254–55). The frequency of overexpenditure and debt as themes in these works suggests a middle-class readership that would have identified closely with such matters. Frederick Edward Weatherly's Oxford Days: or How Ross Got His Degree (Reference Weatherly and Resident1879) goes so far as to provide multiple and lengthy itemized lists of expenses that presumably would have been regarded as extremely valuable to an audience for whom money was an object of concern. Oxbridge fiction appealed directly to readers who wanted both to see protagonists that reflected their middle-class identity and to identify with those they knew were above their station. Thus, the narratives offered in university novels are simultaneously aspirational and cautionary, portraying modest heroes with limited economic resources, relatable to middle-class readers, entering an elite environment and facing there a gauntlet of challenges and temptations. While Deslandes reports that in student publications, undergraduates treat debt flippantly as a tiresome nuisance (69–70), university novels, in contrast, reflect bourgeois sentiments by portraying debt as a profound moral dilemma that threatens both a student's finances and his soul. Because Victorians popularly believed that reading should serve as a means of personal improvement (Weiss 63), Oxbridge fiction provided guidance and warnings to young male readers, often in the form of moralistic – even sensationalistic – cautionary tales regarding overexpenditure and insolvency. Novelists pointedly criticized what they regarded as Oxbridge's highly exploitative environment of extortionate university fees, greedy merchants, and swindling servants that preyed on young men and made debt almost unavoidable. Moreover, they warned that the moral weakness and lack of self-restraint that precipitated overexpediture frequently escalated into more severe vices, character ruin, and family disaster. Promoting the economy, reserve, and self-discipline that characterized the manhood idealized by middle-class readers, Oxbridge fiction draws strong distinctions between the often upper-class “fast men,” who unapologetically take pleasure in extravagant living and sink ever lower into debt and ruin, and those students who exhibit the sturdier middle-class values that enable them ultimately to settle their bills and emerge from the university ready to join the professional classes.
The Oxbridge Novel and the Middle Classes
The ancient universities of Oxford and Cambridge had long been morally suspect to a middle class that idealized industry, production, and economy. Enduring eighteenth-century notions of the university as a dissolute playground where aristocratic “toffs” idly spent four years wasting their father's money made an Oxbridge education seem “one of the least desirable alternatives for a student making the transition from boyhood to young adulthood” (Rothblatt, “Student Sub-culture” 247). Lawrence Stone suggests that “earnest, ambitious, middle-class parents of 19th century England. . . were put off by the century-old reputation of Oxford as a place which encouraged habits of extravagance and dissipation”Footnote 3 (61). John Gibson Lockhart's Reginald Dalton: A Story of English University Life (Reference Lockhart1823) – what George Saintsbury and Mortimer Proctor identify as the first university novel (Saintsbury 335–36, Proctor 62) – established a popular precedent by telling the story of a poor vicar's son who goes to Oxford with good intentions but quickly falls in with a crowd of fast men and succumbs to drinking, gambling, and debt. Major reforms throughout the Victorian age did much to open up the ancient universities to students from nontraditional backgrounds while dramatically improving academic rigor, discipline, and oversight (Proctor 51–55, Weber 33–39). By the second half of the nineteenth century, the combination of academic reform at Oxbridge and the rapid expansion of Britain's middle ranks led to “a great tide of students from the new middle classes, professional, commercial, industrial, and white collar” flooding into the once-exclusive universities (Stone 59, 67).
The gradual opening of the ancient universities beyond the traditional elite helped fuel the success of the Oxbridge novel. Accurate data regarding sales figures and readership of nineteenth-century popular fiction are often difficult to locate or nonexistent. However, the sheer number of university novels and the dramatic surge in titles (38 were published between 1870 and 1889; 69 were published between 1890 and 1909) suggest that Oxbridge fiction was an increasingly popular genre with a growing audience (Proctor 217–22, Batson 167–71, Chainey 254–55). Although the publication record of most of these novels is limited to a single printing, several works – including Rev. Edward Bradley's The Adventures of Mr. Verdant Green (Reference Berens1853-57), Frederic William Farrar's Julian Home: A Tale of College Life (Reference Farrar1859), and Hughes's Tom Brown at Oxford – were widely read and regularly reprinted in both Britain and the United States for decades.Footnote 4
The success of Oxbridge fiction was likely due to its direct appeal to a middle-class readership that was still largely excluded from Oxford and Cambridge. Popular audiences have perhaps always enjoyed reading about the lives of their social superiors. But as the middle class and its values gained prominence in Victorian society, readers wished to see themselves reflected in fiction. Thus, the heroes of university novels are often bright, good-hearted boys from modest families of the minor gentry decidedly lacking in traditional upper-class privileges. Both title characters of Julian Home and Harry John Wilmot Buxton's The Mysteries of Isis: The College Life of Paul Romaine (Reference Buxton1866) are ministers' sons from once-wealthy families who have fallen on hard times and who attend university on scholarship; the protagonists of Tom Brown at Oxford and The Progress of Hugh Rendal are sons of country gentlemen of modest means. Other novels can be rather elusive about the class identities of many of the central characters: Turley tells us nothing of his hero Godfrey Marten beyond the fact that his father has little money to offer him toward expenses, and all that is revealed of Edward Kennedy's class identity in Julian Home is that he joins a fast set of students whose class status is above his own. The financial constraints and unclear class status of so many student protagonists is likely intentional, rendering the central characters ciphers through which readers of the middle ranks could see themselves. Although the sons of rectors and country gentry significantly outranked middle-class readers, the middle class of nineteenth- and early-twentieth-century Britain included people of vastly different incomes and social positions; indeed, some individuals of the traditional upper classes by rank had much in common with the middle class by income. In this way, most Oxbridge novelistsFootnote 5 consciously strove to make their heroes both aspirational and identifiable to appeal to a primarily middle-class readership. In his Reference Hughes1861 preface to Tom Brown at Oxford, Hughes explains that he chose the name Tom Brown because “it stood first in the trio of ‘Brown, Jones, and Robinson,’ which has become a sort of synonym for the middle classes of Great Britain. . . . I wanted the commonest name I could get, and did not want any name which had the least heroic, or aristocratic, or even respectable savour about it” (viii). Hughes and other university novelists actively privilege middle-class values concerning financial accountability and assign overexpenditure as a moral failing of a profligate upper class. Consequently, Oxbridge fiction reflects and affirms a middle-class perspective by presenting young heroes who are challenged to achieve their manhood by successfully negotiating a series of pitfalls that threatens their pocketbook and tests their moral fiber.
A “Baptism of Debt”: University Expenses, Merchants, and Servants
An Oxbridge education was extraordinarily expensive for most middle-class families. Both university fiction and student handbooks outlined the many fees, bills, and necessities accrued during an undergraduate's year. Although tuition fees were reduced for many middle-class undergraduates and sizars (undergraduates who received financial aid), students still faced the expenses of admission fees, matriculation fees, examination fees, degree fees, and caution money; university and college dues; room rental; furnishings; meals and battels;Footnote 6 clothing; coal; laundry; and wages for tutors and servants. Costs could differ broadly: various sources from the second half of the nineteenth century assessed room rent from a low of £4 to a high of £30 at the most prestigious colleges (Latham 59; Weatherly 5; “University Life” 224). The 1863 Student's Guide to the University of Cambridge provided detailed estimates for total annual expenditures, including college bills, grocers' and booksellers' bills, travel expenses, pocket money, and “tradesmen's bills for personal expenses and entertainments”; the lowest estimate was £125, the average £180, and the highest £250 (Latham 64).Footnote 7 Two years later, Cornhill Magazine echoed that while university expenses “need not exceed £130 a year,” a student should never go to university with less than £200 (“University Life” 224). Renowned Oxford lecturer and philosopher Edgar Frederick Carritt recalled that during his undergraduate year at Oxford's Hertford College in the late-1890s, he “lived on £150 scholarships plus presents and maintenance, including holidays, during vacations” (184). Sheldon Rothblatt's review of student handbooks places the cost of a year at Cambridge – depending on lifestyle and college – between £155 and £403 at the turn of the century when middle-class yearly incomes would have ranged between £150 and £1800 (Revolution 66, Perkin 91–93).Footnote 8 In his novelized handbook Oxford Days, Weatherly tallied the total cost for fictional undergraduate Frank Ross's three years at Oxford at £791 0s 9d – a daunting sum, indeed, for a middle-class Victorian family (166–68).Footnote 9
Oxbridge fiction acknowledged the concerns of its largely middle-class readership by regularly depicting students confronting the practical and moral struggle to make ends meet. In The Progress of Hugh Rendal, Portman writes of his protagonist, “With scholarships bringing in a hundred and fifty pounds a year, and an allowance amounting to another fifty, Hugh was no poorer than most of his fellows. But to live on an income of two hundred at Oxford is no easy matter – though many certainly exist on less – and strict economy had to be exercised from the very start” (16). The first-person hero of Turley's Godfrey Marten, Undergraduate – who is sent off to university with £200 for annual expenses, which his father warns is “more than I can afford” – laments that “economy was a thing which evaded me, however zealously I pursued it” (1; 299). For the undergraduate of limited circumstances, debt was frequently portrayed as a near inevitability, almost impossible to avoid. Weiss argues that in responding to the “middle-class nightmare of bankruptcy,” nineteenth-century novelists “would come increasingly to sympathize with the hapless individual crushed by an implacable economic system” (15, 20). Consequently, the student protagonist of Oxbridge fiction is frequently portrayed as a victim to an exploitative arrangement that all but forces him to resort to credit. Reflecting on the overwhelming costs faced by students, Arthur Hamilton Gibbs's The Compleat Oxford Man (Reference Gibbs1911) protested that the undergraduate “is a mere pawn in the great University game” (125), and Weatherly complained of “the tyranny of the system” (29).
Profiting from this large body of new young consumers was a barrage of shopkeepers and merchants who lined the High Streets of Oxford and Cambridge, supplying their needs and whetting their consumer appetites. The History, Gazetteer and Directory of the County of Oxford (Reference Gardner1852) lists a staggering variety of trades that would have catered directly to undergraduate clientele, including fifty-six tailors, thirty-five robe makers, eighty-eight boot and shoemakers, fifteen hatters, nineteen “Hairdressers & Shavers,” fourteen “Furniture Brokers,” seventeen wine merchants, and fourteen tobacconists (Gardner 363–84). Like many earlier nineteenth-century writers, Rothblatt blames student overexpenditure largely on Oxbridge's predatory merchants: “Tradesmen. . . applied unfair pressure to gownsmen. They kept a sharp watch out for entering freshmen, and were uncannily informed about social background and income. They were only too happy to take advantage of a young man's uncertainties about what was expected of him” (“Student Sub-culture” 273–74). University fiction reflected the similar nineteenth-century sentiment that Oxford and Cambridge played hosts to legions of swindlers preying on young men's consumer desires.Footnote 10 Bradley's popular Verdant Green in particular portrays all Oxford tradesmen as manipulative and unscrupulous con artists. Freshman student Verdant is “bewildered” by his tailor's fast talk and easily persuaded to purchase a coat, vest, and trousers “of a neat, quiet, plaid-pattern in red and green, which he was informed, were all the rage” (1: 88). Similarly, in William Winwood Reade's Reference Reade1860 novel Liberty Hall, Oxon., undergraduate Ted Saxon is lured by the flattering High Street merchants into making over £5 in purchases in one afternoon (1: 344). Ignoring Saxon's vows not to buy anything, a tailor tantalizes the undergraduate with scarves, “plac[ing] them all out into the showiest positions, and unreel[ing] a string of eulogiums on their warmth and durabilities,” and quickly convinces him to purchase several additional items (1: 337–38). Students who avoided the High Street altogether nonetheless often fell prey to salesmen. During his first days at the university, Hargrave Ringwood, the young hero of the Cambridge Protestant Magazine's 1847 fictionalized serial of a young man's freshman year at Oxford, is “besieged, blockaded in his garret, by Oxford tradesmen and their representatives” soliciting his business (“Chapters” 442).
Most egregious among Oxbridge vendors' selling tactics, merchants aggressively encouraged undergraduates to buy goods on credit to promote additional expenditure and to tether them to long-term financial obligation. The system of credit – in tandem with usuriously high interest rates – flourished in university towns and was largely criticized for the enormous debt incurred by undergraduates. In his autobiography, Fred Bickerton, who served as scout and head porter of University College of Oxford from 1897 to 1950, notes, “One bad feature of the time, I always thought, was the tradespeople's custom of allowing far too much credit to undergraduates. . . . I can recall cases when the bills reached such proportions that when fathers were faced with them they came down strong and told the tradesman that he had no business to allow a minor so much credit for luxury articles” (6–7). Victorian novelists frequently commented on the ubiquity of the credit system. “[T]he tradesmen, with a few exceptions,” Buxton bitterly warns readers in The Mysteries of Isis, “won't take your money if they can possibly help it. They will be glad to have your name on their books: the money may be convenient to you during term; it is not usual among University gentlemen to pay at once, and so on; and the poor foolish freshman straightway forgets Mentor's teaching, and plunges at once into debt” (293). Saxon's spending binge in Liberty Hall begins when an officious shop owner assures the young man, “O, pray don't think of troubling yourself now Sir. . . . in four years time will be quite early enough for us.” The author observes that, “on the ready-money system,” Saxon “would have left the shop immediately he had bought what he wanted” (Reade 1: 335), but the credit system induces him to linger and to acquire items that he will be obligated to pay for later.
Excessive undergraduate expenditure was further promoted by university servants – called “scouts” at Oxford and “gyps” at Cambridge – who were assigned to students living in college residence halls. While the official duty of scouts was to help undergraduates procure necessary items, including furnishings, housewares, and food, they developed an “unhappy reputation as fleecers of the men whom they serve[d]” and “helped push undergraduates toward more expensive living” (Darwall-Smith, History 384; Rothblatt, “Student Sub-culture” 276). The scouts' position was widely open to abuse: because they were allowed to keep leftover food and other items as perquisite, scouts “had a vested interest in over-supplying the wants of their charges” and therefore frequently conspired with tradespeople to order more than necessary (Mansfield 186).Footnote 11 An 1888 issue of the Oxford periodical Undergraduate lamented the “generations and generations of undergraduates” who had been gouged by “the superior cunning and the fawning tyranny of scouts” (“Scouts” 243). In fiction, scouts are similarly characterized as artful facilitators of student consumption and often bear telling names, such as “Filcher” in Verdant Green and “Sneek” in James Rice's The Cambridge Freshman: or, Memoirs of Mr. Golightly (Reference Rice1871). Weatherly's Oxford Days advises that undergraduates must stand against “the Oxford custom, fostered by the scouts, of ordering too much” (27), as student Frank Ross's scout William purchases “from one of the nearest – and dearest – grocers, a good stock of tea (at 4s. 6d. per pound, of course), coffee, candles, matches, scented soaps, biscuits, jam, marmalade, till Frank was quite bewildered” (28). Portman's freshman hero Hugh Rendal is similarly overwhelmed by his scout's friendly guidance regarding necessary university purchases:
Seeking advice from the King as to the best shop in which to buy cap and gown, Hugh received a great deal more than he sought; namely additional advice – almost tantamount to instruction – where to buy glass, china, cutlery, lamps, groceries, kettles, candlesticks, wine, and many other things needful, according to that authority, to his dignity if not his existence. The King's advice seemed to be something that you could not possibly reject. So he divided the list by two, and spent the morning disbursing some five pounds in the High. (15)
Beyond merely encouraging student expenditure, scouts were characterized in university fiction as aggressive swindlers and leeches. Filcher is a petty thief who pockets many of Verdant's belongings and gifts sent from his family. Samuel Golightly's gyp Sneek ruthlessly squeezes money and pilfers goods from his master, eying him “as a snake might view a fine plump pigeon before he swallowed him up” (Rice 106).Footnote 12
While scouts and merchants were widely blamed for extracting money from undergraduate pockets, some writers asserted that the universities themselves actively colluded with the extortionate credit system that flourished in Oxford and Cambridge's High Streets. Weatherly describes the “iniquitous” policy practiced by some colleges of striking exclusive agreements that required students to purchase items only at certain shops:
Anything in the way of paper, paint, or furniture, has to be procured at one of the shops attached to the college. These are invariably the dearest, charging for their goods 25 and 30 per cent. more than the many other establishments which struggle against these monopolies. . . .
Anything like opposition to the regulation appears at present to be useless. One daring undergraduate at [the fictional] Paul's [College], who ventured to remonstrate with his college dean (the authority in such matters), was met with this characteristic answer: – “It is our system. If you don't like it, the college gates are open. You can remove your name from the college books. We won't detain you.”. . .
And so it would be possible to go on and enumerate many instances in which not only custom among his companions, but college regulations compel the undergraduate to be extravagant and wasteful. (28–30)Footnote 13
At the very least, many argued that the universities were to blame for failing to protect their young, impressionable charges from the exploitative environment that surrounded them. The author of Oxford Unmasked dismissed “the trash talked about young men. . . deserving to pay the penalty of their indiscretion” and countered “why. . . is such an experimentum crucis necessary in a place of education, where the youthful mind ought to be fenced round and guarded from evil and trained to good, not exposed to trials and danger?” (Richards 30).
Victorian writers, therefore, suggested that, when confronting Oxbridge and its attendant credit system, the undergraduate of limited finances was destined to face serious financial peril. In 1847, the Oxford Protestant Magazine fretted that beyond the support of family, the young undergraduate “wonders to find his moderately filled purse empty, and cannot conceive how the money has evaporated” (“Poor Scholars” 400); two decades later, Cornhill Magazine warned parents, “Those who propose to send a son to Oxford on a very small allowance, should bear in mind that in so doing they are placing him in a position in which he requires a world of prudence and self-denial to keep out of debt and danger, and this, too, between the age of eighteen and twenty-two” (“University Life” 225). Novelists likewise devoted much handwringing over undergraduate debt, occasionally interrupting their narratives to offer direct commentary – and heartfelt pleas – to readers while acknowledging a certain hopelessness in their mission. “I wish that I could write a few words of good, powerful, useful advice upon this important subject,” Reade interjects in Liberty Hall, “but so much has been written by cleverer men than myself, and so little has been done. I do not know what to say” (1: 349). Buxton addresses student debt with a similar tone of futility in The Mysteries of Isis:
Let me say a word on this subject. I don't expect to do any good, but a bad system ought to be exposed, even if no improvement results. When a freshman first comes up, flush of money, and full of good resolutions, with his mother's last entreaties and his father's advice still ringing in his innocent ears, he determines never to have a bill, and to pay for everything at once with ready money. He soon finds the difficulty of carrying out this most excellent resolve. (293)
The undergraduate protagonist often finds himself in debt with no real understanding of how he got himself in this position and no idea how to get himself out. During his summer vacation, the eponymous hero of The Progress of Hugh Rendal despairs over his £58 in unpaid bills:
How he could ever have raised such a mountain of debt he could not conceive – there seemed to be no visible return for it. How he was to be rid of or even reduce the load was a still more harassing question. His quarterly income was only £50, his “battels” at the beginning of each term seldom less than £40. Only £20 quarterly remained for clothes, books, boots, journeys, groceries, liquor, tobacco, subscriptions, tips, and a dozen other necessities. How was an exchequer already overstrained to make good such a deficit as this? For make it good he must, sooner or later, that was clear. And yet he could see no possible outlet. (Portman 102–03)
University fiction presents Oxbridge as an expensive and exploitative setting that renders the freshman of modest means an easy mark for financial failure. Throughout the nineteenth century, the general standards of comfort at Oxbridge grew more extravagant, and “[t]he new emphasis on clothes, furnishings, tableware, and entertainments tempted students into a pattern of expenditure suitable to the style of the new age” (Rothblatt, “Student Sub-culture” 273). Novelists insisted that the allurements of the Oxbridge lifestyle were too great a temptation for most young men, and the credit system made overconsumption far too easy. In Verdant Green, the title hero's classmate Charles Larkyns observes, “[I]t is very delightful, when you admire any thing, to be able to say, ‘Send that to my room!’ and to be obsequiously obeyed, ‘no questions asked,’ and no payment demanded” (Bradley 89). Portman similarly notes, “It was so easy when tie or pipe or picture or book seized [Hugh's] fancy to turn into the shop, give his name and college, and request the smiling vendor to ‘send it round.’ More and more things were ‘put down,’ and ‘sent round,’ as time went on; and less and less resistance made to the siren call of the shopman” (30). To avoid the allure of materialism and easy credit – to emerge from Oxbridge unsullied by the shame of debt – seemed a virtual impossibility.
“The Worship of the Golden Calf”: Overexpenditure, Class, and Masculinity
Consequently, consumer enticements were more than just a burden to the undergraduate's purse in the pages of Oxbridge novels; they were a serious threat to his morality. The young hero attained his manhood at the university only by successfully surmounting an often overwhelming onslaught of distractions and temptations. In The Progress of Hugh Rendal, Portman declares, “Self-restraint in the management of time and money is perhaps the greatest lesson that Oxford has to teach”; but, the author continues, “there can be few places on this earth where it is so hard to master: for every element of life is against the learner” (30). Nonetheless, economy and self-restraint were imperative to securing middle-class male identity. The nineteenth-century association between financial discipline and morality meant that resisting or managing consumer temptations was central to achieving long-term success and happiness. Throughout the Victorian age, hard work, thrift, and in particular self-discipline were increasingly aligned with middle-class masculinity (Adams, Dandies 4–7). Writers and essayists conflated moral and economic goals, emphasizing the middle-class man's ability to resist immediate pleasures, save his resources, and invest in future rewards (Adams, “Victorian” 127). “Victorian political economy,” Adams contends, “defined a middle-class manhood distinguished by a forward looking perspective and a capacity for deferred gratification” (Dandies 111).
The Victorian ideal of a middle-class masculinity characterized by self-discipline and economy was regularly contrasted against the supposed failings of the bloated and morally corrupt upper classes. Adams explains, “In authorizing attacks on an allegedly dissolute, profligate aristocracy for failing to live up to its inherited authority, self-restraint became a highly effective basis for claiming moral authority for the middle classes” (“Victorian” 128). Cognizant of their largely middle-class readers, then, Oxbridge novelists pit the values of economy and moderation against the improvidence and moral irresponsibility attributed to elite, upper-class student characters. Nineteenth- and early-twentieth-century writers regularly classified the Oxbridge student body into four or five familiar types – usually fast men, athletes, reading men, aesthetes, and sporting men.Footnote 14 The reading man would have appealed most to middle-class audiences because he was committed to the values of self-discipline, work before pleasure, and investment in long-term goals central to the middle-class ethos. The reading man's most common adversary in Oxbridge fiction is the fast man, since his idleness, reckless spending, and complete avoidance of responsibility placed him in direct opposition to middle-class values. The fast man's lavishly appointed rooms – and the excesses that took place within them – served as easily recognizable markers of wasteful, dissipated living. Vyvyan Bruce, the villain of Julian Home, is from a “wealthy London family” and attends university as a “fellow-commoner” – a student of untitled but rich parents who paid double tuition and fees (Farrar 56; 250). Imitating “his father in his expensive tastes,” Bruce occupies “splendid lodgings, the most expensive which he heard of,” and fills them with “glossy tables, velvet-cushioned chairs, Turkey carpets, rich curtains, and an abundance of mirrors” (86; 56–57). Similar descriptions of student rooms decadently heaped with fine housewares, costly knickknacks, sporting and hunting equipment, framed prints, tobacco boxes, and wine bottles appear in Verdant Green, Joseph Hewlett's Peter Priggins: The College Scout (Reference Hewlett and Hook1841), Tom Brown, The Mysteries of Isis, The Cambridge Freshman, and Oxford Days; such passages served to typify the immoderate habits of their upper-class occupants. In Tom Brown, novelist Hughes details the opulent lifestyle enjoyed by Tom's college-mate Drysdale, “the heir of an old as well of a rich family,” and his “set of reckless, loose young spendthrifts” who dominate fictional St. Ambrose College:
The chief characteristic of this set was the most reckless extravagance of every kind. London wine merchants furnished them with liqueurs at a guinea a bottle and wine at five guineas a dozen; Oxford and London tailors vied with one another in providing them with unheard-of quantities of the most gorgeous clothing. They drove tandems in all directions, scattering their ample allowances, which they treated as pocket money, about roadside inns and Oxford taverns with open hand, and “going tick”Footnote 15 for everything which could by possibility be booked. Their cigars cost two guineas a pound; their furniture was the best that could be bought; pine-apples, forced fruit, and the most rare preserves figured at their wine parties. (22; 3; 2)Footnote 16
Drysdale's gentleman commoner friends enjoy “allowances of £500 a year at least each; and. . . treated their allowances as pocket-money” (22). To further emphasize the blatant waste of this life of conspicuous consumption, novelists frequently point out that many of these purchases go entirely unused. In Peter Priggins, the ridiculous Singleton Slipslop, a wealthy fellow-commoner with a formidable £500 per annum allowance, overloads his rooms “with all sorts of reading-chairs, and reading-tables, though he never read at them, or in them, for fear of injuring them,” along with pipes, snuffboxes, sporting equipment, guns, “and a vast variety of other articles, equally expensive and equally useless to him” (Hewlett 1: 56, 57). University fiction's lengthy descriptions of consumer immoderation simultaneously exposed the dissolute life of obscenely wealthy students (and those students who wished to appear so) and catered to middle-class readers who could regard such scenes with a mixture of moral outrage and prurient fascination.
Oxbridge novelists appealing to popular audiences were careful to avoid depicting indulgence in luxury goods and wine parties among the fashionable set as alluring and instead emphasized middle-class men's superiority to other questionable forms of undergraduate display. To many Victorian writers and commentators, there was something weak, even effeminate, about economic improvidence. Adams explains that middle-class writer Charles Kingsley's criticisms of the “fastidious, maundering, die-away effeminacy” of the “effeminate and luxurious aristocracy” at Oxford suggested a class of students “weakened by luxury or inactivity” (Dandies 98). Consequently, the fast men of university fiction often echo Kingsley's unfavorable description: in Peter Priggins, Slipslop is “exceedingly effeminate in person, and over-particular in dress – showing a decided penchant for jewellery and fine clothes, with an inordinate taste for perfumery” (52). Devereux, one of the “rich men” of the “fastest set in college” in The Mysteries of Isis, is “a pale effeminate man, with drooping suspicious-looking eyes” (Buxton 27, 29). Fast men grow soft from a combination of indulgence and idleness: “Unable to make the mental effort which the least approach to study would have required,” the spoiled fellow-commoner Brogten of Julian Home
suffered his few intellectual faculties to grow more and more gross and stolid, and spent his mornings in smoking, drinking beer, or lounging in the rooms of some one as idle and discontented as himself. It was sad to see the change which even in his first term came over his face;. . . it was a look in which effrontery supplied the place of self-dependence, and coarseness was the substitute for strength. (Farrar 119)
Certainly, significant differences existed among the fast man, athlete, and aesthete types who occupied at least the imaginations of fiction writers, if not the actual college halls of Oxbridge; and, indeed, Victorian commentators reserved special criticism for the aesthete whose student rooms “present the appearance of a lady's boudoir” (“Rooms” 265). While Kingsley's promotion of Muscular Christianity – that curious Victorian doctrine of robust, even aggressive physical vigor and spiritual purity – was initially intended to glorify manly self-discipline among young men, Adams contends that his writings revealed “a surprising link between the Victorian cult of athleticism and the rise of aestheticism” (“Victorian” 131). Many nineteenth-century critics feared that “Kingsley's celebrations of unreflecting impulse seemed to sanction male profligacy” (Adams, Dandies 110). For the middle-class writer and reader, then, the fast man's drinking and carousing, the athlete's preoccupation with sport, and the aesthete's decorative excesses could be perceived as equally condemnable variations of the same moral weakness. All three types wasted money and time on non-academic pursuits and short-lived pleasures and therefore could be contrasted unfavorably against the middle-class values of self-restraint and hard work that distinguished the disciplined and serious-minded hero.
The irresponsible student's lack of manhood was further emphasized by his reliance on his parents to pay his debts. Young undergraduates occasionally abused their financial dependence on their parents to support their university education by presuming that their families would happily cover even their most extraneous expenditures. Edward Berens's Advice to Oxford Freshmen (Reference Berens1853) asserts, “Some young Oxonians, I am afraid, after spending the larger portion of their allowance upon amusements and self-indulgence, drive off the payment of what they regard as their more creditable debts till they take their degree, under the idea that they will then be paid by their fathers. This is a most unwarrantable, – sometimes a cruel, – drain upon parental kindness” (81). Commenting on their most recent High Street shopping binge, the feckless Larkyns of Verdant Green, the son of the rector in Verdant's village, offhandedly tells the eponymous hero, “I suppose the bills will come in some day or other, but the governor [father] will see to them; and though he may grumble and pull a long face, yet he'll only be too glad you've got your degree, and, in the fulness of his heart, he will open his cheque-book” (Bradley 1: 5, 89). A great many fast students in university fiction similarly count on their “governors” to foot the bill. But the ostentatious lifestyle enjoyed by Julian Home's spoiled villain Vyvyan Bruce eventually exhausts the patience of his father, who angrily refuses his son's request for more money beyond his already extravagant £500 annual allowance (Farrar 272). Undaunted, Bruce accrues an additional £150 in tailoring bills and further outrages his father by flippantly suggesting that he pay it (387). Such a brazen attitude among real-life students was certainly aided by the fact that fathers were responsible for any debts accrued by children under the age of twenty-one.Footnote 17 Legally regarded as “infants” (Finn 273), many students eagerly exploited their minority status and embraced consumer lifestyles they believed appropriate to their desired status, confident in their father's ability and willingness to pay.
Novelists and social commentators strongly cautioned students against following the corrupting example set by their wealthier, faster classmates. While undergraduates from the elite classes might enjoy the privilege of living extravagantly without accumulating overwhelming debts or facing comeuppance, readers were warned that they would invite disaster if they tried to follow suit. In Oxford Memories: A Retrospect after Fifty Years (1886), author James Pycroft's former classmate Richard Lyall deplores “the very common case of men who inadvertently become associated with those in whose society they delight, but cannot afford to keep” (1: 235–36). Thackeray declared in his Book of Snobs (Reference Thackeray and Sutherland1848) that the worst of all university snobs are “those unfortunates who go to rack and ruin from their desire to ape their betters” (62–63). Advice to Oxford Freshman similarly cautioned against the impulse to keep up with the Joneses:
A man of large fortune produces at his table a variety of costly wines, abundance of ice, and a splendid dessert. Others, from a silly vanity, affect to do the same, although such expensive luxuries are altogether inconsistent with their finances, and with the general habits of men in their rank of life. . . . At all events, do not you be so weak as to fall into them. There is no disgrace in being poor, but there is disgrace and dishonesty too, in contracting debts which you are unable to discharge. (Berens 80–81)
Deslandes suggests that the frequency of debt among real-life Oxbridge students reveals “the considerable pressures many undergraduates felt to conform to the expectation that their rooms (and their bodies) would function as visible markers of style and substance” (71). The desire to “ape their betters” and gain the approval of the fast set leads many heroes of university fiction to affect a lifestyle they cannot afford. In “Chapters in the Life of an Undergraduate” (1847), a fatherly shopkeeper warns freshman Hargrave, a country vicar's son, that when “a party of men of distinguished rank and of good fortune” sets the bar of expenditure for their college, “[o]thers, with half their means, and without their expectations, are, more or less consciously, drawn into the same vortex: they avail themselves of the credit which cannot well be refused; and hence it is that many young men are either ruined outright, or drag through half a life a burthen of debt” (445). In College Debts, Edward Grantley's visiting family expresses concern over “the general look of luxury” about his rooms, which, unbeknownst to them, he has fallen deeply in debt to produce. “There is nothing here, sir, that you would not see in many other men's rooms,” Grantley sheepishly explains to his rector father. “Well, well – so it may be;” his father counters, “but there's a difference between the finances of the son of a country parson, and those of the men you refer to. I don't like all this waste, Edward” (2: 25–26). Even the virtuous Tom Brown, who is disgusted that “the worship of the golden calf was verily and indeed rampant in Oxford,” reluctantly acknowledges that “he himself was becoming an idolater”: Tom realizes that he feels more comfortable among the fashionably dressed fast students than beside the “faded old gown, shabby loose overcoat, and well-worn trousers” of his much dearer friend Hardy (Hughes 54).
Many Oxbridge students made self-conscious attempts to maintain an appearance of prosperity and upper-class status through conspicuous consumption and flippancy concerning debt. Deslandes contends that the pages of real-life student periodicals reveal “immaturity and carelessness regarding financial matters,” as undergraduates “routinely portrayed themselves as people who willfully disregarded notices of debt and the persistent entreaties of bill collectors” (69, 70). Such economic bravado was often a carefully studied pose. An 1888 article from the Undergraduate humorously exposes the deliberate performance of fictional undergraduate Brown who, when observed by his classmates, “crumples up his bills in his hand, and flings them into – the wastepaper basket. He extracts them afterwards, and puts them away. Brown lives well within his means, but would not care to have this known” (“Bills” 232). Thus, reckless spending and open disregard toward debt were means by which students could display and prove their manhood to their peers by appearing both prosperous and unflappable. Students who aspire to upper-class appearances exhibit an incautious and dismissive attitude toward bills and tradesmen who demand payment in both Verdant Green and Tom Brown (Bradley 57; Hughes 37). Before his ignominious downfall, the extravagant Fitzherbert Osborne of College Debts casually waves away requests for payment by his tailor and condescendingly admonishes him for not filling his orders quickly enough (1: 130–31). But financial immaturity and irresponsibility weren't always merely an act. In real life, merchants regularly faced undergraduate clientele who failed to settle their accounts before leaving Oxbridge,Footnote 18 and some students flouted their economic accountability with shameless audacity: H. D. Pavière, who attended Oxford's Christ Church College, 1912–14, remembered, “A college undergraduate in serious financial trouble was given a sum of money by the Dean to liquidate his debts. Instead of doing so he bought a motor-cycle” (12).
University fiction regularly draws bold distinctions between upper- and middle-class values in terms of economic and academic practices. Students with limited finances who forget themselves and succumb to idleness and wasteful living among the wealthy fast set soon find themselves in trouble. In The Mysteries of Isis, Henry Chunter, a young freshman from a respectable family whose father works in the City, falls among “the fastest set in college – a set of men who prided themselves on the wine which they drank, the cigars which they smoked, and the loo which they played,” and eventually is forced to leave the university (Buxton 2, 27). The author of College Debts explains that Osborne, the eldest of eleven children whose struggling parents made significant sacrifices to send him to university, started down the wayward path when he “had found himself courted and caressed by those superior to him in wealth and station” (1: 127, 271). In Julian Home, the title hero's good-hearted but weak-willed freshman classmate Edward Kennedy is quickly absorbed into the spoiled Vyvyan Bruce's decadent social circle where he abandons his studies, loses money at cards, and drinks “heedlessly of the wine that freely circulated” – habits that soon lead to grave consequences (Farrar 103). In contrast, those students who exhibit middle-class virtues flourish due to their commitment to hard work and self-discipline. The eldest son of a village rector who has endured significant financial hardships, Julian Home recognizes that he had “no prospect of remaining at the University unless he won himself the means of doing so by his own success”; consequently, he eschews idleness and self-indulgence, quickly earns a reputation as “a fellow that grinds” (studies hard), and boasts that he is not “a man to whom lavender-colored kid gloves and unlimited eau-de-cologne were necessaries of life” (18, 12, 250, 405). Similarly, Paul Romaine of The Mysteries of Isis attends Oxford on scholarship, his once-wealthy and “well born” minister father unable to send him otherwise (8, 9, 11). Unabashedly acknowledging that he is “a poor man,” Paul purposely avoids “the fastest, the idlest, the most ignorant, and the most reckless men in college,” applies himself, and passes his exams with a First (83, 301). The strong distinctions drawn between profligate, idle fast men and humble, serious-minded reading men may not have been purely a literary invention; in Cambridge Memories, former undergraduate Richard Lyall asserts that reading men's sober habits rendered them reasonably immune to debt and consumer temptations: “A love of literature is a great safeguard: it produces habits of recreation and visiting very inexpensive. . . . [Y]ou may estimate the degree of self-denial required, and the strong temptation that all but reading men must feel to join a wine set every day after dinneraq Likewise, the contrast between the wasteful pursuits of fast men and the hard-won success of reading men in Oxbridge fiction served both as a useful dramatic device and as convenient shorthand for illustrating moral lessons that privileged the “proper” values of middle-class masculinity.
“The More Painful Consequences of his Reckless Habits at College”: Debt's Repercussions
The social pressures placed on students to adopt to a lavish lifestyle both unsustainable to their budget and incompatible with their morality were daunting. Tom Brown's classmate Sanders wonders, “How in the world are youngsters with unlimited credit, plenty of ready money, and fast tastes, to be kept from making fools and blackguards of themselves up here?” (Hughes 32). Victorian commentators and novelists offered their middle-class readers moralistic lessons that illustrated “the wretched consequences of debt” (“Chapters” 443). To begin, indebted Oxbridge students who had reached the age of majority often found themselves facing administrative action. As a last resort, merchants and tradesmen could report a student's unpaid bills to the Chancellor's Court at Oxford and the Court of Discipline at Cambridge (Deslandes 70).Footnote 19 The Chancellor's Court was a prospect that filled students with dread in university fiction. In Bracebridge Hemyng's Jack Harkaway's Strange Adventures at Oxford (1898), the villainous Kemp panics, “I'm in debt up to my neck everywhere. I owe money to tradesmen, who are dunning my life out of me, and I owe a lot to bill-discounters and betting-men, who threaten to have me up before the Vice-Chancellor or make me a bankrupt in London” (15; bk. 5; ch. 48). Oxford student Hugh Ashby of Inglis Allen's A 'Varsity Man: Passages in the Career of an Impressionable Undergraduate (1901) is begged by his classmate Cardrake to repay the ten pounds he has borrowed because “his tailors had been coming over very nasty, and he wanted to keep out of the Vice-Chancellor's Court” (262).Footnote 20
But appearing before the Chancellor's Court was not the worst consequence of a student's life of debt. Conventional Victorian morality popularly equated a lack of financial restraint with a lack of restraint against a host of even more dreadful vices. Because financial insolvency was regularly associated with a lack of virtue and moral failure (Weiss 19, 71), indebted students were often assumed to be guilty of other sins in which their borrowed money enabled them to indulge, particularly drinking, gambling, and academic failure. Consequently, university novels pushed heavy-handed lessons about financial responsibility through sensationalistic melodrama that traced young men's harrowing downfalls into moral ruin. Student characters who find themselves in considerable debt lie about their bills, borrow money from classmates, and sink into debauched lifestyles. Others resort to desperate, even criminal, measures to keep solvent, to evade creditors, or to hide their debt from their parents. In Julian Home, Kennedy – too preoccupied with the late-night card-playing through which he has lost most of his college allowance – finds himself unprepared for his exams and stoops to cheating. He asks his father to pay for tutoring but uses the money instead to settle gambling debts (305–06). Having “swerved so often from the path of temperance, rectitude, and honor,” the young man flings himself “into sins he had never known before,” is suspended, and eventually attempts suicide (346, 347). The undergraduate villains Kemp and Hunston of Jack Harkaway's Strange Adventures at Oxford, plot to rob a safe to pay off their sizable debts (Hemyng 21). Perhaps most scandalous of all, Osborne of College Debts disappears from Oxford to evade his creditors and, disguising himself as a dashing captain, plots to fool a wealthy spinster into marrying him (1: 210–21). Reflecting on the depths to which Osborne has sunk, the author writes that “he had broken away from his professions altogether,. . . undervalued his promises to father, mother, and sisters,. . . had ventured on the dangerous sea of unlimited credit, and was now lost to that very world by whose notice he had been flattered and ensnared, in the terrible mäelstrom of debt” (1: 271).
While most university fiction is light on romance and positively chaste toward sexuality, financial debt can also be read as a symbolic stand-in for the sexual dangers that young men might fall into outside of the protective family environment and among the dangerous influences of Oxbridge. The equation by Victorian commentators of economic and sexual self-restraint among Britain's middle-classes has been widely acknowledged by scholars.Footnote 21 The economic terms of spending, saving, and wasting were regularly used to refer to both financial and sexual continence; Sussman notes that “excessive expenditure or unregulated flow” – of either semen or wealth – was “the sign of unmanly behavior since the draining of this reservoir of male strength attenuates the work ethic” (96). Michael Tratner similarly asserts, “In Victorian novels, sex and debt are described as dangerous activities that one should avoid when young in order to ‘save up’ so that one can eventually ‘invest’ properly, in a marriage and in a house” (1). The nadir of Edward Grantley's university career in College Debts occurs when he and a classmate get drunk on champagne, pick up a strange young woman, crash a dog-cart into a tree, and are caught by the proctor (2: 114–15). In Tom Brown at Oxford, the title hero's descent into debt and his inappropriate dalliances with a pretty lower-class barmaid whom he has no intentions of marrying occur simultaneously and are arguably one and the same: in both cases, Tom is expending his resources on an improper object of desire that threatens to lead him on the “downward path” to moral collapse (178).
Despite the regular provocative associations made between consumer over-indulgence and illicit vices, university novels curiously deemphasize the pleasures derived from consumption itself. Deslandes contends that the diaries and memoirs of real-life Oxbridge students demonstrate their evident delight in making purchases and decorating their rooms, revealing “sensual celebrations of the pleasures associated with searching Cambridge shops for bargains and pleasing decorative items,” extolling “the considerable pleasures (aesthetic and otherwise) derived from” shopping, and the “[t]he joys of purchasing” (67). Such sentiments, however, are all but absent from contemporaneous university fiction. To be sure, we might regard Gerald Delane of Passages in the Life of an Undergraduate skeptically when, in response to the sizable bills his mother has discovered, he unconvincingly replies, “I wish I had never got these things. I have never thoroughly enjoyed them, of course” (Batty 152). Nonetheless, university novels rarely depict in any great detail the act of consumption, the pleasures derived from consumer goods, or the process of falling into debt. Neither Gerald's purchases nor his debt is mentioned until their discovery in chapter 17. Hughes never explicitly states how Tom Brown has come to accrue £100 in debt; indeed, his best friend Hardy attests that “you haven't hunted, or gambled, or tailored much, or gone into any other extravagant folly” (313). Likewise, College Debts does not trace Grantley's presumably regular expenditures; rather, it's abruptly revealed near the end of volume 1 that he's obtained a shocking amount of goods on credit from the wine-merchant, livery stable, and cigar store (1: 290, 294). While Saxon's buying spree in Liberty Hall represents one of the few detailed accounts of a shopping excursion in Oxbridge fiction, the young student doesn't appear to gain much pleasure from what he's doing or even to express much desire for the items that he purchases; instead, he is presented as a passive mark conned by fast-talking salesmen. Steeped in a middle-class ethos, Oxbridge novels exhibit hesitancy in portraying unnecessary or excessive consumption as wholly pleasurable. The heroes of university fiction do not plunge into debt, but rather find themselves in debt, having been goaded by irresponsible classmates or lured by predatory merchants to make unnecessary purchases. Consumption is rarely depicted as spurred by desire, exactly; rather, it's explained by other motivations, such as conforming to social expectations or being a good host.
In highlighting the negative consequences of student debt for dramatic purposes, Victorian and Edwardian university novels place particular stress on its detrimental impact on families. When Gerald's unpaid bills are finally discovered, Batty underscores the young student's deception and his widowed mother's heartache. “You are my eldest born,” his mother laments, “the one of all my children to whom I have looked for comfort and help in the future, and you have betrayed my trust in you at the outset. It is a cruel disappointment, Gerald” (151). In College Debts, Osborne's cash-strapped father is so dumbstruck by the revelation of his son's debts and related criminal charges that he instantly collapses from a massive stroke (1: 291). Grantley's father is similarly devastated by the news of his son's university debts and academic failure (2: 140–41). Overwhelmed by forwarded bills and threats of legal action, “the poor rector, despairing when he should see the end of this crushing shower, sickened and died under the weight of the mental anxiety and suspense in which he was continually living” (2: 185–87). The elder Mr. Grantley's death fails to deter the bill collectors, however; and eventually Edward's surviving mother and sister are obligated to leave the rectory and move into a much smaller home. “Greatly would it have shocked Grantley,” the author writes, “could he have seen the pale harassed features of his mother and sister as in the midst of their own deep grief they found themselves plunged into the more painful consequences of his reckless habits at College” (2: 188).
Certainly, these fictional examples seem directed at young readers in the hopes that they might be frightened away from the pitfalls of debt through tales of heartbroken and ruined mothers and fathers. “Remember this,” Reade addresses new undergraduate readers in Liberty Hall, “that by running into debt you doubt your parents and insult them; you compel them to pay in honour for that which you think they would not have given you in kindness; in other words when you purchase under their name without their knowledge or consent, you are in reality stealing money from their purses” (1: 350). The author of College Debts expresses in the preface his hope “that some who might read his book early in the course of their academical studies, might be induced by it to shun the tracks of folly, profligacy, and vice, and plod on, through diligence and self-denial, to an honorable distinction” (1: iv). Scarifying tales of young boys from good homes who nonetheless fall into debt and debauchery, however, would have also provoked the anxieties of middle-class mothers and fathers, and the regular emphasis placed on the detrimental impact on families suggests that novelists were aware of a parental readership. While fathers dropping dead over university bills may seem melodramatic, College Debts and similar novels nonetheless likely reflect the very real anxieties of middle-class parents who feared that their financial solvency could be ruined by the thoughtless whims of their sons in just a few short years of reckless living. So familiar was the figure of the “deluded father” oblivious to his fast son's questionable university activities that Mark Pattison, writer and rector of Oxford's Lincoln College, acknowledged it as one of the “stereotyped parts” of university fiction (238).Footnote 22 Widespread Victorian unease regarding the specter of bankruptcy, in tandem with lingering suspicions over Oxbridge's moral dangers, led to the terrifying prospect that the source of financial disaster could be one's own son while he was beyond his parents' watchful eye.
“One Who Paid his Debts”: Settling Accounts and Oxbridge Manhood
The university years, Deslandes contends, were widely recognized as a critical phase in the development of Britain's privileged males into a professional elite of politicians, civil servants, lawyers, educators, and clergymen (48–49, 3). Oxbridge fiction emphasized that the university years also endowed young men with the adult skills of managing money, budgeting, maintaining a household, and demonstrating class identity through the proper purchase and use of consumer goods so prized by the middle classes. Because “success is often pictured in the Victorian novel as the application of thrift, industry, and sobriety” (Weiss 72), proper manhood is achieved by exercising responsible money management and self-mastery over one's desires. As the protagonist of Godfrey Marten departs for Oxford, his father advises him, “You ought to know by this time what money is worth, and that debt is a thing you must avoid. Be a man, Godfrey, and don't forget that the first step to becoming one is to behave like a gentleman” (Turley 1). Students who recklessly accumulate debt or unwisely attempt to keep up with the lavish lifestyles of their wealthier classmates often find themselves insolvent and learn harsh lessons about living within their means. In Tom Brown at Oxford, Tom's father agrees to cover his son's debts but admonishes, “You are no longer a boy, and one of the first duties which a man owes to his friends and to society is to live within his income. . . . A gentleman should shrink from the possibility of having to come on others, even on his own father, for the fulfillment of his obligations, as he would from a lie” (315). In this way, Oxbridge novelists equated adult masculinity with the accountability, discipline, and maturity that marked a young male's readiness to assume the steady manhood required to manage his own future household.
Significantly, Victorian prose and fiction frequently acknowledged that debt was virtually impossible to avoid during the Oxbridge years. The heroes of university fiction who possess middle-class values are often just as likely to succumb to the temptations of overconsumption and the pitfalls of debt as the faster secondary characters who exhibit upper-class irresponsibility. The important distinction, then, is manifested in how they regard and respond to their debts. While Fitzherbert Osborne and Vyvyan Bruce are portrayed as scheming good-for-nothings, protagonists Edward Grantley and Tom Brown have “good manly stuff at the bottom” that ultimately wins out. The wicked, immoderate student indulges his consumer desires with abandon and without apology, he avoids responsibility, and he sinks into dissolution and disgrace. But the protagonist who exhibits middle-class values ultimately prevails: he agonizes over his indebtedness, he is troubled by the hardships he has caused his family, and he endeavors to settle his bills and make things right. Although mounting debts compel both Osborne and Grantley to leave Oxford and shame their parents, the corrupt Osborne resorts to deception and fraud and ends up in jail, while the steadier Grantley joins the army, becomes a war hero, and works to pay his bills, redeeming himself to his family and fiancée. In Julian Home, Bruce's relentless attempts to lure his classmates into vice eventually get him expelled, he is abandoned by his father who declares “your conceit and idleness will be their own punishment,” and poverty eventually compels him to emigrate to New Zealand (Farrar 387–88). Meanwhile, Vyvyan's classmate Edward Kennedy renounces his dissolute lifestyle, takes the civil service examination, and is appointed a post in India (401). Indeed, most of the protagonists of university fiction who find themselves in financial straits ultimately make good. Both Hugh Rendal and Tom Brown change their habits to get out from under their debts. Hugh's scare over his first-year bills inspires him to exert “sterner self-control” over his time and money in his second year:
There were. . . no more careless orders to tailor, tobacconist, or bookseller to “Send me so-and-so, and put it down”; no more evening visits to the theatre; no more sweet squanderings on unjustifiable hospitality. An “eight-hours' day” of work was resolved upon and strictly maintained. . . . And the economy of time helped the economy of money. With his only spare hours spent on the river. . . he had less opportunity and inclination to draw on his credit. And it may be added, in a whisper, that Hugh found more genuine satisfaction in adhering to this new rule of life than he had ever gained from setting all rules at naught. (Portman 103)
Similarly, Tom Brown eventually abandons the fast set that lured him into lending his money and chooses better company. In this way, Tom serves as an instructive example for all middle-class male readers, “working out his adjustment to the new world of men by making his way through the vicissitudes of extravagance and high living toward maturity” (Proctor 113). While most university novels portrayed the Oxbridge undergraduate ultimately profiting from his university years, he achieves manhood only by successfully maneuvering through a gauntlet of threats to his pocketbook and to his soul. For Tom Brown, Hugh Rendal, Edward Kennedy, and Edward Grantley, the vital initiation into adult manhood occurs through the rigorous testing of their financial and moral fortitude.
“In an older time,” writes Barbara Weiss, “men proved their honor by fighting duels; by the time of Queen Victoria, at least among those men of business who valued mercantile honor and respectability, the ‘gentleman’ seems to have been one who paid his debts” (32). Likewise, the Victorian and Edwardian Oxbridge novel suggests that the student hero achieves his adult masculinity during his university years in part by mastering the middle-class skills of setting up accounts, practicing proper money management, and avoiding or resolving debt that transformed boys into professionals and breadwinners. The heroes of Oxbridge fiction are rewarded with the marriages and respectable careers that characterized successful manhood: Tom Brown, Hugh Rendal, Edward Grantley, and Edward Kennedy all marry their sweethearts; Rendal and Kennedy both earn positions in the Indian Civil Service (Portman 289; Farrar 401), Paul Romaine becomes a college dean (Buxton 313), while Godfrey Marten seems destined for a career in the Foreign Office (Turley 342). To be sure, the professional positions in law, politics, academics, and the civil and diplomatic services that awaited fictional and real-life Oxbridge-educated gentlemen were beyond the realistic aspirations of most middle-class readers. Nonetheless, university novels offered inspiring, directly applicable models of success due to middle-class virtue. By presenting tales of humble young men who prevailed through hard work, thrift, and the determination to pay off their debts, Oxbridge fiction sought to inspire readers to emerge from life's economic crucible and assume their own place among Britain's middle ranks.
